New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Essential glue attributes

Posts

Re: Essential glue attributes

#26

Glue is stronger than the wood

jack curtis

I agree, Warren. I've actually tested several of these glues on pieces like test leg/apron joints; and the breaks were indeed outside the joint. I haven't a clue as to why this is desirable, so I put it down to sales hype and have never used any of these glues. Ridiculous.

Jack

Re: Essential glue attributes

#27

Re: Glue as a "fuse" ?

TomD

In furniture, and in joints, I can't for the moment think of such a case, though I do not really know why it would not be desirable. The real world is probably glues that fail way below, or way above the wood's structural numbers. But if one had a glue that would do say 95% and then blow like a fuse that would be great. Maybe a glue for every major wood type and grain failure orientation, it might have it's points.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#28

Nothing obvious about it...

John in NM

I've been mystified as to why you keep coming back to PVA, I assumed this was the continuation of an earlier discussion that I missed. As it is foolish to enter into a debate during halftime, I'm naturally concerned about it. In retrospect you now seem to be making some sense - if I assume that I have been lobbying in favor of PVA, which has not been my intent.

All I've been trying to do is explain the logic behind the goal of "stronger than wood". Its an old saw and a bit of a trite hyperbole, but has an essence of common sense from the builder's rather than repairer's point of view.

I seem to have failed in that explanation however, I should no better than to trot out logic on the Hand Tools forum. A sensible person would have learned that lesson years ago, but I'm an argumentative cuss, not a sensible person.

I suppose my next reply will be "yeah, sure, ok, whatever".... shall we simply take it as read that that reply has been made in advance?

Re: Essential glue attributes

#29

Re: Essential glue attributes

TomD

The idea that the structural characteristics of wood glue are all the same, is a real mind blower. Normally (and yeah, probably every second guy here is actually an engineer...) when wood guys from the furniture end go off on a tear about structure it sounds pretty low end. To start with, the failure modes are generally stuff breaking, with splinters etc.... Imagine designing a car on the basis only of how the structure faired during a crash. Of course for cars that is a critical mode, that people's lives do depend on, but you still need to make cars for the odd trip where they are not blown apart.

Wetting in my world is a pretty diverse scenario also. There, Bill dropped down to the electron microscope level where all bonds look much the same. but getting the glue into position is a major issue. Even the ph of wood can affect whether it gets far off the brush. The concept of wetting here, at a purely molecular level would not help me pick a glue. I don't doubt someone parsed a science text properly, but that is not what wetting means in industry.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#30

Re: You have no idea, evidently...

TomD

" I actually believe war is the best thing ever to happen to civilization and human evolution"

That is like saying: "Brad and Angie rolled around on my floor last night. That must have been the best sex that floor ever had".

Re: Essential glue attributes

#31

I just did this, fixed a chair, that is.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

A friend brought over a chair that had 16 joints, and every one of them failed. It was originally built with hide glue, so re-gluing the joints was within reach.

Unfortunately, the chair had been used for years after the joints loosened, such that I also had to rebuild half of the joints. All except four of the them were repaired with hide glue. Those four were too damaged and had to be rebuilt with epoxy thickened with colloidal silica (because that's what I have).

I hope I'm not around when this one has to be fixed.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#32

The quest for Excalibur continues...

James Watriss

The goal is to build furniture that won't need repair?

Really?

Furniture gets used. Things wear, things get stressed, things break. On chairs especially. I don't believe in things that are indestructible. If longevity is really the goal, then easily repair-able, or maintain-able I can get behind.

I've been doing some chair repair with a local caning shop lately, and the difference between repairing hide vs PVA is huge.

AND, in my day to day, I've seen a lot of old PVA joints that didn't really go the distance in some of the furniture I've owned in the past.

