New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Riving

Posts

Riving

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Riving

Jack Guzman from Maine

Riving and the importance of it was brought up in another thread. I wanted to comment on that without highjacking that thread .

For several years now I have been learning to build Windsor chairs. I also repair furniture.I fix chairs mostly. In that capacity I early-on became aware of the importance of riving. Most chair breaks occur at points where there is grain runout. I have seen legs broken because the grain wasn't continuous through the leg. Also spindles that were turned in factory made chairs usually break with the grain.

When I build a windsor chair I rive legs before turning. I look for straight grained woods to rive for this purpose. I avoid woods with knots or wavy grain.When making spindles I rive to rough thickness and shave following the grain to final size. In windsor style chairs that are made without riving,the spindles are thicker by necessity. With my chairs a 3/8" thick spindle is not a weak piece. In fact when green it is difficult to break one of these if I try.Thin spindles give a chair back "give".It makes for a more comfortable seat.

Chair arms that need to be steam bent would break while bending if not riven.

This is just my own personal experience. I'm sure there are other woodworking areas where riving is necessary or at least very beneficial.

comments?---Jack

Re: Riving

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

No Doubt

Jim in Burlington On

I have no doubt as the best wooden ladders are made that way. If all furniture was made by using that method it might cost twice as much but last for a couple hundred years.

Re: Riving

#3

Re: Not true

TomD

Lack of run-out and riving are two separate things. Structurally, low grain run-out is generally key, there are exceptions, but 99% of the time that would be true. Riving is just a means to achieve that goal, it is often not the best means, and as was pointed out in the other thread riving can be steered, which indicates it does not always result in low run-out, in fact it probably doesn't in almost all cases. Riving can also stress wood in ways that are not good for structure. Some very strong woods do not riv well like elm. Some shapes, well most, don't riv well. Wood that is dry may not riv well, or split. But in optimal cases, it is satisfying, efficient and creates products with good structure.

In most cases low run-out wood is neither desirable, nor necessary. The main evidence for that is that it is generally not used. Most products are not structurally that heavily tested; require grain run out; are laminated, etc...; have engineered standards that are well below the level windsor chaimakers, arrow makers, etc... require. As I mentioned in the other thread. Aircraft graded wood is high run-out by riving magic standards. About 20-1 rather than perfect. And boats are in the 12-1 through 8-1 range.

The riving thing is one of those myths of woodworking.

Re: Riving

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Not true

Jack Guzman from Maine

I disagree with you on several counts. For one,wood that is "steered" doesn't cross grain.Riving separates two pieces of wood along the path of least resistance.When a piece starts to split ,the split can travel at an angle off of parallel by pushing on one side or the other with a froe but the split still follows a line of least resistance,a possible future break.When you cut a piece with a saw you ignore the grain and cut to follow your intended shape.When making a piece of furniture with sawn wood you don't have to stick with straight grained wood. If you make a chair leg out of a piece that is sawn, that leg if stressed would break following that line of least resistance.

You say it's not done because it isn't necessary. I say it's not done because it is far cheaper and easier to make the chair with wood that another person would discard as not straight enough. Also,riving is not practical using machinery.There are far more poorly built chairs out there than good ones. Does that mean that the poor makers are right? I see many broken chairs in my job. In this capacity I am grateful for poor construction,it gives me work. However,I would much rather repair a well built chair than some of the miserable stuff I see. Riven chairs almost always come into my shop for regluing loose joints. Some of these chairs are over a century old. Delicate spindles that have resisted breaking for 100 years of use. The evidence is there to see.

Riving is not used because it isn't financially practical. It makes more sense and should be taught to more woodworkers. I'm not saying it is needed for all furniture. All I'm saying is that it is not overused. It is being forgotten.

I have seen some well built,beautiful chairs that were built ignoring grain and other practicalities for art's sake and I find no fault there.Lots of furniture would not benefit in any way from riving,but in some cases,as with windsor chairs,it does.

I have alot more,I just don't articulate well.---Jack

Re: Riving

#5

My own experiences

Bob Hackett

Many times riving or splitting out pieces work with the wood in ways that work with rather than against the strengths of the material. These split parts follow the nature of the wood and the natural flow of the grain as it grew in the tree. Sawn wood is most often processed for highest yield, for show (such as quarter sawn oak) or for dimensional stability ( traditional cedar siding) rather than for things like strength and flexibility.

