New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Decent Chisel Set?

Posts

Decent Chisel Set?

#1

Decent Chisel Set?

Charles Jackson III

I looking getting a decent chisel set that don't take hours to sharpen and flatten. I looking at getting 1/4'', 3/8'', 1/2'', and a 3/4'' in the lie-nielsen brand, I will use these for dovetails, cleaning mortises, and general woodworking use.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#2

Good choice, Charles.


Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#3

I love my Narex

Ron harper

Quite a bit cheaper

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#4

And I really like my Hirsch

Bruce, a MN Galoot

For the same reason, they're cheaper by quite a bit. Easy to sharpen, can take a whacking, and hold a good edge.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#5

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

david weaver

If price matters, I would go with ashley iles cabinetmaker's chisels instead. They will have relatively finely ground lands and they probably cost half as much or so.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#6

take a look at the Lee Valley

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

The Lee Valley chisels will arrive as flat as any sharpening format you own and as sharp as many would need.

While these issues are important in the beginning, ergonomics is forever. LN copied a classic chisel design. While there are those that believe that anything useful in woodworking was invented at least 100 years ago, I don't. What Lee Valley has consistently developed are modern versions of hand tools that are ergonomically superior. I found the shape and balance of the Lee Valley chisels to be more comfy in my hand than the LN, or its Stanley equivalent.

The sizes you propose are a reasonable start. Depending on the style of dovetails you pursue you may want to fill in some other sizes over time.

The Hirsch chisels I bought some years ago have excellent steel, required considerable flattening and are more top heavy than I have come to prefer.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#7

Re: I could be counted as...

david weaver

...one of the people who doesn't believe that the LV chisels are a design improvement over forged bolster tanged chisels made 150 years ago.

They might be a design improvement over stanley 750s in terms of use one for everything type chisels, but most of the 750 style are carpenters chisels.

The LV chisels might be about the most expensive way, short of hand forged chisels, to accomplish general cabinetmaking tasks that any chisels with a gradual side could do.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#8

Re: I love my Narex

Lars Parrington

i second this reccomendation for narex chisels. steel is decent but easy to sharpen. will not take forever to flatten the backs, but will not take zero time either (as LN or LV chisels might).

at $5 per chisel, you can't go wrong. buy these first. use them for a while, then decide if you still want/need to spend a small fortune for ultra nice ones. after all, they're just pointy bits of steel stuck in a chunk of wood.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#9

plus, at that price

Bruce, a MN Galoot

you would have little inhibition about making any modifications to either the blade or handle. I just re-handled my Hirsch chisels, and I have a set of Narex mortise chisels whose blades I can't stand. They might be next to fix.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#10

Re: mortise chisel blade modification?

Lars Parrington

bruce, i'm curious about what you would change about the narex mortise chisel blades. i have their 6,8 & 10 mm mortise chisels and can't think of any obvious ways to improve them, but i'm always open to new ideas.

agreed that for the price, there's really no reason to hesitate to modify them. i ground my 6mm bench chisel down to have zero lands without thinking twice about it.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#11

Re: mortise chisel blade modification?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I haven't figured that out yet. I'll have to try some others, likely at the tool show in Amana, IA, to decide what I like better. I also haven't had my hands on the new LV bench chisels yet, either, so maybe that style will do the trick, modified to have a hoop on the top.

The Hirsch chisels now look like Bergs with Hirsch blades.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#12

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Charles,

Just on a philosophical note.....Life is long, and you won't remember what you paid for your chisels after a while. But you will have them in front of you every day from now on. You better like them.

So my advice is to not compromise on what you want, even if you have to buy them one at a time. If you compromise, you'll always have that little itch 'what if I'd gotten the other ones...'. And eventually you likely will!

Secondarily, I would suggest that sets are fine, but not necessary, so long as you can sharpen the various ones you have with the same gear. Hard to judge which ones will appeal to you most in 5 years. Nothing wrong with mixing different brands if you're uncertain, then fill in as you go along with the ones you like best (after using them).

One thing I think does make a difference in chisels is the bevel angle. Your mileage may vary, but I like 25 degrees give or take for striking--mortises too--and less than that for paring. The steel needs to take it.

Another thing that makes a difference is availability of the in-between sizes, especially in the smalls. For making the final cut to the baseline in the tail board sockets where the pins will go, you're going to want to make one cut and be done. You might need a 3/16", a 1/4", or a 5/16" to make that cut. LN does make the in-betweens, which is good in my opinion. For example, I like 3/16" a lot.

I can't help with the various choices that are being suggested--I have a bunch of Japanese chisels and a Blue Spruce (which is really a fine paring chisel). But again, don't compromise with what you want. If you end up with something you don't really like, where was the economy?

