New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

Posts

Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#1

Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

This question is relevant to the toothing discussion below. If you want to glue two pieces of metal together the surfaces are machined and lapped perfectly planar and smooth. In a long ago demonstration of cyanoacrylate adhesive, then known as Eastman 910, the ends of two 2 " bars (may have been 2.5") were so prepared, a drop of the adhesive placed on one surface and then the surfaces were mated. One bar was fastened to a crane, the other to a car with the adhesive's inventor inside. The car and inventor were successfully hoisted into the air.

In principle, only two monolayers of something tough and strong that will wet each surface are needed to provide adhesion. Virginia Tech has an adhesives program and I had occasion to ask one of the researchers whether wood is stuck together by adhesion or mechanical interlocking. He responded that given the porous nature of wood it would be difficult to separate the two possibilities, but that the mechanical part is not essential to stick wood, or anything else together by adhesion.

Speculation: Veneer is not going to be easy to plane given that it is mechanically weaker than a board. Could it be that a toothing plane with its may teeth exerts less planing force on the veneer during planing and that is the whole of it?

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Two unrelated questions there???

Jesper, Denmark

When you look at perfectly ground and polished surfaces from the nano-scale of the adhesive molecules, the surfaces still resemble a Rocky Mountain profile. Does this provide tooth to the adhesive? - or just a larger surface?.

i don't know. On the other hand, there is no need to rough-up any machined wood surface for adhesives to stick.

The veneer planing question is several magnitudes away from the other one in terms of roughness. No experience, but gut feel says the plain plane blade will work with less resistance.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#3

Planing veneer

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Planing veneer is not difficult. Period veneers are quite a bit thicker than what people are using today. If there is any tendency to buckle we fasten the veneer at one end and plane away from the clamp. The veneer is planed in tension.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#4

a question for toothing plane owners

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

What difference do you experience planing with the toothing plane compared to a regular straight bladed plane? Less resistance, less tearing, anything?

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#5

Re: a question for toothing plane owners

Sammi Takeuchi

I think if you compare to the plane with same width of blade, resistance "should" be less, but since bedding angle of normal toothing plane is 75 to nearly vertical, it's hard to compare resistance as set up isn't the same.

Also toothing plane used for veneer is very fine that they aren't really made to remove materials, but to scoff and texture the surface. My toothing plane has 28 teeth per inch and with bedding angle of 75 (I don't like near vertical ones), it's not something you want to use for anything other than scoffing/texturing for practical purposes. Even the ones with less teeth are not really fit for removing materials. If you try to remove any more than minimal amount, you are basically trying to plane with a scraper. Teeth serration is very tiny, about 0.2mm in depth and removing very small amount on top of toothed blade does reduce tear out. These are totally different tool from those so called toothed blade sold for bench planes and bevel up planes today. These have very deep and much fewer teeth that is capable of making deep cut like a normal blade. But they are too coarse for veneering and are not designed for that task.

Another thing is that some old musical instruments have textured surface from toothing plane inside without having smoothed out. I don't know if it was for preventing tear out, trying to make better gluing surface or what. Or could be for all those reasons. I don't know precisely why.

Originally, it was thought that scoffed surface will provide better bonding using hide glue, and it was the traditional way of veneering. Probably woodworkers and craftsman of previous centuries felt it makes sense to use toothing planes for veneering regardless of what the knowledge of adhesive today is. If they felt it formed weak bonding, they would have done away, but since they didn't, probably they didn't think it was any less inferior than bond between two smooth surfaces.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#6

craigd

Q about HH hammer veneering

craigd

If the substrate and veneer are smooth, is it possible to get a starved joint when you hammer veneer with hot hide glue? I'm guessing unlikely but if so, that would be a good reason to tooth.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#7

maybe the opposite....

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Maybe "hammering" is incapable of squeezing out excess glue and the grooves of the toothing plane provide a place for it to go, as needed.

"Staved joints" are a myth. It takes just two molecular layers of adhesive to make a bond. Considering the viscosity of glue it would be impossible to apply sufficient pressure to squeeze all of it out from between any two surfaces.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#8

Re: a question for toothing plane owners

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Interesting information which leaves me even more puzzled as to the purpose of "toothing", an operation apparently unique to hide glue and hammer veneering.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#9

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

roger lance

Watch the Woodwright episode listed by Derek Cohen below for insights into why a toothing plane (not the modern toothing blade) is used in veneering. Some reasons given were:

1) A toothing plane will flatten surface of highly figured woods (without tear-out) from which veneer is cut.

2) A toothing plane is used to remove the saw marks from surface of veneer.

