New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

In defense of Krenov

Posts

In defense of Krenov

#1

In defense of Krenov

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

This post may more properly belong below in response to comments on "Krenov Style Woodworking". Never-the-less......

What I don't intend to defend is the philosophical musings. I have never looked to a woodworking guru for guidance on how to live my life. I find these proselytizing life style woodworkers tedious. Unfortunately Krenov spent much of his books getting touchy-feely with woodworking and devoted too little text to describing the clever ways he engineered and executed stuff. I have been pestering one of his former students (Finck) to write a book on Krenov woodworking techniques so they won't become lost. Finck teaches a class on some of them and I can say that most would finding building some of his styles a problem without some insight as to how he went about it. For example, take this wall cabinet as an example....


As far as design, it is both attractive and functional serving to display life's trinkets where a picture might otherwise reside. Controversially, it is assembled with dowels. But, to make this cabinet one makes the door first for it is impossible to predict the exact final shape of the the bent lamination door until it is made. This constraint leads to many trial fittings of the cabinet to get the precise fit of cabinet to door required to make this piece look attractive, for its attractiveness relies on the precise reveals of its pieces. These fittings are done with the cabinet dry fit with but a few of the many dowels that will finally hold it together. When all is well these worn out dowels are tossed and replace by fresh ones. I thought I was smarter than Krenov and built the first of these cabinets with "superior" M&T joinery. The M&T joints became sloppy loose by the time I had everything fit well. What is not obvious is that a glue joint tight stable back made from veneered plywood provides the structural support to aid the dowels in keeping it together.

Similarly, precise fitting glass panels provide rigidity for the otherwise frail door. I would argue that nothing beats the clever Krenov style catch that holds his doors shut, and the often overlooked pin that takes weight off the hinges when the door is closed. And there are the shelf supports, custom grinding of twist drills to make clean cutting spur bits, custom ground router bits to make more attractive rabbits (something that could be done with the hand tool equivalent), attractive application of knife hingery, and the list goes on.

It is easy to think of Krenov in terms of his philosophy. But it is his engineering and design that could have lasting value for those not devoted to his life style.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#2

Re: In defense of Krenov

Howard Pollack

Thanks for this comment Bill. I'm a big fan of Krenov and appreciate the elegance (in many senses) of his work. It would be wonderful to preserve the methods. -Howard

Re: In defense of Krenov

#3

Re: In defense of Krenov

david weaver

This is a good post, I agree bill. I also get tired of life philosophy, and it's one of the reasons I've read nothing of krenovs. I don't much care for krenov's furniture style, either, but that's a personal taste thing. Don't care much for modern furniture, in general. Lots of folks must, though, because it seems to be what paid makers are making.

I think that cabinet would look better if it were flat and had mouldings, maybe most wouldn't share that sentiment. I also never get excited to see rails that overlap stiles, instead of the converse, but I understand the reason they're probably on that cabinet (necessary due to the bending).

Re: In defense of Krenov

#4

Interesting post title

Ron Harper

I never thought I would be on a woodworking site where Krenov would require defending. I can understand not caring for scandinavian modern styling. But Krenov was clearly a genius and he got most of us to understand that a truly marvelous piece of furniture is set apart by subtleties that most of the world will miss.

Was he a little different? Certainly... Most geniuses are. Goes with the territory.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#5

Made sense to me

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I live about three-four hours south of Krenov Central (the Fort Bragg College of the Redwoods campus where he taught after his books came out), and I have to say, I do get tired of yet another delicate little cabinet at the local shows. No question that many of his designs are elegant, but it's like hearing a really nice song over and over again; after a while, you don't much like it.

Maybe I'd feel differently if I lived in the kind of house where there's room for a cabinet that holds only a little but takes up floor space.

Bill Tindall has brought up a different element of Krenov's work: his thoughtful engineering. I'm glad he has, because I'd never thought about that element of his work, and it will encourage me to approach pieces with a new sensibility. I doubt I'll fall for them, but I may have a more complex perspective on them.

I read Krenov's books in my impressionable youth. The parts that stick, the parts I now find useful looking back, center around his passion, almost obsession, for looking at the details: for evaluating wood grain to select and orient a piece of stock on a door, a cabinet, etc., so that it supports the design instead of fighting with it. I realized, later, that this idea was not unique to Krenov, but he was one of the few furniture-making writers in the 1970s who was talking about it. So I am grateful to him for those lessons. Bill T. has opened up another area of Krenov's passion, the passion for right engineering details; a complement to what I got from his books. Thanks, Bill.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#6

Another point

Ron Harper

I think, from what I have read, that Krenov would insist that a lot of the work that makes a piece truly distinctive is done with hand tools. Like all the recent icons of the craft, he certainly used power tools, but he would insist that there are some things that are done much better with hand tools.

