New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Riving

Posts

Re: Riving

#26

Stephen Shepherd

Thank You Mr. Reductio ad absurdum

Stephen Shepherd

Red Herrings, ad hominems, lets throw in a dilemma, paradox and conundrum to the mix.

As for the first photograph, if it were a chestnut log, Mr. Lincoln could have split it into rails before you could talk about your fancy gas powered chain saw.

As for the second picture, have you ever seen a puncheon floor from an old barn? Split from poplar, 5 feet wide, 16 feet long and over 3 feet thick in the center and way to big to be sawn.

Get some of your information correct please.

Stephen

Re: Riving

#27

This has become a silly discussion

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

The people I know that make Windsor and ladder back chairs like to split out their parts. Seems to be a part of the enjoyment of chair making. The obvious fact that it can be easily done no doubt enables making your own parts a practical part of chair making. This is the only branch of woodworking where I encounter wood splitters. (I do split locust posts because it mostly works and when it works the logs split easily and reliably. But I don't consider it hand tool woodworking)

The people that make tables and chests of drawers saw their wood, no doubt because it was discovered several centuries ago that splitting was an inferior way to get these parts .

It would seem that these obvious facts would leave this topic with nothing useful to discuss.

Re: Riving

#28

Amen


Re: Riving

#29

The machines decided


Re: Riving

#30

Re: The machines decided

wilbur

Ever since Skynet became self-aware, things have been messed up.

Re: Riving

#31

Re: Meet Mr. Tautology.

MikeL

With slight modification, I guess we can also write:

"So yeah, sawing is faster under ideal circumstances for those projects where sawing is faster. Kinda a tautology."

Re: Riving

#32

Re: Thank You Mr. Reductio ad absurdum

TomD

It wasn't an ad hominem, it was the tautology that I was refering to as Mr. Your statement was general, as in always faster. I'm the guy drawing the distinctions, so your 5 foot wide floorboard does not harm my point, though it is certainly interesting.

Re: Riving

#33

Re: Meet Mr. Tautology.

TomD

I agree. But I am not in the business of claiming it is always faster. I am in the horses for course camp. It is the folks who are in the always faster, always stronger, always follows the grain camp, whose point hangs in the balance should one counter example appear.

Re: Riving

#34

Re: This has become a silly discussion

TomD

"The people I know that make Windsor and ladder back chairs like to split out their parts. Seems to be a part of the enjoyment of chair making. The obvious fact that it can be easily done no doubt enables making your own parts a practical part of chair making. This is the only branch of woodworking where I encounter wood splitters."

It is common in other activities, split cane rods, though not actually wood; the very vibrant field of bowmaking; Maybe still at the factory level in arrow making; Musical instrument sound boards, and so forth. There are many times when I have a small part to make that I split it out rather than saw it for safety reasons.

"It would seem that these obvious facts would leave this topic with nothing useful to discuss."

The main points to me, though the discussion appears to have broken down, is the always faster, with the grain, and stronger bit.

Re: Riving

#35

Re: This has become a silly discussion

Kees

Once upon a time, overhere in The Netherlands, we had a triving wainscot business. Wainscot was riven oak paneling. We're talking 16th/17th/18th century now. Oak was imported by the boatload from Eastern Europe, riven in panels and sold all over Europe. Any old chest, or wall panel was made with wainscot. It is really beautifull full of ray flecks. Waanschot is the Dutch word. So it must have been profitable at that time, despite the fact that the Dutch had loads of wind powered sawmills too.

Re: Riving

#36

Almost nothing is ever always


Re: Riving

#37

Who used the word "always"?


Re: Riving

#38

a good example

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Quarter sawing is not efficient on most mills. If the goal was quartered lumber, the source was old growth white oak and the lengths were short splitting out the billets would be quick, much quicker than sawing. Ditto for oak shingles, widely used here in TN in the early days. I used to see them on some old abandoned cabins up in the "hollows".

Splitting billets will be quickest when the desired lengths are short, the species splits easy and predictably and, the logs are available that yield straight grained appropriate lengths. Deviate from this specific situation and sawing reigns. ( excluding the micro market for bows, and is there anyone hunting now days that doesn't use carbon fiber arrows?)

For a time drawer parts in Philly were made from white cedar, derived from split shingle stock.

Re: Riving

#39

Another example

Kees

Beech billets for plane making and probably saw handles too. The old ones usually are perfectly quartered with beautifull ray fleck patterns. And for a plane this layout is also technically the best, no warping troubles in a dado plane for example.

The best quarter"sawn" wood and the most yield from a log is when you rive it. In short lengths that should still be possible even on a rather large scale, if there was still demand for such wood. I don't think anyone in the furniture business cares about it though. Peter Follansbee is a living example that riving is still possible today. He works in a museum though, which probably says enough.

The only large scale splitting and riving being done today is probably in the firewood business. So, all nice straight grained wood is ending up in the stove.

Re: Riving

#40

Re: Another example

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think your comments about beech planes are a bit overstated and maybe romanticised. I have made planes from both sawn and riven material. A good sawyer can make very nice quartered material and there is usually less planing work with sawn stock. Even with riven material, once you have a flat side planed, it is often expedient to saw a parallel side before planing flat. If I had a beech log that I wanted to get the most yield from in usable plane blanks, I would choose sawing for that yield. And I have certainly seen old planes that were made of wood that could not have been riven economically.

Here is an excerpt form the Seaton chest book:

In examining the kit of planes one is struck by the poor quality of timber used. There are numerous knots and places where wild grain is present . . . Given material of this type, it is highly unlikely that it would have been riven: poor-quality timber will not split readily.

Re: Riving

#41

Re: Another example

Kees

Well, I bow to your knowledge, sir!

The Seaton planes indeed seem to be pretty subpar. i have some planes from that period (Dutch and British) and most of them are perfect. I also have a late 19th century fillester with a big knot in the side! It still works allright though.

When you want that wunderfull ray fleck pattern on the side like, you only seem to find on these old planes, you need it quite exactly qs. Often the other side is rather bland in that case.

Re: Riving

#42

Ray fleck

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It is interesting that you say that the ray fleck is often only pronounced on one side. When you have a billet that is slightly wedge shaped (with two radial surfaces that are not quite parallel), you have a choice of keeping one nice radial face or taking some off each side for more uniformity. Maybe the traditional method was to flatten the best radial surface and take all the wedge from the other side. I don't know.

Re: Riving

#43

Re: Ray fleck

Kees

And of course when the rings are almost flat, you can squeeze out more rayfleck on both sides. But I often find just a little tilt in the rings removes all the flecks from the radial surface. At least for me, it's often hard to predict.

Re: Riving

#44

You clearly have not had experience with Am. Beech

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Most firewood places won't bother with it. I have a lot of it and it is otherwise valueless so I, with effort, burn it, splitting as little as I can get by with.

Typical splitting procedure. Drive in two large steel wedges with 10 pound maul. Add two dogwood wedges and drive them as far as possible. Remove the steel wedges and chop the fibers holding the two sides together to free them.....Repeat.

Unlike oak one never knows where the split line will travel. For oak, if it is dry, I can split it with two or a few whacks with a 8 pound splitting maul even if the log is 2' in diameter. Oak just pops apart. Nothing splits as easily as oak.

Re: Riving

#45

Re: You clearly have not had experience with Am. B

Kees

No indeed :D

In Europe Beech is highly regarded for fuel. It splits easilly, dries fast, has a high caloric value and it grows in abundance. Large straight trees.