In defense of Krenov
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
This post may more properly belong below in response to comments on "Krenov Style Woodworking". Never-the-less......
What I don't intend to defend is the philosophical musings. I have never looked to a woodworking guru for guidance on how to live my life. I find these proselytizing life style woodworkers tedious. Unfortunately Krenov spent much of his books getting touchy-feely with woodworking and devoted too little text to describing the clever ways he engineered and executed stuff. I have been pestering one of his former students (Finck) to write a book on Krenov woodworking techniques so they won't become lost. Finck teaches a class on some of them and I can say that most would finding building some of his styles a problem without some insight as to how he went about it. For example, take this wall cabinet as an example....

As far as design, it is both attractive and functional serving to display life's trinkets where a picture might otherwise reside. Controversially, it is assembled with dowels. But, to make this cabinet one makes the door first for it is impossible to predict the exact final shape of the the bent lamination door until it is made. This constraint leads to many trial fittings of the cabinet to get the precise fit of cabinet to door required to make this piece look attractive, for its attractiveness relies on the precise reveals of its pieces. These fittings are done with the cabinet dry fit with but a few of the many dowels that will finally hold it together. When all is well these worn out dowels are tossed and replace by fresh ones. I thought I was smarter than Krenov and built the first of these cabinets with "superior" M&T joinery. The M&T joints became sloppy loose by the time I had everything fit well. What is not obvious is that a glue joint tight stable back made from veneered plywood provides the structural support to aid the dowels in keeping it together.
Similarly, precise fitting glass panels provide rigidity for the otherwise frail door. I would argue that nothing beats the clever Krenov style catch that holds his doors shut, and the often overlooked pin that takes weight off the hinges when the door is closed. And there are the shelf supports, custom grinding of twist drills to make clean cutting spur bits, custom ground router bits to make more attractive rabbits (something that could be done with the hand tool equivalent), attractive application of knife hingery, and the list goes on.
It is easy to think of Krenov in terms of his philosophy. But it is his engineering and design that could have lasting value for those not devoted to his life style.

Some of us are just wired that way... pretty annoying 




