New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Wilbur's new tool box

Posts

Wilbur's new tool box

#1

Wilbur's new tool box

Ron Harper

Wilbur has just posted a very cool Odate inspired tool box made from borg pine over on his blog Giant Cypress.

It is an incredibly sane solution for a Western tools user like me who only has to move a few tools a few times a year. I have been wrestling with meeting this need for a while. This is a minimalist, but very effective solution for me. I think I will devise some sort of shooting arrangement for the lid.

This will easily hold a couple of panel saws, a back saw, three or four planes, chisels, marking and measuring, etc.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#2

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

James Watriss

Hey Ron,

I think Wilbur's tool box is great. Not all of us are H O Studley, and while I wouldn't give up my North Bennet chest for anything, I think it's important to have a sense of proportion about this sort of thing. You really don't need a shrine to your tools. They shouldn't be enshrined anyway, they should be rolling around on the bench, or tucked out of the way in a convenient spot until called for again. Until I got to school, I used a plywood box that I built in the basement, and that served me just fine.

Nothing wrong with being proud of your work, but that work should make it out of the shop sometimes.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#3

Re: Japanese punk

TomD

A crate by any other name would smell as sweat. There is a kind of Japanese punk aspect to this when one considers one can barely buy toilet paper in Japan without accumulating a nicely fit kiri box.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#4

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

jack curtis

Great job, Wilbur. Now all you need are to add two small wheels at one end with a handle at the other for transporting at the shows.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#5

Here's mine *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I made this box a year ago, although the inspiration for my box came from Bob Le, posted on WC a few years back. I had made a larger one that would hold jointer planes, panel saws, etc., but it turned out to weigh 75 lbs. fully loaded. That was too much, so I pared it down. This one was slimmer originally, but I expanded it so a cordless drill would fit inside as well. Sorry for the fuzzy pic - it's the best my phone camera will do.

This box is held together with torx-headed deck screws, nothing so elegant as cut nails, and started life as a pallet. I also planed down all the parts to 9/16" to save weight. Unlike Ron, I carry tools to work all the time, so this really does have to hold most of the essentials. That alone has made me re-think what constitutes essential tools to do a job.

I will have to make a couple chisel rolls and something better to hold smaller things like rules, small squares and marking stuff.


Bob Le's toolbox

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#6

Got me thinking.

Ron Harper

I will probably carry 2 24 in panel saws, my new Bad Axe "jack saw"', three planes a 5' a 4' and lee valley low angle block. 3/4 and 1/4 chisels, 10 ft tape measure, combination square, hammer, egg beater, yankee drill ( which I use for pilot holes) six inch rule, small plastic tub of nails and screws. 2 middle sized screwdrivers. That is about it. If that is not too heavy, I may throw in my 923 and a small roll of bits.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#7

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

Brian from Monument

I have what may be or is an incredibly dumb question.

This looks like from Bruce's picture like a shipping box.

Do the Japanese woodworkers really keep tools in this style box without dividers, protection for blades etc?

How do they keep from having tools get damaged in this style box?

Are these boxes used for shipping/moving job to job or just storing tools?

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#8

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

Schtoo

Yes they do use them to move tools, and it used to be moved by hand, not by wheel so lots of jiggling and joggling.

All edges are covered with wraps, thong type covers or concealed in the body of the tool, all tools are wood bodied. Not much weight, not much harm can happen.

But, a properly packed box makes the Studley tool chest look like a sparsely populated shipping container...

And if you're wondering what's supposed to be a full tool set;


I don't think they're all supposed to fit in that box, but aside from the saws, it wouldn't surprise me at all if they did all fit...

Stu.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#9

question

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

what are the two objects immediately to the right of the paper (black and gold appearing)?

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#10

Re: question

Bob Hackett

They look like ink pots, equivalent to western chalk lines. Don`t understand why there would be a need for two sizes though.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#11

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

wilbur

Thanks for the comments, everyone!

Brian, if you haven't seen my blog post about my toolbox, here's the link: http://giantcypress.net . There you'll see that my saws go into a saw wrap and are tied together, as are my chisels. The wraps keep the saws and chisels from rattling around and being damaged. So there is protection for saws and chisels — it's just not built into the box.

The planes, being wood blocks with the blades wedged into them, are pretty durable and resist being damaged, especially since you can pack them tightly. My marking gauges have a recess that protects their cutters when they are fully retracted.

According to Odate's book, a Japanese woodworker would use a box like this to transport his tools to his jobsite, where he would work out of it until the job was done, and then he would pack his tools and move to his next gig.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#12

Re: question

wilbur

Hi Bill,

Those are sumitsubo, which serve as a combination ink pot/chalk line/plumb bob. They were used with a "brush" made of bamboo, which are the lighter stick-like things in the picture. They would have a hollow part that was filled with a ball of raw silk that was doused in ink. The brush would be dipped in the ink for marking. A line on a wheel ran through the ink-soaked silk ball, and could be stretched out and snapped for marking a line.

There are lots of good examples of sumitsubo here: http://www.daikudojo.org/Archive/gallery_misc_tools/sumitsubo/

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#13

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm torn between using a tool wrap, as you use for both saws and chisels, and the individual trays that Bob Le uses. Not having decided, most of my stuff just gets thrown into the box and is free to rattle around and damage edges :) .

