New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

In defense of Krenov

Posts

Re: In defense of Krenov

#26

More Krenov...and Bill's killer rift ash

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

This thread is bringing back recollections from past Krenov reading, and useful things I had almost forgotten where they came from...

One of the very best repair techniques I ever learned was from Krenov (much better than 'put ebony over it' ;) ). And that is to take a gouge and excise the offending part, or smooth a 'holiday' in a fragile edge or surface. Then use the same gouge to go cut a divot with matching grain. Dip the divot in hot hide and press it in there, and clamp it tight. Few hours later, smooth with plane, file, what have you, and done! Similar to the way the old guys cut bellflowers into a leg.

Also, how to finish the inside of a drawer with very thin shellac.

Also, how to make a false astragal where two cabinet doors close on each other.

Also, guide blocks for dovetails. How to.

Many others.

________

As for Bill's cabinet and rift ash, anybody's welcome to their opinion. And here's mine: It's killer, and perfect for the application. I look forward to Bill's writing desk from this material!

Wiley

Re: In defense of Krenov

#27

Ash

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Ash is only coarse grained when it grows fast.

I have rarely encountered something made with two wood species that I liked.

What probably failed on your upload was a delay in posting. If you open a post, download a file and take too long to send the picture will vanish and be replace by that funky symbol seen in your post.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#28

Insightful?... Who decides that?...


Re: In defense of Krenov

#29

A little trolling?

Ron Harper

Cult?... C'mon John

I never did like Michael Jackson... He did Ok.. Millions did.. Could I have missed something?

Just sayin

Re: In defense of Krenov

#30

After all the Hooooo Haaaaaa

Ron Harper

That sure is a pretty cabinet. The only change I would consider ( this is really picky ). Might be to quiet the grain that is visible on the inside back of the piece. You do not want the grain to compete with the objects displayed against it. I said it was picky.

Nice work Bill.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#31

Not at all...

John in NM

Trolling requires the intent to get a rise out of you (or anyone), and that is not my intent. You may find the word "cult" a bit strong, but it is what I call a group that allows no criticism of their idol to go unchallenged. As the term "cult of personality" has been in common usage for decades, I do not think my use is inappropriate. If anyone else does think so, speak up, I may well be wrong and can always be convinced by a rational argument.

The point, if you can get past my unfortunate choice of words, was that if one requires that negative criticism only be made by an equally gifted designer, what justification is there for the neophytes like me or you to offer positive criticism?

Re: In defense of Krenov

#32

Why, the all the other forum readers of course...

John in NM

You are all quite free to dismiss me as a ranting fool :D That's the risk we all take in writing our ideas down and hitting the post button.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#33

Re: Why, the all the other forum readers of course

Ron Harper

I fear we will not agree. I know what kind of work William Duffield and Derek Cohen are capable of. I have seen their work. If I do not know if a critic has ever built a breadbox, his opinion will not receive the same weight with me as William or Derek's. That seems so obvious to me.

The internet is haven to many with opinions and little else.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#34

Re: Not at all...

Ron Harper

I would never presume to criticize Maloof or Krenov or Peter Follansbee, or Mac Headly, or more than a hundred others who are clearly superior to me in talent and skills.

I may not care for they stylings, but it would never occur to me to suggest how Krenov or Maloof could be better. Unthinkable.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#35

And that is your choice to make

John in NM

In that at least I can agree with you. The world would be a dull place if we all saw it the same :D

Re: In defense of Krenov

#36

Good heavens, why not?

John in NM

If you start with the assumption that you will never have a valid critique to make, certainly you'll never find one. At some level, doesn't innovation come from allowing the possibility that there is room for improvement? Isn't that very attitude a part of what we admire in guys like Krenov?

Why should anyone be above criticism? Saying that you would not presume to criticize Krenov is entirely different than saying that you have never found anything to criticize in Krenov.

I hope you've not found the discussion too unpleasant, I'm afraid I kind of enjoy a good debate :D

Re: In defense of Krenov

#37

Re: Good heavens, why not?

Ron Harper

It seems to me that criticism, to be valid, needs to come from one's peers.

Is that elitist?

The craft we love is about performing. Those who cannot should not presume to criticise those who can.

My $.02

Re: In defense of Krenov

#38

Did bill make the ash cabinet...

david weaver

.. in the picture in his first post of this string?

Gad...if he did, I would've been less rude talking about it if I'd have known it was his.

I just don't care for krenov's stuff at all and got wound up in it.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#39

Elitist?  No...

John in NM

I wouldn't call it that, just a bit myopic...

Innovators, like Krenov, are usually dismissed as kooks by their peers. Decades later, the genius is obvious to us, but it was not obvious initially. I would speculate that in the 1950's, following your logic would have had us saying "who is this Krenov guy who presumes to criticize traditional design?".

Now Krenov is part of the tradition, that is the only thing that has changed since he was unknown.

Ironically, I do not much like the ash cabinet Bill posted. Just not to my taste and I didn't bother figuring out why. But the painted one I do like, I like it more every time I look at it.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#40

Re: In defense of Krenov

cstanford

New York Times story (obituary really):

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/20/us/20krenov.html?_r=0

Re: In defense of Krenov

#41

Re: Ash--image illiterate

Bruce McCrory

Hah! My image uploads only work when they are not needed, eg., the Marmite Kid on the Torpedore thread.


Re: In defense of Krenov

#42

Re: And yet...

Bruce McCrory

In an obtuse way, I think we are hearing: "Blasphemer!"

Anytime people or a group get their panties in a knot over independent thinking, the moment is ripe for manipulation of sentiment, and at worse, heinous abuses due to loss of individual freedoms.

We can find lessons and guidance in all tagged "signatures". I wonder how a delicate brass knife hinge can stand up to supporting an open door. How quickly will the door begin its inevitable creep to the floor? More importantly, which is on display ... case, or hidden curio?

Ciao-

Re: In defense of Krenov

#43

Re: Did bill make the ash cabinet...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I read three of James Krenov's books in the 1970s. At that time they were a refreshing contrast to the then prevalent belt sander, router table, oil stain, spray finish mentality. He certainly influenced even those who did not copy his siyle or designs.

When I saw the ash cabinet, I thought that Bill had made it. Krenov liked to have a special quality about his timber, as if he had searched for just the right piece. I'm sure Bill did give a lot time and thought to the stock selection, but it isn't as obvious as in Krenov's work. Over recent decades a lot of customers have been more eager to pay for a fine piece of wood than fine craftsmanship.

I am not sure that I would call this cabinet well engineered. If as Bill comments this cabinet really requires many trial fittings, needs care at every turn, it seems like a lot of work for a cabinet that is rather understated, almost bland. In addition, I think it would be a restorers nightmare: getting the dowel joint apart, repairing the rails or dealing with delamination, glass that needs to be a tight fit to stiffen the door.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#44

Re: I am glad..

david weaver

I started this stuff as a hobby in the middle of the last decade rather than 5 decades ago.

I do recall that when I was growing up, the local preference for furniture was white pine stained or flatsawn oak stained, and no amount of routering the edges of items was seen as out of bounds.

My parents still have a lot of it in their house, having mastered the circular saw, jigsaw and a couple of power sanders.