New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Hand stitched some rasps...

Posts

Hand stitched some rasps...

#1

Hand stitched some rasps...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello All,

Since others have been posting about new things they have been making, I thought I'd do the same. I spent about 2 hours one evening making a small rasp I felt I needed for my bow making. I have a particular need for a small, slightly larger than a needle file-shaped rasp, one that had a coarser tooth pattern than the Auriou riffler rasps I bought from ToolsForWorkingWood.com. Specifically, I use the flat side of the tapered tool to shape the concave sides of the ebony "frogs" that are at the grip end of a musical instrument bow. First, I use a #3, #4 or #5 incannel gouge to get the rough shape, and then use the flat side of a file or rasp to smooth out the surface and blend it into the throat opening, sort of a saddle shape. For years I used a 00 cut Grobet needle file but this takes some time and I felt I wanted a more coarse cutting tool, so I tried the Auriou rasp which does a pretty good job, but it is too short and narrow to work well. Their model makers rasp also works, but is too large, so I thought I'd try to make a tool that worked better and faster. The quest for this elusive shaped rasp followed the mantra that using the most efficient tool to get the job done quickly often yields the best result.

(And before anyone says "just use a crossing file-shaped file or rasp for this kind of shape", all I can say is, this method produces a more smooth, very crisp edged shape than the crossing file. Many other bow makers do this as well, and it works.)

Remembering that David Barnett had once mentioned on these pages that he had made rasps for his jewelry work set my mind thinking: if he could do this, so could I. In fact, he again made the suggestion earlier today (!) in another post about files so, nothing like blind faith and serendipity...

I had some small lengths of unhardened W1 water hardening steel lying around, so I shaped one piece into my preferred rasp blank size. I also took a worn 3-cornered saw sharpening file, softened it with a MAPP gas torch and let it cool slowly. When cool, I ground and filed it to a similar shape for a second blank.

Rummaging around, I found an old leather punch I knew I'd never use, so I reground the end to form what I thought would work to punch out the teeth of a rasp. I carefully looked at the 5 or 6 hand-stiched rasps I had in the shop for the kinds of impressions made just behind the teeth and based the punch on these observations.

I based my "technique" - call it what you will, on that which I had remembered seeing in the British I.A. Recordings "Wilf Davies - File maker" - a video that I bought a few years ago and recommend to anyone interesting in how hand-stitched file were made. Also the Auriou website shows several folks working and these helped me think how I was going to try this. I should have watched these videos right before I attempted this...


Using clamps and wood pieces to hold the blank in place on the workbench, I tried the punch and it worked pretty well. The very tip of the punch broke off immediately, but this didn't seem to affect it much - in fact, with the very tip slightly dulled, it seemed to form teeth regardless. Anyway, the very tip of the punch creates the gullet of the tooth, so a slightly rounded gullet might be preferable (?). All I know, my punch tip broke off quickly...

Being right handed, I held the punch with my left hand and hammered with my right. I knew that I wanted the rasp to be able to cut significantly using a side-to-side sweeping motion, so I looked at the rasps that did this well and realized they all had the teeth tilted to the left, a natural result of hold the punch in one's left hand.

I used a 2nd section of W1 "test blank" to test the punch. After making a few teeth, I checked them with an eye loupe and compared them to my Auriou rasps to better refine the punch bevel angle and shape. Took a few tries, but I settled on an included angle of ~92 degrees and a bevel angle of ~85 degrees. Too acute a bevel angle and the tip broke off easily, and too obtuse an angle and the resulting tooth looked wrong.


Then I tackled the actual prepared W1 blank. Starting at the tip, I found that my unpracticed punching technique worked best moving in a line from my upper left to the lower right. The size of the punch dictated how closely I could space the teeth since if I tried to space the teeth closer, the punch would disrupt adjacent teeth. As I write this, in retrospect, I should have watched the Auriou videos just before I tried my hand at stitching. I later noticed their workers stitch from the lower right to the upper left. Next time, I'll try this method and maybe I can stitch the teeth closer together.