Jack mentioned two instances where riving is critical for success, chair making and bending wood, I would add basket making and making tool handles to that list. As Tom mentions, there are ways around this, such a laminating, that allow you to use inferior grade material in many of the same applications but other than for convenience sake why would you?

The whole point to WWing is take trees and make either useful or beautiful things from them. Seems to me one of the best ways to begin the process would be to have a better understanding of trees and the wood that comes from them as a departure point. This is an area that most WWer`s seem to overlook. Most of the WWers I know are content to repeat myth, dogma and mistaken assumptions about material rather than do some research or spend time in the woods rather than the lumber yard.

The exceptional strength, flexibility and beauty of using riven wood from trees most appropriate to the project at hand is most definitely NOT one of those myths.

Re: Riving

#6

Question about riving

Patrick Gibbons

I associate riving with green wood. Is it successful with dried lumber? If not then that's why it's not done as much. I have virtually no access to green wood, other than yellow pine.

Re: Riving

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Question about riving

Jack Guzman from Maine

When making chairs,it is better to use green wood but dried wood can be riven as well. I'd guess that this is how shakes were made. Some woods split easily wet or dry. Try it on a 4x4 of straight grained fir or something similar.---Jack

Re: Riving

#8

Re: Not true

Jim Crammond

First off, to insure we are talking about the same thing, I assume this is about the verb rive, pronounced with a long i that rhymes with hive. According to the Webster's Third New International dictionary to rive means to make or form (as laths or boards) by splitting. I didn't find an entry for riv.

Tom D. wrote "The riving thing is one of those myths of woodworking." As Jack said, I find this statement contrary to my experience. Riving makes use of the natural strength and weakness of the wood, i.e. in splitting it utilizes the natural weakness of the wood by splitting with the grain. In use it takes advantage of the strength of the long grain. Some woods such as elm do not rive well so historically, I doubt that it was riven,

Roy Underhill devotes Chapter 2 of his latest book, "Working Wood With Wedge and Edge" to the subject of riving wood. He says in part "Wagon spokes, chair rungs, hayforks-anything where strength is essential- all are riven from the log...Sawn stock, weaker and costlier. Riven stock cheaper and stronger." According to Bruce Hoadley in "Understanding Wood", Straightness of grain is important because of the effect it has on strength properties."..."Bending and tensile strengths are more drastically affected (then compressive strength). Modules of rupture, for example, is reduced by about 20% by a slope of 1:10 and by 45% by a slope of 1:5." Chapter 4 Strength of Wood

Riving is not appropriate for all types of woodworking, modern machinery allows for the quickest, most cost effective preparation of stock. There are some types of woodworking where it is the best, quickest method of getting the stock you need.

Jim

Re: Riving

#9

Change does not equal progress

Ron Harper

When machines began to be used to make furniture, many accomodations were made to speed production and cut costs. Not all those changes improved the products being produced. Just sayin......

Re: Riving

#10

Re: Not true, still

TomD

"I disagree with you on several counts. For one,wood that is "steered" doesn't cross grain."

Yes it does, if you look at the continuum, from splitting to getting out ash basket stock, it becomes all the more obvious. whether it crosses grain is a mater of dimensions, and intent of the craftsman. When the dimensions are wrong, you can't stop it crossing, which is why it is a limited technique. Which is OK.

"Riving separates two pieces of wood along the path of least resistance.When a piece starts to split ,the split can travel at an angle off of parallel by pushing on one side or the other with a froe but the split still follows a line of least resistance,a possible future break."

That is the cross grain happening. The path is a function of the grain, but also forces. Try to rive 1/8" off a balk of 3x3, and you will see the cross grain ripping happening.

"When you cut a piece with a saw you ignore the grain and cut to follow your intended shape."

That is not a rule. Brian Boggs gave up splitting some parts and now saws them because the saw does a better job. So if I am cutting out a Mahog neck, I will look for the grain line and when possible cut the waste so the grain follow the plane of the finger board.

