New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun foot

Posts

Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun foot

#1

Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun foot

Bill Tindall, E.TN.


I was making practice bun feet for my first Chester County piece, an approximate reproduction of the Winterthur 8 drawer chest. They looked ok but something wasn't quite right and I was clueless as to the problem or what would fix it.

It happened that Alan Batty was teaching a class that weekend (Alan professionally turned furniture and architectural parts in England for 50+ years). I took along one of my bun feet and asked Alan what was wrong. He delighted at the opportunity to turn another of what may have been hundreds of these feet made over the decades.

He chucked it up and removed 1/32" or less from the pole regions of the "sphere" (you can detect the shiny parts left by his superior shearing cuts), chamfered the transition to the cove and most importantly made the cove asymmetric, with the arc next to the sphere matching its radius and the remainder more tightly arced. Took him about a minute or less.

I came to the realization at that point that I could never achieve the design skill and experience of a professional furniture parts turner. Too much to learn and too much practice to master it on an occasional basis. But I was able to learn how to make a good bun foot and I have been able to reproduce this one for other pieces. But without a mentor how does one achieve perfection on the next need for an "organic" furniture part?

Re: Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun foot

#2

Re: Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun fo

Bruce McCrory

How do you learn all these things? [Paraphrased.]

You bring the question to a forum, and share the knowledge gained. Thanks!

And, thanks for the black gloss input, too.

Re: Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun foot

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun fo

Jack Guzman from Maine

I had a similar problem making windsor chairs. I read lots of books. Practiced methods. What got me close and turned on the light was youtube. Watching Curtis Buchanan build a chair taught me many things I never could have gotten from a book. I envy Elia Bizzarri his opportunity to be apprenticed to Curtis.

Like Bruce,I thank you for sharing your experiences (and your tip on gloss black)---Jack

Re: Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun foot

#4

Re: Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun fo

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

You didn't mention it but one of the things that Alan did was to also change the centerline on the "sphere" part, he raised it up a tini bit above the center line so that it too is asymetrical. The reason for both of the changes he made to your bun foot are due to the angle that it is viewed from. If the piece of furniture were 9' tall and included a similar turned finial at the top it would be skewed opposite, but much less due to its smaler scale and closer proximity to your eye.

If you are interested in this aspect of design it is decended from Palladian arcitecture and I would recomend going straight to the source and read a translation of Palladio's four books on archietecture. many of the styles of furniture you seem to be interessted in have their roots in Palladian archetecture.

Robin

Re: Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun foot

#5

Re: Inching up the design mountain- perfect bun fo

david weaver

ask on a forum or copy a good piece.

I've seen more than one person (including George Wilson) mention that if you don't have confidence in your designs, then dead copying an older piece (no liberties, copy as in every aspect) is a good route to take.