New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

Posts

Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#1

Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

David Weaver

Simple question.

My shop most of the year ranges between 45-50 degrees in the winter, to about 80 degrees in the summer (it's halfway below ground).

60% humidity or so all year.

I can't find any information on OBG about a lower temperature limit, so I'd assume it will work fine at lower temps?

Asking only because I'd like to put a plano clamp setup on one of the walls, and the thermometer on the wall reads 50 degrees pretty much from late october through march.

Keeping the glue warm isn't an issue.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#2

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

I like the glue a lot, but don't know the answer to your question. Unless someone here knows the answer from direct experience in similar temp/humidity, and even if they do, I would suggest place one call or email to Patrick or his wife Kristen. They'll know for sure, and won't steer you wrong.

Phone no. and email at bottom of this page:

http://www.oldbrownglue.com/articles.html

Both of them are very helpful and easy to talk to.

Wiley

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#3

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've never talked with Patrick, but it's worth ordering the glue just to talk with Kristen.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#4

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

viscosity is not an irrelevant issue. The glue needs to flow across and wet the wood surfaces as well as penetrate pores. What ever answer you get I think warming the wood will be beneficial. However, the answer is easy to determine. Do a test gluing and break the joint.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#5

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I would say, get a 220V cube heater for the times when you glue up stuff. I used one when I needed to put the finish on the only kitchen cabinet set I ever built (for a friend, that convinced me that this wasn't what I wanted to do for a living, story in itself). In any case, the 4800W cube kept my double garage warm (70 degrees) while I applied the finish (and I live up north).

The nice thing about it is that you use it when needed, and don't spend the energy money when you don't need it...

DC

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#6

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

CStanford

Too cool and wet.

Set up some infrared lamps and space heaters and warm the immediate area where the glue up will take place. Use electric heat, you don't need more moisture in the air. Run the lamps and heaters several hours before you start to work and put the wood to be glued in the same area so it too will be warm. Keep the OBG in a pot of water on a hot plate set as low as it will go.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#7

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

david weaver

Yeah, I figured it's not ideal. It's putting the squash on the plano clamps. I've been using liquid hide there for several years but I have only glued panels together when it's warm.

I need to glue something up tomorrow, but it's just a case with HBPT on the top and through dovetails on the bottom, I'll probably glue it anyway because it should never get a load in a direction it's not mechanically reinforced.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#8

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

TomD

There probably is a lower limit, but your temps are not that bad. There are a number of ways to get the heat to the part. Warming the part with a heat gun or stove or in a heat box. You can also heat the part by using excessive amounts of the glue. The glue itself will keep the glue on the wood surface warm. You scrape off the excess and slap it together, or you can mush it together and get lots of squeeze out. Since the squeezeout can be popped back in the pot, you don't have to worry about slopping it around.

The first few minutes of this are pretty entertaining:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E6iSvL2McYM

I have two heat boxes, one for guitars, and one for bows, so I have a place to put stuff, even though my shop is often around 35. I crank the heat when I am in it, but not that much of the stuff actually warms up, even if the air hits 50.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#9

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

CStanford

In reality, this time of year your shop is at the lower limit for most PVAs much less HHG or the pre-bottled hide glue. You would have to really warm up a corner of the shop for hide glue.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#10

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

David Weaver

Through the door is a heated (and dry) basement, it's probably about 60-65 degrees. I guess my intention could easily be to take the parts for the glue-up into the basement, put them in the corner with a box heater and let them heat up. Heating the glue is no problem.

Right now really isn't an issue because everything that's more critical (glued together panels) is already done. But I will have about a dozen door panels to glue soon, and they'll be TBIII glued because they're going in the kitchen. I can't recall what made me think I was using hide glue on them. I guess it's no big deal. I'm just looking for an excuse to buy the plano setup, though it is not by any means necessary for kitchen cabinet door panels.

7 years on, I'm still waiting for my first failed glue joint. I'll relay back what the OBG makers think is acceptable.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#11

Kitchen gluing

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

We sold lumber for many years and the primary customers were custom kitchen cabinet makers. Never saw any of them use other than ordinary yellow glue. I don't see anything about a kitchen that would require any special adhesive.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#12

Re: Kitchen gluing

David Weaver

I figured I'd use III, or whatever bottle has the lowest glue temp. All of the gluing will be over the next two months.

I don't anticipate a sink overflowing at any point, but you never know. When I was in an apartment, I was on the bottom floor and the first to have an overflowing sink. It had rental grade cabinets and the veneer delaminated with the first overflow.

I don't want face frames or panels subjected to that kind of separation. Doubt it would happen, but hopefully I won't be in the house long enough that repairability of anything matters.

I'm sure the next owners will rip the cabinets out for the latest and greatest style of RTA, anyway.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#13

Re: Unspeakable things...

David Weaver

Just as an aside, during my college years, I worked at a cabinet factory. Not cabinet shop, a factory.

The dados in the face frames were far wider than the cabinet backs and assembly was done in a huge pneumatic clamp. Each clamp attached the face frame to the back, sides, and any dividers, and the operators glued and stapled everything together in less than two minutes per cabinet. There were two clamps, and the line put together 70 an hour (sides came to the line pre cut by some monstrous CNC gadget), face frames and doors were already done, everything just was put together and packed, and guides installed on the assembly line.

Anyway, the huge tolerances in the frames and stuff were there to make sure no fit every slowed down the process, and hot melt held everything together. Surprisingly well for huge glue gaps. Woe be to the person who accidentally stuck their hand in the cabinet and touched hot melt after it came off the clamp and. The clamp operators' arms looked unreal, huge pocks and scars where hot melt had dripped.