I think there is an interesting comparison between Krenov and Maloof. I will never have the skill or talent of either, but I have learned much from both of them.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#7

What both of them did

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

was collect special wood. I went to a seminar given by Maloof at his home years ago--he lived a few miles up the highway from us. A big part of his business was finding the right wood--it was a strategic requirement, of course, and he was proud of his wood. Had a few storehouses for it. And he knew every board.

Mr. Maloof used power tools as though they were hand tools, such was his facility with them. He had a huge band saw from somewhere in eastern Europe with a 1" (at least) band on it. He roughed out a rocking chair arm for us, starting from what looked like a 3" x 4" billet of the right length. He used a template or two to make marks on the billet, walked over to the bandsaw and literally carved it out--his arms were just flying around that saw on both sides, with his nose inches from the band. (He told us don't try that.) When he had it close, he walked back over toward our group and picked up a 3HP Speedmatic router with a roundover bit in it--held the router in one hand by the D-handle, with the work in the other hand, and went over the arm with that router, all the while standing up and talking to us without interruption. His forearms looked like they were made out of corded cable. He was 79 at the time.

Wiley

Re: In defense of Krenov

#8

The great ones paint with wood grain


Re: In defense of Krenov

#9

Re: In defense of ... Photo-grain Pergo?

Bruce McCrory

Was that medicine cabinet made with that Scotch Tape stuff? They put it on fake, foam plastic molding and Pergo-like flooring.

My irreverence for this piece, and generally, his curio cabinets---did Krenov ever make anything else?, yes, wood planes--is the 'oh-so-perfect' balance, and 'don't-interrupt-that-balance' obsessions. I suspect one could easily flip the above sample top-for-bottom to fit a left swing door need; and no one would notice.

Any smoke and mirrors? Besides mirror image wood?

With that example (thank you, for the photo) I stand by and expand my earlier comments.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#10

I can answer one question...

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

....but the rest of your statements left me baffled. The wood is rift cut ash from some logs harvested near where I live and sawed for me by Jack Malone. I found the wood a welcome departure from the foreign woods, particularly pear, that Krenov used for his cabinetry. I never heard why he eschewed US hardwoods. Some of the curly rift ash will be appearing in a desk under construction. I am smitten by rift ash.

So you don't like rift cut ash (as a curiosity what woods have you recently used?), and you don't like Krenov designs. I'm fine with that, but these topics were not part of my post which focused on Krenov engineering. If you despise Krenov you may not be familiar with his engineering contributions. I think the engineering has wide woodworking application and this was the topic of my post.

For example, what better way to hold a door closed than the Krenov rub closure? I use it on every door, including Period pieces. As Krenov advocates, most agree that door rabbits look better with a slight radius. And the list goes on.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#11

Re: Huh?

TomD

"What I don't intend to defend is the philosophical musings. I have never looked to a woodworking guru for guidance on how to live my life. I find these proselytizing life style woodworkers tedious."

As well you should, though I would appreciate the actual quote where he says anything of the sort. I am sceptical that it exists. He is normally very delicate about transferring his ideas to people. Often people react at though they were being held to the fire when the gentlest of presentations is being made. It normally has more to do with them. His style is to talk obliquely about "a certain kind of work or worker". Some of his points are all the more valid today. He asks (asks!) how if we all read the same stuff, and have access to the same methods and tools, what will personalize our work? That is even more true today with such level access to all the information on the craft.

" Unfortunately Krenov spent much of his books getting touchy-feely with woodworking and devoted too little text to describing the clever ways he engineered and executed stuff."

I guess five books one of which is entirely technical (and I think the thickest), is too little... At least for me. "Too little" is subjective, but as to whether he covered all the "novel" points you raise below, I would have thought he had covered most. He wrote a whole book pretty much exclusively about his technique. And wrote a whole chapter on that type of cabinet.

I find it hard to believe he used plywood backs structurally, or that he jammed the glass in tight. He mentions not having it so loose it rattles from passing trucks. So there may be details lost as you say, but most people would probably get most of what they need from actually reading his books as opposed to pretending they had, or being frank enough to admit that they hadn't.

"But, to make this cabinet one makes the door first for it is impossible to predict the exact final shape of the the bent lamination door until it is made."

That is certainly not true, though it is often convenient not to bother, particularly on one-offs.

" What is not obvious is that a glue joint tight stable back made from veneered plywood provides the structural support to aid the dowels in keeping it together."

I'm going to need two sources on that. Not that there is a thing wrong with plywood. If it didn't exist, most of us would be hard put to make it.

"Similarly, precise fitting glass panels provide rigidity for the otherwise frail door."