Bottom line for me, the only furniture I've ever seen that was guaranteed never to be repaired is pre-fab particle board. That's not to say that it's durable, just that it's not repairable.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#33

Re: I loathe glue creep

TomD

"I've never had a glue joint structurally fail. The worst of failures I've seen and encountered have only occurred with PVA and that is glue creep. I loathe glue creep, whether it's an almost visually imperceptible transition between panel boards, so fine you can barely feel it with your fingertips, or the ridges that sometimes become proud around a joint, it's inexcusable and characteristic of abysmal craftsmanship—at least to my standards.

And in luthiery, even lower."

I feel the same way, but there are better PVAs than what exist in the stores, and there are circumstances where the issues raised are not a big deal. I have been using hide glue since about 85, but even in lutherie, pretty much the standards we all aspire to have all been set with PVA. We live in a woodworking world where there is a competition to the top, but that is an anomaly.

Not sure what has happened the last few years, but for a long time all the factories that make the most collected instruments had defaulted to PVAs. Now that there is this idea that hide creates a better sound, and when you look at the sophistication some of the factories can automate, I guess they could do hot hide glue. Is that happening? Like Bob Taylor could probably automate hide glue if anyone could. I'm talking the real stuff, not just some heat activated

Re: Essential glue attributes

#34

Re: The trouble is this...

Chris Friesen

"Bill's point is that it is far more important to most of us, as builders, to produce work that will not need repair more than to produce work that will be easy to repair."

There are some types of work (chairs or musical instruments for example) where the expectation is that they *will* need repair at some point in their usable lives. For this type of piece using a repairable glue only makes sense.

For something like a panel glue-up where you don't expect it to ever need repairing it makes perfect sense to use something like PVA.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#35

Hide glue data

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

When typically used in long grain joinery all the common woodworking glues used for building furniture are stronger in shear strength than wood. Specifically, both hot hide and liquid hide are in the neighborhood of 3500 psi (University of Deleware Furniture Conservation Department data). This value exceeds the common woods we use by up to a factor of two and it is not greatly different from other woodworking glues.

This fact leads to the conclusion stated in the last paragraph of my original post. This fact also leads to other useful conclusions. If your hide glue, or any other, is not drying to a tough solid there is something amiss for it was designed to cure to a tough solid. If your long grain joints are not breaking wood when tested there is something amiss with the glue or application for it was designed to be stronger than wood.

The context here is actual, not virtual, furniture making, not violin restoration, museum conservation, house or boat building, Period Reenactments, book binding, etc. If you want to discuss the glue attributes for these applications start your own post so as to not confuse the by standing furniture builders that might want to learn something about furniture glue.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#36

Hot hide glue

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The use of hot hide glue is an art. Like any art, experience is essential, training is extremely helpful as is watching others work. Technical articles are not so helpful. You can read books about violin playing if you want, but unless you have a real violin in your hands, have a real teacher to work with, and listen to others playing, you will not know much.

Susan Buck is a fine expert in microscopic analysis of paint and varnish on period furniture. I have heard her lecture and I think I have met her. However, in 1990, when she did the glue study at Delaware, she was in a two year conservation program, having spent the previous 10 years in marketing. Even then she was concentrating on paint, not glue. I don't think she then had the science background of Bill Tindall, or any previous experience using hot hide glue.

Susan used a two to one ratio of water to glue by weight, which strikes me as rather thin. My hide glue package suggests one to one, then thin if desired. She was also apparently unaware that hide glue was available in different strengths. She tested only up to 84% humidity, which is more than reasonable for a museum, but in this region humidity and temperature can exceed 90% and 90 degrees for days.

It is ridiculous for people without a body of experience and real world training to be making statements about this art.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#37

Re: But isn't that what we are discussing?

David Weaver

There is a point being missed, and warren has probably made it implicitly. There is a very wide range of strengths between nothing and wood failing instead of glue.

In some cases, that may mean hundreds of years of hold. I still haven't had hide glue fail on anything but a plane handle, which is understandable (and it wasn't my glue job that did, I don't know how old it was). I've used it many times where I didn't have "book" strength clamping and I'd imagine if I went and started breaking apart my joints, I could find lots where the glue failed instead of the joints.

