Hot hide glue
Warren in Lancaster, PA
The use of hot hide glue is an art. Like any art, experience is essential, training is extremely helpful as is watching others work. Technical articles are not so helpful. You can read books about violin playing if you want, but unless you have a real violin in your hands, have a real teacher to work with, and listen to others playing, you will not know much.
Susan Buck is a fine expert in microscopic analysis of paint and varnish on period furniture. I have heard her lecture and I think I have met her. However, in 1990, when she did the glue study at Delaware, she was in a two year conservation program, having spent the previous 10 years in marketing. Even then she was concentrating on paint, not glue. I don't think she then had the science background of Bill Tindall, or any previous experience using hot hide glue.
Susan used a two to one ratio of water to glue by weight, which strikes me as rather thin. My hide glue package suggests one to one, then thin if desired. She was also apparently unaware that hide glue was available in different strengths. She tested only up to 84% humidity, which is more than reasonable for a museum, but in this region humidity and temperature can exceed 90% and 90 degrees for days.
It is ridiculous for people without a body of experience and real world training to be making statements about this art.