New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

Posts

Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#1

Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

William Duffield

In another discussion here, I made the observation that I have problems getting my head around working out of a tool chest, but have gotten pretty good at working out of Systainers. While this was a thinly veiled reference to using some of my forked tailed apprentices, it got me to thinking about whether I might adapt them to some of my muscle-powered hand tools that either need more protection, have lots of bits and pieces that need to be kept together, or need to be brought closer to the bench when I'm working with them, and quickly gotten out of the way when I'm done. Rob Lee sells these boxes in various sizes directly from Tanos, who is also the manufacturer for the Festool tool boxes of the same name.

If you are unfamiliar with these, here is a link for reference: Tanos T-Loc Systainer® Storage System

Obviously, Rob Lee doesn't make and sell the ABS vacuform inserts that would fit exactly the tools I want to put in each container, so I'm going to have to build my own inserts and padding. Has anyone here done this, and can offer any good advise or warn me of pitfalls I might run into? I'm thinking I'll make them mostly from wood, since I'm pretty good at that.

Right now, Lee Valley is offering free shipping, so I'd like to decide whether to "pull the trigger" on the ones I think will suit my needs.

For example:

- I can fit a half set of hollows and rounds, a pair of snipes bills and a pair of side rounds into a Sys4. The inserts for this application should be easy, but the others are more complicated.

- My plough with all its accessories and my skew rabbet plane will fit nicely into a Sys2.

- Three of my router planes and 4 of my shoulder planes will fit well into a Sys1.

- All the tools I think I need for doing inlay and stringing will also fit in a Sys1.

I know these aren't as sturdy as a traditional anarchist's wooden tool chest, but all of mine have held up well in the environments where I use them.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#3

Re: Vacuumless plastic moulding in the home worksh

TomD

That is what I would have said. There is probably a pretty easy way to do this with vac bags. If you have a standard module, you could build a frame over a box with a vac under it. Then clamp the plastic panel over the box, in a frames, over a space that would hold the tools. Then heat the plastic with a gun while running the vac. Even a shop vac will get you as much as 600 pounds of suckage on a 2 square foot area. which compares fairly well to big butts.

I don't know what else is out there, but kydex is a structural material that is used in heavy use items. There is stuff that is used to cosset Easter Bunnies until they are eaten. While something of that sort might seem insufficient, a tray to hold tools does not need to be all that tough, and it could be supported with spray foam or epoxy bogg. Then one can flock it or something. I don't know what the clear plastic is, but it must be dirt cheap.

When folks use ply in drawer bottoms, it is often 1/4". That same size is often used in dingies when people walk around on it directly, and in sailboats up to 35 feet. The difference is just how much framing (or foaming) it has, so the actual sturdiness of the membrane does not have to be that great. Of course, if you want a thin membrane that has structural properties, you are more limited.

Other materials are castings in fibreglass, or you could use syntactic foam in trays.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#5

Do they protect well from moisture/rust?


Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#6

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

wilbur

Hi William,

I know you easily have the skills to make a French-fitted insert for your various tools. If you want to go the whole Systainer route, Lee Valley sells 1" thick foam inserts. http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=68754&cat=1,43326,68749,68749,68749

Get enough to fill your Systainer, and cut out spaces for your tools.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#7

Re: Do they protect well from moisture/rust?

William Duffield

Probably not, at least not as well as a wooden chest with a tight fitting lid, but much better than the shelves some of these tools are sitting on now. I can always add a container of silica gel to each box.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#8

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

William Duffield

"easily have the skills to make" is not the same as "have the skills to easily make" :) Thus, a quandary, and more questions for myself: Will I need to upgrade to the next larger Systainer to make room for 2" of foam? That's well worth considering, and better to do it now, before I order the Systainers. I found Lee Valley's foam for the Mini-T-LOC Systainers, but missed it for the regular size T_LOCs.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#9

Re: Foam blocks, foamboard stacks...

William Duffield

Thanks guys. I think the high tech molded plastics are overkill for this application. After all, Festool does just fine with black ABS plastic that's about 1/16" thick. In all the time I was selling Festool, I only saw one insert broken, and I think it was stabbed by a fork lift. Their only tool that uses closed cell foam instead is the DF 700 XL Domino.

