New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Old Try Plane

Posts

Old Try Plane

#1

Michael Donaldson

Old Try Plane

Michael Donaldson

Shortly after I started woodworking, I purchased a 22" wood bodied try plane on ebay. It has been one of my favorite planes ever since. So today, I tried to see what I could find out about its history.

The plane body is stamped "Underhill Clinch & Co. New York", and is also stamped with the owner's name: GW Stafford. The iron is marked "Westport Tool Co Cast Steel"

From what I could find, the Underhill and Clinch company was founded in 1856 in New York, and was in importer of hardware. They went out of business in 1950. I have found very few planes with their name stamp on them. I have not been able to find any information on the Westport Tool co. If any of you know anything about either the Underhill and Clinch Company or the Westport Tool Company, please pass it on.

The only GW Stafford I could find that made sense was George Washington Stafford, born in Rochester New York in 1829. He worked as a blacksmith in Michigan, Illinois, and California, where he went during the gold rush. In 1868, he returned to the east coast through New York (which is where I would like to imagine he purchased my try plane). He married an English immigrant and they settled in Iowa, where he died in 1892.

Even though there is no way to know for sure my plane was his, it was fun trying to find out anything I could, and coming up with a possible answer. I love old tools.

Re: Old Try Plane

#2

Re: Old Try Plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Michael,

I hear ya, talking about those woodie try planes! Most satisfying!

A quick perusal of the web brings up the fact that Underhill, Clinch & Co. issued one or more illustrated catalogs. Google books shows the cover of one here, from 1894, all 1,080pp of it:

http://books.google.com/books?id=uXT4tgAACAAJ&dq=inauthor:%22Underhill,+Clinch+%26+Co%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=I4ENUczGIsTC0AHCp4HgBQ&ved=0CDQQ6AEwAQ

Unfortunately, I couldn't find one for sale at abebooks or amazon. Among public libraries, apparently only the New York Public Library has a copy:

http://www.worldcat.org/title/illustrated-catalogue-of-hardware/oclc/39978258

Incidentally, the google search brought up a bunch of genealogy entries for former owners and members of the firm, back in the day.

The planes appear to be rare. For example, American Wooden Planes, 4th Ed., said only that "Underhill, Clinch & Co. was probably a hardware dealer. Examples: a molding plane, and a smoother seen in the tool collection of the Huntington Historical Society, Huntington, Long Island, NY, Ca. 1850."

AWP gives it three stars (***) for rarity, meaning 'very rare', between 50 and 100 examples probably extant.

How wide is the iron? 2-1/2"?

Wiley

Re: Old Try Plane

#3

Michael Donaldson

Re: Old Try Plane

Michael Donaldson

yeah, it has a 2 1/2" iron.

Re: Old Try Plane

#4

Michael Donaldson

Re: Old Try Plane

Michael Donaldson

thanks for all the extra info, too. I guess the rarity is why I couldn't find any information on it. I really wanted to know about what year it was made.

Re: Old Try Plane

#5

Re: Old Try Plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Michael,

The Westport Tool Co. blade was made by G. W. Bradley's Edge Tool Factory in Weston, CT (see link below). This factory was founded by G. W. Bradley in the mid-1830's, was washed out in 1854 by a flood, then rebuilt by the eldest son Miles Bradley, continued in operation by Miles and other family members, was sold by the Bradley family in 1906, and eventually burned to the ground in 1911. So the iron in your plane appears to be pre-1911 at the latest. And if the plane maker was founded in 1856, then the iron was likely made in the rebuilt factory after the flood.

Perhaps the 'cast steel' mark gives a hint of manufacturing date?

Wiley

http://yesteryearstools.com/Yesteryears%20Tools/Bradley%20Axe%20Co..html

Re: Old Try Plane

#6

Re: Old Try Plane

Niki

Hi, do you mind if I ask what you paid for your planer? I just was given the exact same type by my grandmother. It was my grandfather's and he passed away a few years a go.

The plane body is stamped "Underhill Clinch & Co. New York", and is also stamped with the owner's name: GW Stafford. The iron is marked "Westport Tool Co Cast Steel"

I am curious as to what this could be worth, since it seems very rare.

Thanks,

Niki

Re: Old Try Plane

#7

Re: Old Try Plane

David Weaver

Value on a plane like that is about $10 to $40 depending on condition ($40 if it is spotless with no chips, no cracks, little wear around the mouth, straight, etc).

For a plane to have substantial value, it either needs to be a presentation piece or be much older.

Re: Old Try Plane

#8

Re: Old Try Plane

Niki

Hi,

Thank you for the reply!

Niki