"When making a piece of furniture with sawn wood you don't have to stick with straight grained wood. If you make a chair leg out of a piece that is sawn, that leg if stressed would break following that line of least resistance."

It is a decision you have to follow or not to follow. If you start with the same veneer grade log, you can saw with the grain or not, and you can saw "inferior" pieces. But the function is only compromised if the run out makes the part insufficiently strong, that run out is pretty bad, as I said aircraft spars are 20-1.

"You say it's not done because it isn't necessary. I say it's not done because it is far cheaper and easier to make the chair with wood that another person would discard as not straight enough."

That doesn't apply to us, I don't care what the factories do. I'm OK with what the EAA says for aircraft and Boggs and other do with chairs. Aesthetics often forces grain alignment also. A tapered leg can look awful without the grain alignment, most of us are already doing the right thing without making a big deal about it. A badsaw generally allows far more precise grain decisions, because it can cut at any angle.

"Also,riving is not practical using machinery."

Or desirable, you can cut any line you want. Rivers are the ones with most of the limits.

"There are far more poorly built chairs out there than good ones. Does that mean that the poor makers are right? I see many broken chairs in my job. In this capacity I am grateful for poor construction,it gives me work. However,I would much rather repair a well built chair than some of the miserable stuff I see."

This doesn't apply to us. We are above that.

"Riven chairs almost always come into my shop for regluing loose joints. Some of these chairs are over a century old. Delicate spindles that have resisted breaking for 100 years of use. The evidence is there to see."

The myth isn't that riven parts aren't good, the myth is that that is the only way to align grain, that is simply false, and people who sell stuff using that argument should beware. The other part of the myth is that 0 runout wood is required for absolute top drawer best of the best work, that is mostly not true. And if one wants to claim it is true, one should have some facts. I don't mean that confrontationally, just where is the evidence?

Part of the reason for this myth is that there isn't much middle ground, we have old windsors and the ones made by premium makers, and we have the factory junk. But if Michael Dunbar suffered terrible arthritis, but wanted to carry on, he could do the exact same chair with a bandsaw. I don't know about the back spindles I wouldn't want to have to saw those...

"Riving is not used because it isn't financially practical. It makes more sense and should be taught to more woodworkers. I'm not saying it is needed for all furniture. All I'm saying is that it is not overused. It is being forgotten."

I know you mean the factories. I get that and agree. But I have 125 acres, a lot of it in red oak, and I rarely find pieces that riv well, they almost all have slight twist (does anyone know whether the norther forests are more prone to twist due to position of the sun?). This wood is often perfect stuff, I don't have a BS at the farm so I get very poor yields splitting it. The ability to use 100% quality wood that has slight twist is very financially useful even to the small guy. Twist actually makes the part stronger too, it won't split as easily. They should charge extra. The guys I know and read about who do the pro work, spec veneer grade logs. These are expensive and unavailable to many of us. This wood is really over the top for most parts of the chair.

"I have seen some well built,beautiful chairs that were built ignoring grain and other practicalities for art's sake and I find no fault there.Lots of furniture would not benefit in any way from riving,but in some cases,as with windsor chairs,it does."

If you have the proper grade of wood riving is the most efficient and fun way to build, but it does not build any more strength into the chair than sawing out the parts along the same planes.

"I just don't articulate well."

Don't agree with that either! :)

Re: Riving

#11

Re: My own experiences

TomD

"Jack mentioned two instances where riving is critical for success, chair making and bending wood, I would add basket making and making tool handles to that list."

I certainly don't want to saw ash basket stock. But tool handles, chairs and wood for bending do not require riven stock or even sawn stock that is zero aligned. Arrows are an example of objects far more highly stressed and they do not require it (though I generally require it, no down side to being picky). Many chair parts are very thick, and do not require riving to get alignment, or alignment to be strong enough. Metal straps will allow one to bend almost any wood. When bending stuff like ebony binding on guitars, one often has no idea what the grain orientation is, since there isn't any early or late wood to give a clue. Same with any tropical wood. This is the mythmaking at work. Riving might be a good way to get from a-b, but it is not magic beans.

"The exceptional strength, flexibility and beauty of using riven wood from trees most appropriate to the project at hand is most definitely NOT one of those myths."

