Essential glue attributes
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
An effective glue must have two essential properties. Focusing just on wood gluing, first it must wet the wood. In the context of adhesion wet means the electrons of the cured glue must be mingled with the electrons on the surface of the substrate. This "mingling" is not enough to say that a chemical bond has formed like what holds the glue molecules together, but it is similar. We can assume that anything sold as wood glue meets this criteria and we can not worry further about it unless we spilled linseed oil, or some such, on the wood before gluing and thereby changed the surface properties of the wood.
Second, the cured glue must be, ideally, as strong as the wood. When a joint is stressed the wood should be the weak link and we get wood failure. This failure is the goal of gluing. Or, the bond between wood and cured glue may fail. If the wood surface is not contaminated and the glue properly applied this failure won't happen using a glue designed for wood. A common failure here is to let the surface of the glue dry too much before assembling the joint. Or, in the case of protein glue, to apply at too low a temperature.
In a practical joint there will be a layer of cured glue between the two wood surfaces. To get wood failure the mechanical properties of this bulk cured glue must be better than the wood. Any glue recommended for wood will be stronger than wood unless the glue has been "damaged".
"Undamaged" wood glue of any kind will cure to a tough plastic. A thin layer of cured glue will be flexible and very strong like a piece of Mylar or Nylon.
In the case of the protein glues the protein molecules can be chopped up by bacteria, mold or other chemical action, enhanced by high temperature or retarded by additives. These processes render the glue brittle instead of tough. The particles in the yellow glues must coalesce to become tough. They will not coalesce below a certain temperature, nor if the moisture content of the wood is too high. The result will be a powdery or rubbery "cured" glue.
Because all wood glues are equivalent in terms of wetting and toughness the choice of what glue to use is made on the basis of secondary considerations- price, availability, use temperature, shelf life, working time, convenience, Period Correct, etc. "Better" only has meaning if the relative importance of these secondary considerations are defined.




