Re: thanks Stephen
CStanford
Okee Dokee.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: thanks Stephen
CStanford
Okee Dokee.
Re: thanks Stephen
CStanford
Franklin International
Technical Support
Phone 1.800.347.4583
Fax 614.445.1295
contechserv@franklininternational.com
Re: Folks at OBG said...
David Weaver
... Patrick at OBG said if the glue gels, you'll get a cold weld instead of a good glue joint. He suggested wiping the joint with a very hot wet rag before applying the glue instead of heating the joint and glue with dry heat.
Presume about 50 degrees is where the glue gels from franklin's guidelines, patrick didn't provide a number or an estimate of one where the glue gels.
Dry heat....NO
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Well I would not heat with dry heat either because you will be unlucky and crack the wood occasionally. But I certainly would have the wood at living room temperature. It will hold the heat long enough to enable the glue to bond if the temperature is not too cold.
I follow this practice on winter time spray finishing. Even at 30 degrees, my lower tolerance for winter finishing(that would be May in MN) the wood retains enough heat to flash the solvent. and get the piece dust free. I move into the living area to cure.
Re: Folks at OBG said...
CStanford
Warm the area, the materials, and the glue. Infrared lamps are your friend. By all means use Patrick's suggestion but put on a belt and your suspenders.
If these glues worked at low temps the manufacturers would be shouting it from rooftops. Loudly. I can assure you.
Re: Folks at OBG said...
David Weaver
I think they may have taken a scorched earth view of what warming the area means, and assumed that I might do it indefinitely.
Warming the glue in warm water and storing the boards in a warm area until just before the glue up were going to be about it, at least in this case.
The panel issue is separate, more to do with where I can install a plano panel clamping apparatus. I can reasonably make that area about 65 degrees.
I'll still glue a few butt joints without doing anything other than using warm glue and see how they'll fail in the fifty degree shop.
Re: Folks at OBG said...
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi David,
"I'll still glue a few butt joints without doing anything other than using warm glue and see how they'll fail in the fifty degree shop."
Good plan! Suggest let a couple of them sit 24 hrs., and a couple others sit 48 hrs. See if it matters.
Wiley
Re: Folks at OBG said...
CStanford
If you're gluing panels and have any doubts at all, stick a few dowels in the joint.
Re: Folks at OBG said...
CStanford
Dowels will help keep the joint from failing in shear.
Re: Folks at OBG said...
CStanford
Though I doubt a floating panel will ever experience shear stress....
Here you go though and from Japan, no less:
http://www.ewpa.com/archive/2008/june/paper_167.pdf
Re: Folks at OBG said...
TomD
Shear failure is about the last thing I would expect. Dowels cause more problems than they solve when glued into sidegrain butts.
Speaking of the dry heat. One has to consider that some products, like soundboards are nearly impossible to split before they are built into the instruments, or braced. This is why that guy in the video was able to heat them to 100F. But there would be other situations where it would be disastrous.
Speaking of wet heat, that is also covered by excess hide glue application. The old timers used hide glue in a number of ways, they would for instance apply it to both sides of veneer, because the hammer worked better on the dried glue. They were not scared of the clean up that sloshing it around might entail.
I can't think of too many situations where I have had cold weather glue joint failure that were not obvious when the joint was assembled. Normally when I am working in the cold I get a really thick joint, and one can take it apart. If the joint closes, it is normally good. I suppose the simple version is that if it seemed OK it was OK, OK being went together as one would expect in normal temps. With white glue, if it runs too cold, rather than getting a starved joint it turns chalky if it is too cold, that kind of thing. In warm temps it would be harder to spot a starved joint.
What I Found (liquid hide glue)
David Weaver
I forgot to post my findings, but here's what I found.
shop temperature, 52
* I heated the glue in warm water
* left pieces for a case to be glued in the adjacent basement (about 60 degrees, that's the best I've got on limited time)
* glued the assembly in the shop, did get what patrick referred to as a cold weld, anything that wasn't tightly glued into the joints (any squeeze out) gelled quickly. I let it go, anyway.
The gelled glue dried hard the next day, and in handling the case around, I don't hear anything loose. I'd imagine the gelled glue is a matter of penetration more than it is strength of the glue (the squeeze out laying on the dovetails was plenty hard)
The case is through dovetails on the bottom, HB dovetails at the top and dado for all of the shelves, so it's not critical that the joints are super monster strong, it's just going to sit in place and hold books. It was a good test piece, as opposed to some big tabletop or something like that where the edge joints need to hold. (No worries, it'll get a back, top moulding, base and trim on the front - I won't let the world see the wood on the ends, despite the fact that my daughter is probably going to beat it senseless when she gets it, anyway)

Then, I took some cutoffs, planed their edges and made a test joint in the shop. That was a lot more optimal than joining a whole case of stuff together, because I could get a thin glue line pretty quickly and no movement after spreading the glue and setting the joint quickly.