Bottom line - even not really observing the correct way to do this resulted in a serviceable tool that worked as intended. And I have room, a lot of room, for improvement!

When done, the blank looked remarkably rasp-like, and cut ebony and snakewood scraps I had lying around. But knowing that all good rasps are hardened, I used the MAPP gas and a a small acetylene plumbers torch to heat the blank to red/yellow heat and lowered it straight down into some salt water (~1/2 cup salt to ~3/4 gallon water). This hardened the rasp very well, but it warped so severely that the "flat" side was no longer flat and just trying to put a bit of hand pressure on the rasp to straighten it, promptly broke it in two! I guess it was hard!


Not taking no for an answer, I took the 2nd blank, the one made from a softened file, and tried the punch on this and found the steel much harder than the W-1 - so much so, that I needed to reduce the bevel angle a bit to around 80 degrees to form teeth without breaking the tip. Anyway, I punched out the 2nd blank with a bit more care than the first, having had some practice.



Since the file blank already was bent away from the flat side (convex), I knew that when hardening it, the stresses would cause it to straighten out, which it did. I cleaned up the hardening scale with a brass bristle brush and tried the rasp on an ebony frog blank and it worked much faster than the Auriou because it was more coarse, and was of a better, larger size for this task. The next image shows my rasp teeth above and the Auriou #14 riffler below. Note that the Auriou riffler edge has file-like teeth; I didn't feel I needed these since my rasp was only used on the face.


BTW, the rounded side of my rasp is purely for comfort. The rasp worked as intended and easily worked the concave surface of the frog blank.

I'm glad I tried this excursion into rasp making, and it certainly won't be the last I attempt to make. Thanks for the suggestion David!



Over and out,

John

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#2

Rasp tooth patterns for comparison...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello again,

At David's encouragement, I thought I'd post a few of the teeth patterns of the other hand-stitched rasps I have photographed...


Pictured above is my little rasp (at top in all the images, for comparison) and a French-made Auriou model makers #14 rasp. You can readily see the slightly s-shaped wavy rows of teeth from upper left to bottom right. The teeth face towards the upper right.


Next: an unknown German-made flat rasp. I purchased these from Gotz, a German seller of musical instrument tools and accessories ( www.gotzviolins.de ) Note the angle is more horizontal, neither tilting to the left or right. These rasps are quite aggressive, and leave a moderate finish. The stitching pattern is less obvious than the Auriou example, but you can make out the straighter rows of teeth from upper left to bottom right.


Pictured above a hand-made rasp by PECHAR Rasps in Tuttlingen, Germany. Their website is at www.pechar-rasps.com for more information. They are of stainless steel, hardened after the teeth are stitched. Note the angle is more tilted to the upper right. Very hard to see the stitching pattern, but still teeth go from from upper left to bottom right. By my eye they seem much more spaced apart. These rasps are less aggressive than the one above, but leave a wonderful finish. I feel these are among the very best of the hand-stitched rasps. I own and use these all the time. I can't imagine making a bow without them now.


Another German-made rasp, this time the flat side of a half-round. Note the teeth tilt to the lower right and are more elongated. I own these, but don't use them much, so I can't comment on how they work. Not too suitable for bow making - I think they were supposed to be for the softer woods used in violin making, i.e. spruce and maple.


Yet another German-made half-round, same maker as the previous. Here the teeth tilt to the upper right but are still elongated. Same comments as the previous...



Lastly, a ~35 year old Polish-made rasp for comparision. Note that the teeth in each vertical row were created by a single punch. They are hand-punched out in groups of ~20 and then repeated along the length of the rasp. The teeth are not tilted - they are horizontal. Hand-stitched, but more mechanized. It cuts just OK.

Food for thought,

John

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#3

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

Lars Parrington

this is awesome! i've never been able to rationalize spending $100 on a rasp, even with as much good things as i've heard about them. it never occured to me to make my own. now i'm convinced it would be an easy task.

thanks for sharing!

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#4

Re: Rasp tooth patterns for comparison...

