Hand stitched some rasps...
John Aniano in Central NJ
Hello All,
Since others have been posting about new things they have been making, I thought I'd do the same. I spent about 2 hours one evening making a small rasp I felt I needed for my bow making. I have a particular need for a small, slightly larger than a needle file-shaped rasp, one that had a coarser tooth pattern than the Auriou riffler rasps I bought from ToolsForWorkingWood.com. Specifically, I use the flat side of the tapered tool to shape the concave sides of the ebony "frogs" that are at the grip end of a musical instrument bow. First, I use a #3, #4 or #5 incannel gouge to get the rough shape, and then use the flat side of a file or rasp to smooth out the surface and blend it into the throat opening, sort of a saddle shape. For years I used a 00 cut Grobet needle file but this takes some time and I felt I wanted a more coarse cutting tool, so I tried the Auriou rasp which does a pretty good job, but it is too short and narrow to work well. Their model makers rasp also works, but is too large, so I thought I'd try to make a tool that worked better and faster. The quest for this elusive shaped rasp followed the mantra that using the most efficient tool to get the job done quickly often yields the best result.
(And before anyone says "just use a crossing file-shaped file or rasp for this kind of shape", all I can say is, this method produces a more smooth, very crisp edged shape than the crossing file. Many other bow makers do this as well, and it works.)
Remembering that David Barnett had once mentioned on these pages that he had made rasps for his jewelry work set my mind thinking: if he could do this, so could I. In fact, he again made the suggestion earlier today (!) in another post about files so, nothing like blind faith and serendipity...
I had some small lengths of unhardened W1 water hardening steel lying around, so I shaped one piece into my preferred rasp blank size. I also took a worn 3-cornered saw sharpening file, softened it with a MAPP gas torch and let it cool slowly. When cool, I ground and filed it to a similar shape for a second blank.
Rummaging around, I found an old leather punch I knew I'd never use, so I reground the end to form what I thought would work to punch out the teeth of a rasp. I carefully looked at the 5 or 6 hand-stiched rasps I had in the shop for the kinds of impressions made just behind the teeth and based the punch on these observations.
I based my "technique" - call it what you will, on that which I had remembered seeing in the British I.A. Recordings "Wilf Davies - File maker" - a video that I bought a few years ago and recommend to anyone interesting in how hand-stitched file were made. Also the Auriou website shows several folks working and these helped me think how I was going to try this. I should have watched these videos right before I attempted this...

Using clamps and wood pieces to hold the blank in place on the workbench, I tried the punch and it worked pretty well. The very tip of the punch broke off immediately, but this didn't seem to affect it much - in fact, with the very tip slightly dulled, it seemed to form teeth regardless. Anyway, the very tip of the punch creates the gullet of the tooth, so a slightly rounded gullet might be preferable (?). All I know, my punch tip broke off quickly...
Being right handed, I held the punch with my left hand and hammered with my right. I knew that I wanted the rasp to be able to cut significantly using a side-to-side sweeping motion, so I looked at the rasps that did this well and realized they all had the teeth tilted to the left, a natural result of hold the punch in one's left hand.
I used a 2nd section of W1 "test blank" to test the punch. After making a few teeth, I checked them with an eye loupe and compared them to my Auriou rasps to better refine the punch bevel angle and shape. Took a few tries, but I settled on an included angle of ~92 degrees and a bevel angle of ~85 degrees. Too acute a bevel angle and the tip broke off easily, and too obtuse an angle and the resulting tooth looked wrong.

Then I tackled the actual prepared W1 blank. Starting at the tip, I found that my unpracticed punching technique worked best moving in a line from my upper left to the lower right. The size of the punch dictated how closely I could space the teeth since if I tried to space the teeth closer, the punch would disrupt adjacent teeth. As I write this, in retrospect, I should have watched the Auriou videos just before I tried my hand at stitching. I later noticed their workers stitch from the lower right to the upper left. Next time, I'll try this method and maybe I can stitch the teeth closer together.
Bottom line - even not really observing the correct way to do this resulted in a serviceable tool that worked as intended. And I have room, a lot of room, for improvement!
When done, the blank looked remarkably rasp-like, and cut ebony and snakewood scraps I had lying around. But knowing that all good rasps are hardened, I used the MAPP gas and a a small acetylene plumbers torch to heat the blank to red/yellow heat and lowered it straight down into some salt water (~1/2 cup salt to ~3/4 gallon water). This hardened the rasp very well, but it warped so severely that the "flat" side was no longer flat and just trying to put a bit of hand pressure on the rasp to straighten it, promptly broke it in two! I guess it was hard!

Not taking no for an answer, I took the 2nd blank, the one made from a softened file, and tried the punch on this and found the steel much harder than the W-1 - so much so, that I needed to reduce the bevel angle a bit to around 80 degrees to form teeth without breaking the tip. Anyway, I punched out the 2nd blank with a bit more care than the first, having had some practice.


Since the file blank already was bent away from the flat side (convex), I knew that when hardening it, the stresses would cause it to straighten out, which it did. I cleaned up the hardening scale with a brass bristle brush and tried the rasp on an ebony frog blank and it worked much faster than the Auriou because it was more coarse, and was of a better, larger size for this task. The next image shows my rasp teeth above and the Auriou #14 riffler below. Note that the Auriou riffler edge has file-like teeth; I didn't feel I needed these since my rasp was only used on the face.

BTW, the rounded side of my rasp is purely for comfort. The rasp worked as intended and easily worked the concave surface of the frog blank.
I'm glad I tried this excursion into rasp making, and it certainly won't be the last I attempt to make. Thanks for the suggestion David!


Over and out,
John












