New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Pardon, my slip is showing

Posts

Pardon, my slip is showing

#1

craigd

Pardon, my slip is showing

craigd

I'd like to thank everybody who took part in the discussions on slips, it helped very much when I actually needed to make some. In this case, a shaker table "kit" I got from a friend who took an intro to wood working class but wasn't able to finish the table and had no interest in doing so.

I made the slips mondo just 'cause and the drawer front slot was cut with a Lee Valley

box-slotting bit after the slips were glued in place.


Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#2

that's a nice looking drawer- bottoms

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

That kit provided some nice lumber. Can we have a picture of the finished piece?

In my continuing investigation of any old drawer I can poke into I have found that the English not only successfully make drawer sides thin, the bottoms are thinner still. While resawing to get thin bottoms by hand would have added significant expense to a set of drawers in 1720, compared to beveling the edge of thicker lumber, it is a trivial task with a band saw today. I have seen large drawers in old English furniture with bottoms that appear as thin as 1/4". It makes for a light drawer which is easier to manipulate and I would presume would wear less. It doesn't take 3/4" poplar to hold your socks.

My drawer bottoms have become what ever I can get from resawing scraps of 4/4 lumber (about 3/8") and beveled as needed to fit a 1/4" channel. Pine and basswood make dandy bottoms wood.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#3

Re: that's a nice looking drawer- bottoms

Tony Zaffuto

I use roughly 1/2" stock for drawer sides and my slips are much smaller with a smaller quarter round profile on top.

For those who live near Lancaster, PA, the downtown City Museum a few years back, had a number of PA furniture pieces on display and it was from what I photographed, that I based my drawer construction on. Quite simply, it is an extremely easy way to build elegant looking drawers (at least the insides and bottoms!!!).

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#4

craigd

Re: that's a nice looking drawer- bottoms

craigd

That kit provided some nice lumber. Can we have a picture of the finished piece?

I think the lumber is Alder, which seems to work pretty much like Poplar. Not my favorite - planes beautifully, dents easier than butter, end grain tears like crazy. It does soak up oil like a tanker, up there with oiling under a vacuum.

The front is 3/4", everything else is 5/16 to 3/8. The slips provide a 1" bearing surface, which will be nice for this very soft wood.

No, you can't see the finished piece, but only because I'm applying finish. This is what it looks like with raw wood & BLO'd top (will get orange shellac and glazed):


Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#5

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

Sgian Dubh

To my eyes, the slips are a bit heavier than I find aesthetically attractive. I generally prefer them slimmer one way or another so that they don't intrude so much into the drawer space.

For instance, you could make them about 20 mm X 12 or 13 mm and set the narrow edge facing up and down-- this way they take up less space horizontally.

Alternatively, if you make them about 18 mm square and in one edge you cut a groove ~6 mm wide that is about 8 mm in from one edge and 4 mm in from the other edge you can arrange this slip so that only the 4 mm thickness intrudes vertically into the drawer above the drawer bottom. 6- 7 mm (1/4"- 5/16") thick drawer bottoms are more than adequate for most drawers, even large ones, as long as you're not storing rock samples or other heavy items.

Having offered a slight negative comment, my positive comment is that by including the slip you have been able to incorporate more attractive slim drawer sides. The thick drawer sides that are common in American furniture, in both historical and contemporary examples, often look a bit cumbersome to my eyes, although I understand why the practice is common in the US, and they generally function pretty much the same. Slainte.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#6

craigd

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

craigd

Indeed, the slips are way too bulbous. I didn't measure when I made them so I just checked and they are 14mm wide (well, the one pictured is), it is the tallness that is so attention grabbing. So your second suggestion should take care of that.

For this drawer, I'm pretty sure that a 1/8" - 3/16" groove in the 5/16" sides and a kicker glued to the side bottoms would work just fine. But slips are cool.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#7

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

jack curtis

Yeah, but that's all just a matter of degrees. I know that there are advantages to using slips and that when well done they aren't unattractive; but I've got to say that I hate using drawers that have any intrusion at all. And I'd never buy or make such a drawer, just too much trouble arranging things. Again, I'm trying to not be critical because those in this forum seem to love slips, but still, I hate them.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#8

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

David Charlesworth

Richard,

These posts remind me why I like flush drawer slips, even though they are a bit more trouble.

