New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Hand stitched some rasps...

Posts

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#26

Re: William's method is better, ...

William Duffield

But, do you use a file on hardened M2 HSS drill blanks? Files work great if you are pointing annealed steel and planning to harden it later, but then you should stick with O1, W1, W2 or 1095, for example, and you'll need a torch and a couple of fire bricks, at least.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#27

Re: Rasp tooth patterns for comparison...

John Aniano in central NJ

Hello Sir William,

Sorry for the tardy replies - family issues again...

I can show you the "flat side of a tool to create a curved surface" idea in person. Will you be at the CJWA meeting on Wednesday? I can bring the rasp and frog blank to give you a demo.

Bottom line in words: The flat side of the tool does indeed tend to cut at the edges, as you observed. This tends to smooth out the high spots and bring a concave curved surface into a smooth, sharp edged yet even shape. Works far better than say a crossing file of that approximate curvature. The nature of a crossing file to achieve a concave surface in the conventional sense is to push the file lengthwise over the work. This matches the convex surface of the file to the concave surface of the workpiece. If the crossing file rocks at all, the corners of the work (front/back) are rounded. In what I've described, the tool (file or rasp) is moved in both a forward as well as a side motion. This gives you a clean cut without the possibility of rocking. The tool tends to "register" better with the curve as it gets established. Crossing files are used for bow making - I have several, but tend not to use then for this shaping need.

Take care,

John

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#28

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

John Aniano in central NJ

Thanks Ron,

I probably overheated the blank as you said. Probably tilted the rasp as well during the quench, another no-no...

To Ron and the larger audience: I did notice in the Liogier video linked by David that the longer rasps were quenched in a sort of jig that no doubt, kept them straight. Not sure how this would work, but they did seem to use the jigs during the quench step. If you have watched the video, I'm guessing they are quenching in water (or brine) not oil - what do you think? The Wilf Davies video on filemaking specifically describes the amount of salt in the correct brine as one that will float an egg, but he cautioned that it took much experience to be able to judge the salt level correctly.

John

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#29

Re: rasp maker's hammer...

John Aniano in central NJ

David,

Great, now I have to find/make a raspmaker's hammer! :D

Actually the square hammer heads look to be pretty simple to fabricate on my little milling machine (a Rusnok) Probably the hardest task will be to find the stock and drill out the hole for the handle. And of course, hardening the face of the hammer...

Thanks again for all the encouragement!

John

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#30

Re: Rasp tooth patterns for comparison...

William Duffield

Yes, I'll be at the meeting. I'm looking forward to your demonstration. I'm always eager to learn new techniques and new tools. For some reason, your written description still leaves questions unanswered. All I can imagine is the file cutting terraces in the valley of the frog, so I'm sure I've got something wrong in my head. I also don't appreciate what a "crossing file" is. Maybe we can persuade Wilbur to video the process and post it on giant Cypress?

If all your carving vises are permanently attached to your benches, I could bring my PanaVise for work holding.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#31

Re: cutting a convex shape with a flat tool...

John Aniano in central NJ

Sir William (how did you get that name anyway???),

The file/rasp is pushed sideways more than it is pushed lengthwise. In my first post I mentioned that most files/rasps are handed, that is, they tend to cut better from one side or the other. I'm pretty sure most (sorry for the sinister folks out there, S. William included) are right handed and when I'm holding the tool on the work and move the tool from the bottom right towards the upper left of the work, the file/rasp cuts. In fact, most files/rasps will cut quite well moving only from top to bottom, no lengthwise motion is needed, but helps if it is present.