It absolutely is mythmaking. We could take a log, cut one ladderback chair leg out by BS, and another by riving, take them to finish; hand them and 200 others so prepared over to you and I guarantee that you will not have any idea which ones were riven, and which ones were sawn. What sawing won't do is allow you the same experience of making, aesthetically, and otherwise, but the end result is going to be the same in most cases, and I am sure a machine could be made to cover all cases. Final ahdn finishing can make a difference, but how you bust the wood out does not.

I also covered in the other thread the technical cases where scraping is your huckleberry.

Re: Riving

#12

Re: Not true

TomD

"Roy Underhill devotes Chapter 2 of his latest book, "Working Wood With Wedge and Edge" to the subject of riving wood. He says in part "Wagon spokes, chair rungs, hayforks-anything where strength is essential- all are riven from the log"...Sawn stock, weaker and costlier."

Obviously they were riven since they didn't electricity and chinese bandsaws, or even Italian ones... Sawing was by hand, or by mill, which is obviously going to have a price attached. In the modern world riving often raises the cost either in dollars, wasted wood, or elbow grease (a good thing to spend in my case since I don't have a gym memberships).

"Riven stock... and stronger."

This is obviously not the case in some regards. I have been working with wood in engineering applications (not an engineer, but read everything I can get my hands on, acutaly tests parts in jigs, get old WWII texts when wood was pushed to the max, and hang my a$$ out there were failure means very bad things could happen to me and my kids, etc..) When you see a bogus claim like that you have to consider some stuff:

- stronger how? Not along the plane of the split. That is probably a minor point in many apps, but not all.

- stronger than strong enough? Surplus strength is not a benefit, and should not drive one to great efforts in the shop or argument. Some parts are chairs are more subject to breakage than other.

- Is there a possibility of just using a larger piece, this is basically the story behind the lower half of a windsor. Yeah I get that in some cases this would be off point, but the history of woodworking is adapting to changing wood stock availabiliity, and the history of chairs is on to sawn wood, M&T, laminated or extreme bent wood.

"According to Bruce Hoadley in "Understanding Wood", Straightness of grain is important because of the effect it has on strength properties."..."Bending and tensile strengths are more drastically affected (then compressive strength). Modules of rupture, for example, is reduced by about 20% by a slope of 1:10 and by 45% by a slope of 1:5." Chapter 4 Strength of Wood"

So basically you have to have a concept of where the weakness in a design is. In most chairs it is at the joints. The governing loads are the ones that have to be met to hold the joints together. By the time a piece is big enough to provide that strength it may be big enough to render concerns about grain straightness moot. To get back 20% strength in a 1.25" diameter leg you need to increase the diameter by 11%. So if the leg would have been ok at 3/4" but it needed to be beefed up to 1.25" to carry the joints, the strength got upped 2.8 times already. And 10-1 is terrible grain, that would on a rung be complete runout every 5 or so inches. Who uses wood like that?

Neat quotes!

Re: Riving

#13

Re: Myths don't equal quality either.

TomD

You are right, the reverse is also true. But the simple point is that A) You can get grain alignment in most cases better with a saw than riving; B) stronger than strong enough gets you nothing.

The real problem is that in a competitive environment, the last cut you make is your profit. This very often means that the race to the bottom goes several cuts too far and products take hits they can't recover from. But that has nothing to do with the individual craftsman.

Re: Riving

#14

Splitting oak

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I don't know anything about riving but I have split vast piles of red oak for firewood. At least here in TN oak tends to split easily and parallel to the length of the trunk, unless the piece is cut where the butt swells in which case the grain follow the profile of the butt swell. I am more inclined to think harsh climate leads to lack of straight grain than latitude. The high elevation pine in the western states typically grows with a spiral grain readily seen in the dead trees.

I have been to an Ames Tool factory where ash handles are sawed. The lumber is sawed like for any other application, then the blanks are inspected and those with unacceptable grain runout are rejected.

Re: Riving

#15

Trying to understand the differences...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Folks,

Is this disagreement about two alternate ways--riving and band-sawing along grain lines--to obtain sticks with little or no run out?

I thought the difference that Jack and Bob were originally bringing out, was between riving and just running lumber through a saw in whatever way it came off the log, with no attention to grain orientation.