Again, that would be a two sourcer for me, wood movement still exists in these pieces though the pictures do show precise fits.

"I would argue that nothing beats the clever Krenov style catch that holds his doors shut, and the often overlooked pin that takes weight off the hinges when the door is closed. And there are the shelf supports,"

FAC P180-190

"custom grinding of twist drills to make clean cutting spur bits,"

Kinda obsolete but... FAC P133

"custom ground router bits to make more attractive rabbits (something that could be done with the hand tool equivalent),

That was common place, and still available, but the Asian bits, bankrupted our local guy.

"attractive application of knife hingery, and the list goes on."

FAC P180-190

"It is easy to think of Krenov in terms of his philosophy. But it is his engineering and design that could have lasting value for those not devoted to his life style."

I still return to the books, for the technical, sometimes to keep it simple. Today almost everything he wrote about has been superseded one way or another. I do make the odd Krenov plane still, since I can knock one out in 45 minutes. But I don't consider them superior to other styles, which having grown up with them is a bit of a shock. Probably third or fourth down the list, and it would probably be further if I knew more world styles. I think the way he does dovetails is a useful method for the type of work he did, for the practical reasons he gave.

And much of his technical advice is just standard stuff he was taught in Europe. It is one of the silly aspects of the craft that techniques get renamed after the person who first did them in a video, or an article. Sometimes they really did a lot of work to rediscover these techniques, even though there are thousands of people out there who never stopped.

I would be interested in a book, but it is a bit of a thankless task to just parrot back someone else's techniques. That would be the value to me, to know exactly how he, and the college did things over time. But not much of interest purely practically. So if it ended up being a gumbo of David's techniques that really would confuse the issue, possibly be useful in it's own right.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#12

Re: In defense of ... Photo-grain Pergo?

TomD

"My irreverence for this piece, and generally, his curio cabinets---did Krenov ever make anything else?, yes, wood planes--is the 'oh-so-perfect' balance, and 'don't-interrupt-that-balance' obsessions. I suspect one could easily flip the above sample top-for-bottom to fit a left swing door need; and no one would notice."

Yeah, he did, as the most cursory examination, probably of amazon even, would reveal. But, he did intentionally limit himself. He mentioned in the books a near fear of trying chairs, that he thought too difficult. Anyway, when any of us comes up with an instantly recognizable signature piece I guess we can criticize. Maloof made a lot of different stuff, his chairs are very well known. I think a lot of his stuff is not nerely as successful. His let's screw it together approach worked wonders in chairs that was not in his casework. At least as pictured in his books.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#13

Re: It's yours? Oops...

Bruce McCrory

That's a 'two-for-one' insult! As Bruce scrapes it from his own face....

Nice cabinet, Bill. To critique ... it's a little too perfect. Too Krenov.

Yours truly, ... Still vertical, anyway... :\

Re: In defense of Krenov

#14

Re: Interesting post title

John in NM

I think lots of woodworkers probably don't much care for Krenov, we just rarely mention it on the internet so we won't waste hours and hours arguing with the fans. In many cases I would guess it is the exuberant fan culture of which people tend to tire, not really Krenov himself.

The guy was human after all.

If it helps, think of it as music. Not all musicians think a whole lot of rap, or rock, or pop, or classical, or jazz, pick your flavor and someone won't like it. People simply develop preferences, it shouldn't be all that surprising when we stumble across one.

All that aside, being the argumentative skeptic that I am, my first impulse on reading Bill's post was to go ahead and try to make that bow front cabinet box first, door last :D Some of us are just wired that way... pretty annoying :D

Re: In defense of Krenov

#15

Re: I can answer one question...

TomD

"I found the wood a welcome departure from the foreign woods, particularly pear, that Krenov used for his cabinetry. I never heard why he eschewed US hardwoods."

In his books there is a piece made of doug fir, I think it was.

It would be interesting to know a little more about his life as a cabinetmaker. He is mostly known for his books. He does not show up all that much in books of 20th century furniture. But I don't know to what extent he made stuff after he started teaching. I know he had a shop and still made stuff.

The point being, he learned and practised cabinetmaking in Sweden. Wrote some books that mainly contain work from that period. He was working in the woods of the culture he worked in, Europe not Sweden. And he carried that to the college which got containers of wood from offshore.

The other thing is that there are certain fields where it is hard to sell NA woods. Guitars being one (soundboards aside, certain maples).`Sometimes true is stuff as disparate as wooden bowls, to veneer wrapped cigarette lighters. At various times.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#16

...I guess we can criticize."

Bruce McCrory

"Anyway, when any of us comes up with an instantly recognizable signature piece ...