I'll try again with more words... So, looking at my workbench in front of me, I hold the ebony workpiece (~1 inch across x 2 inches long x 1/2" thick) on a leather covered block so I can better hold it up off the table with my fingers of my left hand (sorry, don't need any fixtures to hold most bow making parts). My left hand is holding the work along the long edges of the concavity formed using the gouges, thus my thumb is closet to my body, the index finger furthest way. This makes the work positioned with the concavity running from right to left. The back of the frog is to my right - the "throat" opening is to my left. I hold the rasp/file with my right hand and start the cut from the bottom edge closest to me. I rest my right index finger on the rounded portion of the back of the tool and provided downward pressure. The tool is contacting a large portion of the frog blank at the edge closest to my body. I then move the file/rasp across the work, away from my body, working a sweep from the right edge nearest my body to the left edge furthest away. The tool moves lengthwise, maybe 1-2 inches. Remember, the file/rasp has teeth on a section only maybe 3-1/2" or so long! The file/rasp remains aligned lengthwise from right to left. I tend to also keep the point of the rasp/file away from the edges as it can dig in. The rasp/file action is almost like that of a plane being skewed strongly. I don't know why this works, but it is far better than simply pushing a crossing file (which usually has 2 differing, but shallow convex cutting surfaces on both sides of the tool) lengthwise to create a concave channel that matches the convex shape of the tool.

I guess if this fails to explain/convince, I'll have to demonstrate. I'll bring all the needed tools including a typical crossing file to the meeting. Maybe we can put some ebony dust on our Italian food before the meeting. Who needs pepper!

John

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#32

Re: Rasp tooth patterns for comparison...

William Duffield

OK, If you don't need the PanaVise, that's good. I just pulled it out, and it needs a tune-up, anyway.

Yes, being of the sinister persuasion, lots of rasps and files don't perform as well for me as I would like. That's why I've bought two Auriou left handed rasps. I've had instruction in draw filing, but the difference in chirality between myself and my instructor was more than frustrating.

You'll have to ask Sir Ray the Irreverent* about the nom de plume, because he gave it to me. I used to sign my posts here and before that on Badger Pond, "William, on the Cohansey" (the Cohansey is now found in my WC profile), and I guess Ray didn't think it was stuffy enough, so he prepended the undeserved honorific. What makes this epithet particularly ironic is that I am a member of a group commonly referred to as "Quakers", the guys with the wide brimmed black hats and long black coats, who made the "cereal shot from guns." In the 18th Century, they were persecuted in Jolly Old because they believed in the tenet, "All men are created equal." Thus, they would not remove their hats in front of the king or anyone of nobility, which pissed off a bunch of stuffed shirt twits. The also would not use the third person honorific "you", but instead addressed everyone in the now archaic second person "thee", "thou", etc. and would not recognize nor use any totally undeserved honorific title, including "your highness", "your honor", "sir", etc. Being of an irreverent persuasion myself, I find the title "Sir William" mostly just funny, but try not to use it except in the context of a certain tongue-in-cheek "secret society" in which you and I participate (No, not the one associated with making Windsor chairs).

*Ray W… (followed by nine more random letters, mostly consonants) doesn't post here anymore, nor even lurk, so I guess I can get away with insulting him all I want.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#33

Re: Oops, Above should reply to JBA's "…flat too


Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#34

Better explanation: concave shaping w/flat tool...

John Aniano in central NJ

William, et. al.,

Having written the long, improperly titled, description this morning, I went to my shop and looked carefully at the tool and work and noticed something I hadn't realized:

The idea of using a file/rasp to smooth a concave curve is based on the fact that the width of the tool must correspond to the radius of the curved surface of the workpiece in order to work well. I'm basically using the widest tool I can to smooth a concave surface. Analogous to shaping a concave surface with a flat-bottomed wooden spokeshave or a skewed short plane. Since the file/rasp cuts on a stroke from side-to-side in my method, the width is the controlling factor here. A larger radius concave curve would require a wider file/rasp used in this fashion. I'll bring a ~1" wide flat rasp to smooth a ~10" radius curve to the CJWA meeting tomorrow night and you'll see that this method does work as advertised. For the small concavity of the sides of an ebony bow frog, the width of the tool is roughly ~1/4" or a bit wider, maybe 5/16" wide and this allows the curve to be "fared" very evenly.

Hope this makes it more clear,

John

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#35

Re: William's method is better, ...

Patrick Gibbons

Good point. I've used chromoly for punches. A popular book on desktop machining recommended this steel for such things. It machines well, is fairly rust resistant and has good hardness and toughness. Tempering is not so tough to do. Easier to learn than sharpening and the supplies necessary are cheaper than sharpening stones. W1 drill stock is cheap and easy to work with. Your method is simple and requires no investment to speak of. After fashioning it, it's ready to go. Either way, you have a hand made tool that works well.