Wiley

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#13

Hoop?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I have some hoopless dogwood handled chisels that I pound on regularly. Haven't see a need for hoop yet. On the other hand the hoop is not very comfy whilst paring.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#14

Re: Hoop?

TomD

There is pounding and pounding. Most people are tapping like there are lots of tommorows, which is fine, and less noisy, but the fact is that the pros of the past often used hoops on chisels and other tools. There has to be a reason.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#15

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

TomD

+1 on that. I don't doubt there are people who will never feel the itch, but if you think you are at all in the upgrader class, I see no reason to put it off. I bought a 3 chisel set of 1/8, 3/8, and 5/8 not my particular choice, I find a 1/4 and 1/2 most useful, but I still have and use those chisels and never feel like I need to take them off display on the main rack behind my bench. These were Japanese chisels back when they were the only serious non-antique choice. Now I have had them over 30 years, and I have a relationship to them that I wouldn't if they were blue chip chisels. I am not against BC chisels, by the way, and I bought one of those way back when. I now have no idea where it is, which says it all.

I went to a Lie Nielsen tool event, and looked at their bench chisels. They had zero appeal to me and seemed pretty similar in vibe to the Stanleys. I haven't used either, so on that count there could be big differences. I probably would have bought them if they had had any charisma at all, I don't have a good set of western chisels.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#16

The reason, I'd say...

John in NM

Is to protect the handle from improper pounding. I've yet to see any mushrooming of an un-hooped handle when pounded vigorously with a wood mallet. Use a steel hammer and you need that hoop. Interesting that mortise chisels are rarely if ever hooped - those get pounded if anything does.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#17

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

david weaver

Look to the vintage tanged chisels for charisma. They will be nearly identical in steel to the japanese chisels, maybe slightly less carbon, and maybe a tick softer because folks were sharpening on charnleys, arkansas stones, idwals etc.

A lot of the chisels now just look like a piece of bar stock was taken, laser cut and a handle slapped on it. Just ugly. That doesn't include the LN chisels like socket types, but they are quite expensive due partly to their level of finish and partly to what LN gets for what they make. Same with the LVs. I know LV spent a great deal of effort trying to build a better mousetrap but the aesthetics are lacking.

The chisels with hand forged bolsters are extremely pleasing to look at, and the super plain steel makes them very nice to use. They just usually take a lot of prep time, which Charles is looking to avoid. (and it takes quite a while to find them, but you've got plenty of that if you already have good japanese chisels).

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#18

Well said Wiley

Ron harper

I really do like my Narex chisels. However, i would not have bought them if I did not already have a few wonderful Charles Buck paring chisels. I use my Narex mostly for widening my knife walls for class three saw cuts, and for zipping out dados, etc. for fine paring it is the Charles Bucks every time. I do not mean to suggest that the Narex chisels would not be good for paring, I just do not need to find out.

I learned late about buying the very best quality tool you can. I did not have the required discipline as a young guy. We need to encourage young guys that if you have the choice to buy three OK tools or one excellent tool, buy the excellent one. Every time. You will not regret it.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#19

three reasons

Bruce, a MN Galoot

1. as Tom says, the hoops must be there for some reason, although I don't know what it is. I have two big Berg chisels, a 2" and a 1.25" that have had the snot pounded out of them, witnessed by their splintered handles, and they started life with hoops. I will replace those two when I can find a reasonable source of Masur/Karelian birch.

2. I don't mind them if they're done well.

3. I don't have any access to most of the woods that you seem to find laying about.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#20

I really like my Ashley Iles

Patrick Gibbons

The AI chisels were modified about 3 years ago with smaller handles, thinner blades and narrower lands. The backs are slightly hollowed and one only needs to flatten the very end. I have a mixed lot of the older and the newer chisels. I modified the handles (cut off) on some of the older ones. I also have a few smaller sizes in the butt chisels to use with dovetailing. The new chisels are real cabinetmaker's chisels. The steel is good and easy to sharpen. The price won't break the bank. I wish I had them all in the new style. And thus the chisel wars continue...

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#21

Won't matter

Bruce, a MN Galoot

back in the days when the rec.woodworking was the only game in town, this line of thought was called MTBTYT - My Tool is Better Than Your Tool, no matter what either party had.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#22

Re: Well said Wiley

Charles Jackson III

How easy are the Lie-Nielsen and Ashley Chisel to flatten? can you use waterstones for the process?

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#23

AI's are easy to flatten


Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#24

Re: Well said Wiley

david weaver

AIs are easy to flatten, LNs are, too. Both can be done with waterstones just fine.

Re: Decent Chisel Set?

#25

Consumes way too much energy to no purpose