What's in a title?
Michael Donaldson
What are the differences between a Carpenter, a Jointer, and a Cabinetmaker? What would each make?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What's in a title?
Michael Donaldson
What are the differences between a Carpenter, a Jointer, and a Cabinetmaker? What would each make?
Depends on what time in history and what place
Re: What's in a title?
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Carpenters put up buildings, generally working on site. Joiners work at a bench, usually in a shop. They make furniture, windows and doors, mouldings, wainscoting, panelling, anything made at a bench.
In the late 17th century, the term cabinetmaker arose, referring to a joiner who made furniture exclusively. However the term cabinetmaker only rather slowly replaced the term joiner to mean a furniture maker. Throughout the 18th century fine furniture makers referred to themselves as joiners or cabinetmakers and some men used both terms.
In the late 19th century the term carpenter took on a general meaning of woodworker, and even today some people use the term for all woodworkers, whether they are making a deck or a highboy. With the revival of hand work in the 1970's the traditional terms joiner and cabinetmaker have been revived. Carpenter should probably be reserved for guys who put up buildings.
Today the term cabinetmaker is used by two different groups. Those who make traditional furniture, with an emphasis in hand work, and those who make kitchen cabinets and the like from sheet material. There is little overlap between these groups.
Re: What's in a title?
Bob Hackett
For those of us on the coast of Maine a "joiner" works on a boat. Most likely one made of wood.
Re: What's in a title?
TomD
I think these terms are reserved for those who have been through the seven year traditional apprenticeship. Carpenter in addition has the modern meaning for those who have their papers. I do joinery I make cabinets and many other things, I never refer to myself as a joiner or cabinetmaker, and I am not sure the phil Lowes of the world do or should either. I'm an amateur, and I don't take second place to anyone. It takes 35 years to get where I am, not seven. But I am not terribly useful to anyone else and it cost me most of what I might have otherwise made, not the reverse.
My Grandfather was a joiner in the early 20th. He couldn't have hired any of these American experts I don't think, since none of them were properly processed. A lot of these new experts are known because they teach, research and sell themselves, not because they could do what the old guys did. If they wanted to put in a long cold day for peanuts they wouldn't spend so much time in avoidance behaviours. As Franz Klausz said, and expert knows what to do next, and next, and next (and how to price it). He isn't a guy who doesn't know how to do it, but has a great video on what he figured out on how it might have been done in any of 40 ways. MY GF's worker's day started ripping stock by hand. Their time might have been better spent discussing saw design, or finding a "bench saw", but that wasn't how it worked.
Re: What's in a title?
Brian from Monument
I disagree that the terms should only apply to those that went through the antique system of apprenticeship, journeymen, master path to learn a trade. Those that practice the art of joinery or cabinetmaking can call themselves joiners or cabinetmakers regardless of how they got they learned what ever skills they have.
Their status within the profession will tell by the products they make.
Education has come a long way and yet not far enough for some. The system of indentured slavery or whatever you want call it is not current and superficially appears not to be legal anymore. Yet many professions that are younger have not yet grown the institutions (including professional slavery).
Further the work that one does is not identified by the grade of professional development it is graded by quality that is apparent. If we look at the products of a beginner, journeyman, master and a person who has self grown skills we don't label the work that way ; we evaluate it by it style, joinery, fit and finish (please add any other judgments that I have omitted for brevity).
I prefer to view those titles as a classification of skill sets and what I can expect them to be able to do. More along the lines of a plumber vs a cabinetmaker vs a framer vs a farmer vs a software developer vs a pilot just to name few related and unrelated professions.
Re: What's in a title?
TomD
You are free and should feel entitled to view those terms as you wish. The only advantage to my approach is that it is reality, in so far as it applies to the modern trades in many countries. But there isn't any reason why that should affect the US etc...
"I disagree that the terms should only apply to those that went through the antique system of apprenticeship, journeymen, master path to learn a trade. Those that practice the art of joinery or cabinetmaking can call themselves joiners or cabinetmakers regardless of how they got they learned what ever skills they have. Their status within the profession will tell by the products they make."
That last comment is exactly the point, you know them by what they do and not by the term. When I go to the doctor, I know he has a certain education, has sworn an oath etc... And in many cases is closely supervised, has requirement for continuing education, insurance... When a guy says he is a cabinetmaker, it means absolutely nothing, as you say, the work is definitive.
"Education has come a long way and yet not far enough for some. The system of indentured slavery or whatever you want call it is not current and superficially appears not to be legal anymore. Yet many professions that are younger have not yet grown the institutions (including professional slavery)."
I'm not really getting this, but you can go to some euro countries and do a legal apprenticeship, and come through it with a license to charge for your services. In the absence of doing that you can't bill and you can't hire. I like the freedom we have to practice without a license. I wouldn't give it up, or pretend to be a product of the rival system.
"Further the work that one does is not identified by the grade of professional development it is graded by quality that is apparent. If we look at the products of a beginner, journeyman, master and a person who has self grown skills we don't label the work that way ; we evaluate it by it style, joinery, fit and finish (please add any other judgments that I have omitted for brevity)."
In my world the Master is the schoolmaster type of master, not the hey look at me I am great master. So I don't know why I would call myself a master when I don't have a swelled head, or anyone I am a master over. Again if what counts is the product, then it stands by itself and pretending to be a professional when you are not doesn't make much sense. Professional has several senses, one just means I take money. Another means I am a member of a profession with standards, which serious woodworkers in the US aren't.
"I prefer to view those titles as a classification of skill sets and what I can expect them to be able to do. More along the lines of a plumber vs a cabinetmaker vs a framer vs a farmer vs a software developer vs a pilot just to name few related and unrelated professions."
I think that makes sense, but I would break the words out, and how they are used in three ways:
- One is a mater of identifying the area of specialization, though more often than not there isn't one.
- Another is a mater of specific titles that refer to stages in the apprenticeship; Journeyman, Master. People who aren't masters shouldn't call themselves that, any more that people should claim to have been Navy Seals, when they drove truck in a supply role. Since these terms aren't limited, one ends up mixed in with Cabinetmakers of minimal skill.
- Again, there are the people who use the terms as titles, as you say, like plumbers (which is an actual trade). That is OK I guess, but since some of these terms imply either professional credentialling, or roles within a trade, I think it is dubious. And so did many people in the earlier part of the woodworking revival who settled, proudly, on the term "woodworker".
But it remains that since there aren't any rules on this, any view is a valid as the next.
And made yet more complex, in the building trades,
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
by the concept of "licensed contractor." In California, at least, you can get a contractor's license without necessarily having a lot of knowledge or skill in the particular trade, as demonstrated by the licensed plumber who ruined my parents' plumbing some years back - making direct connections between galvanized and copper pipe with no dielectric joint, making solder joints I'd have been mortified to make in junior high, and so on.
But that wanders somewhat from the presenting question, so I'll stop.
Re: What's in a title?
Brian from Monument
One final thought...
"Those that can't teach those who can."
My experience in life. at least in my profession is that those who teach can teach.
That doesn't mean they know all about the job. Much teaching is compartmented.
IE several teachers teaching different parts of the overall subject.
Whether or not you agree with the above;
The reality is that the titles mentioned are all archaic.
They don't apply to the majority of todays professions.
Most professions don't have a formalized system of apprenticeship, journeymen and masters.
Superficially it seems like it might work well.
The titles also seem to be a stratification of the workers into a caste system.
I would bet that a master of a shop be making cabinets as well as instructing.
The quality of his shops work would be the sum of the work of all those so engaged.
So he is not really just a school master rather a "technical lead" type role OR even a managerial role.