Isn't Tom D. saying one can get a similar functional result from band-sawing, by sawing to follow grain lines?

If the above is so, then I believe saying "riving is a myth" is incorrect. Tom's true argument seems to be that there is at least one alternative to riving that will get an equal result.

Wiley

Re: Riving

#16

You are correct, sir

CStanford

...he said channeling Ed McMahon

http://s1051.photobucket.com/user/CharlesStanford/library/

Re: Riving

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

and I agree with that

Jack Guzman from Maine

This thread is getting me confused. I'm not even sure where to put this reply.I agree that riving and sawing with the grain are just as good. I never heard these myths and I make no claims that riving is the only way. I think riving is a forgotten practice and should be brought more into the light. It has it's place in woodworking but is by no means the only way to an end. It is a useful practice.I don't know what the disagreement is about.Or if there even is any.---Jack

Re: Riving

#18

He is pseudo riving.

Ron Harper

Just using a power tool to do it

Re: Riving

#19

The difference may be...

Bob Hackett

The difference between the straight grained old growth trees that were available when the practice of riving was more widely used to produce workable stock and the less desirable second, third growth and plantation forests we draw from now.

Sawing may be quicker, more cost effective and produce acceptable parts with higher yield rates when dealing with most trees being felled today.

For me the primary difference is in the understanding of the nature of the wood starting with a better understanding of the things that produce it, trees. From there it progresses to how to best dry your locally harvested wood. This type of consideration becomes lost when we either mail order or run down to the lumber yard and buy whatever is available with little regard to things like grain direction, case hardening, induced stress due to drying, dimensional stability, wood movement, etc.

Always a way to "work around" something by using glued lamination or other reinforcement, increasing size to add strength or using modern adhesives such as epoxy to bolster wood or joint strength. Many times a deeper understanding of the material along with proper selection and preparation of the stock negates the need for most of these additional measures. When your 20 something football player son flops his full weight down in that relatively light weight and flexible chair you made and then leans it back on two legs you`ll be glad you split those legs out and didn`t stop at "good enough" or use a "work around".

I know some very accomplished WWers who still believe the myth that durable and reliable furniture can only be made from kiln dried wood. Many types of Myths grow and are perpetuated on both sides of whatever fence we`re standing around. Myths cease to perpetuate when we share knowledge based on both confirmed fact and experience. I have yet to see anyone publishing something that disproves Hoadley`s extensive work in the field of understanding wood in relation to it`s strengths and weaknesses.

One of the truly big mistakes made most recently by the wood industry was with pressure treating softwood for rot resistance by way of processing that wood using things like heavy metals such as arsenic and copper. A better understanding of appropriate materials, construction techniques as well as finishing techniques by the end user would allow the same or better final results without over-processing or the use of dangerous and toxic substances to make a wood do something it isn`t suited for.

BTW- I too would consider sawing out to follow grain to be "Pseudo-riving" and wonder why someone would do it except to make up for lesser quality material or that they were attempting to make something from wood that doesn`t split well (Elm, some Oaks and Apple come to mind) . Careful selection of wood would allow you to "bust out" a part far more quickly and efficiently than reading, marking out and then following the line when developing these types of skills. Being able to do this type of prep work with a saw probably means you already have that deeper understanding part down. If you know how and why to follow the grain then all you need is the right grade log to make it happen. I personally would be more selective and stop trying to use ill suited or inferior grade material and a saw to make up for a poor choice in material.

Nobody in their right mind would consider riving woods like the Ebonies or Rosewoods unless they lived in a 3rd world country and had no other choice. Likewise they wouldn`t try it here in North America with difficult woods like Elm or Apple unless their chainsaws are dead and they really were desperate to drag that wood to the truck. I see those types of examples as an "apples (pun intended) and oranges" argument. It`d be like me saying burls and crotches are of no value in WWing because I can`t split them. :D

I love working with burl, curl, quilted figure, stump wood and crotch wood but keep my wedges and other riving tools in the truck when working with them. For those types of material it`s pretty much saws only but that doesn`t stop me from using them whenever I can get them :) .

Re: Riving

#20

Re: Trying to understand the differences...

