New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Scaling line and berry (or not)

Posts

Scaling line and berry (or not)

#1

Scaling line and berry (or not)

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

While it is of historical interest to research what was done on Period pieces, this issue is of little relevance to someone making a chest of drawers today. Scaling the pattern to the increasing drawer height in a chest of drawers can be a decision made on the basis of what looks best, and, can the builder do it.

The scaling technique I posted here on WC and retained in the archives as well as the published PW tip illustrate a trivial technique to accomplish scaling of the classic diamond or serpentine pattern. A variable radii trough cutter enables the scaled troughs to be cut with one tool. Alternatively, with fixed radii tools at least two tools per drawer height will need to be made which is not an insignificant impediment for four drawer heights.


Given the tools and technique to accomplish scaling the other consideration is appearance. The picture shows a scaled diamond pattern on a 6 3/8" top and 8 7/8 bottom drawer of a chest of drawers. Scaling fills the space and the pattern on each drawer can be made a consistent proportion of the vertical space inside the stringed border. However, scaling will make the length of each pattern longer. I have no unscaled examples, so the reader will have to imagine the pattern for the smaller drawer transferred to the larger drawer and imagine how it would appear. I am no arbiter of taste so each builder will have to decide what looks best for themselves.

(note: "In the flesh" the contrast of holly to walnut is not as dramatic(over the top) as the picture represents. The walnut was oiled before varnish and the oiling subdued the holy contrast.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#2

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

Sgian Dubh

Visually I find it a little odd that the scale isn't proportional horizontally as well as vertically. I may be viewing or reading this out of context, but it seems to me that the large gap between the left vertical stringing in the small drawer and the first berries should be replicated in the large drawer, where there is a small gap between the left vertical stringing and the first berries: either that or large/small discrepancy reversed.

Can you please expand on this discrepancy for me, eg, is there another proportioning element that I'm not aware of, or perhaps the drawers are from different furniture pieces. Slainte.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#3

Not Bill, but....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

the strict logic of the pattern won't admit the horizontal and vertical scales to be varied independently of each other. There are only two decisions--the large radius and the small radius. And there is a fairly tight relationship between these in order to maintain the 'look', though they can be varied some.

So the 'look' of the pattern would have to change in some way, or another pattern element added, in order to flesh out each drawer to the same distance from its borders all round. For example, to fill the space at the ends of the small drawer, you'd actually have to add a new element to the pattern.

Bill will be along to provide the real reason, after a while :) .

Wiley

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#4

Spot on

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

The pattern is composed of one major and one minor circle radii. The length of the pattern is not an independent variable from height. The length to height ratio is 5:2.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#5

Re: Spot on

TomD

Yeah, that part is obvious, but the question remains as to whether that is good design. What did they do in the past, did they leave unfilled gaps? Extend the design?

If you had 5 drawers and a progression like 4,5,6,7,8. Say the width was set by the bottom drawer at 6-2, or 24 inches, and 8 inches tall. The gap at either end would be 2 inches. The next drawer would be 7 inches with a gap of 3.25. 6 with a gap of 4.5 a side. 5 with 5.75 a side. and 4 with 7 per side. So most of the changes are pretty linear, but the aspect ratio of the waste areas goes from .25 to 1.75. The ratio of the drawers goes from 3 to 6. The ratio of ratios is 7-2, which is pretty noticeable.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#6

Re: Spot on

Sgian Dubh

Thanks for the explanation Wiley and Bill. I can see the relationship now.

I wonder though, if an attractive end result could be devised if you were willing to experiment and swap out the arcs of circles, defined by their radii, and replace them with elliptical sweeps derived from foci? In other words, could the width always be a constant in the end result, whilst the height of the design could vary according to the available space. I have no evidence to support my speculation, just musing on the possibility.

I also speculate in this way because I observe that the strict adherence to arcs derived from circle radii sometimes seems to lead to a certain amount of stiffness, formality or notchiness in some of the transitions from one arc to another. It's a minor observation I suppose, but my eye is somehow picking it up, and leads me to thinking about elliptical sweeps and how they might link together.

I suppose my musings relate to observing the profile produced by modern router cutters for mouldings such as the Roman ogee (two intersecting arcs), whereas old Roman ogees tended to be formed out intersecting elliptical sweeps. The former are visually a bit stiff whilst the second tend to be sweeter on the eye. Slainte.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#7

Re: Spot on

CStanford

Roman moldings are based on segments of circles, Greek ones on ellipses. I tend to like the latter much more.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#8

How would you cut them!

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

There are 90' feet of troughs on the chest of drawers I made. Contemplate laying out and then free hand gouging 90' of these contemplated ellipses. Compared to the merchants of Philadelphia people of modest means bought this stuff in the 1700's. They could not afford free hand ellipses, if they were more attractive.

However, were there a demand, I can imagine Bridge City developing a tool to gouge out ellipse troughs.

