New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Quartersawn drawer sides

Posts

Quartersawn drawer sides

#1

Quartersawn drawer sides

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

I'm interested in what you folks do in selecting material for drawer sides. I've never experienced trouble using plain sawn drawer sides, but then our climate here is very forgiving.

On a project coming up, I have a choice--quartered white oak drawer sides and back (two drawers, approx. 15 x 15 x 3-1/2), or plain sawn maple. The maple would probably look a little crisper, in terms of contrast against the satinwood fronts, but then the oak is quartered. I notice the old desk or library table I'm sitting at has quartered oak drawer sides.

What do you folks do in selecting drawer sides, for example:

1. Indifferent between plainsawn and quartered; pick on looks and whatchagot

2. Use quartered if you have it.

3. Make it a point to use quartered.

4. Depends on _______________.

Thanks in advance,

Wiley

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#2

doesn't matter in this case

http://Bill Tindall, E.TN

On a 3 1/2" drawer it is irrelevant using quartered lumber, or not. On such a small drawer the following is irrelevant too. In this case I would use what ever you think looks best, if looks of your drawer sides is important. Personally drawers are where my reject wood winds up. In fact this morning I sorted through my pile of shorts and pulled out all the poplar, and cherry and walnut sap which will get turned into drawer bottoms.

What makes the most sense for long term service is to make the drawer runner from something hard and durable. Maple is ideal. And, make the drawer side from something softer. The idea is that it is easier to repair a worn drawer side than the groove milled into the drawer divider or runner.

On tall drawers I use quartered lumber for the sides. I saw a slow growth poplar log now and then for this need.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#3

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

TomD

I prefer to use quartered wood. The absolute height of the drawers is not critical. Height, design and tolerances. There are certain parts in cabinets that are normally quartered so buying stock so it can be sawn to needed form is a good practice.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#4

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

CStanford

Best practices indicate quartered material for drawer sides. Sure, at some point of narrowness it becomes less an issue but if you have quartered material, and already narrow material unlikely to be used elsewhere, I would absolutely use it in your application.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#5

A matter of taste

Steve Elliott

The reason for preferring quarter sawn stock for drawer sides is the smaller amount of wood movement due to seasonal changes in moisture content. For the shallow drawers you are planning I doubt seasonal changes will even be noticeable.

For some reason I just don't like the combination of satinwood and oak. I'd go for maple drawer sides and possibly look for quarter sawn stock if I really wanted to be particular. I'm not sure just why satinwood and oak seem to clash for me. Partly it's a matter of the type of furniture I associate with each species and the historical era they were used in, and partly it's the appearance of the two species that just don't go together, at least to my eye.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#6

oak sides

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

the only valid reason I can imagine to use quartered oak for a side is if one is reproducing Period English furniture. Otherwise it would seem to have little merit for this application. I think the only reason the English used it is that it enabled the construction of very thin sides. hardly an issue on a small drawer, but a big weight saver on a large drawer.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#7

Another issue....availability

roger lance

As much hard maple with which I have come in contact, I've rarely, if ever, found quarter sawn hard maple.....all flat sawn (I realize that there has to be both rift and quarter sawn boards produced when a log is flat sawn)....maybe they are being selected out of the offerings I get.....I use flat sawn hard maple for both drawer runners and drawer sides....no problems noted....but if I had the chance, I'd buy rift or quarter definitely.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#8

not so

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I realize that there has to be both rift and quarter sawn boards produced when a log is flat sawn).......Check my article on hardwood lumber production in the Articles section to see how a log is sawed "for grade", meaning to get the most high grade lumber and concentrate the worst. This technique doesn't produce any rift or quartered lumber. Occasionally if the logs are poor, cants will be produced and these gang sawed which will make rift and quartered but it will likely be in the lower grades. Occasionally one of these boards will be trimmed to yield a top grade board which will be rift or quartered. I have seen such show up but not commonly.