TomD

"I thought the difference that Jack and Bob were originally bringing out, was between riving and just running lumber through a saw in whatever way it came off the log, with no attention to grain orientation."

Far be it for me to be on topic... :)

I would never pick up a piece of wood and shove it through a saw without looking at grain orientation, no serious woodworker wood in a demanding situation. There are doubtless jobs that require this, but I don't do it. I don't put pieces through a saw without looking to see whether the piece I am using will be cut with or against the grain.

"Isn't Tom D. saying one can get a similar functional result from band-sawing, by sawing to follow grain lines?"

That is exactly what I am saying, and that stronger than strong enough is meaningless.

"If the above is so, then I believe saying "riving is a myth" is incorrect. Tom's true argument seems to be that there is at least one alternative to riving that will get an equal result. "

The myth is that it is better, which we see repeated yet again below where Bob mentions his large son. Those legs would have been just as strong if sawn with the grain, and the chair might well have been as strong if the legs were sawn a little cros grain, because we still have no numbers for any of this stuff. They might have been a lot stronger if he had sawn the piece out of a curved knee type piece of wood, and not bashed it around riving it or steam bending it (where those techniques are used). Though the extra strenth may have been wasted on this chair.

Re: Riving

#21

Re: The difference may be...

TomD

"For me the primary difference is in the understanding of the nature of the wood starting with a better understanding of the things that produce it, trees. From there it progresses to how to best dry your locally harvested wood. This type of consideration becomes lost when we either mail order or run down to the lumber yard and buy whatever is available with little regard to things like grain direction, case hardening, induced stress due to drying, dimensional stability, wood movement, etc."

I could see how that might be a handicap for someone without trees on their property, felling, spliting, riving, milling, and hewing experience.

"Always a way to "work around" something by using glued lamination or other reinforcement, increasing size to add strength or using modern adhesives such as epoxy to bolster wood or joint strength. Many times a deeper understanding of the material along with proper selection and preparation of the stock negates the need for most of these additional measures."

The point about the larger dimensions is that the extra strength you seem to be after may have been reached long before we got to the dimension that made the joinery possible. And hoadley's numbers show that while there is strength loss, 1 degree here or there, which is within the losses from either method, is not critical.

" When your 20 something football player son flops his full weight down in that relatively light weight and flexible chair you made and then leans it back on two legs you`ll be glad you split those legs out and didn`t stop at "good enough" or use a "work around"."

This is the myth, there is no meaningful increase in strength by spliting out. There is in fact no increase in strength, zero. Some of the work around would be bad in some way perhaps, but they would not be weaker either. Laminations sure aren't. How can larger dimensions be weaker? There is in this area a desire to bless riving beyond it's purely practical means. At some point the part is the part. It does not mater how it got that way, CNC to riving, makes no difference.

"I know some very accomplished WWers who still believe the myth that durable and reliable furniture can only be made from kiln dried wood. Many types of Myths grow and are perpetuated on both sides of whatever fence we`re standing around. Myths cease to perpetuate when we share knowledge based on both confirmed fact and experience. I have yet to see anyone publishing something that disproves Hoadley`s extensive work in the field of understanding wood in relation to it`s strengths and weaknesses."

I doubt his work says that two identical wood specimens created by different means, have radically different structural properties. what he does say as you quoted him is that absolutely gross run-out such as you will never see in anything made for FWW or even the cheaper rags, is weaker by 20%. That isn't shaking me much.

"BTW- I too would consider sawing out to follow grain to be "Pseudo-riving" and wonder why someone would do it except to make up for lesser quality material or that they were attempting to make something from wood that doesn`t split well (Elm, some Oaks and Apple come to mind) ."

What about a gunstock, a musical instrument neck, a rib in a boat, pieces that are too large to move and need to be sawn on the spot. Some people have physical limitations, others don't have access to wet wood, don't want to buy the tools, who knows. I do riv parts, I have all the tools, I just don't buy the blarney. I may riv the part but it won't be the magic beans aspect. It will be whatever makes sense at the moment.

" Careful selection of wood would allow you to "bust out" a part far more quickly and efficiently than reading, marking out and then following the line when developing these types of skills." You have to read the part anyway, maybe if you have access to veneer grade logs which I don't you can just go about it one auto pilot. I don't find it slow on a Bandsaw, or I would just riv it. I just don't get that grade of wood very often.

