New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Reproductions-how faithful

Posts

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#26

Re: About actors I disagree.

William Duffield

OK, .in the theatre, or on the Silver Screen, it's called "Suspension of Disbelief."

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#27

I guess I cannot communicate

Ron Harper

We can particularize everything so that we can't compare anybody, if that is how we want to argue.

My point is they all create concepts. Someone has to bring those concepts to reality. For me, it seems that the art is in the creation, not in the reproduction of the concept. That is following directions. In a great many cases that requires a very high level of skill, but to me it is different than art.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#28

The other possibility...

John in NM

Is that many of us are simply argumentative cusses :D

In some cases of sculpture I agree with you. Some artists choose to work in ways that do not require great technical skill, but are no less artists in my view.

But why put "design" up on a pedestal and make it somehow superior to technical construction skills? As Tom pointed out, we do all design to some degree, just as we are all capable of building to varying degrees. From that point of view, maybe there is no distinction to be drawn between the two.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#29

Re: So basically...

TomD

Yeah, I was not suggesting it was a good thing, but it may have been a necessary thing for us to have ever heard of him and for his designs to have ever been built. Like Obama, a guy that does not seem to lack confidence. I would not have run at the time that he did since I would not have believed I had the experience. But he believed the stars would never align again, which is probably true too.

Where do you get that he did not have hands on experience, unless you mean he did not drive nails himself. He may even have done that, but he certainly was under the roof of projects he designed, watching them being built. I don't buy that he didn't have hands on. The other thing about Wright is that he lived for ever, and had several sections in his career that were the length of the careers of others. He had a commercial career, a domestic career, etc...

For me Fallingwater falls under the same category as early aeroplanes, they are never right first out of the gate. The Wrights are a good example there, they knew how to build, and what they didn't know they modelled on the cheap for very little money or effort, they jumped ahead of the scientific establishment, and government funding of the day. But on the other hand someone today looking at someone similar would say they didn't have hands on because they were bike builders, not aircraft guys.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#30

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#31

Re: Not hands on?

TomD

There is no question he was technically sophisticated, and the few architects I have dealt with were often very well schooled on specific products that were head and shoulders above contractor grade stuff. Often due to their industrial or commercial product exposure. But none of that is hands on. I would be surprised if he did not also have that at some level, but I do accept one learns stuff about wood from handling it that is not always available through theory, neither fully replaces the other. I would not call working on skyscrapers (nor am I suggesting this is being said) hands on, but it probably could include something more than actually driving the nails. I think project managing his own enormous projects, the two Taliesens would qualify at the smaller end of things. And it is also worth considering that he did not just design shells he designed everything. He had to know from lighting to heating, not in terms of what was available in catalogs, but what was required to make all these things custom, and all the furniture.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#32

You may have a point...

John in NM

Some of Wright's more spectacular structural problems could well have been caused by the contractor skimping on rebar or cement in his concrete mix. Or using a locally available, clay rich aggregate instead of trucking in clean gravel. Any number of frauds are possible and happen regularly when stuff is to be buried or covered in liquid rock.

I will point out that I did not drag architects into this discussion. I attempt to apply my theory to their profession out of a sense of sportsmanship more than any thing else.

All I'm pointing out about Wright is that his buildings probably would have benefited from some hands on experience -- as an example, you can see the difference in concrete that has some clay in it as it's being poured, if you've seen it before. You recognize mistakes you've made before and avoid them.

Now I'm not, repeat, not saying that this is required.

The advantage of using examples that are hyperbolic, is that it is easier to illustrate a point by pushing it to the extreme. I probably should not have played along with the architect tangent, the smart debater would require their opponent to justify their example rather than try to defend his own position using an example not of his own choosing. The Van Gogh example works much better for me from that point of view - its so ridiculous that it makes my point with no further discussion. What can I say, I like the challenge :D

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#33

Re: You may have a point...

TomD

One thing I liked about Wright was his poured concrete block method. I don't particularly favour the results, but I liked the do it yourself modular approach. I assume he had tried this himself, just not sure how one could make plans and so forth without at first mixing some concrete and seeing how it works. Of course he might not have dirtied his hands, but he would have looked over the results, one imagines. I would be curious to know more about how he did stuff like that.

Great fun tossing these things around I enjoyed it as much as you seem to have.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#34

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#35

Re: The Froebel blocks

TomD

Heard about those, though it is split as to whether the point is what he learned from their use, or the opportunity if presents a parent to grandstand and take credit for having formed the child by having given it the blocks. A few carefully selected toys can lead to a lifetime of credit claiming, in the right hands.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#36

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#37

Building Blocks & a piano

Steve Elliott

My father had a set of blocks made with different sized blocks--twice as long, half as thick, and so on. They went together to make very neat house-like structures. We built "houses" with cantilevered roofs and carports that were probably influenced by Frank Lloyd Wright's legacy, though we didn't know it. The set of blocks was passed on to the next generation when my siblings and I were done with them. No other toy came close to providing as much enjoyment for so long.

For a few years during grade school I took piano lessons, which ended when the piano teacher told my parents they were wasting their money. It seemed that I played by ear instead of reading the music. I still own that piano and play by ear for my own amusement. The paint is wearing off the black keys and the wooden piece behind the keys is so worn you can tell I don't curve my fingers the way my teacher wanted.

It's been my way to work things out for myself, to make a connection with a tool and what it can do, rather than finding a teacher to show me. I've had some good teachers, too, but it's getting a feel for things myself that has taught me the most.

My favorite tools and toys don't take batteries.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#38

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#39

Re: Another "slowly I turned—step by step" momen

William Duffield

I wonder how much of your observations could be applied to teachers of woodworking?

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#40

Makes me wonder about

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Stevie Wonder's music reading skills.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#41

Or Ray Charles'