New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Rob Lee.....request for info....

Posts

Rob Lee.....request for info....

#1

Rob Lee.....request for info....

roger lance

Mr. Lee....now that you have introduced your prototype shooting board plane at Amana, would you show some pictures of the plane and give some discussion of it's specifications for those of us who were not at Amana and who await September when the plane will be offered for sale? Thanks Rob.

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#2

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

Rob Lee

Hi Roger -

Caught me out of the office (for two weeks) - so pictures won't happen... nothing to shoot anyway, as we just received castings, and have yet to cut metal.

Some shooting plane stats:

• Length: 15-7/8”

• Base width: 2-1/8” (to fit Stanley #52 shooting board)

• Blade: 2-1/4” wide, bevel up, 25° bevel angle. O1 or PM-V11. All of our standard 2-1/4” bevel up blades will fit this plane.

• Bed: 12° bed angle, skewed 20°

• Blade Adjustment: Typical Veritas “Norris” type adjuster, three set screws to precisely locate the blade, and rock the blade forward/back to adjust square

• Mouth opening: adjustable toe piece with adjuster screw

• Weight: 7-3/4 lbs

• Rear tote: adjustable for angle. Plane can be used with the blade down for jointing.

I do have a pdf rendering, and if i can be presumptuous - I will email it to you to post!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#3

Dang it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

another LV product to want.

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#4

Not so fast...

Scott in Montana

As I understand it, not only is Lee Valley introducing this new shooting plane but maybe a half dozen or more other planes. Plus a few new tools including awls.

Just when I caught up to the Joneses... they refinanced! Just when I caught up to Rob Lee........

Scott in Montana

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#5

A drawing - WARNING - high drool factor

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Rob indeed sent Roger Lance a drawing of the plane; Roger asked for a little help in translating the PDF that Rob sent into a format Wood Central would like, and here it is, a little fuzzier than the original because of all the gyrations it went through:


I am presently telling myself that, really, I don't need a specialized shooting plane. Really. I don't. Keep telling myself that. Really. I don't.

Sigh. Self-hypnosis doesn't work very well.

By the way, Rob, will there be a left-handed version, in keeping with your normal policies?

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#6

craigd

What up with the Balde eh?

craigd

Might have a screw loose but ain't no setscrews in my bald 'ead.

Now I'll probably have to buy one just to check. Not that I want one, oh no, not me ...

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#7

Thanks Rob and Bill for the help....


Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#8

Just to add to your denial issues.....

roger lance

I've read elsewhere that there will be a left hand version.....probably fit your hand real well.....

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#9

Boo-YAH!! Bring it on!!


Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#10

Yes on the leftie version

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I heard from Rob that there will be. Time to buy a new piggybank.

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#11

Who needs it?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I never understood this kind of plane, especially the staggering price for one from LN. Shooting isn't something that one does much of building typical furniture, and it isn't something difficult to do with a multitasking plane of typical design. In fact the low angle plane LV sells is outstanding for shooting board ends as well as its common role of surface planing. Why would anyone buy a dedicated shooting plane?

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#12

Mostly, its about who wants it??.....

roger lance

Bill....I agree with you that for most this is a want not a need. Despite my highly developed fiscal conservatism, I'm a wanter. I may not make the purchase.....just use a regular plane. As you point out, the LV BUJ does a good job as a shooter and would in all honesty meet my limited shooting needs. But wants are not purely logical. I will make a little speculation here.....not that I've been looking for a used LN 51, but I don't remember ever seeing one for sale....YMMV....I would think that if you were to decide to sell your expensive LN 51, it would not take long....so, you'd have a minor financial loss but have the experience of owning/using this exceptional tool.

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#13

Define "need".

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I do not actually "need" a lot of things in the shop: more than one handplane, more than a half dozen assorted chisels, one backsaw could do dovetails and tenons, a tablesaw, router, random orbital sander ....

I don't need a shooting plane. However I have 3 dedicated ones (Stanley #51 - now retired; LN #51, and a shopmade Strike Block Plane) :O

I find more use for a shooting board than a ROS. It is an extremely useful tool that also gratifies ... nothing like sneaking up on that "perfect" fit. It is great for sizing and squaring drawer fronts and stretchers before dovetailing or sawing tenons. It is, clearly, a dedicated tool - but so is a ROS, and mine (a Festool I purchased 15 years ago) only gets pulled out about two or three times a year. Perhaps I should get rid of this quality tool for a multi-use sanding block?

I played with the plastic model of the forthcoming LV shooting plane in January when visiting the factory. It clearly will set the bench mark for shooting planes. Indeed, I can see an immediate advantage over my (common angle but skew-bladed) #51 and even my strike block plane (with a low cutting angle): the LV is BU and offers both a low cutting angle (for end grain) and, with a blade swap, a high cutting angle (which will be valuable for side grain). This does not say that it is a "need", but it does say that it meets a need for some and does so very well.

Incidentally, LN also has a leftie in the pipeline, but there has not been (as far as I know) any word when it will be launched.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#14

The motivation of the question

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Over on the main board a stunning "first guitar" is posted. It was mentioned that some specialty tools were bought that in fact were not essential. I think it a common situation that when getting into something new persons are tempted to buy stuff that isn't essential because they don't have the information to make an informed decision. The new- to- the- task person sees others using the tool, the tool is recommended by an authority in the field, it is hoped that the tool will compensate for lack of skill or experience, etc.

Forums can provide a new- to- a- task person a diversity of opinions on the need and utility of a tool for this task. In the case at hand a shooting board and plane are unequaled for tidying up the ends of boards for precise joinery. The shooting board can be a trivial task to build and any sharp plane will work adequately with it. Additional responses to my original question will provide additional information to the prospective customer on their need for an elegant shooting board or specialty plane.

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#15

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: A drawing - WARNING - high drool factor

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

(Plunk) sound of my jaw bouncing off my bench..... wow, ...a clear winner again Rob... so this is what can happen in a 48 game season when you stop going....great work as aways!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#16

Re: Define "need".

cstanford

My view is that you made Bill's point better than Bill himself. For what it's worth of course.

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#17

I understand it... but would not likely buy one...

John in NM

A lot of the appeal of specialty tools has to do with appreciation of a tool that does the task 5% better. A sense of luxury perhaps, like driving a really nice car. Price is less important to those who buy Mercedes' than the appreciation of the machine.

But bear in mind, my newest car is a 2002 model, and I've only once paid more than $5,000 for a car :D

I always think that if I were in a more prosperous position, I too would buy luxurious products. But the reality is that I would probably stick with my cheap cars and old tools, and buy lots and lots of wood :D

Re: Rob Lee.....request for info....

#18

Re: Who needs it?

Ron Harper

It really is not about need. Paul Sellers makes a very convincing case that you CAN make very nice furniture with only 10 good hand tools. Most of usher have a lot more hand tools than that.i do very much

understand your point, but the tool maker would be in bad shape if we only used 10 tools made to last multiple lifetimes.