"I personally would be more selective and stop trying to use ill suited or inferior grade material and a saw to make up for a poor choice in material."

That's the myth again, pieces of wood with slight spiral, and minor grain cross are not inferior in any way, and they are falling down along my beech every winter. They are inferior riving stock, but not chair stock. That's the myth again, the process is more important than the product (which it can indeed be), and let's pretend it is actually about the product.

"Nobody in their right mind would consider riving woods like the Ebonies or Rosewoods unless they lived in a 3rd world country and had no other choice. "

These things are relevant depending on what we are discussing. If all you do is build chair legs, and you have access to really great wood... Then... Have only hammer everything looks like a nail. and the above is an apples and oranges example, since all you build are chairs. But if we look at the universe of demanding structural woodworking riving isn't even a blip of relevance. Let's be frank. John Alexander' s book, and others like it, changed lives. People drank the Kool-aid, and not many of them boarded the plane back to the real world. That's a world where people still design planes made of wood, but in accordance with the needs of the structure, and not just the tools they prefer to use.

Re: Riving

#22

Re: and I agree with that

TomD

I am probably the only person who cares about these distinctions. I make up for it by caring a lot... :)

Also, I don't think this is the kind of disagreement were as say between power tool users of a type and hand tool users of a type, where if they met in a pub, they might not have much in common. It is just about technical stuff.

I'm active in a lot of different aspects of woodworking, and you get to see the ingrained prejudices that sometimes hold various crafts back. Different aspects of metal working see the effects of heat in completely and sometimes startlingly ignorant ways. If you are active in say welding, bicycle making, knife and tool making, and blacksmithing, it is hard to stand by and just watch these guys run into walls when you know the answer to their very problem. But there is often something unspoken, a deep prejudice that does not want to change, so just sticking your head up and giving the answer leads to a ton of resistance. Bicycle guys (to oversimplify) believe heat over about 700 degrees harms steel terribly. As you know that is a level where some useful steel properties do transition, tool hardness, through spring hardness. So someone should just tell them their steels don't hold enough carbon, so they could not worry about it, right? Oops, turns out their whole world revolves around that myth.

In our world we stick by methods that have no absolute advantage if they perpetuate the hand tool advantage. We want to believe. I riv stuff even though I know it makes no difference, it's fun, it is sometimes the tool for the job. My summer place is way more primative so I use tools like that. My winter place is way more cluttered so I use hand tools there also. One reason I use hand tool is because the lack of dust doesn't threaten my machine tools as much. I'm doing this stuff no mater what. Therefore I can release these myths since they don't actually do anything for me.

That is open to everyone. Woodwork the way you like to, not because of myths. Over time it will open up more of everything not less. If wood that could not be rived was "inferior" they wouldn't make cool stuff like Adagio or the de Havilland Mosquito bomber, and that would be too bad.

Re: Riving

#23

Stephen Shepherd

Riving is faster than sawing.


Re: Riving

#24

but best done with green wood


Re: Riving

#25

Re: Meet Mr. Tautology.

TomD

The point assumes we are talking about only those craft items like primitive chair legs, rake parts etc... Largely a list of essentially obsolete items. Items where riving is faster. So yeah, riving is faster under ideal circumstances for those projects where riving is faster. Kinda a tautology. Making the same project like a chair, by getting in touch with rounds, would be faster still, if you like the Flintstone vibe. These arguments only work when the playing field is well tilted to start with.

I remember once harvesting what I thought was a really nice piece of wood off my property for the bench of a shaving horse. We went at it with wedges and never got it apart. It had a slight twist and would not pop. I never thought to just rip it with the 026 Stihl. Probably due to oxygen depletion. Since I had to have that saw anyway, I could have sawn that piece in the time it took to get the splitting tools together.

I don't think you can riv this baby faster. I ended up spliting out the plane stock. But I got a solid bench top out of it also. 5 inches, or 4. This is a great example. I sawed some very valuable wood out of pieces that had substantial rot in them, and never would have been splitable, even if Thor had happened by to swing the hammer. The saw plane is lined up with the pith.


Riv this!