New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Decent Chisel Set?

Posts

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#26

Re: Well said Wiley

Charles Jackson III

Thanks guys.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#27

scott grandstaff

whats with sets in the first place?

scott grandstaff

Personally I don't want a "set" of anything. Sets are for little girls with their purses and shoes!

When I want my 1/2" chisel, I want to know it from across the room! I don't want to pull out 5 chisels and squint at a mark on the side.

I want my 1/2, and I want it now!

I want mine different from each other. Not as easy to do as you might think. :)


yours Scott

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#29

the practical reality

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

So how long did it take to accumulate chisels spanning the range of sizes one might need to own to work efficiently? For those focused on making stuff buying a set of chisels is the only practical way to get on with woodworking. Additionally, it seems unlikely 10 different styles would all be equivalently at home in one's hand. While it might be beneficial to buy "one ofs" to find the one liked best, after that there is considerable merit to filling out a set where they are all optimally alike. For the frugal, sets are usually cheaper. Finally, while it lacks the refinement of your rack I know exactly where my about half inch chisel is- 4th from the right, but that is not how I think about choosing it, nor would it be by the shape of its handle. In fact I can't tell you the exact size of any of my home made chisels. It isn't important and I have never measured them. I look at the rack and visually choose the size blade for the task at hand.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#30

scott grandstaff

Re: the practical reality

scott grandstaff

I honestly don't know how long it took to round up those chisels you see.

They might be 10% of the chisels I own. I doubt it though. Probably less than that.

Finding and making old tools work is one of the fun parts for me!

Because I can.

Building another table or dresser or some other thing I'm going to sell? Or one of my relatives is going to try weaseling me out of?

Yeah yeah, I'll get to it.

But you know what? They all leave my tools alone.

Mine!

Old chisels are a dime a dozen! If your woodwork is so important you can't afford causal sat morning garage sale cruising, or a pleasant trip to the swap meet every now and then? Old tool shows maybe?????

Where you don't just see tools, but you see all manner of everything cool ever made? And its often cheap for the finding?

There is no time for this?

Well maybe you better quit messing with websites and buckle down and get to work! heehehehehh

If a person was actually so hyper sensitive a minor variation in grip or blade length, here or there, would throw your work off? Kind of embarrassing, I'd say.

I dunno, maybe robotic CNC milling or something else that takes the human quotient out of the equation, might just be for you.

If the steel in the best chisels made in 1,120,000 years of human evolution don't seem good enough? Or you find it difficult to sharpen them?

Hand tool woodworking may not be your ballywick after all.

New, old, whatever, tools need to be sharpened.

I don't mind that.

Sharpening a tool is when you center yourself and plan the job ahead. Sharpening itself is kind of a brainless activity, relying on muscle memory more than anything.

So you get to let your mind wander into where you are going.

Personally when I have to choose, I will choose steel that is a little softer and easier to sharpen. Some steels, both modern and antique, are tempered just too hard for my liking.

I have been known to re-temper tools when they are too hard. Get them back down into my range of comfort.

This is easy. Just bake a pie! It takes near an hour for a fine peach pie and the temperature range is just about close enough. All you have to do is sneak your tool onto the back of the rack, when the wife ain't looking. ;)

yours Scott

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#31

Re: whats with sets in the first place?

jack curtis

Anybody who has a chisel rack like yours probably would want to be more hesitant about criticizing little girls. Mind you, I like your rack, gorgeous; but definitely more tarted up than necessary.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#32

Scott, not only do you make a good point

Patrick Gibbons

You make a great chisel holder too. The handles are nice. Always like looking at your work.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#33

scott grandstaff

Re: whats with sets in the first place?

scott grandstaff

Anybody who has a chisel rack like yours probably would want to be more hesitant about criticizing little girls.

Heh heh good one Jack!

You saw the inlaid pearl, didya?? ha

Don't worry, I have made plenty of plain ones too.







yours Scott

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#34

scott grandstaff

--Bad-- chisel rack

scott grandstaff

From the "saving you from my mistakes" department...........

Here is yet another chisel rack.

This one was a total failure!!!!

Do not use oak, at least not western black oak in a humid climate, in your chisel racks. Or any other tool rack where you are going to store steel tools. I am sure there are other dangerous oaks as well.

This one worked great for 1/2 a year.

But over the winter?

It made nasty black streaks across my chisels!! Yikes! I had to polish them all back out, grrrrrrr.

The tools didn't even have to touch the oak. Merely being around that much tannic acid wanted to eat them alive!


just sayin

yours Scott

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#35

Re: whats with sets in the first place?

CStanford

I'm not sure what's more little girlish - spending time shopping and generally futzing about to put together an eclectic set [of too many chisels] or just taking three minutes to order a set and being done with it.

If your chisel racks are reminiscent of Imelda Marcos's shoe closet in their general profuseness then, well, you get the drift I assume....

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#36

Is there a 12 step group?


Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#37

Re: the practical reality

TomD

"So how long did it take to accumulate chisels spanning the range of sizes one might need to own to work efficiently? For those focused on making stuff buying a set of chisels is the only practical way to get on with woodworking."

It took me a long time, I started around 1979, and I pretty much finished it up around 2002. But one never knows, and if carving ever latches onto me, I will be in deep trouble.

I am sure you are right about buying sets, or whatever. When I started I didn't have much money, and made a few mistakes. By now I have everything one can imagine, so I can knock out 3 chisels, all I really need, in an evening. But I couldn't do that when it mattered.