Re: Not true, still
TomD
"I disagree with you on several counts. For one,wood that is "steered" doesn't cross grain."
Yes it does, if you look at the continuum, from splitting to getting out ash basket stock, it becomes all the more obvious. whether it crosses grain is a mater of dimensions, and intent of the craftsman. When the dimensions are wrong, you can't stop it crossing, which is why it is a limited technique. Which is OK.
"Riving separates two pieces of wood along the path of least resistance.When a piece starts to split ,the split can travel at an angle off of parallel by pushing on one side or the other with a froe but the split still follows a line of least resistance,a possible future break."
That is the cross grain happening. The path is a function of the grain, but also forces. Try to rive 1/8" off a balk of 3x3, and you will see the cross grain ripping happening.
"When you cut a piece with a saw you ignore the grain and cut to follow your intended shape."
That is not a rule. Brian Boggs gave up splitting some parts and now saws them because the saw does a better job. So if I am cutting out a Mahog neck, I will look for the grain line and when possible cut the waste so the grain follow the plane of the finger board.
"When making a piece of furniture with sawn wood you don't have to stick with straight grained wood. If you make a chair leg out of a piece that is sawn, that leg if stressed would break following that line of least resistance."
It is a decision you have to follow or not to follow. If you start with the same veneer grade log, you can saw with the grain or not, and you can saw "inferior" pieces. But the function is only compromised if the run out makes the part insufficiently strong, that run out is pretty bad, as I said aircraft spars are 20-1.
"You say it's not done because it isn't necessary. I say it's not done because it is far cheaper and easier to make the chair with wood that another person would discard as not straight enough."
That doesn't apply to us, I don't care what the factories do. I'm OK with what the EAA says for aircraft and Boggs and other do with chairs. Aesthetics often forces grain alignment also. A tapered leg can look awful without the grain alignment, most of us are already doing the right thing without making a big deal about it. A badsaw generally allows far more precise grain decisions, because it can cut at any angle.
"Also,riving is not practical using machinery."
Or desirable, you can cut any line you want. Rivers are the ones with most of the limits.
"There are far more poorly built chairs out there than good ones. Does that mean that the poor makers are right? I see many broken chairs in my job. In this capacity I am grateful for poor construction,it gives me work. However,I would much rather repair a well built chair than some of the miserable stuff I see."
This doesn't apply to us. We are above that.
"Riven chairs almost always come into my shop for regluing loose joints. Some of these chairs are over a century old. Delicate spindles that have resisted breaking for 100 years of use. The evidence is there to see."
The myth isn't that riven parts aren't good, the myth is that that is the only way to align grain, that is simply false, and people who sell stuff using that argument should beware. The other part of the myth is that 0 runout wood is required for absolute top drawer best of the best work, that is mostly not true. And if one wants to claim it is true, one should have some facts. I don't mean that confrontationally, just where is the evidence?
Part of the reason for this myth is that there isn't much middle ground, we have old windsors and the ones made by premium makers, and we have the factory junk. But if Michael Dunbar suffered terrible arthritis, but wanted to carry on, he could do the exact same chair with a bandsaw. I don't know about the back spindles I wouldn't want to have to saw those...
"Riving is not used because it isn't financially practical. It makes more sense and should be taught to more woodworkers. I'm not saying it is needed for all furniture. All I'm saying is that it is not overused. It is being forgotten."
I know you mean the factories. I get that and agree. But I have 125 acres, a lot of it in red oak, and I rarely find pieces that riv well, they almost all have slight twist (does anyone know whether the norther forests are more prone to twist due to position of the sun?). This wood is often perfect stuff, I don't have a BS at the farm so I get very poor yields splitting it. The ability to use 100% quality wood that has slight twist is very financially useful even to the small guy. Twist actually makes the part stronger too, it won't split as easily. They should charge extra. The guys I know and read about who do the pro work, spec veneer grade logs. These are expensive and unavailable to many of us. This wood is really over the top for most parts of the chair.
"I have seen some well built,beautiful chairs that were built ignoring grain and other practicalities for art's sake and I find no fault there.Lots of furniture would not benefit in any way from riving,but in some cases,as with windsor chairs,it does."
If you have the proper grade of wood riving is the most efficient and fun way to build, but it does not build any more strength into the chair than sawing out the parts along the same planes.
"I just don't articulate well."
Don't agree with that either! 