New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Not a Hand Tool In Sight

Posts

Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#1

Not a Hand Tool In Sight

JDK

I simply can't believe this guy's workshop. What I think is most amazing, however, is there are no hand (edge) tools whatsoever in his shop.

Thoughts?


Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#2

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

Sandor

Check closely from 0:39 to 0:43

Seriously though - OMG.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#3

Works for him

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I hope his productivity matches his investment.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#4

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

john sayles

OK after several passes through the video I spotted a single smooth plane on the counter at the back of the shop.

I'm pretty sure it's there to hold down some papers.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#5

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

Gary Hodgin

I bet he's single and probably going to win. Either my eyes are deceiving me or he has the largest hand screw I've ever seen (at about 1.5 minutes).

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#6

Haven't been there in a while...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

The guy lives nearby (15 min. drive or so). He won Wood Magazine's first "best shop contest", oh, ages ago. He's firmly on the electron side, I visited the shop a couple times (seems like he changed a few things, I'm not surprised :) ). Jacques served as our local WW association's president a couple years ago.

What's amazing is that he can use all the machines in his shop, takes quite a bit of planning! I did not look for hand tools when I visited, one is just overwhelmed by the density of machines in that shop...

I'll have to keep an eye open next time I visit :)

DC

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#7

Re: so what?


Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#8

Re: so what?

JDK

Please don't get me wrong. I find absolutely nothing whatsoever wrong with his astonishing tool collection, and I wish him all the joys his remarkable shop can bring him.

I'm simply amazed, and thought others here might be as well.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#9

Re: Works for him

Kevin French

Is that possible?

Theres a LOT of inventory there.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#10

Takes a lot of skill...

John in NM

To use nothing but machines, just like using nothing but hand tools. I'm forever trimming things that I didn't quite make the right size with the machine :D

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#11

And no saw dust.


Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#12

Re: Takes a lot of skill...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

on another forum, I suggested that one way to fix the problem of fitting parts was to plane them. The response was that if the parts didn't fit right off the machine, you're not going to improve the fit with a hand plane. :O

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#13

I worked for a guy who thought that way...

John in NM

He positively cringed when he saw me pick up a chisel :D

For production work he was right - making the same part over and over, it pays to have the machine set up and calibrated to do everything the same every time. For one off work like we did there, I found the time to be a wash between fussing with the tenoner to get it just so and taking a swipe or two on each tenon to fit them. Making a piece with a dozen or so tenons it really didn't seem to matter.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#14

Re: Takes a lot of skill...

Kevin French

And if they knew that wasn't true the price of old hand tools would triple.

Ignorance is bliss and let sleeping dogs lie.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#15

Re: I worked for a guy who thought that way...

Kevin French

I picked up a very nice #3 type 11 from the metal bin at the dump. I was checking it out as a guy who works at the dump said, 'No one uses those any more', he had found it and tossed it back in.

I just replied 'Ya, but they look nice on a wall.'

Explaining would have been a waste of time.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#16

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

MikeL

I'm pretty sure that's a Stanley #4 on the bench at about 0:46 and then again at 0:55. Could be that all other hand tools are stored in chests/cabinets and only pulled out when in use.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

well put


Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#18

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

TomD

He has a giant bench one can only make sense of by imagining he does use hand tools, or at least a belt sander.

I don't know how he keeps the place dust free, it is an awesome.

I imagine he is pretty productive just to be able to outfit that shop. My shop is a dump but tight. Tight shops excel at making prototype stuff because you can make anything, but you do not have the efficiency that comes from having a near empty shop for sure. On the other hand you may be productively making a large boat in the back yard and the indoors allows you to make every part kind of thing.

That guy Matthias Wandel who put up the video is amazing. I am currently making one of his marble pumps/runs. It kills me to build from plans, but in this case it makes sense. He has a lot of interesting stuff on his sight, home made machines, etc...

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#19

Didn't realize this came from Matthias'site

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Yeah, the guy is pretty amazing... He treated us to a demo of his homemade jointer, made using a portable planer's cutterhead and motor, pretty impressive.

And trust me, the air siren works!

DC

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#20

Not a lot of room to work in sight either

roger lance

but the guy is a testament to organizing.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#21

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

Guillaume

He is a member of the Ottawa Woodworkers association and no, he doesn't have much time for sweat equity. He is however an inveterate collector of any electron eaters, whether he needs them or not...

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#22

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

Brian Greene

Jacques is actually a very accomplished woodworker. I think he has four daughters and he has built most of their furniture. He is in his 70's and has been WW for more than 50 years. It works for him.

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

#23

Re: Not a Hand Tool In Sight

Guillaume

Hey Brian,

I realize that my reply may have sounded a tad dismissive. I was by no means questioning Jacques' ability as a woodworker.

My reply was based on my conversations with Jacques and visiting his shop. He is a self-admitted electron-eating tool collector and hoarder and will, as you know, go out of his way to find (or acquire) a power tool to do any given job.

A visit to his shop is always a tad awe-inspiring and a bit scary. I am afraid of getting lost in his basement shop. As an aside, some of those tools are there for life; when he first got into his house (before I was born I think!) he paid to get an access excavated and an opening cut through the foundation to get the large tooling in.

Guillaume

(who wouldn't know what to do with some of Jacques tools)