New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Fret Saw

Posts

Fret Saw

#1

Fret Saw

Larry Wyatt

Pretty frustrated right about now. Bought a fret saw and it arrived today. This is the model.

http://goo.gl/FuiQW

There are no instructions. I'm having a heck of a time getting the blades in. Gotten two in so far and both broke after just a few strokes. I'm not even half way through the dovetail waste after two blades, for goodness sake. And why does the handle swivel?

Oh, and my sternum hurts, but I expected that.

Help me, Mr. Wizard!!!

Regards,

Larry

Re: Fret Saw

#2

Re: Fret Saw

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You are putting the blades in with the teeth pointed toward the handle, yes? Most saws of this type (fret, coping) in my experience work best when you're pulling the blade toward the cut.

Not sure why the handle would swivel. My examples of this saw type have had rigid handles.

If it is from Lee Valley, write them; they've got great customer service.

Re: Fret Saw

#3

Re: Fret Saw

Larry Wyatt

Hi Bill. Yes, I set it up to cut on the pull stroke.

Re: Fret Saw

#4

Re: Fret Saw

CStanford

Wrong saw for dovetail waste - use a coping saw, the blades are more robust.

Re: Fret Saw

#5

Re: Fret Saw *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Larry

I used one of those fretsaws for a few years. It is wonderfully light but, although the most rigid one for its length I had come across to that point, it is still quite floppy compared to what is available.

To insert the blades one does need to use a fair amount of compression of the frame. You could place it in a vise and squeeze it until it is compressed enough to work with.

At the end of the day a small Knew Concepts (3" or 5") with a swivel blade clamp is the one you will keep for the rest of time.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Knew Concepts review

Re: Fret Saw

#6

Re: Fret Saw

Larry Wyatt

I've been using a coping saw for years, but it doesn't work for thin kerf Japanese saws, for which I've developed quite a fondness.

Hiya Derek. I looked into the Knew Concepts saws before I bought this one. They're works of art. I just thought that I'd try the less expensive route first, but I may have to go the way of the beast. :D

Thanks as always.

Warm regards,

Larry

Re: Fret Saw

#7

Re: Fret Saw

david weaver

coarse coping saw, cut straight down the middle of the waste and cut a curve toward one end to terminate near the bottom corner of the waste and then cut straight across.

It takes me about the same time to do that as it does to cut with a fretsaw, maybe less, except the coping saw rarely breaks.

Re: Fret Saw

#8

Re: Fret Saw

CStanford

Exactly like David said and you don't need a $150 coping saw either.

Re: Fret Saw

#9

Re: Fret Saw

david weaver

Whatever is available at the local hardware store is fine. I've never had better, though I've tried a couple of fretsaws and regretted it when it wasn't fretwork.

Re: Fret Saw

#10

Re: Fret Saw

CStanford

Eclipse coping saw for me. Anything that uses flat bar stock for the frame works just fine.

Re: Fret Saw

#11

Sharpest saws?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David, Charles, and all you folks,

Who makes the sharpest fret saws and coping saws? In fret saws, I am speaking of saws in size 1 and larger, not the really tiny 2/0, 3/0 etc. And especially skip tooth.

Last time we talked about this, someone (maybe David B.?) had a non-Olson source that various people said made the sharpest ones.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Fret Saw

#12

Re: Sharpest saws?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David Barnet recommended Bahco saws. I'm still using up some Lee Valley blades which need sharpening before use. I think they are Olsons, but LV would not identify them.

Re: Fret Saw

#13

Re: Sharpest saws?

cstanford

I use Spear and Jackson blades. They seem sharp enough though I can't claim that I've ever done any sort of serious comparisons. Highland Hardware has them, at least I hope they still do - I'm running low.

Re: Fret Saw

#14

personal preference

Chris Friesen

Both fret/coping saws will work for dovetails, the advantage of the fretsaw is that you can do a 90 degree turn at the bottom of the kerf.

Re: Fret Saw

#15

Re: Saw tweaks

TomD

When I use a coping saw, I put the blade in so it faces back towards the frame, then I teak it so it is angled out about 30-45 degrees. I drop it down the slot, And it takes right off in more or less the right direction. This works great if the idea is to drop enough waste that a paring cut will remove the rest. It is not tight enough that the saw will remove all the waste, but that is never my intention.

I try as much as possible not to use a saw cause it slows me down. But sometimes it is the right option, and students love it.

Re: Fret Saw

#16

Re: Fret Saw

R Payne

Fret saws tend to break blades when the sawyer twists the saw while sawing. The remedy for this is practice (and a lot of blades).

Re: Fret Saw

#17

Re: Fret Saw

Larry Wyatt

Excellent advice that I shall heed. Thanks!!

Larry

Re: Fret Saw

#18

Jack Guzman from Maine

Jewelers saw

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have used a small fretsaw called a jewelers saw for years for dovetail waste.I find a coping saw too heavy.I very seldom break a blade. I prefer the ones with the option of turning the blade sideways but both kinds work.It doesn't have the depth of cut but that is the reason the blades don't break as easily. They are cheap and plentiful. A good option until you can afford a knew concepts saw(I want one of those).---Jack --a little late to the party

Re: Fret Saw

#19

Re: Fret Saw

Patrick Gibbons

I would never spend that kind of money on a fret saw (Knew Concept). That's why I put it on my Lee Valley wish list and let my wife buy it for me for my birthday. It's a dream to use. My problem with coping saws has been the issue of stiffness. I have an old Craftsman (I thinks it's a Millers Falls) that's much stiffer than my Olsen but still not stiff enough.

Re: Fret Saw

#20

A slow way to remove waste?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

For stock that isn't thin I found a fret saw to be a tediously slow way to remove waste. Given that one has to chisel or pare anyway, I think it is as fast to simply chop it out. If saving labor is the goal, use a band saw, regarding the teeth of a coarse toothed blade to be a power chiseler, with the teeth functioning as the micro chisel to nibble wood up to very near the scribe line.

What is the split here- chiselers vs fret sawyers?

Re: Fret Saw

#21

Re: A slow way to remove waste?

Larry Wyatt

Hi Bill:

Yes, for me the question is chiseling vs. sawing. And I could use the fret saw for other matters as well.

I ordered the Knew Concepts saw yesterday. :-)

Larry

Re: Fret Saw

#22

Chiseler


Re: Fret Saw

#23

Re: Sharpest saws?

david weaver

I haven't done any comparisons, either. If I need faster, I go more coarse rather than doing anything to them.

I think I've used olsons and buck brothers blades, I don't remember being overwhelmed by either, but I don't remember seeing any smoke, either.

Re: Fret Saw

#24

Chisel...it's how I started and still do.


Re: Fret Saw

#25

I think maybe this is the one...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I think someone or two said these saws are excellent:

http://www.bensscrollsaw.com/blade.html

I'm looking at the double skip tooth, because it's thin enough at 0.012" to get down a dozuki kerf, but also has 16 tpi, a little coarser than I'm getting right now with Olson.

Wiley