New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

acid finish on steel

Posts

acid finish on steel

#1

acid finish on steel

Jerry Gibbs

Robin Corell posted a picture of a bar stool. Legs were steel with an acid finish. I don't have a clue about an acid finish or where to ask to have it done. Can anybody get me started? I have a walnut slab I want to make into a simple desk with a steel frame base. Jerry

Re: acid finish on steel

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: acid finish on steel

#3

Yikes, nasty stuff

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Most MSDA sheets I look at appear more alarming than the ingredients warrant. This one is an exception; it is a bad as it says it is. Selenium compounds are exceptionally toxic. While I would have no fear of brief exposure to phosphoric acid Fluoroboric acid can cause nasty and long lasting burns that require specialized treatment. I have no idea how the leftovers could be legally disposed of. I need to supplement my sheep with selenium so it is not an issue when highly diluted. Ditto for the other stuff, should that suggest a means of disposal.

Gloves can be way worse than not using them if they leak with stuff like this. This would be a mixture that I would double glove, nitrile with the heavy "kitchen" gloves over the nitrile.

Re: acid finish on steel

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: acid finish on steel

#5

Hydrofluoric gets my vote

mark hennebury

Hydrofluoric acid is the nastiest stuff that i have used.

Reading the MSDA sheet is scary as hell, but using it no fun either. I used some years ago for glass etching...once. Sandblasting is a lot more comfortable way.

However I currently do have a dilute Hydrofluoric in the shop for glass clearing ( removing mineral deposits) Splash shield and Double gloves when i use it, (always worried about a leak in the glove)

Re: acid finish on steel

#6

Stephen Shepherd

If you have the time...

Stephen Shepherd

wash the steel/iron with soap and water and let it dry. Then put it in a bucket of urine, checking every week to see the progress. Safe, renewable and easily disposed of properly.

Stephen

Re: acid finish on steel

#7

Re:  I learned everything...

TomD

I need to know about hydrofluoric acid in breaking bad.

Re: acid finish on steel

#8

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: acid finish on steel

#9

HF a poor choice for dissolving corpses

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Sulfuric acid would indeed dissolve a corpse. HF would not and it would be greatly more expensive and harder to get.

The reason hydrofluoric acid is so bad has to do with bones. HF easily passes the skin barrier, penetrates flesh and eventually finds bone that it reacts with to make calcium fluoride. I don't know why this is bad but it is. I am told the pain is unbearable and the sores slow to heal. The antidote is a magnesium compound(epson salts?)which reacts with HF to make an insoluble product

A good friend ran the lab at Oak Ridge that recovered the U235 from the separators. HF was used to dissolve the uranium. The women that worked in the lab occasionally suffered nasty burns. The first material recovered was put in a vial and sent to the president for show and tell. When it was returned my friend kept it in the lab safe. The scientists were unsure of precisely how much uranium was needed for a critical mass. To be sure there was enough even this first vial of material was sent off to Los Alamos to be packaged and given to the Japanese (story from Kent Brannock).

Re: acid finish on steel

#10

there is just no place like woodcentral


Re: acid finish on steel

#11

And now for something completely different

Patrick Gibbons

Their bluing is great for aging nails and screws. It can be applied after the metal is in the wood and won't discolor it. So far I haven't been poisoned yet, but I have had cancer.

Re: acid finish on steel

#12

Re: HF a poor choice for dissolving corpses

TomD

The generosity that surpasseth understanding, though I think they got the message.

Re: acid finish on steel

#13

Re: Yikes, nasty stuff

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

It is impossible to tell what is in any product by looking at the MSDS. It is common for companies to not list the true ingrediants or proportions on an MSDS this is perfectly legal as long as they list all the actuall ingrediants and an amount equal to or greater than the amount for each ingrediant. this is done to acount for manufacturning variables along with possible substitutions. the true reason is to keep propritary recipes secret

For instance on the MSDS for aluma black it lists a bunch of ingrediants along with water and the % by weight for each ingrediant. for Aluma black the acids and sulfates all add up to 18% by weight and the water is 94% by weight. even using the new math this cant be correct. so what gives? Birchwood Cassy dosent want to give away the recipe for their product so they list all the ingrediants and maybe an extra one or two and say that the prodcut contains no more than what ever thay want so long as it is more than what is actially in the product.

I'm not saying to ignore what is in a MSDS. I think we have to asume that any product could contain the amount of any chemical listed on it and to take any precautons nessesary to safely protect ourselves, but also know that the MSDS does not acurately reflect what is in any product.

Robin

Re: acid finish on steel

#14

topcoat?

Jerry Gibbs

Does the steel need a topcoat after the acid treatment?

Re: acid finish on steel

#15

Re: topcoat?

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

Yes, the steel will neesd a sealer. It will look very blotchy and have some light surface rust. I use a small propane torch to heat up the metal to drive off the moisture that is in the pores of the metal and while it is still warm I apply some paste wax. I use Tre wax, but johnsons is just as good. The wax will darken the color and even put the tones a bit if it is solid while the metal is warm enough to melt the wax.

Robin