Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun foot
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
I was making practice bun feet for my first Chester County piece, an approximate reproduction of the Winterthur 8 drawer chest. They looked ok but something wasn't quite right and I was clueless as to the problem or what would fix it.
It happened that Alan Batty was teaching a class that weekend (Alan professionally turned furniture and architectural parts in England for 50+ years). I took along one of my bun feet and asked Alan what was wrong. He delighted at the opportunity to turn another of what may have been hundreds of these feet made over the decades.
He chucked it up and removed 1/32" or less from the pole regions of the "sphere" (you can detect the shiny parts left by his superior shearing cuts), chamfered the transition to the cove and most importantly made the cove asymmetric, with the arc next to the sphere matching its radius and the remainder more tightly arced. Took him about a minute or less.
I came to the realization at that point that I could never achieve the design skill and experience of a professional furniture parts turner. Too much to learn and too much practice to master it on an occasional basis. But I was able to learn how to make a good bun foot and I have been able to reproduce this one for other pieces. But without a mentor how does one achieve perfection on the next need for an "organic" furniture part?