William Duffield

What confuses me in your description is how you use the flat faces, as opposed to the convex faces, of these rasps to shape the saddle shaped (hyperbolic paraboloids, approximately) surfaces of your frogs. It seems to me that the curved faces of the rasps would be ideal for this, while most of the surface of the flat face would not even contact the wood, and only the edges, which are not toothed, would cut grooves.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#5

Very cool!


Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#7

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

R Payne

Quote

"When done, the blank looked remarkably rasp-like, and cut ebony and snakewood scraps I had lying around. But knowing that all good rasps are hardened, I used the MAPP gas and a a small acetylene plumbers torch to heat the blank to red/yellow heat and lowered it straight down into some salt water (~1/2 cup salt to ~3/4 gallon water). This hardened the rasp very well, but it warped so severely that the "flat" side was no longer flat and just trying to put a bit of hand pressure on the rasp to straighten it, promptly broke it in two! I guess it was hard!

"

First let me say cool and thank you for posting.

From this description it sound like you may have overheated the steel during heat treating. That will lead to large grain and weaker steel (and may contribute to warping).

For simple carbon steels (like W1), you want to get just a bit hotter than when the steel no longer attracts a magnet (don't put the magnet on the steel then heat, the magnet will loose it magnetism before the steel is ready, hand a magnet from a wire and see if it is attracted to the steel or not), for my eyes, in a darkish room, that is between dark and bright red, maybe going on orange. Definitely not yellow.

ron

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#8

An interesting discussion

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I enjoy hearing about someone doing what I would have considered impossible.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#9

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#10

Re: An interesting discussion

Patrick Gibbons

Weygers has a section on making rasps and files in The Complete Modern Blacksmith, pp255-257. He advises heating to a light cherry red. Your rasp is a beautiful thing. Another example that more can be done well than most believe.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#11

This Post is why I enjoy Woodcentral

Ron in Sterling, CT

While being an avid producer of sawdust, I thoroughly enjoy reading about other tasks, especially toolmaking as related to woodworking. I too, would never considered making a rasp, but this thread certainly gets the mind to thinking ...... Thanks for posting John.

Ron

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#12

Re: This Post is why I enjoy Woodcentral

Stuart Hough

I agree, too! I have a few questions, also.

1.) David, your punches look like converted center punches...is that correct?

2.) Is heat-treating done before or after stitching?

3.) Would oil-quenching negatively affect the end result?

As others have stated, this thread has really made the process seem doable for just about anyone, and has my gears really turning. After the initial outlay for the heat source and materials, it seems that you could make and entire set of rasps for amazingly less than the outlay to purchase a "full set" of Auriou's or others. The biggest investment would be the time to actually do the stitching. After watching a video of hand-stitching a few months ago, it seems as though it does take some skill, but it's not so difficult that the average person couldn't turn out some fine results with some practice.

Thanks for the posts!

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#14

Re: HSS for stitching punches

William Duffield

The 1/8th inch square tool from HF is the perfect place to start to make your own chisel point brad awl or bird cage awl.

If you are a mini spindle wood turner, the cutoff tool would make a good mini-parting tool, and you could even make a round skew from the 1/4" round blank. That's all the cutting tools you'd really need for turning pens.

In general, I prefer the 6" steel tooling from Enco, even though they are more expensive, because once you put an inch or so of the HF tool in the tool handle, the working end is really short. Although HF's description isn't clear, I think four of the tools in the set are only 2-1/2" long.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#15

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#16

Re: Tips for Making Awls

William Duffield

Content Warning - Several Power Tools Used Here!

…But you end up with useful hand tools ;)

You'll need a mini-lathe (or bigger) and an angle grinder.

Install a keyless three jaw chuck in the headstock and secure it with a draw bar. I use this one from Woodcraft.

