New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Reproductions-how faithful

Posts

Reproductions-how faithful

#1

Reproductions-how faithful

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Buried way below are a couple of questions that I decided would benefit from new threads.

First and most provocative is how far do you all stray in doing a "reproduction". Personally, I reproduce style and I never reproduce a piece. In doing the work I use "best" available, to me, technology.

The Chester County piece was sized to daughters specifications while keeping the overall proportions proportioned. The feet will be bun feet because I Like bun feet and they go with this period furniture. The sides are frame and panel because some Chester County Period pieces are frame and panel and I think this element goes with the overall flavor of the piece. Plus it is an opportunity to employ some of the spectacular wide walnut lumber I have accumulated over the years. The molding is approximate Period Correct as estimated from a picture. The drawers are English with slips because I think this makes the best drawer. The back is frame and panel because it makes the best looking back and it uses up thin left overs from resawing drawer sides. The framing is overkill dovetail joinery everywhere. The socketed dovetail dividers are fun and easy to make so I put them on all the dividers. I don't use dust panels because they are silly on a modern piece and it adds unnecessary weight. The result, a chest of drawers with style similar to a Period Chester County piece. And why Chester County? It's "refined" country furniture which looks at home in an informal home setting. The latter "high end " Philadelphia furniture doesn't.

My research proposal was accepted by the Chester County museum so I will be studying the style some more in a couple of weeks.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#2

Depends

Ron Harper

Since I made the switch to hand tools, I am not doing work close to your level. I hope to get back near there in the future, but not now. So, take these comments with maybe two or three grains of salt.

It seems to me that if you are doing it for yourself or as a gift for family, do what seems right to you.

If someone really wants a true reproduction, it becomes another matter, that can get complicated.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#3

Re:  Reproductions-how faithful

TomD

"First and most provocative is how far do you all stray in doing a "reproduction". Personally, I reproduce style and I never reproduce a piece. In doing the work I use "best" available, to me, technology."

I think I know what you are saying, but just in case... I see 3 things, the style in the sense of the features of decoration proportion etc... But another meaning of style could be the mechanics of the stuff holding it all together, the style of that in vogue at the time. When you say you do not reproduce a piece, do you mean you do not reproduce the specific thing, say a card table, or only that if you did it, it would be with your adjustments (which might be true of the people of the day also). Seems to me that comes out as 6 possible scenarios.

Some of the 6 options would probably not warrant the use of a term like reproduction. And given your normal edge I would be surprised if you cared. It could simply lead to an unnecessary semantic discussion that is really pretty obvious anyway.

I can imagine wanting to make a reproduction that would virtually be a forgery, if I could get the wood. Seems like a pure challenge. But I can also imagine wanting to make it as well as I could, or in my normal "style". Reproductions don't generally interest me though. I prefer to do "original" designs, mindful that everything comes from somewhere...

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#4

Good points

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I know some shops that do work for museums and the like. These clients can specify every detail be true to the original, or not. Alf Sharp, past SAPFM Cartouche winner, told of doing work for the Hermitage in Nashville. At first they specified Period Correct construction but after enduring the substantial additional cost settled for looking Period Correct when done.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#5

more good points

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

There are a few on the main board that have the talent to successfully do original pieces but I think it is rare. Most woodworkers do reproductions, more or less, because they don't have the talent for original design. I include myself in this category.

I know some Period Piece woodworkers that reproduce mainly for the challenge of recreating some classic piece. Some of the classic pieces are certainly technically challenging, way more so than any of the modern stuff I see being made where fancy wood seems to be a key design element.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#6

Provocative

Ron Harper

I believe that most here would agree that there is a difference between craft and art. A superb craftsman can reproduce a piece perfectly, including mistakes that may have been made when the original was built.

It takes an artist to design a piece that folks will want reproduced. I really do believe that, to a point, design can be taught. But only to a point. I do not care hoe good a coach you are, you cannot make a Michael Jordan. Only God can do that

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#7

The flip side...

John in NM

I've mentioned this before, but I remember a friend of a friend once referring to someone (a sculptor) as a "good technician". The guy did not intend that observation to be complimentary.

The ability to design, without the ability to build well, is more useless than the ability to reproduce without new design. Having had a bunch of art school friends while in college, I don't really see the ability to design as all that rare. The rarity is in the combination of abilities and in the drive to practice enough to produce good work of novel design.

Design without execution is not art.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#8

Re: The flip side...

Ron Harper

A gifted playwright does not have to be a good actor.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#9

Re: The flip side...

John in NM

We are not discussing plays or acting....

However, I will point out that without actors, the play will never be performed.... Did Van Gogh simply hire someone to apply paint to canvas for him? If he had, which of them would be the artist? Why should we expect less in furniture if we are going to elevate it to an art?