I'm thinking also a true French fit with suede or felt is too much work and more protection than I really need as well. After all, they're just user tools, not collectables. If I make the partitions out of wood (baltic birch and tulip poplar), maybe with hot melt glue and leather where it's really needed, I can change the partitioning if (when) my needs change. 5/8" separation required by the perforated foam grid doesn't allow for as tightly packed tools, so I'll have to think more deeply about that option. The lid foam I think is a good idea.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#10

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

Paul Dzioba

William,

I think my woodies would feel all out of sorts in one of those hi tech boxes, sort of like a country bumpkin in the middle of downtown Manhattan. :b The Systainer system is kind of neat concept though for organizing and transporting your tools. I personally would rather work out of a tradional tool chest in my shop for the easier access but then again you need a forklift to lift it and a pu to transport it with the amount of tools we would keep in it. Have you thought of Japanese type tool boxes? I think Wilbur just built one. We woodworkers are clever fellows. I bet we could design them so they are light, modular, stack, interlock, etc. Rabbets, nails, glue, and 1/2" pine. Partitions easy to glue in with hide glue (reversible for design updates). Add a briefcase handle to the front for easy transport. I bet you could get most if not all the systainer tricks.

regards,

Paul

P.S. I don't have a traditional tool chest. I work off of shelves and out of drawers and cabinets. I run a very small amount of heat all the time to keep the humidity down and the tools from rusting. I am thinking of building a traditional chest for the shop. It would probably gain me some room to store more wood. :D

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#11

Wilbur's Box ....yes

Ron Harper

Easily made, can be scaled, easily compartmentalized, they are wood and this IS Wood Central :)

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#12

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

William Duffield

We won't tell them they're gauché :) The Systainer for the moulding planes is a temporary solution, to get them off the shelf until I can build a plane till and storage cabinet with doors to give them proper protection. I need something to keep the stink bugs from hiding in them in the winter.

First step in planning is to select the tools I want to keep together and see what they will fit into.

I started with a subset of my stringing and inlay tools and a mock-up box the size of a Mini-T-LOC Systainer (a new introduction at L-V and already out of stock). This is obviously insufficient, since it doesn't hold the cutting gauge or the stringing sizing tool or a few other things I would want at hand, so it's back to the drawing board for this one. The stuff in the lower left corner is a work-in-progress. More on that later.


Here's a preliminary arrangement of my plough and rabbet planes, gauché as well. The diagonal arrangement is due to the auxiliary bloodwood fences I added to them. My Stanley #78 won't fit, so it will have to go. Note that the plough fence has short rods and long rods. I think it is a good idea to make sure I can stow the fence with either set attached and either set stowed separately.


I also have a pair of side rabbet planes and a skew rabbet blcok plane that I should try to fit into this one. In addition to the planes, I have to find room for all the accessory blades, etc., that L-V has made this tool roll to hold. Blade Roll. I think a flat panel with lots of slots, mounted in the lid, should be easy enough to put together.

And a preliminary arrangement of routers and shoulder planes. The µ-shoulder plane is in a black box under the µ-router plane box. The Stanley #71 and Record #072 won't fit, so I'll have to find them new homes as well.


Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#14

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

jack curtis

Like tool boxes and cabinets everywhere, this all assumes that you've got a complete and final tool set. Add one more tool, and, well, you know how this goes. Not that it's a bad idea, I just have little tolerance for fitting and refitting. I'm also drawn to the Japanese version, have an antique one built/used by a wooden shoe maker that came with some neat tools; so now I could make wooden shoes. :)

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#16

Re: Ahhh...  Assault Drills!

TomD

By the way, expensive tastes...

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#17

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

Patrick Gibbons

William, this spring I've been making storage for things in much the same way you are doing here. My thinking is that the prettier something is, the more work it takes to make and the less I get done. Also, it was my wish to make using only materials I already have in the shop. So far I have spent less than $7 or $8 on this and that. Pop Wood has a book on storage that is a compilation of mag articles. My B-I-L gave it to me for Xmas a few years ago. It has a great article on making storage boxes that stack and also open from the front so one does not have to unstack them to get to contents. I'll see if I can dig it up later. I built four of these in a weekend (I'm very slow). French fits look good but are not versatile and hold less. They take too much time to make. As the systainers are already made they are fast. I would divide them up as quickly as possible. Just my thoughts. I know others will not agree with my basics.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#18