Historically, I don't know when these were first done? Was it an arts & crafts thing or earlier?

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#9

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

Sgian Dubh

I agree with you David; the flush style slip I think is more elegant. It is hardly any more work than the common slip, but it does mean there's no intrusion into the space at the bottom corners of the sides. I suppose the one slight disadvantage is that it requires a thicker drawer bottom, needing to be about 1/2" thick as opposed to about 1/4" thick for the more common quadrant style slip.

Just to ensure we're talking about the same thing, there are a couple of sketches of the style below. I don't have any handy actual examples to photograph.

As to the origins of this style, I can't say for sure. You may be right about it starting to show up around the late 1800s or early 1900s, but I haven't done any research into this. Slainte.

 photo Alt-Slip-Fit-700px-web.jpg

 photo DrawerSlipAlternative-700px-web.jpg

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#10

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

David Charlesworth

Richard,

That's the one. I like it very much.

My students make a lot of small drawers about 12 inches wide, and use 6 mm maple veneered mdf, for the bottoms. I would have thought one might manage a larger drawer with 3/8" ?

If the drawer is inadvertantly glued up with the back narrower than the front, adjusting the slips makes it possible to still have a well fitted bottom. (Which is of course what we all need#######).

best wishes,

David

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#11

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

roger lance

Perhaps an intrusive slip is not desirable for a drawer that will hold important papers/documents.....but as has been pointed out socks, underwear, and their ilk are indifferent to the drawer (or drawer slip) that contains them.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#12

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

jack curtis

Maybe so, but that would mean you'd have to know how a drawer were to be used when making it.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#13

Now that's a useable slipped drawer. Thanks.


Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#14

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

Sgian Dubh

3/8" thick bottoms can be good for larger drawers David, with 1/4" fine for small ones. If 1/4" thick is desired for larger drawers there's always the option of adding a front to back muntin or two so that the span of the 1/4" stuff is reduced meaning there's reduced likelihood of sagging.

Now, with 3/8" thick bottoms there's almost always a need to make some adjustment in the position of the groove in either a quadrant slip or worked directly in the side. The groove can remain the same width at about 1/4" and a shy 1/4" tongue created working from the underside of the bottom. But the groove in the slip or drawer side needs to be raised by an 1/8" or so to prevent the underside of the drawer bottom fouling the carcase construction if it sags or due to wear of the slips or runners, and also so that a decent sized drawer stop can be fashioned.

I always work on the basis that the underside of the drawer bottom should be at least 1/4" up from the bottom edge of the slip or drawer side for the just described reasons, ie, fouling because of sagging, etc and for the creation of a drawer stop. The only exception to this in my working methods is for the very smallest drawers, the sort you might use in small jewellery boxes, or found inside the pigeonholed area of desks, etc. Here you're likely to find drawer bottoms as thin as 1/8" and set up from the bottom edge of the drawer side by as little as 1/8" or 3/16". Drawer sides in these cases might be as thin as the drawer bottom, or perhaps just a bo'hair fatter.

And yes, everyone likes a nicely proportioned or fitted bottom, whatever the political incorrectness of saying such things nowadays, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#15

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

Sgian Dubh

Jack, I suppose if the maker is constructing a chest of drawers for a bedroom it's reasonable to suppose that the most likely items will be soft and will easily conform to the intrusion of slips in the corner.

On the other hand, making drawers for a contemporarily styled desk, document storage, or for many kitchen type applications, then the slips could be intrusive. However, in these circumstance most drawer boxes nowadays, even if craft made rather than mass produced use 1/2" stuff or thicker for the box itself, often ply, with the groove worked directly in the sides and front (and often the back too), and all mounted on metal drawer runners of one sort or another. Afterwards, it's common for a show front of some sort to be attached. Whilst this isn't the only form of construction, it's fairly typical, and of course leaves the inside corners square. Frequently the drawer bottom is glued in too, but that's often not really necessary, but probably doesn't do any harm either. Slainte.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#16

Re: Now that's a useable slipped drawer. Thanks.