What made you decide on the rolls as opposed to trays? My OCD side is inclined to go with trays. That's just me, though. Yours is decidedly better than mine in one important respect. Your handles are added to the outside of the box, whereas mine are slots cut into the ends, similar to Mr. Le's. However, mine are lower because that position fits my hand better. I've decided I don't like the slots in the end approach, though, because that gives errant tools the opportunity to wiggle out of those holes, and they do.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#14

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

wilbur

Why rolls instead of trays:

1. Weight. The rolls are very little added weight compared to a tray made out of wood.

2. Protection. They do a perfectly good job of protecting the edges of the chisels and the teeth of the saws, and in the case of the saws, bundling them together is an effective way of preventing them from being kinked. In addition, should the box be accidentally dropped, my tools will stay in the rolls, but they could easily pop out of a tray.

3. Size. The tool box's length is dictated by the length of my saws. I imagine I'd have to build a tray that fits well within the dimensions of the box, which means a very long tray, which probably won't match well with the chisels I would want to carry around.

4. Convenience. Not having to build a tray saves time. Also, I had these tool wraps around. They were probably bought as an add-on to some other Japanese tool purchase I was making at the time. :D

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#15

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

Brian from Monument

Wilbur,

Thanks for the link. Now I think I understand. A different philosophy to english approach.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#17

My nominee for quote of the year (so far)....

roger lance

....a properly packed box makes the Studley tool chest look like a sparsely populated shipping container....

Stu, I know you sometimes feel there is no place to begin to respond to what sometimes is posted on sharpening, etc, etc......in this case, ditto.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#18

Thank yee kindly.

Schtoo

Wow. I'd like to thank the academy and...

Different way of working though. I love the Studley chest for what it is and while it's all shoehorned in there, everything is able to be got at fairly easily.

These boxes, transport only. Shoehorn it all in, move the box to the new work place, unpack it all and get to work. Economy of space and a smaller box that's heavy is easier to move than a bigger box that's just as heavy.

I'm kind of surprised nobody got all uppity at the comparison to be honest...

Stu.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#19

Mechanics solution

Bill Tindall, E.TN

I don't have much occasion to take tools out of the shop but when I do I employ a "tool box" inexpensively available at any place that sells mechanis tools. That and a milk crate has gotten me to the few classses I have taken or daughters house to fix something.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#20

Re: Thank yee kindly.

William Duffield

There's a difference in working philosophy.

Those properly using a western toolbox must know exactly where every tool is placed in the box, and know which movements efficiently retrieve that tool and which movements put it away. They must also be disciplined to put the tool away instead of setting it down on the bench. It means the bench is always free for the stock and to perform the next operation, and you are not accidentally stepping on the tools you've laid all over the floor.

I can't do it, but I've worked with furniture makers who can work from a tool chest, and their efficiency can be amazing. Hopefully, I have the presence of mind to at least put away my tools that are all over the bench, before trying to lay the next piece of stock down on the bench. The other problem with the way I work is that I often have to take several steps to get to the next tool, instead of reaching into the chest, putting the tool in my hand tool away, sliding a tray or two and picking up the next tool.

A different question comes to mind when contemplating the Studley Chest: Why was he spending so much extra time decorating the chest when he could have been using that time and those skills to build pianos for paying customers? A certain amount of it can be justified as "practicing skills," but if he was being paid by the hour or by the piece it doesn't add up. I am not criticizing the chest or Mr. Studley. To the contrary, I am pleased that it was built, I am pleased that it was preserved, I am pleased that the owner is providing access to it, and I am very pleased that Don Williams and Chris Schwarz are documenting it in such detail that it can be reproduced. I hope some skilled builders will make the effort to do faithful reproductions of it (but not at the expense of denying essentials to their families), and will use what they learn in the process to inspire them to create new, original works of their own.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#21

Me also

Ron Harper

For many years I actually convinced myself that I was a disciplined orderly person. Not so. I could not work from a chest. Perhaps I could have if I started that way, but after so many years of working from open racks and shelves, it just makes no sense to me. I am re reading Jim Tolpin's New Traditional Woodworker. I was gratified to learn that he feels the same way. As a part of my switch to hand tools and taking the Paul Sellers on line course, I am trying to improve my "patterns of work". Perhaps an old dog can learn new tricks, but there is resistance.

I am pleased to report that I am selling of some of my stuff that I will never use, and has no possible collector appeal. There is resistance to that as well.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#22

Re: thanks

TomD

There are a lot of good things about this method, but for me I don't like getting my hands dirty, and I have trouble keeping ink fresh and unfrozen. I use the alternative method of special pencil and japanese chalk line which is super accurate. I also own a Japanese ink line of modern design where the ink is kept wet in a sealed plastic container, however this type requires a separate source for the pen.

Here for you Bill:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0h70nm9allo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=endscreen&v=YNkt3cVxLEc&NR=1

This one also shows some chisel work, and begs the question "why doesn't he hold the chisel by the blade like a real woodworker?"

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#23

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

TomD

It would surprise the heck out of me. Odate makes no such claims, and I have seen a few of those filled by pros and they were not that full. Making a jigsaw puzzle out of it is not too efficient. When I switch shops in the summer, I get by amazingly well on a couple of saws, 4 chisels, a block plane, a rough and smooth plane, and various marking tools. At least I can find the stuff I need.

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#24

that was interesting

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Framers are the cheapest labor one hires for a building a US house. I don't think the "nail drivers" I hired would be up to the task of framing Japanese style. Curious how they measured with the square and not a ruler. Indeed that was a CHISEL!

Re: Wilbur's new tool box

#25

Re: that was interesting

jack curtis

The square doubles as a ruler, has standard demarcations on both sides of the L.