New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Posts

Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#1

Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Sgian Dubh

Some of you may remember this sketch from some time back.


Well now the drawing has become a piece of furniture which looks like this:



There are a few more images at this web page: http://www.richardjonesfurniture.com/Cabinet-Furniture/Torpedore/Torpedore.html

The main driver for this piece in its design was external aesthetics: in other words its visual impact at first appearance. Functionality was really a secondary consideration. There's an exploration and bringing together of some strong motifs, ie, the juxtaposition of sweeps and curves in the 'torpedo' shaped leg, reflected in sweeps elsewhere, and these contrast with the straight vertical lines witnessed in the tambours in conjunction with parallel lines in the rift sawn cherry legs, side panels, and bottom front rail. In deliberate contrast to the parallel lines elsewhere the top itself shows off tangentially sawn wood for an arched grain pattern. There's also an intended trompe l'oeil effect in that each tambour stave was individually dyed so that, when both tambours are closed, there's a gradual colour change from one stave to the next and the tambour appears to recede further than it actually does because of the darker 'shadows' at the outer limits. Finally, there's a bit of playfulness in the sand dune inspired overlapping finger pulls of the tambours.

Inside the main cabinet is a sub-cabinet of hard maple with four adjustable shelves and a nest of graduated drawers on Grass Tipmatic touch release slides. The maple was chosen to present a deliberately contrasting 'clean', uncluttered, pale interior.

I have a lot of work in progress photographs, including CNC work, construction of the tambours, dying and polishing the maple tambour staves, some images of the drawer making and fitting of them to the touch release drawer runners, and so on. I'm hoping to gradually work my way through these photos and tell the story of the construction, but I'm not able to put a time line on completing that project. Slainte.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#2

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Don Stephan

Wonderful craftsmanship, design, execution as always Sgian. Thanks for sharing.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#3

Subtle details in a not-so-subtle piece!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That is one bold design. Wouldn't fit in my house, but I can see it fitting in a modern house, and making everything around it look inadequate by comparison.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#4

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Nice Richard .. very nice.

The bright colours may attract someone else first, but my eye is taken with the way you have handled the details.

The legs look to be proportioned to "lift" the eye up. That is, if the rounded outsides were lower (they look to be lightly higher than the middle), it would cause the cabinet to seem bellied. It looks "light".

There is a lot of symmetry there, which is relaxing and balances the in-your-face tambour colours. The vertical tambours outside are replaced by the horizontal lines inside.

The separation of the two figured drawers to the top and the bottom create a pleasing balance.

Lots of ying and yangs.

I really like this piece.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#5

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

CStanford

Fantastic example of bona fide professional cabinetmaking from start to finish - conception, design, drawings, and execution of completed piece. The rest of us largely hack it up, truncating steps or not completing the steps in a professional and workman like manner as you have. A professional, like you, can think it, draw it, sell it, then execute it.

When people wonder about the difference between pro and accomplished amateur they need look no further than this project of yours.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#6

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Patrick Gibbons

It looks like an artistic rendering of a TV. The tambour is the show. I would love to have that in my house. As for details, it is very interesting to me how much the handles on the tambour add to the look of the cabinet when it is open. I can't tell from the picture, is the inside back maple or cherry? From your comments I believe it's maple. While the tambour is bold, the color change is organic. I really like it.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#7

Questions

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

How is the top fastened on? What do you finish something like this with to keep the colors true after finishing and over time? I expect the color scheme was precisely thought out and any change in the color from the finish would throw off the desired effect.

Love the shape and it would look great in rift ash or maple, as well as the rift cherry....including the doors.

While my mind is on the thought of color, furniture doesn't usually rely on a color scheme to make the piece. Rather, it is usually shape and grain, things that don't change over time, or even refinishing. Were I to be a perspective buyer I would wonder about the longevity of the appearance of this piece. But then that is what research is about. Experiment and observe the results. I admire your tolerance for risk.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#8

Re: Questions

john sayles

Wow - so this was done with "hand tools"?

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#9

a guess

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I'll bet, like most woodworking of this caliber, it was done with what ever tool was best for the task with power tools serving the role of apprentice.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#10

Color

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Furniture usually doesn't rely on color to make the piece? A lot of amateurs don't worry about color, but if you are trying to sell the furniture it is a different story.

Power tools serve the role of apprentice? I think that if you actually worked in a hand tool shop you would be disabused of this notion rather quickly. It is pretty easy to teach a 12 year old to make dovetails , mortise and tenon, even carving. Much harder to learn ripping or stock preparation and be efficient at it. And it is hard to imagine journeymen sitting around drinking tea while apprentices got the stuff ready for them to go to work.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#11

Very nice

Ron Harper

I agree with Bill H.

I am impressed by the small changes in line and shape.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#12

Power tool as apprentice?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I don't think Bill Tindall was picturing the journeymen in an all hand tool shop sitting around drinking tea while the apprentices did prep work; organization of work for good flow, and having multiple projects going to maintain that flow, is hardly a new concept, and I imagine that the work of the apprentices was assigned so that their tasks coordinated with the tasks of the journeymen.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#13

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Richard,

Thank you for showing us what happened! I have a feeling this torpedore is going to be much anthologized in future surveys of modern design. It's a classic of our era.