Sgian Dubh

Now that you've seen it Jack, might we see one like that from you some time in the future? Slainte.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#17

some practical drawer information going on here

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I changed the title some to reflect the content of the previous discussion. This is yet another good discussion for drawer enthusiasts, carried on by people actually making them. Nothing like experienced advise. Thanks so far for the information and the helpful drawing (though I remain unsmitten by the flush bottom slip, as I don't see the fuss over the sticky-up kind.)....... (can't wait to see the book)

For a large chest of drawers I use a 3/8" bottom and raise the edges (as in raised panel) to create a 1/4" lip. The panel goes into the groove with the bevel down. I locate the bottom of the slip groove up 3/8" from the bottom. The result is 1/4" clearance between bottom of drawer and drawer runners. But I didn't arrive here by Sgian's path considering drawer sag and/ or wear, even though we got to the same destination.......

I think the weak part of the drawer bottom will be the wood between the drawer side groove, or slip groove, and the drawer bottom. This is long grain and it will split if loaded much. Loading will occur when the drawer is withdrawn (or used as a step stool). I thought this groove should be at least 3/8" up from the slip or drawer bottom.

Typically I think people use bottoms that are way more robust than necessary. It made sense in 1720 when it would have been expensive to resaw to achieve a thin bottom but now for anyone owning a band saw it isn't. Captured on 4 sides even a 1/4" bottom on a 30 x 20" drawer will not flex much if loaded. I expect the groove would split out before the bottom would fail. In fact, it would seem that the "fuse" should be the bottom. I would rather reglue a failed drawer bottom than a drawer side.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#18

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

jack curtis

Yes, of course all that's true; but then, how often are items repurposed these days?

I'm not advocating sloppy/lazy construction as the only alternative to slipped drawers.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#19

Re: some practical drawer information going on her

jack curtis

"Captured on 4 sides even a 1/4" bottom on a 30 x 20" drawer will not flex much if loaded. I expect the groove would split out before the bottom would fail. In fact, it would seem that the "fuse" should be the bottom. I would rather reglue a failed drawer bottom than a drawer side. "

I've got this tv stand that has a 30X17 drawer with a 1/4" bottom captured on 4 sides. It's the only drawer in the house that sags, pulled by its own weight right out of the grooves. No slips, btw, just some sort of veneered masonite bottom. It doesn't much matter why or how this drawer fails, every time I walk by it I threaten to actually build that new entertainment center.

I'd rather fix a failed bottom than a side, too; but since it's such a cheap piece of junk...

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#20

Re: Now that's a useable slipped drawer. Thanks.

jack curtis

Maybe, but it would probably be overkill. I make all but the smallest drawers with centered wooden runners, except in my shop I have a few with metal side runners. None of them have failed in 15 years of use.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#21

Re: some practical drawer information going on her

Sgian Dubh

"can't wait to see the book"

I presume you mean the one on timber tech Bill, that I've been working on only since 2005! I'm pleased to tell that I'm working on the very last section about ecological and environmental issues as they pertain to wood. And in that section I'm working on the final sub-section on the PEFC, so that should be no more than about 1000 words I think. Then just a little closing paragraph or two.

The last jobs on it are to tweak a section I've already written to update information on appearance grading of wood here in Europe. And just last week I dropped off a section on wood strength with a structural engineering lecturer at the local university for peer review-- I don't want to make a complate wally of myself with formulae, and their results. After that I need to finish off the index and add more entries to the partly completed glossary.

Then I suppose there will be the fun of trying to find a publisher... I've had a couple interested in the past, but I wouldn't agree to sign a contract with them when they offered, oh three or four years ago now. I wanted to remain on my schedule, not theirs, so I'm glad I didn't sign anything back then what with all the challenges I've faced over the last three years or so. So, at this point I have no idea if anyone is still interested in the darned book. Slainte.

Re: Pardon, my slip is showing

#22

Re: Now that's a useable slipped drawer. Thanks.

Sgian Dubh

Jack, I think in some cases drawers with slips of whatever configuration are over the top. They're a waste of time and effort in much furniture where, for example, a simple box mounted on slides is a better and cheaper option.

Drawers with slips tend to come into their own in situations where traditional premium craft skills are an integral part of the design, and even in that circumstance slips aren't always necessary. Some workers, particularly those that copy pre-nineteenth century British furniture, or are inspired by pre-nineteenth century British furniture think drawer slips are nothing but an abomination foisted on to the downtrodden Victorian workers and to a gullible buying public by evil Victorian slave drivers. Slainte.