Struggling

Ron Harper

As I have often acknowledged, I am past my youth where change was easily accepted. For all the time I have done woodworking, my hand tools have been on shelves or hanging wall cabinets. I have redone my shop, and am pretty much a hand tool woodworker, with the exception of the occasional thicknessing help from an electronic apprentice. All my tools are within two steps of where they will be used. I do not believe that I could adjust to working out of a chest, anarchist or democrat, as cool as those chests are. BUT, I have the occasional need to transport a few tools to church for a volunteer project, to a mission trip, or to a step-daughters to "fix" something. I looked at Tom Fidgen's design, and as cool as it appears, I do not like it. No place for saws, and why the open space? Wilbur's box seems ideal to me. It is completely scalable so that one can have different size boxes for different tasks. It can be modified slightly by adding spacing strips to the floor of the box to keep Stanley planes from banging each other. I can make one just long enough to store a couple of 22 inch panel saws. I can add my "jack saw" three planes, a few chisels, mallet, square and rule, eggbeater, nd still carry it.

My angst comes from knowing that Paul Sellers will include, in a few months, a traditional portable tool box as part of his on line class that I am taking. Oh what to do? I think I will build Wilbur's box next week, and if I decide I like the Sellers box better, SWMBO would love to have Wilbur's box to transport stuff back anf forth to school.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#19

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

William Duffield

If you can find the name of the storage book, I can look it up on Amazon or ABEBooks and buy a used copy cheap.

I agree, in this case, fast is important. There are other things I would rather be building. That's why I'm starting with systainers. They're quick to access, and quick to move, especially when I have to do work or teaching away from the shop. I already have a dozen or so, so I'm used to using them.

Unlike David's "tools is tools" example, almost everything I want to put in them is sturdy enough and of small enough value it doesn't need to be French fit. Note that David's fitting is done with modular perforated foam, which is cheap and quick, but as you point out, wastes a lot of space.

I think 1/8" baltic birch dividers, half lapped, are going to be sufficient for most of my needs, but I'm going to have to construct some diagonal divisions, at least for the joinery planes. I've already fitted out one systainer for parts storage using this technique, so I've got patterns that fit and can be adapted.

I've also built structures using loose tenons, but the smallest Dominos optimally use 1/2" plywood, and 3/8" plywood is pushing the limits of this technology. The advantage is they go together without glue, and so can be reconfigured as needs change (think TinkerToys).

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#20

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

roger lance

I don't know on what day God invented drawers....but, I find it is good....


and close to the workbench too.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#21

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

William Duffield

Nice, and a very nice, matched collection of tools, too.

Do you ever worry about the drawer binding during humid weather, and upon giving it a yank, dumping all those planes on the floor? :( I think I would be tempted to put partitions, probably low ones, between them.

I have many other planes and saws, that I'm not addressing with the current project, that I need to build drawers or a till for. When I built the chest under my workbench, I followed the theory that I should make the drawers shallow (less than 2") because I knew that if I made them any deeper, stuff would get piled on top of stuff, until I couldn't find anything. But that means that most of my bench planes don't fit. You obviously don't have that organizational problem. By making the my go all the way through, with drawer access from either side, I also solved my problem of overextending the drawers, since I never need to pull them more than half way out.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#22

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes

roger lance

Those drawers have been thru many seasonal cycles....so they've been adjusted for binding and that's not been an issue for years. When I designed that workbench many moons ago, it was before I had any hand tools to speak of....so the drawer sizes were chosen blindly without specific tools in mind....and this grouping of tools is directly tied to my participation on this forum....LV tools always got favorable reviews, so I went with LV....the webbing structures I made to support the drawers are also dadoed into the framing of the bench and add to its rigidity.....but if I were to make a bench today, I'd be looking at full extension hardware which also allows you to change the height of drawers in a drawer bay if you want.

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#23

Japanese tool kits, take a look at these: *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The traditional toolchest that Wilbur built isn't the only style of Japanese tool kit. Take a look at this google translation. Bear in mind that the translation is a bit rough. There are some other interesting things at this website, too. Scroll all the way to the bottom for arrows to navigate pages.


http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&ie=UTF8&langpair=ja|en&u=http://www.geocities.jp/hatanokoichi/naisou.html&rurl=translate.google.com

Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#24

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tool Chests & Boxes *LINK*

#25

Re: Japanese tool kits, take a look at these:

jack curtis

Thanks, Bruce, very interesting. Along those lines, I'm in the process of designing chisel drawers that will transport nicely in a larger box. They'll be normal for the main storage, but also include hinged tops that will protect them when outside the cabinet. That way I can easily pull out and pack particular drawers for impromptu traveling.