BUT, they aren't failing otherwise when someone isn't intentionally breaking them. The idea that the joints are probably weak if the glue doesn't pry chunks of wood off is far fetched, and it's not supported.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#38

Re: Hide glue data ... Rattlers ahead?

Bruce McCrory

I was going to speak to the following:

Because all wood glues are equivalent in terms of wetting and toughness the choice of what glue to use is made on the basis of secondary considerations- price, availability, use temperature, shelf life, working time, convenience, Period Correct, etc. "Better" only has meaning if the relative importance of these secondary considerations are defined.

.... in the context of musical instruments and their repair using butter knives. However, in the process of avoiding duplicity, found others were lambasted for doing just that.

I don't think using posteriori to protect flawed a priori works very well. No, correction, it doesn't work at all.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#39

Re: I find use for several glues...

eliot d

John in NM: Why "horrors of horrors" when in comes to contact cement? I must say that I never use it except to attach melamine-type sheets to a substrate. ( And I believe that it is the glue of choice for that application.) I find myself wondering, though, what would happen if you just used it like any other glue. What's it made of, anyway?

Re: Essential glue attributes

#40

Contact cement...

John in NM

I've mostly used it for laminate too, on the rare occasion I've done any laminate work. One shop I worked for kept trying to use it for paper backed veneer. Seems like there were lots of prolems with bubbles and glue creep.

I'm sure if you do a lot of work with it you get used to it, but I never did. I don't think it would work at all used as a normal glue. I seem to remember trying to put some weather strip on a truck of mine in college (before I'd done much gluing of anything) and not believing the directions that said to apply to both surfaces, let dry, and put them together. Used a whole tube and never got the weatherstrip to stick adequately.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#41

Re: Contact cement...

eliot d

Yeah, that's about what I figure, too. But I'm still curious: itt does have this nice quality of sticking instantly once both surfaces are a bit dry. That could presumably come in handy for something more than veneer,etc.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#42

You're right, it is quite handy

John in NM

My only current use is a spray can of something similar to contact cement. It's great for making cardboard boxes for shipping. Some varieties are foam safe and very handy for sticking fabric to foam or foam to foam. Got a car headliner that is sagging? You can glue it back, at least for a while, with this stuff.

I read once that the original application that it was designed for was sticking leather and faux leather to aluminum camera and binocular bodies. No idea if that is strictly correct, but it would excel in that application.

I just don't much like it for woodworking :D

Re: Essential glue attributes

#43

Re: Contact cement...

TomD

It gets used a lot with leather because leather either is soft and floppy or something soft and floppy is being adhered to it. So making up shoes several types may be used, though one has to be careful because the rubbers involved can stop transpiration, and make shoes uncomfortable. Leather will often get backed up with stitching.

Contact cement is a type deffined by it method of use, rather than other glues that are often described by what the glue is like Hide, Epoxy PVC. So there are many different types of contact cement, some are very reliable glues. I used some 3M type 77 to apply regular wood veneer with great success, though I can't now remember why. Barge is excellent around water.

Re: Essential glue attributes

#44

It is good for boats....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

One of the first things I ever assembled from wood was a wood kit canoe. (While it was dandy to fish from, for recreational paddling it had the hull speed of a river barge) At the time I lived in St. Paul near 3M and in that age 3M had tech service that a mortal could call up and get advice. I thold them that I wanted to glue wood together and that the joint must be waterproof and ideally have slight flexibility. A product with a long number was recommended. The directions were to coat both surfaces and stick them togehther and that I would have a few seconds to adjust. It was a contact cememt. It worked ideal for the task but I would not use it to assemble furniture.

Contact cement is a solution of some tough polymer with the porperty that the polymer remians a bit sticky when the solvent evaporates. In this "a bit sticky" state if two surfaces are brought together the glue molecules will mingle and a bond will be formed between these surfaces. Because the glue reamains somewhat fluid a bond will creep if loaded.

Because of the solvent and cost of raw materials to make these adhesives they will be more expensive than water based adhesives like white glue.