I have been asked to "collaborate" with "designers" before. Translation, I do all the work, they get all the credit and most of any money. Usually they simply wanted to hire my experience because they had none of their own. I have little respect for physical designers who cannot execute their own designs. They may have a talent for conceptual work, but they are not artists.

Artistry requires practice and hard work. Those who do not wish to commit the time to it are not artists, however unique their concepts and sketches may be. I do not consider myself to be a skilled designer - so if I copy a piece, no one considers it "mine" so much as a reproduction. We should apply the same metric to those who design and cannot build.

The artists (and there are some here) do both.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#11

Re: The flip side...

Ron Harper

How many buildings did Frank Lloyd Wright or I. M. Pei build. .

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#12

Re: more good points

TomD

"There are a few on the main board that have the talent to successfully do original pieces but I think it is rare. Most woodworkers do reproductions, more or less, because they don't have the talent for original design. I include myself in this category."

I think it is like a lot of things where people just don't try. The second woodworking project I did was a strip canoe, and I designed it. I was about 19 at the time, I didn't know how to design a canoe, there weren't any books or software, and it was a bit of an intimidating project. At the time, and to some extent true today, the plans for canoes were not at the same level as the commercial product, or where at the least antiques of value in their day. So one had to design a canoe if one wanted an up to date design. Like an American kid who might grow up with the idea that he could be President, I just felt it was verging on required of me to do the design brain work as well as the making.

As I was struggling with that project (the table saw I had made smoke), I discovered Krenov, and his designer craftsman approach fit into my conceits at the time. I discovered along the way, that if one tried to design things, often the first example was imperfect, but the second would often be great. So that does raise the question of who wants to make the first one that is imperfect. I was up for the challenge, and while the canoe I made had a few flaws, nobody realizes it who looks at it, only I know. I also discovered along the way that the masters, were just guys like me. A guy who had got all kinds of write ups in the mags; came from a long lineage of designers; made a big deal of his technical background; it turned out, had gone through an almost identical process in his seminal canoe design, so one demystifies this stuff over time.

But I found out when teaching that most people will not try out what one teaches, even if it is really and truly slanted at them. They just don't want the failure, and I procrastinate also, so I get it.

These days I do all kinds of stuff, I copy stuff often because I want the object I am copying at a consumer level; Or I modify stuff to my needs, chairs to my height kind of thing, as we all do; Or I design completely original stuff; I kinda lost interest in being the next Krenov when I realized that I was no good at selling myself. But developing some kind of design facility both technically and aesthetically is important to me, and just a mater of practice. Wood turning is an aspect of all this were many quite normal people focus on design, and many actually end up with recognition that their efforts have distinguished them, in the literal sense of separating their work form others.

If you think about this board, most of us are way beyond where we need to be in technical knowledge, but there is rarely anything on design. I mean one of the special things about hand tools is the design scope they open up, or the old design styles they allow. Many of us may be doing that, but we don't like to talk about it.

"I know some Period Piece woodworkers that reproduce mainly for the challenge of recreating some classic piece. Some of the classic pieces are certainly technically challenging, way more so than any of the modern stuff I see being made where fancy wood seems to be a key design element."

I agree that the modern work is often too simple, though that does offer scope to take it to the next level. If you look at an early Maloof piece, he was making the round turned leg stuff that was modern at the time, but he took his chairs to a different level because they allowed a more sculptural approach. I never felt the rest of his furniture could get to that level. I think it is easy to underestimate the subtlety in some modern work, in making bowls small differences make a big difference, and most people don't have the guts to experiment on top of hundreds of hours of base work, when it comes to furniture. Still there is more on top of more in a lot of antique furniture. And I wish I had a mastery of their forms, having only read a few books.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#13

Well, like playwrites...

John in NM

We don't seem to expect architects to be able to execute their own designs, at least not entirely. I will point out however, that Wright in particular is famous for some very leaky roofs due to what can only be described as structural stupidity. There are no doubt other examples of this kind of builders ignorance in his architecture, that is simply the one that springs to mind.

Had he done a little building on his own, we can only suppose that his designs would have profited by it.

And don't even bring up Frank Gehry.... his designs prove another point to me, one that I cannot express here without being accused of trolling :D :D :D

I should point out that I am not arguing that those who build but do not design are superior in any way to the converse. My point is that those who do both are the ones that I find admirable. I have known a few and learned a lot from them.

Obviously there is an element of disapproval lurking around in my thesis, it would be pointless to deny that. I've rarely found a builder-not-designer who possesses the ego I've often seen in the designer-not-builder. This observation is probably why I've thought on the subject on and off, but it should not be taken as a hard and fast rule that I believe is always the case.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#14

Which period?

jack curtis

When I say period, I mean some traditional style, whether colonial, federal, shaker, arts & crafts, etc. However, most everyone else I know of mean 18th century and earlier. So, what do you mean by "period?"

