My data point
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Sir Wm. and all,
Two days ago, I checked the temperature of my Hold Heet (don't ask
). I bought 3 cheap, made in China, meat and candy thermometers down at the local CVS drug store. The three together cost $16-17. I bought three, figuring I'd get three cheap opinions, and maybe take an average, or if one was way out, discard it.
The brand on all three is Good Cook. One looks exactly like your candy thermometer--it reads from approx. 75-400F. The other two are meat thermometers, the steel-probe-with-dial type, non-digital (you read the needle), that read up into the 200 to 220F ballpark. I took three readings, each time with all three thermometers in the glue together. Each time, the thermometers were within a degree of each other--in other words, they were as close as I could read the dial. It didn't seem to matter how deeply immersed the metal probe ones were in the juice--I immersed them the last inch, and then tilted the glue pot so they were mostly immersed, and it didn't matter.
Turned out, the Hold Heet was drifting between approx. 128F and 135F, in those three readings. I've had it a few years, and knocked it onto the floor from 4 feet at least once, klutzing around. Ordered another one from Joel yesterday. This experience does point up that there is a definite advantage in having non-automatic glue pots where you're measuring the temperature as you go--if anything goes wrong you know it before you lay up the veneer or glue the joint. On the other hand, I'm willing to pay for convenience and pay attention to how the glue is acting. In this case, I could see it wasn't dripping off the spoon exactly right--didn't cling together right, even when thick enough. But it seemed to do OK in breakage tests, and it formed strings properly, so I took a chance. I won't again--the best indicator seemed to be how it dripped off the spoon or spatula.
That's my story.
Wiley