Re: Decent Chisel Set?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Charles,
Just on a philosophical note.....Life is long, and you won't remember what you paid for your chisels after a while. But you will have them in front of you every day from now on. You better like them.
So my advice is to not compromise on what you want, even if you have to buy them one at a time. If you compromise, you'll always have that little itch 'what if I'd gotten the other ones...'. And eventually you likely will!
Secondarily, I would suggest that sets are fine, but not necessary, so long as you can sharpen the various ones you have with the same gear. Hard to judge which ones will appeal to you most in 5 years. Nothing wrong with mixing different brands if you're uncertain, then fill in as you go along with the ones you like best (after using them).
One thing I think does make a difference in chisels is the bevel angle. Your mileage may vary, but I like 25 degrees give or take for striking--mortises too--and less than that for paring. The steel needs to take it.
Another thing that makes a difference is availability of the in-between sizes, especially in the smalls. For making the final cut to the baseline in the tail board sockets where the pins will go, you're going to want to make one cut and be done. You might need a 3/16", a 1/4", or a 5/16" to make that cut. LN does make the in-betweens, which is good in my opinion. For example, I like 3/16" a lot.
I can't help with the various choices that are being suggested--I have a bunch of Japanese chisels and a Blue Spruce (which is really a fine paring chisel). But again, don't compromise with what you want. If you end up with something you don't really like, where was the economy?
Wiley