New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Fret Saw

Posts

Re: Fret Saw

#26

What is the split--chisilers vs. fret sawyers

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Fret sawyer here.

Have never made a real study of it, but I like to proceed like this, because I can get so much done with only one vise fixing. Drawer sides, after scribing base lines, but nothing else....

1. Gang drawer sides in vise (in two's, though some do this with four sides).

2. Mark tails, across top, and on the side facing me only. The second drawer side doesn't need to be marked, other than the scribe line.

3. Saw the tails with rip. Pick up crosscut and saw the end pieces, which fall out.

4. Pick up fretsaw, drawer sides still ganged, and complete the cuts to scribe line. All the tail board waste falls out.

At that point, I have made one vise fixing, it took less than 5 minutes going slowly, and I feel like I've gotten way down the road on those drawer sides.

Wiley

Re: Fret Saw

#28

Re: Coping Saw

William Duffield

Home made.


Re: Fret Saw

#29

Re: A slow way to remove waste?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used a coping saw since 1975. It might be marginally faster than chisel only. I did a trial this afternoon making four tails. It took 48 seconds to make the dovetail saw cuts and the coping cuts. This time includes twice repositioning in the vise for the end cuts. The breakdown is roughly 25 seconds for 8 dovetail saw cuts, 14 seconds for the coping, 9 seconds for the end cuts.

I think the band saw method is slower.

Re: Fret Saw

#30

Question

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Indeed a coping saw cuts quickly compared to a fret saw. But the blade thickness plus set in the blades I have is too thick to fit in the dovetail saw kerf. Given the people that use a fret saw this must be a common problem. How do you avoid the problem of coping saw blade kerf being wider than the dovetail saw kerf.

Re: Fret Saw

#31

Re: bandsaw slower...

david weaver

the bandsaw being slower is my experience, too. I came to the coping saw because I wanted fastest but still relatively accurate so I didn't have to fidget when fitting.

Re: Fret Saw

#32

Re: Got a saw set?

William Duffield

The obvious answer is to either use a saw set and put more set in your dovetail saw, or stone your coping saw blade to narrow the kerf.

Re: Fret Saw

#33

Here's one solution

wilbur

Don't try to fit the coping saw in the dovetail saw's kerf. Instead, make a second cut (shown as the black line in the picture), aiming for the corner of the dovetail waste. That should pop a small sliver out when you hit the corner, and that should give you enough room to turn and saw across the baseline.


Of course, one way to avoid this issue entirely is to chop the waste out. :D

Re: Fret Saw

#34

clever, thanks

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

The tiny teeth of fret saws are just too slow in my experience but a coping saw does get on with sawing . One could also use the dovetail saw to make that first cut.

Re: Fret Saw

#35

Jack Guzman from Maine

both

Jack Guzman from Maine

I saw between the tails and chisel between the pins.It's how I learned and I'm used to it.---Jack

Re: Fret Saw

#36

Re: Question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The coping saw can have quite a bit wider kerf and still get down the dovetail saw kerf. Here is a related example which might be easier to visualize. If you make a cut for a few inches with a rip saw, then switch to a saw with a wider kerf, the wider saw just slips down to the bottom of the kerf without really widening it. Because the narrow kerf does not give enough clearance, the saw is harder to push until you get past that initial narrow section. Attempts to get the wide saw to widen the existing kerf are not very fruitful.

When I first started using the coping saw for dovetails, I had a bit of a radius where I went from the dovetail saw kerf to the new kerf. Over the years this radius got smaller and smaller. If I look at it now I can hardly believe how tight a turn I make with the saw. It would be difficult to explain this as well.

Re: Fret Saw

#37

Depends...

John in NM

I expect that confidence level has a lot to do with speed with whatever method one chooses. Practice a lot with the bandsaw and you might just find it faster. Same with the coping saw or chisel.

Re: Fret Saw

#38

Knew Concepts

Patrick Gibbons

Just used mine for the first time and was happy to discover it to be as fast as my coping saw. Other fret saws I've used were not so fast. I'm working with a species I haven't worked before and I'm not sure how much a difference it makes.

Re: Fret Saw

#39

Question for you sawyers

Alex Y

Are you sawing to the base line, or just removing the bulk, then paring?

Sawing to the line on the vertical cuts is very doable with a quality western DT saw, and I am sure it is with a Japanese-style saw as well for those who use them. but crosscutting to the line with a coping or fret saw seems impossible for any but the very roughest of work.

Re: Fret Saw

#40

Re: Question for you sawyers

Chuck Bjorgen

Alex -- I'm still pretty new at this but in some of my initial trials with my Knew Concepts fret saw I found I tended to tilt the saw a bit downwards toward the back so sawing to the line became disastrous to my dovetails. I've tried to straighten these cuts in practice but now generally stay clear of the cut line. I bought the basic $50 saw that doesn't have the tension release lever.

Re: Fret Saw

#41

Re: Question for you sawyers

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Alex,

Saw close, then pare to the scribe line. With practice, you can leave yourself a thin paring job. But to get a shaved baseline, I have to pare.

Have long since learned not to make absolute statements about what is possible--someone else may be able to skip the paring step. I can't.

Wiley

Re: Fret Saw

#42

Re: Question for you sawyers

TomD

You can saw to the baseline, on the tails with a motorized fret saw. I have had a good excaliber one for about 30 years that has about 50 feet on it. Just picked it up at some flush moment. I am currently finding some uses for it, but I have tried to dovetail thing, and it works great. The problem is that with some of the finer saws I prefer to saw with, the blades that will turn in their kerfs are too fine for this kind of cutting.

On the hand saw, I use a rough cutting blade and the idea is that one will leave just enough to pare or chop away. Beginers at seminars seem to really like this idea. Chopping out is relatively easy, but one has to follow the steps of whatever method one choose religiously. A small difference in process can make the whole thing either very clumsy, or the results may turn out badly. There are a number of deliverables, like not backing over the line, not stalling out where the results take for ever and feel careless, and not blowing out unsupported grain, and on and on. But with cutting out with a saw, it pretty much becomes a simple operation. The downside is that time wise, once one works out the actually chisel method it takes about the same time as chiselling the saw waste, so the whole saw step is wasted time and wasted money on an expensive saw.

Re: Fret Saw

#43

Re: A skill skipper.

TomD

The idea is not that it is faster, but that it requires less skill, I don't see many people who have mastered chiselling running out and buying a saw so they can speed up the process. If you have thin stock you can get a thin chisel and actually cut right through without relief cutting. Chisels are always faster and cleaner. Well at least with common size stock. Maybe if we regularly dovetailed 3/4 inch to 3" stock it might be different.

Funny thing when you consider all the threads on chisels how people try to avoid the main uses for which they shine.

Re: Fret Saw

#44

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Question for you sawyers

Jack Guzman from Maine

I get as close as I can without touching the line.---Jack