3) A toothing plane can be used in any direction regardless of grain.

4) A toothing plane is used on the substrate to help placement of veneer and reduce movement/slipping of veneer during gluing.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#10

Possible modern equal to wooden toothing plane

roger lance

See the Veritas Scraping Plane (05P29.01) with a toothing blade of 25 teeth/inch....the blade is bedded at an angle similar to old style wood toothing planes....Derek might weigh in with an experienced opinion.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#11

that's got it

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I worked for someone that insisted on precise language. He advocated that if you didn't speak precisely and accurately you wouldn't think precisely and accurately.

By calling this device a "toothing plane" it leads one to presume that its purpose is to "tooth" the veneer. Had it been referred to as a "toothed" plane its true function would not have been obscured.

Thanks for the research into this topic.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#12

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

TomD

"In principle, only two monolayers of something tough and strong that will wet each surface are needed to provide adhesion. Virginia Tech has an adhesives program and I had occasion to ask one of the researchers whether wood is stuck together by adhesion or mechanical interlocking. He responded that given the porous nature of wood it would be difficult to separate the two possibilities, but that the mechanical part is not essential to stick wood, or anything else together by adhesion."

I am not sure about your language here. I have attempted to get on top of the mechanisms of gluing and related language, but have not been successful. I thought the main one were mechanical and chemical. Wiki indicates 5 sub categories for adhesion, so in saying mechanical, or adhesion you are in the first case using with "mechanical" a sub category of adhesion generally.

"Speculation: Veneer is not going to be easy to plane given that it is mechanically weaker than a board. Could it be that a toothing plane with its may teeth exerts less planing force on the veneer during planing and that is the whole of

I don't see any reason for discounting the standard explanation, but toothing planes are excellent for reducing tear out. In some crafts they are the main do-all plane for roughing and everything else, because the craft involves very tear-out prone woods, and gluing is going to follow on immediately. There are some woods that when a problem shows up, it shows up in a lost chunk/disaster. Today we have in general distribution planes that are capable of very fine work, but it was not always thus. I doubt they had planes capable of handling certain veneers in older times, and they would probably have provided surfaces that were so polished that roughing up would have been an extra step.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#13

Re: maybe the opposite....

TomD

"Maybe "hammering" is incapable of squeezing out excess glue and the grooves of the toothing plane provide a place for it to go, as needed."

That may show a possible misunderstanding of how hammer veneering works. The idea cooling as much as clamping. Cooling occurs by squishing the glue out of the joint. So giving it a place to hang around and not move off, would retain the heat, and be counter productive. The hammer is a rounded edge, upon which, conceptually the force when applied is infinite. Of course, the reel world intrudes with various forms of deformation, but the force that can be applied is considerable. It is probably greater in most cases than clamps.

Speaking of which, I have a c-clamp with a built in pressure gage. It is designed for determining the camber of cross country skis. The contact point is less than 1 square in, I would guess. I was testing skis the other day, and I got to 110 PSI. At that point it was hard to turn the handle on the C clamp, it is about a 6" clamp, of excellent construction. It did set me to think that probably the clamping pressure, often in the hundreds of pounds, listed for c-clamps, and other clamps, are probably wildly exaggerated. The real pressures are probably a lot lower, and probably something like a hammer is exerting far greater pressure, for what that is worth.

""Staved joints" are a myth. It takes just two molecular layers of adhesive to make a bond. Considering the viscosity of glue it would be impossible to apply sufficient pressure to squeeze all of it out from between any two surfaces."

As may be, but it is possible to starve a joint, there may be something more complex happening, like the guy clamped down, and then didn't adjust for loss of glue space, etc... But whatever it is, it does happen now and again, and the term will do for now until something better comes along. The mere fact one needs only a few molecules of glue, and that the clamps may not be capable of displacing all the glue, does not cover all the bases. It might with your carefully prepared example of a steel test piece. That is the kind of prep where a film of water might have done the trick.

Re: Is gluing mechanical locking or adhesion?

#14

craigd

On toothing planes *LINK*

craigd

The Anthony Hay's, Cabinetmaker (Colonial Williamsburg) blog has a nice discussion of the toothing plane from a historical perspective:

You can smooth rough sawn veneers without worrying about tearout.

The tooth marks (on the substrate and veneer) keep the veneer from moving around and aid in adhesion (no reason why given).

Use a toothing plane to get a gnarly veneer show surface flat, then sand/scrap to make pretty. Again, no worries about messing up a nice veneer.

Other uses.


http://anthonyhaycabinetmaker.wordpress.com/2011/01/29/the-toothing-plane-a-tool-of-our-time/