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#15

Re: Well, like playwrites...

jack curtis

Building technology is so much more complicated today than say, 60 years ago, that there are many types of architects involved in the design. There's the plumbing, a/c/h, structure, etc. So the architect whose name is on the bottom line is really more of a manager/visionary than a builder. It's always easy to look at someone else's work and see it as less significant than one's own.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#16

Re: Well, like playwrites...

TomD

"We don't seem to expect architects to be able to execute their own designs, at least not entirely. I will point out however, that Wright in particular is famous for some very leaky roofs due to what can only be described as structural stupidity."

I am not sure what you are referring to, he made a lot of flat roofs, as did others, as are many commercial buildings today. I guess there are benefits to flat roofs, but they also pass a bit on the easy way of doing things. I think that today the materials allow these to be reliably built, and I am not talking necessarily about the materials that are in current use.

Wright also forged ahead with stuff like the canti on Fallingwater that has become so expensive. He was warned at the time, he did what he did. End result: iconic building that outlasted it's clients. Not, however, an iconic building that outlasted it's reputation which is a bit much of a bill to ask private citizens to foot for a cottage...

"There are no doubt other examples of this kind of builders ignorance in his architecture, that is simply the one that springs to mind."

Wright did many structures that were "interesting" by todays standards, and innovative, like his concrete work. His use of rubble foundation, and single board walls are examples of other unusual techniques today. His radiant heating was failure prone. But many of these things made great steps forward, and such progress is often incomplete. The reality is that most builders lag the curve a lot and architects often advance it, but only if they have an interest in materials. Wright had several huge, life long building projects, that he lived in more or less year round, so he was more than familiar with the structures.

"And don't even bring up Frank Gehry.... his designs prove another point to me, one that I cannot express here without being accused of trolling :D :D :D"

Oh Canada!! If that makes you feel any better. Guys like him are sticky traps for very wealthy elites...

"Obviously there is an element of disapproval lurking around in my thesis, it would be pointless to deny that. I've rarely found a builder-not-designer who possesses the ego I've often seen in the designer-not-builder. This observation is probably why I've thought on the subject on and off, but it should not be taken as a hard and fast rule that I believe is always the case."

Designers are a dime a dozen, we all design. If we are talking about pro accredited fields that are also engineers, like NAs, or Architects (?), require degrees and membership in professional associations, then don't they have the right to have at least the ego required to lead a project?

I have worked with Kurt Hughes a bit over the years. He designs multihulls, and has some kind of degree. He is also an innovator in the field, a third generation guy. There were the wild eyed founders, the consolidators, and kurt was from a generation with a little more education who refined the breed. But now he finds himself pushed around by arrivists. He tells an amusing story of needing a stamp, so sent his plans to an engineering or NA firm, who in turn went to the only guy they relied on for such work, Kurt. Oh well.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#17

Falling water was the infamous one...

John in NM

Though bold, those cantilevered members sagged to a degree that would have the whole thing red tagged these days. Roof leaked from the get go, probably due to that sagging concrete and the inevitable cracks that result. Wood parts started rotting more or less at installation, due to the complete lack of concessions to the extreme humidity of the location. Condensation and mildew are also chronic problems due to the humidity and the fact that concrete wicks moisture.

No one disputes that it remains a beautiful and unique design. If only it had been designed by someone with practical experience in construction. The structure has only outlasted its original owners due to it's famous architect and the resulting herculean efforts to preserve it.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#18

Re: Falling water was the infamous one...

TomD

The problem is that practical people don't build stuff like that. Though some kind of canti structure is built often enough. It turned out badly for the state, the client did OK.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#19

Re: Falling water was the infamous one...

TomD

Actually I shouldn't say that. Often there is a reason why buildings are donated...

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#20

Re: Falling water was the infamous one...

TomD

Also Wright was a chancer by some accounts a person who set himself up to take unecesarry risks and thrived on it when it didn't squash him. So some of his decision may not come down to a designer vs builder thing,

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#21

So basically...

John in NM

That last point would make him a lesser designer wouldn't it? Letting ego or whatever irrational thrill he gets from taking silly risks interfere with the success or failure of what he designs. But that is beside the point, and perhaps not even true.

My point is that his structures likely would have benefited if he had had actual hands on experience fixing or avoiding real world problems. Nothing more.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#22

Re: The flip side...

William Duffield

That's a totally different concept. Actors and playwrights don't build anything from materials. They are in the same bucket as lawyers and heiratics. They only have to be good liars.

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#23

David Barnett

Your clarity of thought and speech is refreshing.


Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#24

You forgot the politicians!   

John in NM

Doncha know they hate to be left out? :D :D :D

Re: Reproductions-how faithful

#25

About actors I disagree.

Chuck Nickerson

The play on paper is just a blueprint. The actors construct a performance.

Their construction just happens to be "written in the wind" (an old Italian saying).