That test joint failed about 20% on wood (cherry) and 80% at the glue. I was surprised that it broke any of the wood, if I had a better test piece it may not have. I'd imagine that in an ideal situation like that where the joint goes together quickly and tightly an edge joint would still be good in the long term, but it's probably not something I'll risk.
I was able to get spousal permission to put plano clamps on the wall in the semi-finished basement based on the results, so it's not a lose lose situation, and i have a good place to put them right under an outlet in case I feel like I'd like supplemental electric heat in the spot the panels are being glued.
I think OBG might have a higher gel temperature than franklin's offering, but I can't tell, because my franklin was out of date and I pitched it. Rockler is right down the road from me, and for whatever reason it seems like they often have franklin liquid hide glue on the shelves that is past date or close to it.
Even at near 60 degrees in the basement, the OBG is going nowhere (gelled) in the bottle. It doesn't really matter if you're heating it, but I was still surprised to see that.
hide glue service date
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Franklin uses a different means of liquifying the glue than what was historically used, urea, which leads to a more stable glue. Urea decomposes over time, releasing ammonia which attacks the protein in hide glue. Hence, the expiration data on this traditionally made glue must be considered. Evidence suggests that the Franklin product is stable for years, which is a good reason to prefer it.
Re: What I Found (liquid hide glue)
CStanford
A bookcase of that ilk (it's quite nice!) will inevitably be dragged across the floor fully loaded. The glue needs to cure strong.
Hopefully..
David Weaver
..if the glue that I intentionally left on the outside of a few tails as a layer (to see how hard it would dry) is an indication of the glue underneath, it should easily withstand that. Impact will be another story, I don't know if your 3 1/2 year old is like mine, but mine is super strong for her size and she's "rammy" like a goat.
Whether or not it would pass a magazine article test where someone put it on a hydraulic machine intended to break it, and hung a car off the end I don't know.
As fast as the glue glommed up into rubbery stuff after I joined it together, I was pretty pleased that it managed to dry very hard and clear. It's just a major inconvenience because you to hurry and join pieces before that happens, sort of defeating the purpose of using a glue with a long open time. Preheating the boards would've been a good idea, but my time window didn't allow it.
Uh oh!
Tony - Memphis
I have a bottle of Franklin on my shop that has a date of '09 I think. I have been using it. I tested a joint with it and it was very strong (I coldn't break it - the wood failed). I just used a good portion of that bottle gluing down some veneer on some mdf last night. It cured good and hard. Time for a new bottle anyway.
Tony
Re: Your luck is better than mine..
David Weaver
... my first experience with expiration dates was to notice that a bottle that I purchased from Rockler expired shortly after I purchased it. About 6 months later, that same bottle (that had been living in my basement, which is between 60 and 70 degrees depending on the time of the year) was a gelled-over blob, despite fresh glue franklin LH glue being fairly liquid at 70 degrees or whatever.
IF I knew then what I know now, I would've put it in the sink to see if I could make it liquid and test it again.
I went to rockler to get another bottle, and by that time all of the bottles on their shelves were past date. They were gelled, too. I mentioned it and the next time I went there, there were none.
Fortunately, that's been rectified since then.
what does "gelled over"mean?
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Liquid hide glue dies by having the protein chopped up into smaller pieces either by microbial or chemical processes. This process leads to glue that is less viscous and dries brittle. If you glue became more viscous, or what ever gelled means, it was because it was cold or it lost water.
The Franklin liquid hide glue viscosity is very sensitive to temperature. On the rare occasions I use it I warm it if the shop is even cool.
Re: what does "gelled over"mean?
David Weaver
Gelled over meaning it was like rubbery. I don't know if heating it would've gotten it to liquid, I didn't know enough at the time to figure it out. At standing room temperature, it was like a hard porous gelatin in the bottle, though.
All of it (OBG, franklin, etc) is very sensitive to temperature so far as I can tell.
I don't have any loyalty to one brand or another (not that anyone accused me of that) and would buy the franklin local if I could get it all the time.
The stuff that I put on that gelled dried to a nice hardness, but you can plane it off in shavings, it's not brittle. I'm pleased with the result, this is the first time I've used it when it wasn't summer.
Re: Hopefully..
CStanford
Mine is rammy too...