Wood River Keyless Chuck

The #2 Morse taper adaptor that comes with it is tapped to accept a 5/16-18 NC threaded rod. The draw bar is needed because you are not going to be using your tail stock and lateral forces tend to work the chuck loose if you don't use a draw bar. A Jacob's chuck will work too and is cheaper, but you can't use one extracted from your drill press because its #2 Morse taper adaptor is designed to be removed with a drift, and is not tapped. Woodcraft also sells a collet chuck for use in a woodturning lathe for about $100.

Collet Chuck

If you have a scroll chuck, that works if the diameter of the HSS tool is not too small. Depending on your scroll chuck, you may be able to grip a smaller diameter drill blank if you remove the jaws. The photo shows a OneWay Talon chuck without jaws.

Chuck the HSS drill blank in the keyless (or other) chuck. Install an abrasive cutoff wheel appropriate for hardened steel in your angle grinder. Put on your PPE. Get the tail stock out of the way. Turn the lathe on at a low speed. Turn on the angle grinder. Grind the tip of the blank to a point. Let the awl point cool off. Grind off the coarse scratches and polish with a series of finer abrasives. I start with diamond sharpening stones.


This method also works for making draw bore pins, but you don't need a HSS draw bore pin, do you?

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#17

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#18

Re: And if you don't have a lathe...

William Duffield

You could even use an eggbeater or a breast drill, but they're quite a bit more difficult to control to get consistent pressure on the grinding wheel. Since we are into motor skills here, why not use an eggbeater and a hand cranked grinder? :D

And, if you have a lathe, even a treadle lathe, its also useful for making the handle for the awl.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#19

Re: And if you don't have a lathe...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That's the method I used to make my awl. It works extremely well, although it was a bit tough on the wheel. Then I chucked it into my DP and went to town with W/D paper up to about 600 grit.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#20

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#21

Re: Rhetorical question

William Duffield

Drill press and angle grinder works, too, if you don't have a lathe.

But, every woodworker should have a lathe, don't you think?

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#22

Re: Rhetorical question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

lathe I have, but not a chuck like that. It's on the need-to-have list.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#23

Re: Rhetorical question

William Duffield

If you keep your Morse tapers really clean, and don't apply too much lateral pressure with your grinder, you can use the Jacob's chuck from your drill press (without the draw bar). Most modern lathes (not Crapsman) are equipped with headstocks and tailstocks with #2 Morse tapers. Jacob's chucks are really inexpensive. The other chucks I suggested, and also the Jacob's super chuck, are just more precise and/or easier to use, but not essential. If you want a scroll chuck, because it has interchangeable jaws, and is really easy to use, and doesn't rely on the MT, you don't need to buy a OneWay. Nova (Teknatool) chucks are almost as good, and have a lot more jaw options. Woodcraft sells a completely functional scroll chuck (Wood River house brand) for a lot less and sometimes on sale with several jaw sets, and PSI has even better prices on Chinese chucks that work. There are other manufacturers as well, including Axminster. At the other end of the spectrum of keyless three jaw chucks is Albrecht, a German manufacturer of very high quality, accuracy and precision, but an order of magnitude more expensive than the Chinese knock-off I use. The Chinese appliances are all good enough for almost all woodworking applications, and in most cases for making your own woodworking tools.

While I have a wide variety of chucks for my lathe, I still don't have a collet chuck, and I don't know why, but it's really not necessary for gripping hardened HSS, because any chuck you use isn't going to ding up your tool steel.

If your lathe doesn't have #2 Morse tapers on both the headstock and tailstock, and also a 1"-8 or 1.125"-8 threaded headstock, you really might want to consider replacing the lathe before investing in any more accessories.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#24

Re: Rhetorical question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Using a Jacobs chuck is a good idea. I have one for the tailstock that will work well. While the lathe (Delta Double Duty dating to the 1930's) isn't great, it also isn't for sale while I'm around. It was my grandfather's, bought from my grandma in the summer of 1963 for $15.

Re: Hand stitched some rasps...

#25

Re: William's method is better, ...

Patrick Gibbons

I've used my Sherline metal lathe for such things. I've found lathe filing with the appropriate file is fast and very controllable. Leaves a very smooth surface that is ready for Emory cloth or other abrasives.