Like Bill and Derek, I am struck by the subtleties: The top being rather thin draws the eye quickly to the horizontal (much more than a thicker top would--the eye is attracted by the 'tension' of the thiner weight), which balances all the vertical emphasis elsewhere such as the tambours, the legs, and the rift grain of the sides.

The fully sculptured legs (not just curved in front elev, but also side elev), and the bold curvature--it's not trying to be subtle, but the sculpting takes extra wood out and gives them lightness and tension. The placement of the center of curvature (that Derek spoke of) enhances the effect.

Truly a piece of work to be proud of! And amazingly, all the features were designed in in the first place.

Wiley

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#14

Re: Questions

CStanford

Tolerance for risk? In the dyed tambour? "Reliance on color?"

What in the hell......

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#15

Re: Power tool as apprentice?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think work flow is kind of a 20th century concept. One of the reasons for doubting the idea that multiple projects supported that flow is the crowded shop conditions in former times. There wasn't a lot of room for multiple projects. Here is a carriagemaker from 1900 or so: four guys in a space that is smaller than many solo workshops today.


img

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#16

Re: Questions? ... Shhhh ...

Bruce McCrory

Shush ... little one. It's only the wind trying to come down the chimney.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#17

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Bruce McCrory

I like! Fresh.

I thought Krenov Disease had set in....

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#18

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Sgian Dubh

Thanks for the comments Derek.

You're correct in your reading of the legs. The outer curve is not an arc, it's a spline created in AutoCAD that has a tighter radius in the upper third of the leg than it has in the lower two thirds. The width (radius) at the foot is 30 mm and at the top it's 40 mm.

I think this is one of those pieces that has what we in the UK call a 'Marmite' quality, ie, most people either love it ot hate it. You seem to be more in the first camp. Slainte.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#19

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Sgian Dubh

Charles, your flattery is making me embarrassed, but I appreciate it too. Slainte.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#20

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Sgian Dubh

Patrick, the back panel is maple veneered MDF. Slainte.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#21

Re: Questions

Sgian Dubh

John, you may have, or you may not have noticed in my first post there was a mention of CNC work. Is there some reason I shouldn't take advantage of whatever tools and equipment are available to me?

I don't understand what point you were trying to make. It's not important to me that this section of WoodCentral is headed by the title 'Hand Tools. I'm aware that users of this particular forum are usually passionate about woodworking, furniture, joinery, design issues, tools, and generally enjoy looking at examples of a design exercise leading to a finished item. This area of WoodCentral sees a great deal less of 'OT' subjects than the main forum, and woodworking subjects are dissected, ruminated over and debated in great detail.

I contribute here more frequently than I contribute anywhere else on WoodCentral, although at best I'm no more than an intermittent contributor in this forum, yet almost every visitor to the Hand Tools forum (I suspect) generally knows I care little for how a result was achieved.

I like to think I know my way around hand tools pretty well, and a great many were used in the making of Torpedore, but I can't deny that I also used AutoCAD, AlphaCAM, a CNC machine, finish spraying facilities, and such things as three phase surface and thickness planers, spindle moulders, bandsaws, etc.

I'm trying to work out from your inscrutable comment if you have a problem with those woodworking methods, because I can't see what it might be. I also tend to the thinking that those that gravitate primarily to hand tool usage in their woodworking endeavours are perfectly able to assess and critique wooden artefacts (furniture) made using methods not restricted to just hand tools. Slainte.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#22

we settled that question some time ago

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It's just good to have you participate. Design is design. How you got there is important. How you built it is less so, except to the extent that there are many of us who would like to be able to learn from the process you used.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#23

Re: Questions

Sgian Dubh

Bill, the top is simply screwed into place from the underside. It had to be fastened in place to the main cherry carcase prior to installing the maple 'sub' cabinet, which itself is screwed into the cherry carcass. There was no special allowance for expansion and contraction because the grain of the top is in the same direction as the grain of the cherry carcass.

The dyes used are spirit dyes of the so-called non-fading type. They were applied with a spray gun and the polish is pre-cat lacquer. I imagine there will be change in the colour over the years, but I suspect they'll remain vibrant for a few decades.

I suppose something so strikingly coloured does involve risk, although I really didn't consider it to be so because I was trying to achieve an outer appearance that really drew the eye. Form proportion, shape, rhythm, balance, etc, as well as the unexpected use of colour I think managed to do that. Slainte.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#24

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Sgian Dubh

Wiley, I appreciate your considered comments. Slainte.

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

#25

Re: Torpedore- a completed cabinet.

Sgian Dubh

I'm glad you like it Bruce, but I don't understand the Krenov Disease comment. I'm not being snippy, I just don't understand it.

To be honest, and I should probably whisper it especially as this is an American based forum, I've never been a full-blown Krenov fan-- there's respect on my part of course, but I'm not at all influenced by him as far as I can tell: I could never get through more than a page or two of any of his books before I wanted to throw it away. I know, it's a sacrilegious stance to take in many woodworking circles, but that's just me I suppose, possibly because my furniture making endeavours were informed more by British tradition and industrial workshops than through other influences. Slainte.