New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

Posts

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#2

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

roger lance

Leo....here's another work holder that's based on the wedge....


it also comes in handy at times.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#3

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#4

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

neat idea...have you tried it yet?

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#5

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

Larry Barrett

Looks like this would work well on William's swiss cheese meta-bench.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#6

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

roger lance

This idea has long been used in sailing to secure ropes from being pulled out of place.....see cam cleats.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#7

Leo Cuellar

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

Leo Cuellar

Yes, and also for holding your long handled tools in the closet or garage, etc.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#8

Leo Cuellar

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

Leo Cuellar

Been there done that and everything else as well.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#9

Leo Cuellar

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

Leo Cuellar

Not yet, Bill, but I'll be making a set when I get time.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#10

Leo Cuellar

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

Leo Cuellar

I think anything would work well on that device, it is seriously cool. :)

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#11

Leo Cuellar

Re: And another: Nautilus cams + video

Leo Cuellar

I imagine that they would work well no matter how big or small they are: say a miniature pair for one of the little handheld vises? I like that they are deployable in a few seconds.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#12

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

AlanWS

For handplaning, it might be more compact and effective to use only one cam to hold the work against a flat surface.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#13

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

TomD

There is noting new about cams, a novel use is still a novel use.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#14

Re: An interesting work holding idea.

TomD

That is what I was thinking, two cams does not increase the force, one cam would convert all the back pressure into lateral force, and the use of a solid side would increase friction, lower bruising, and also if the fixed side were at the bench edge keep the work more under the shoulder.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#15

Re: A Flawed Work Holding Idea

William Duffield

Hmm. I build a pair of these clamps a few years ago, but never thought to try them on the Loxiliary Bench. I'll have to give them a try. As shown in my photo, I think they are more useful for carving than for working with rectilinear stock, as shown in the video Larry provided.


My clamps didn't work as well as I had hoped because I got the angle of the logarithmic spiral a little too steep for the most effective grip on wood. I think 10°, as shown in the first figure in the following linked article, should be appropriate for hardwoods, but only if you are clamping between a cam and a flat surface. If you are clamping between two cams, then I think a 5° spiral for each cam would be more effective. However, more experimentation is needed. Since the effective range of motion of a cam with this shallow of an angle is much smaller than the golden spiral, it requires a lot more dog holes, spaced much closer together, to grip any arbitrary width of stock. Perhaps the application of PSA sandpaper would allow a larger angle to be effective.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logarithmic_spiral

Right now, the Loxiliary bench is in the back of my vehicle, under a mini-lathe, a work-mutt, a pile of extension cords, three overloaded tool boxes, and a roll of Ceylon Satinwood veneer, as I got home from three days at the Somerset Woodworking Show late yesterday evening, and my tail was dragging. I was there demonstrating the bench and some tool making techniques. It will take most of today to get everything unloaded, back into the Toolworks, and put away, and then maybe I can try out the cam clamps.

Note that the clamps in the video that David Barnett posted, since they are a Fibonacci spiral, laid out with a compass, instead of using an appropriate formula to generate the Golden logarithmic spiral that he is trying to approximate, do not have "an angle." In other words, it varies as the clamps are rotated. Also, I note that he is not very careful to even follow with his bandsaw the spiral he drew. Even if he got it right, IMHO, the golden spiral is much too steep for effective holding of hardwoods.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_spiral

Also, I understand why he thinks loose dowels are an advantage (they're not), because that allows them to stack more easily, but it also means that the dowels can become separated from the cam clamps and lost, or fall through the dog holes in the bench. It also takes longer to set them up and take them down, because there are a lot more pieces to handle. Instead, I would glue and wedge the dowels into the clamps, and to make them stackable, drill another oversized hole or two in each clamp. Of course, if you glue in the dowels, you have to make sure you make two left-handed and two right-handed cams, instead of four the same.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#16

Re: A Flawed Work Holding Idea

roger lance

A strip of 100 grit psa should make a significant difference.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#17

Re: A Flawed Work Holding Idea

William Duffield

Yes, unless you've already finish planed or sanded the surface you need to grip.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#18

Re: A Flawed Work Holding Idea

David Weaver

How about those $3 rolls of tool chest rubber that HF carries. A strip of those would improve things, and wouldn't mark a piece.

Re: An interesting work holding idea. *LINK*

#19

Re: A Flawed Work Holding Idea

roger lance

or some of that rubber matting that LV sells....it has an adhesive underside.....25K01.11 for example.