Right. It's a good thing we aren't in a museum, or temple. It would get really boring deifying people.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#17

I think Tom's point

Ron Harper

Is that the credential of the critic is important to understanding the value of the criticism.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#18

A way of looking at the cabinet.........

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Most of the stuff I build fills a need. I need a place for socks for example. There was a corner at our entry that was put there for a future corner cabinet that would provide a place for some of our life's accumulations of neat trinkets and heirlooms. As our use of the house developed it became apparent that the corner cabinet was not going to be a good idea. So what to put there? I don't know anything about art so putting a picture or sculpture there was not a good option and it would serve no purpose other than occupying space.

A wall cabinet seemed to fit the space and need. So who to go to for wall cabinet inspiration.......It was not hard to answer that question. And this style fit into our eclectic "farmhouse casual" decorator scheme. Think of the wall cabinet as a picture that hangs on the wall and the picture can be changed from time to time by replacing the trinkets. I found it an outstanding idea that met the need.

It soon became apparent that I didn't have the knowledge and experience to build what I wanted to build. A practice run seemed prudent, so I made one from poplar. It turned out well. Daughter spied it, painted it and hauled it away for her art treasures. Maybe you will like it better. I am sure Krenov never milk painted and lacquered one!


Re: In defense of Krenov

#19

And yet...

John in NM

The credentials of the the supporting cult members are irrelevant.

Here's a good one to ponder... why should you guys care that another poster here does not revere Krenov (or any one else) as you seem to do? Why should it matter what they think or say?

Personally, I do not find Tom's standard for acceptable criticism to be correct. Only the "in club" or "elite", who themselves are designers in the same class are worthy to express negative opinions? Give me a break! What utter rot, and tired, predictable rot at that.

At least no one has said "do not blaspheme!!!!".... that is something I guess :D

Re: In defense of Krenov

#20

Re: And yet...

TomD

Keeping in mind I don't pass that test either. But my point was more subtle, apparently. Criticize all you want, but for me it crosses over into an area of fair comment when one criticizes the standard. It's one thing to go on and on about Phelps not being as great a Champion as Spitz, or vis versa, but maybe you should think twice about saying a swimmer who holds a world record is a sucky swimmer. At that point I would like to know what you know that the rest of the world doesn't and on what basis.

I notice that all the blah blah aside, nobody has defended the idea that having an instantly recognizable signature piece and style is a weak accomplishment in furniture making.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#21

Re: ...I guess we can criticize."

TomD

There is informed criticism, and not so much... It's predictable, people show up without a clue and then get upset when it doesn't work out for them. There are a heck of a lot of people who know more than I do on this subject but apparently they weren't available.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#22

It's not about the designer's abilities...

John in NM

It is about the legitimacy of the critic. I maintain that the critic's credentials have absolutely no bearing on the validity of his critique to an impartial observer. Whether he says anything insightful stands entirely on its own, as it should.

The idea that a critic has to be "qualified" by anything past the insight of his words is absurd to anyone with a shred of objectivity.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#23

Re: A second view

Bruce McCrory

Your cabinet intrigues me, Bill. More for the wood used rather than the style. I have an ash plank weathering at the moment, waiting for inspiration. Another picture: [Maybe, it will display .... x]


There are things about the piece that I would alter, and yet, I think still keep it within the style. Ash has pretty coarse grain. The carcase is arced grain; the door frame rails are straight grain. I would either change the texture with a second species, or carry the same grain sweep into the rails. Probably, switch woods, as reasoned below.

Curios by nature, especially when placed in "small spaces" are small. A brilliant revelation. However, when the enclosure, and the background, and the objects also, are detailed, translucent, or the same color the two clash and camouflage one another. Unless it is done intentionally, requiring accentuation of the similarities to pull off, there is great dis-harmony. There is loss of accentuation of the objects displayed and the display, itself.

A way to fix the texture conflict is to use a second wood. Because the ash is the case material, I would use a solid (fine texture) background. Maybe, walnut, cherry.

The final change I would do is the muntins. Again, they are conflicting with the innards--what is displayed. It is probably pricey, but curved glass is the solution. I was, but won't discuss the hazards of curved glazing. See the photographer's umbrella?

Anyway, these observations by no means are intended to belittle. It is easy to criticize. This is a personal exercise to reinforce in my own mind design that works, details that conflict or reinforce. And, in this case, how I can use my own ash board. It won't be a curio cabinet only because I don't like them.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#24

Re: A second view--No photo

Bruce McCrory

No picture ... Grrr!! Forget it. Loading images is too flakey--un-repeatable results.

It was another picture of your cabinet Bill. You are famous.

Re: In defense of Krenov

#25

Re: Huh? His own work-around

Bruce McCrory

I think Bill described his own solutions for building the cabinet. Seems reasonable to me....

Ciao (Slainte!)