New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Workbench: Old School

Posts

Workbench: Old School

#1

Workbench: Old School

Phil

Base is done: top in progress.


img

Re: Workbench: Old School

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Workbench: Old School

Dale Lenz

Looks great! Is that your shop floor in the picture?

Re: Workbench: Old School

#3

Re: Workbench: Old School

Phil

Ha!, I wish. I wanted to move the base outs of harms way when I was moving around 6 foot lengths of 8/4 maple that I'm using for top. I decided to move it to a safe place in the house.

Re: Workbench: Old School

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Workbench: Old School

Dale Lenz

Just thought that was way to nice of a floor for a shop, but one never knows.

Re: Workbench: Old School

#5

Re: Workbench: Old School

roger lance

Phil....the base looks absolutely great....beautiful attention to detail.....and you have escaped Rouboism.....for fun, you could inform SWMBO that where the bench sits is the new shop because you like all that light from those windows and a wood floor will be easier on your back.....but then, you might wind up on your back.....can't wait to see the top!

Re: Workbench: Old School

#6

Re: Workbench: Old School

Peter Evans

I have a very similar base, and it is very stable. Whilst it can be disassembled, I have not in 10+ years ever needed to tighten the bolts - rock steady (but base is heavy recycled [therefore dry] Australian 4x4 hardwoods, if that makes a difference).

Looks great.

Re: Workbench: Old School

#7

Re: Workbench: Old School

Phil

Thanks. Given all the chatter over the past couple of years about Roubo, I was left with only one choice: go traditional (I have no problem with form over fucntion: it looks cool, good enough for me).

If this base sits where it is for too long, I have a feeling I will be commissioned to build a slightly different top: perhaps a sewing table, or maybe a buffet table (I'd better get going on the bench top).

Re: Workbench: Old School

#8

Re: Workbench: Old School

Phil

Thanks. I try to keep the humidity level in my shop in as narrow a band as possible with heat/dehumidifiers/AC, so I'm not too concerned about movement. Besides, the stretcher/leg joints are glued and drawbored (if the drawbored joints fail, I'm planning on blaming Chris Schwartz.)

Re: Workbench: Old School

#9

Re: Workbench: Old School

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Nice looking shop- hardwood floors, lots of windows, even central heat :) .

Good looking bench too. What is the first thing you are going to build on it?

Re: Workbench: Old School

#10

Re: Workbench: Old School

Tom

Looking really nice. I have to say that over the years, if I have learned something about making benches on the fly, maximizing wood yield etc... It is to make the bench top first and the base second. It is a nice idea to have a base to build the top on, but it hasn't worked out for me. Usually I either have material that can be more efficiently used by changing dimensions, or my hardware is different, or I change the joinery, and before you know it something is in the way of something else. It's probably just me...

Of course if you are either smarter than me, or using detailed plans and not messing around with them, it probably works either way.

Re: Workbench: Old School

#11

Re: Workbench: Old School

Phil

I generally work from a rough "back of the envelope" plan and that has been my approach on this project. I thought it would be a good idea to get the easy part of the project done and out of the way first: then I could concentrate on the top which has large heavy pieces that can potentially do lots of damage if they slam into something in a cramped shop. I don't think there is one right way to approach it: my approach seems to be working (so far).

Re: Workbench: Old School

#12

Re: Workbench: Old School

Phil

Build on it? A workbench is not a means to an end: its an end in itself! In fact, I have the thought if building something that I will be submitting to a WW mag. for publication: with any luck, you will be reading about it at some point.

Re: Workbench: Old School

#13

Re: Workbench: Old School

CStanford

Solid, very nice start. If it is sitting in the room it will live its life out you'll have a very nice set up indeed.

Re: Workbench: Old School

#14

Re: Workbench: Oh, that's too bad ..

Bruce McCrory

I was trying to figure out how you were installing the Moxon double vise...

I am thinking of throwing out the renter and taking back my basement room, for a work shop.

Re: Workbench: Old School

#15

Re: Workbench: Old School

Tom

Your base is so nice I have full confidence... My problem is that I work exactly the same way, and I always get into trouble. I follow plans, actually come to think of it, the second full one was my plans! That normally makes the adapt process more reliable... Or should...

What always happens to me is the spacing of the dog holes vs base spacing; extent of the L bracket for the vise; Length of the vise screw, or other hardware; position of vise mounting hardware relative to dog holes; position of the projecting tenons and wedges, relative to the tail vise gap; postion of base relative to Tucker quick release pedal; whatever... There is some sneaky detail I didn't fully conceptualize, that ends up giving me trouble. Hey just being honest, as Krenov said there are always a lot of little pieces that most people hide away, and try not to have to talk about...

I don't know that I would call it a right or wrong way to do it, or did call it that... But I do know it is a lot easier to modify a base to fit a top than a top to fit a base, should there be any problem, as obviously there won't be for you... But you never know who is listening. And it just seems so logical to warm up by doing the base first, and thereby having a firm foundation to build the top on. Just not doing that again, a man has to know his limitations.

Another thing people tend to do is build all the wood stuff first, then buy the hardware. I see this all the time on the bike threads, and other hobbies, people have a million question about the dimension of this, and how they would mount that. Isn't it just common sense to buy all the parts first, but very few people actually do that. Worse still, not having bought the parts, people then change their minds half way through when some better stuff comes out, which is sensible enough, but it does make laying plans difficult.

Amateur custom design process starts like this: Build base, build top, buy hardware, find out the bench actually isn't the right size for the parts they need to build or doesn't fit together (or obviously in most cases comes out fine). (or in the case of boats, start with the size they can afford, or with bikes build the frame first, because it is cheap, etc...). Pros, start with the intended service, pull the hardware, build the bench. In their case top or bottom first is probably irrelevant since they don't really have any baggage around building easy parts, or using parts of the bench to build other parts, or getting the top and bottom to match up... They are probably on different lines if they do the work enough.