New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Designing a box for a plough plane

Posts

Designing a box for a plough plane

#1

Designing a box for a plough plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I returned to the shop this past weekend for the first time in two months. I guess one should not be surprised that I had a couple of weeks of flu following my return to a steaming Australia from the cold and snow of US and Canada.

Anyway, before I left for the other colonies I had begun designing and constructing a box for a bridle plough plane built several months ago. It was to be basic (it's just a box!) yet needed to be interesting enough to earn its place in the shop.

The box began as a simple dovetail construction mixing two West Australian woods, Jarrah and She-oak, both of which had featured in the plough plane.


It did present a few interesting moments, such as a tricky diagonal saw cut to open it up ...


Initially I had been inspired by the lines of a military/campaign writing desk.


I went so far as to French fit the 8 irons in a frame-and-panel insert (that was fun - the Jarrah is both brittle and hard) ...


It became apparent that this was not going to work. Just too bulky and too heavy to manoeuvre.

Perhaps it would look better orientated like this?


That was even worse!

The trouble was that I had worked hard to match the dovetails on the sides, and I had to let this go. So, after some soul searching, the box has ended up like this ...


The front is a frame-and-panel lid/door. As mentioned , one of my goals was to make the box as simple as possible. I did not want mouldings or fancy fittings. Indeed, I did not want any brass hinges, handles, or catches to show on the exterior.


As you have anticipated, the front opens downward ...


.. to reveal the plough (much easier to grab now than leaning into a box). This is held in place by a bracket at the rear ..


.. and the irons with the rescued French-fit tray. They are secured by a single cross piece ...




And the remaining section of the box? It will be converted into a writing desk.

Regards from Perth

Derek

p.s. I think that it is time to build a light box. Apologies for the quality of the pics.

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#2

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

roger lance

Derek.....a wonderful example of an evolution of design.....great result!!.....congratulations!!

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#3

Interestin process. Good post


Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#4

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

wilbur

Terrific job, as always!

I really like the idea of storing the plane on its side. I have a box with a sliding lid that I store a Record 44 and 43 in, and I've always thought the box was a bit too big for what it should be. Turning the plane on its side certainly will reduce the footprint of the box.

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#5

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I like how that turned out, Derek, much better than it started. Slimming down the box helped a lot. I know you put a lot of work into calculating the position of dovetails so they would line up properly when the box was cut, but this is much better. The sloped front is snazzy, too! ;)

It gives me a good idea for what to do for a box for my 45 (I don't have the original, but I don't like it, either).

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#6

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

It seems to me that it would look better with the top on top. I like the way it turned out. The smaller size seems more appropriate. I don't understand why you want it to open from the side. However, it would depend, I suppose, on where you locate it in the shop. As usual, impeccable workmanship.

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#7

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Patrick

Opening from "the side" (or front, as I would call it) make it easier to access the plane. The box is on the top of a low cabinet in the corner of the shop. It would be different if the box was a tool chest and accessed from the top.

I'd take a photo of the placement in the shop if it did not presently look as though a bomb had gone off! :)

If I had shelf space I would not have bothered with a box - I just want to protect the plane from accidental damage. So this box had to be functional, enabling all the parts to be easily accessed. Form comes from Function.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#8

pre-construction drawing?

Jerry Gibbs

Admire your work and your ability to get quality projects down with a busy outside schedule. I have poor design skills, either on paper or computer and am working on same. I'm curious what designing you did before construction and whether you think something like a Sketchup design could have prevented the problem. Jerry

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#9

Re: pre-construction drawing?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Jerry

I think that my history of changing horses in mid gallop is evidence of my poor ability to think through some projects! :) All that this has taught me is not to fear changes and repairs.

My ideas come from various sources, and slowly distill as I attempt to visualise it all. No doubt the ability to evolve a design in Sketchup would speed up the design and build process. I have yet to master this program - tending to avoid the learning required rather than denying its worthiness - and rely on sketches, which are not always to scale or in proportion.

Actually, your post is a greater help than you realise. I have been dithering over a writing desk build as it is so technically complicated. Using Sketchup could help enormously.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#10

I hesitate to say it but...

Bob Hackett

In this case thinking INSIDE the box exceeded the expectations.

As always, incredible work all around and an inspiration to take things to the next level for the rest of us.

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#11

Nice work!

James Watriss

Good decision to nix the lid. Some tools are just oddly shaped, and rectilinear doesn't suit.

As always, gorgeous work.

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#12

Question about the top

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

Is there something that makes it stay closed?

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#13

Re: Question about the top

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Patrick

I mentioned earlier that I was trying to avoid any external adornments or fittings.

My plan was to add a rare earth magnet at the intersection of the lid and box. I am in two minds whether to still do this as, with the lid leaning over, the weight of the (French fitted irons) in the lid holds it down. This is quite secure, even when carried.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#14

Re: Question about the top

Patrick Gibbons, beside Buffalo Bayou

Part of the elegance of the design. The box invites one to use the plow. A project like this is more difficult to design because it needs to be used first to prove the design itself. I'm thinking about something I made over a year ago that I want to remake and change but as it's already made and working it doesn't get high priority. A designer that doesn't use his designs will perpetuate poor products.

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#15

The box has its position in the shop.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Patrick

The box is in its place. It is easy to access. The hard part was tidying up the shop to make room!!! It does not get as tidy as this very often.



This is in the corner of the shop where similar tools are stored ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Designing a box for a plough plane

#16

Re: The box has its position in the shop.

Patrick Gibbons

My shop fixtures aren't nearly as nice as yours. I've been trying to put my shop in order lately and it confounds me how much time it takes for making the simplest of things. Saturday I spent three hours fixing a drawer for file (hand and mill, not paper) storage. It's an unwelcome truth for me that the appearance of my shop mirrors the quality of my work.