Other than on spice boxes these decorations don't have a wide appeal. While the style was popular through most of the 1700's in eastern PA it never caught on anywhere else that I know if. I don't know anyone selling chests of drawers so decorated. Even Steve Latta, the current guru in the field, hadn't use these decorations on a chest of drawers. However, they resemble the geometrical patterns on painted chests which I also like. To me the Winterthur 8 drawer chest of drawers, which is the signature piece of line and berry decoration, is the most attractive piece of furniture I have even seen.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#9

Shhhh

Mark Hennebury


CNC router or flatbed plotter. But don't tell anyone that i mentioned it on a handtool forum

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#10

Re: How would you cut them!

Sgian Dubh

I'm not suggesting you should have actually gone ahead and executed a design based on ellipses Bill: I read the thread in which you discussed setting out the pattern, working the grooves, fitted the stringing, etc. It was a time consuming job for you, and I can imagine it would be a great deal extra work to base the design on ellipses, and that's assuming using ellipses would be able to give you a satisfactory layout.

But, I suppose, as mentioned by Mark, a CNC machine along with AutoCAD and AlphaCAM would make fairly short work of it all. I see nothing wrong with mentioning computerised working methods on a hand tool forum. After all, this forum wouldn't exist if it weren't for computers and their programmes, etc. Computers are just tools, as are chisels, saws, planes and the like so they're therefore (sort of) honorary hand tools, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#11

Re: You'd Use One of These

William Duffield




For stringing, you'd need to make a double toothed cutter to replace this one.


This one was made by George Wilson for the inlay in the Williamsburg Historic Trades reproduction of the Seaton Chest.


No electrons need be sacrificed in its use.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#12

Re: How would you cut them!

William Duffield

Maybe we should retitle the forum "Workmanship of Risk"? :D

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#13

Beautiful!


Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#14

like I said......

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Available from Bridge City Tools in their collectors edition in Rosewood and Brass for $3845 plus postage. Of course if the idea caught on the clever engineers at Lee Valley would introduce one for only $350.

I wonder how it would look to do the designs on maple with a laser?

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#15

Certified Organic Line and berry

Bill Tindall, E.TN.


I can't begin to imagine how it was done, never mind how it was conceived. But it is on an artist friends blanket chest.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#16

Re: like I said......

William Duffield

They're not exactly high tech. You could easily make one that was totally functional, but a lot less elegant than George's, completely from hard maple, with the exception of the blade and a couple of nuts and bolts. You wouldn't need the swiveling cutter head as long as the ellipses weren't too eccentric.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#17

Re: Certified Organic Line and berry

roger lance

This look reminds me of Harvey Ellis who used similar lines on some pieces he designed for Stickley.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#18

Re: "Friend of Bill's"

TomD

That has a ring to it. I could probably live without Bill's woodworking book, but I think I would read his how to meet people book. I live in Toronto, and know only one other woodworker. Bill knows everybody, and they are all famous people. I never look at one of his projects in much awe, but his Roladex is pretty impressive. I just sound snarky, I am actually impressed.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#19

Re: Shhhh

TomD

I beat you to it, but I gather you actually own one! Seems like a great compliment to hand tools. Many power tools do what they want, you can't get them to do what you want. Everything has it's limits, but CNC can go from the discussed elipses, to a guitar form, a signature, just awesome.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#20

sharp eye

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I never heard of him but from this example of the work I need to learn more.....not that I could emulate it.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#21

Re: like I said......  35 bucks

TomD

What about a dremel, two push pins, a spectra string. Or just templates.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#22

life's philosophy....

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Somewhere early on I discovered that someone knew more about anything than I did/would. So I set about to get to know as many of these people as I could encounter, help them as I could, and ask for help when needed.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#23

Re: sharp eye

roger lance

Could be Ellis....or not....we're talking almost 100 years ago when Ellis worked for Stickley.....Ellis designed several pieces for Stickley who produced them in his factory....they were "lighter"....thinner in appearance than what Stickley had been making.....and had the inlay work....Robert Lang might know....he did a book on Ellis/Stickley.

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#24

Yep, side trip . . .

Bob Lang

It's very close to one of the Harvey Ellis/Gustav Stickley inlays, picture attached is my rendering of the original from page 284 of the new "Great Book of Shop Drawings for Craftsman Furniture". The inlays originally appeared in "Shop Drawings for Craftsman Inlays & Hardware", now out of print, but most of that book is included in the new one.

In the day, these were sawn and assembled from veneers, then the entire design was applied to the furniture part. Expensive and time-consuming, these never made it past the prototype stage with Stickley, and originals are very rare. Today, they spank them out with a CNC and slap them everywhere they can.


Bob Lang

Re: Scaling line and berry (or not)

#25

where to see it

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

My artist friend who lives in St. Paul says there is a display of this furniture in the Minneapolis Art Institute museum.