hide glue
eliot d
I've been using a bottled hide glue recently for some inlay and gluing together the parts of fairly small decorative boxes. Is the "real stuff" that you get from crystals and a glue pot better? (I have a birthday coming up.)
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
hide glue
eliot d
I've been using a bottled hide glue recently for some inlay and gluing together the parts of fairly small decorative boxes. Is the "real stuff" that you get from crystals and a glue pot better? (I have a birthday coming up.)
Re: hide glue
William Duffield
It's different, yet very similar in some respects. Check out recent thread with video and discussions in Bob Rozaieski's Logan CAbinet Shoppe blog. One aspect not mentioned is the advantage of liquid hide glue for repairing small areas of loosened veneer during furniture restoration. Since it is thin, it wicks under the veneer, and then 3M blue painter's tape is enough to hold it down while the glue dries.
http://logancabinetshoppe.com/blog/2013/02/quick-tip-13-dont-fear-the-hide-glue/
Also, watch Woodwright's Shop episode 3110 on hammer veneering with Steve Latta. He discusses the differences between pearl hide glue and ground hide glue. In addition to the glue pot, you're going to need to build a veneer hammer.
http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/3100/3110.html
Finally, you'll want to discuss the culinary appeal of hide glue with my shop dog.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Knox Unflavored — the 'white tea' of hide gl
William Duffield
Way too many things in this world with a picture of a Golden Retriever on the front, and on the back under the list of ingredients, "not for human consumption."
How come I gotta pay sales tax on this stuff?
And then there's Kikapoo Joy Juice, whose recipe escapes me at the moment
.
Re: hide glue
eliot d
I watched the video, but it didn't really get to my question: I simply want to know if the stuff in the bottle is as good as making your own.
Hide glue in a bottle vs. hot hide glue
wilbur
Hide glue that comes in a bottle is often called "liquid hide glue". This is hide glue to which something has been added to slow down its drying time. The advantage of this is that it can sit in the bottle and be used when you want without firing up a glue pot. I use this all the time instead of PVA glue.
Hot hide glue is the stuff that comes in granules, and then you put it in some water and heat it up in a glue pot. Hot hide glue sets up very quickly, and it does take a little time to prepare prior to using it.
In terms of one being better than the other, it depends on your application. Given my experience this weekend, I don't think anything can beat hot hide glue for veneering. On the other hand, the quick dry time might be a disadvantage for a complicated glueup, although many people I trust say that the tack of hot hide glue is so good that you can glue up, say, a drawer one piece at a time without using clamps.
In terms of strength, hot hide glue seems to be a little stronger than liquid hide glue, but this probably has something to do with the gram strength of the hide glue granules that you start with, and is probably mainly important in situations like instrument making, where the glue has to resist the constant tension of guitar strings over a long long period of time. For making furniture, either one will be fine.
Re: hide glue
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Eliot,
Here's a reprint of a July/August 2007 Fine Woodworking test of various glues. They used different woods, and from snug to loose joint fittings:
http://www.oldbrownglue.com/pdf/HowStrongisYourGlue_FWW.pdf
The liquid hide and the hot hide ended in roughly a tie, in this testing. The main difference I have found is in the working time of the two products: sometimes it's more convenient to have the really fast tack of the hot hide, and other times you need more time to apply the glue and fiddle with the parts to get to final fit.
Wiley
P.S.-- a little more on hot hide
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hot hide is especially good in situations where it's difficult or awkward to get a clamp on the part you're gluing. (For example, when making those bandings I showed in a different thread.) In those situations, you can just use your fingers: dip the part into the glue pot with a pair of hemostats or your fingers, bring it out dripping, and just press it into place with your fingers. Hold it for a minute, and by that time, the glue will be seizing, and you're done. As the glue dries further, it shrinks and pulls the piece in even tighter. Wipe away waste glue with a moist rag after 10 minutes, when the waste glue has gelled. By that time, the bond glue will have set.
If you have a bunch of such parts to glue, you can move on after holding a piece in place for a minute, wipe your hands off on a wet towel so you're not sticking to everything, and do the next piece. What looks like a complicated job can move along really fast, because of the fast tack of the hot hide glue.
Wiley
Re: P.S.-- a little more on hot hide
eliot d
I've got it now. Thanks.
"as good" is not the right qeustion
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Any glue commonly used will be effective at making furniture. The question is which is easiest to use, or cheapest, or Period correct, or has the longest or shortest working time, will be most moisture resistant, fills cracks, takes stain, etc. etc. Pick what ever attribute is most important to you and ask a question about how this or that glue stacks up in this factor.
In out class we used yellow(for stringing, banding and veneering)), Franklin liquid hide (for medallions) and hot hide (for making banding). Each was best in our situation for the application it was used for. In 1720 hot hide would have been used for everything.
Re: "as good" is not the right qeustion
wilbur
Why was yellow glue considered to be better than hot hide glue or liquid hide glue for stringing, banding, and veneering? I might be missing something, but I can't think of any property that yellow glue has that would make it more suitable for those tasks than LHG or HHG.
