Reproductions-how faithful
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Buried way below are a couple of questions that I decided would benefit from new threads.
First and most provocative is how far do you all stray in doing a "reproduction". Personally, I reproduce style and I never reproduce a piece. In doing the work I use "best" available, to me, technology.
The Chester County piece was sized to daughters specifications while keeping the overall proportions proportioned. The feet will be bun feet because I Like bun feet and they go with this period furniture. The sides are frame and panel because some Chester County Period pieces are frame and panel and I think this element goes with the overall flavor of the piece. Plus it is an opportunity to employ some of the spectacular wide walnut lumber I have accumulated over the years. The molding is approximate Period Correct as estimated from a picture. The drawers are English with slips because I think this makes the best drawer. The back is frame and panel because it makes the best looking back and it uses up thin left overs from resawing drawer sides. The framing is overkill dovetail joinery everywhere. The socketed dovetail dividers are fun and easy to make so I put them on all the dividers. I don't use dust panels because they are silly on a modern piece and it adds unnecessary weight. The result, a chest of drawers with style similar to a Period Chester County piece. And why Chester County? It's "refined" country furniture which looks at home in an informal home setting. The latter "high end " Philadelphia furniture doesn't.
My research proposal was accepted by the Chester County museum so I will be studying the style some more in a couple of weeks.