All that said, the face frames and the doors were surprisingly well put together, but every person on the line had a set of putty sticks and a rag in case there was a gap in any fit. The fit of the frames to the boxes was purely a function of hot melt.

In 9 months of working there, I can recall getting cabinets back for only one reason (i.e., the customers only cared about one thing)...color matching. White paint was a b*tch for the finishing department to get white enough to match RTF doors, and the paler colors that were off white stains were also trouble - if they had any yellowing in them at all, customers would send them back.

So, after seeing what counted for woodworkers there, I don't plan on doing cabinets to the same level as I would do for something that can go with me. I don't know what the doors were glued with ( that was another department ), but I'd imagine it was PVA. Everything seems to be made these days assuming you'll replace it in 20 years, anyway.

Almost 20 years ago now, the maple and cherry doors that we used still look contemporary. Back then, though, most of the orders where oak raised panel and flat panel doors with a honey colored stain. Pretty ugly. Always thought the RTF doors were sinfully ugly (and heavy), but they sold in pretty large quantity, too.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#14

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide g

CStanford

Let us know. I'll be surprised if it's below 70*, maybe 65* but we'll await word from on high.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#15

Re: Kitchen gluing

TomD

I built my trimaran out of substantially non waterproof glue. It really isn't a problem unless the product is saturated or in such a humid environment that the object would be destroyed anyway. I would not select titebond on that basis though the best glue overall might be the II or III anyway. I use I only because it is proven for creep, but in a wet environment that would not be your first concern, almost anywhere else it is though. I could see using a waterproof glue directly under the sink. I suppose.

I don't think there is an air temp that is too cold, within the range one would find OK for working in. 35 is pretty brutal to start with. All I need to do to get good glue bonds at that temp is raise the air temp to about 50, which is a whole lot colder than a real 50, And I carry the glue bottle in my pocket. There is a point where the smeared titebond goes white as it dries, which is pretty obvious. That is my cue for the fact it is way to cold, but popping the temp a little and keeping the glue bottle warm is all it takes to avoid that fate.

Hide glue likes to be at 140 so any temp you want to work in is too cold, the issue is how fast it looses heat, and as mentioned one can engineer that in a number of ways. In the past people worked in unheated shops, or shops with a stove in them that were cold anywhere the stove was not.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#16

Stephen Shepherd

No

Stephen Shepherd

As long as you can get it out of the bottle and smeared on both surfaces and clamp it together it will work. It will cure out at even lower temperatures. The thinner [warmer] the better as it helps wet both surfaces.

Stephen

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#17

Re: thanks Stephen


Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#18

Re: thanks Stephen

CStanford

A link that you might find informative:

http://cool.conservation-us.org/coolaic/sg/wag/1990/WAG_90_buck.pdf

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#19

Re: thanks Stephen

CStanford

From Franklin's website:

Application Temperature

Above 50°F.

Open assembly time

10 minutes (70°F./50% RH)

Total assembly time

20-30 minutes (70°F./50%RH)

Minimum required spread

Approximately 6 mils or 250 square feet per gallon

Required clamping pressure

Enough to bring joints tightly together (generally, 100-150 psi for softwoods, 125-175 psi for medium woods and 175-250 psi for hardwoods)

Method of Application

Can be applied by roller or dip spreader, pressurized oil cans, plastic applicators, brush or stick.

Cleanup

Damp cloth while glue is wet. Scrape off and sand dried excess.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#20

Re: thanks Stephen

CStanford

Bond strength stats from Franklin:

http://www.titebond.com/product.aspx?id=9e9995b4-08eb-4fc6-8254-c47daa20f8ed

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#21

Re: thanks Stephen

David Weaver

Thanks Charles. You're killing my ability to call a plano panel clamp setup practical in my shop, though I could easily put it in a corner and run a space heater there.

I wonder if the 50 degrees is due to flowout, or due to strength.

I'll glue two or three test joints and see how they fail if they are put together unheated.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#22

Re: thanks Stephen

CStanford

I think the air, the workpieces being glued, and the glue itself needs to be warmer than 50* and the RH down off of 60% too if you can.

Of all three, obviously it's easier to control the temp of the glue. You can warm it gently in hot tap water or just leave it in the house until time for gluing.

My lousy two cents.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#23

Re: thanks Stephen

CStanford

Think about it like this - if it worked well and reliably below 50* that's something Franklin would tout, not keep a secret.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#24

Re: thanks Stephen

David Weaver

Well, if the ambient air is 50 degrees and the RH is 60%, I can probably warm a corner an extra 10-15 degrees without issue, which will drop the RH from 60 to about 40%.

Re: Is there a lower temp. limit for liquid hide glue?

#25

Re: thanks Stephen

David Weaver

Probably, but you never know what the actual mechanism causing the lack of performance may be. If it's because viscosity is too high, it can easily be solved by making the materials warmer and gluing them but letting them cure in another area.

If it's because the glue doesn't cure as well in a cold spot, then that's different. That's, I guess, why I'll test it. I'll probably use TB III for cabinets, but I would like to be able to use a clamp setup with any type of glue if I'm going to fork out the considerable coin that the plano setup costs. I already have a setup of bolted cauls, which is fine, but if I have to do 15 panels for doors and drawers, it's going to get old fidgeting with loosening and tightening the nuts on the bolts.