Re: "as good" is not the right qeustion
eliot d
My main concern was whether or not I should "spring" for a hot glue pot and go through the extra steps in making up hot hide glue. After reading the FWW article on various glues, I can't see any significant difference between LHG and HHG, so unless I learn something new, I believe I'll just stick with LHG where it works well and PVA for most stuff.
answer
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Stringing and banding- Hot hide sets too quick for amateur hands. Liquid hide is way too slow. Yellow , just right.
Medallions -it is difficult to wrap one and then inset it without tiny gaps. Liquid hide made these gaps largely invisible.
Veneering- We needed to lay up a veneer stack to use to slice banding from. Slathered on some yellow glue and into the vacuum bag it went. Yellow or white glue and vacuum bag is fool proof and low labor. I see vacuum bags in every commercial shop I have been in. One has to conclude that this approach is easier and more reliable.
For those on the side lines. Hammer veneering is not fool proof. It is an entertaining parlor trick for some demonstrators but from what I see in the trade it has been replaced by vacuum bags. I have seen two highly experience professionals get burned using this technique where a vacuum bag would have been successful in anybody's hands. In fact in one case I used the veneer that failed to bond successfully and bagged it with white glue with no fuss. In the other case the demonstrator never did get a good bond on one curve of a serpentine drawer front.
You will have a lot of company......
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
for that is what you will be seeing almost everyone that makes furniture doing.
A Nice Parlor Trick *LINK*
Re: answer
wilbur
"Hammer veneering is not fool proof."
Well, a nine year-old was successful at his first attempt at hammer veneering this past weekend. So was this 48 year-old.
My back door neighbor, who is an excellent woodworker, will attest to the fact that vacuum clamping veneer isn't fool proof, either.
I would submit that nothing in woodworking is foolproof. I would also submit that going with what most professional furniture makers do isn't always a good marker for success. If we really used volume of output as a marker for successful furniture construction technique, we all would be making furniture with veneer covered particle board.
Yes, and
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
if we follow Paul Dzioba's link to Patrick Edwards' site, we can scroll down and see the reproduction pair of tables that he himself made. Patrick's site map here,
http://www.wpatrickedwards.com/Sitemap.htm
takes us to galleries of other completed pieces of work. The section 'At the Bench' explains that he does his work by hand.
Caution, opinion coming
: Since the world is big enough to hold both Steve Latta and Patrick Edwards, perhaps there is room for all of us and our differences.
Wiley
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Oh, no! You, too?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
You're right, David, I take it back. Too much kumbaya spoils a good row over glue. Pretty soon we wouldn't even have sharpening fights ending with "...your problem is you just don't know how to sharpen." I like those. Nuther thing: Why anybody would want a chisel made out of rolled steel is beyond me--if it ain't hammer forged, it's junk. Same thing with saws. Sump'n else: tails first.
Wiley....feeling purty good now
foolproof...
John in NM
You are quite correct, nothing is truly foolproof, or at least nothing worth doing is. I have seen problems with vacuum bags and yellow glue - bubbles that never disappear. It was probably because it was paper backed veneer and the paper wasn't permiable enough to let the air pass through.
Be that as it may, I have done quite a bit of bag veneering, and it is quicker, easier, and more reliable than hammer veneering. While I wouldn't call hammer veneering a palor trick, I will say that it is no surprise to me that professional shops all use vacuum bags 
skip the pot, try the glue
John in NM
Two things I like a lot about hot hide glue. I've been using the same batch for years - only mix what you need and the rest sits in a jar on the shelf. Never seems to go bad. I also like the smell. Call me weird, but there it is. I must be half shop dog 
Like David says above, there are lots of options for glue pots that work quite as well as the expensive ones. A little crock pot should run under $20 at Walmart or the like, or if you frequent thrift stores you can probably find one for under $5. I use a coffee cup warmer and a 1 1/2" copper pipe cap - already had both so it was free. Cup warmer was $10 but that was easily 20 years ago - bought it to keep a pot of dopping wax (lapidary) liquid. No idea now why I thought that was necessary....
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Oh, no! You, too?
wilbur
Was with you until that last one, Wiley. Pins first. 
just curious
Paul Dzioba
What about repair to the veneer down the road? Hide glue sticks to itself and can even be reconstituted. What about PVA or Unibond or any other glue? How difficult is it to re-attach a loose piece or splice in new veneer? Do you need to to remove the glue to a fresh wood surface? Is this furniture throw away or do the furniture makers care about down the road. Just sayin.
Paul Dzioba
white glue is a hot melt adhesive
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
I don't know anything about Unibond, but white glue can be worked as a "hot melt". In fact a friend was needing to attach some complex fret work to a chest on chest. The problem is attaching it without glue squeezing out into the cut outs. I suggested he dab a bit of white glue on the wood, let it dry, then iron it onto the case. To check out this suggestion he did some testing and it worked just fine.
Someone set up for hot hide would have done it that way. Someone not experienced using hot hide would have likely screwed up the application.
It is an obvious fact that most shops, amateurs and factories have long since successfully moved on from hide glue. They don't have it on hand and wouldn't know how to use it if they did. Hence, recommending hot hide glue for this or that application is simply not a useful recommendation t most. Given that the modern glues and techniques for using them (vacuum bags for example) work successfully for all or certainly nearly all wood woodworking there is no motivation to abandon their recognized advantages.