The tiny mills that saw with a portable band mill will saw rift and quartered lumber if they don't turn the logs, a practice that is inconvenient on these kind of mills.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#9

Re: oak sides

CStanford

The 'only' reason were a pretty good ones - refinement with strength and stability. These are all good reasons regardless of whether one is building a reproduction of a British piece.

Three quarter inch thick white pine, for example, looks clumsy, cumbersome, and left-footed by comparison.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#10

so...

roger lance

if you turn the log as it goes thru milling, then you may purposely avoid rift and quartered boards....but if a log is just flat sawn without turning, you will have rift and quarter sawn boards.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#11

Narrow quartersawn stock

Steve Elliott

For narrow stock that I want to be as stable as possible I've found it worthwhile to buy thick stock that is flatsawn and resaw it. This produces narrower pieces with quartersawn grain orientation. The higher cost of 8/4 or 12/4 lumber is offset by the increased yield of the sizes I want to have.

I like doing this when I need frame stock for frame and panel doors. I want the door to stay flat (that is, not twisted) so that the alignment of the door isn't affected by seasonal changes in humidity.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#12

I would word it different

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

As the tree grows it sheds limbs, so that the clearest lumber will be on the outside of the log. The log is turned to saw as much high grade lumber off the outside of the log as possible and concentrate the low grade lumber into center of what is left.

In the simplest case, a cut is taken off one side of the log to provide a flat secure surface to support the log on the mill carriage. The log is turned down to rest on this flat face. A second cut is taken to remove a slab of bark 90 degrees to the first cut. Then boards are sawed until a defect is hit that would lower the grade. The log is turned 180 degrees and the process repeated. The the log is turned 90 degrees and sawed until a defect is hit. Then 180 degrees. A multitude of other decisions are made to optimize the yield of high grade lumber.

A hydraulic device turns the log and the process is very quick. There is little time lost hunting for the high grade lumber. The low grade cant is often sent off to a gang saw to rip it into low grade boards very quickly.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#13

Definitely, maple. And, not figured!

Bruce McCrory

If your wood is figured, it is too silky subtle to contrast with a coarse grain, such as oak. Let QS oak play its own kingly role.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#14

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

Patrick Gibbons

I've got a lot of thin maple in stock. My lumber supply sells what they call brown hard maple and at the time I bought it, it sold for under $2.00/bd ft for 4/4". This included S3S stock that was sanded to 3/8" or 1/2". Maple tends to warp, cup, etc. I've since come to the conclusion there are better woods for drawers. My criteria is for a secondary wood with good stability for easy fabrication. QSWO would be a consideration for me if I needed 1/4" thick sides. For 3/8" and thicker, I think poplar, basswood, beech, red oak are all good choices based on their price. I used cherry of about 7 or 8 inches wide on a project for drawers about 2 or 3 years ago. It's not quartersawn but has not given any problems with sticking.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#15

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

Sgian Dubh

Wiley, dovetailing tangentially sawn fronts to quarter sawn sides can lead to significant discrepancies in the shrinkage factors. If the drawer is tall the differential shrinkage between the side and front could, in theory, cause splitting and other problems in the side pieces when the front swells. In practice I’ve not come across this setback with my own work, but I have seen antiques where failures of one sort or another have occurred.

In the UK quarter sawn oak is a traditional material for drawer sides, as Bill Tindall and others have mentioned. Teamed with tangentially sawn American mahogany fronts the shrinkage factors for both are about the same, ie, from 30%- 0% MC in both timbers, 5.3% shrinkage for radially sawn English oak and 5.1% for tangentially sawn mahogany. It’s worth considering these shrinkage factors when you’re making choices about your drawer making material, especially if the drawers are tall. Slainte.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#16

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides--followup

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks so much to all, for taking time to respond to my small issue. You folks brought up some things I had not thought about. Interesting argument that Roger and Bill made about whether quartered/rift maple can even be found--I never see it, maybe because as Bill says, there normally are no hardwood 'center flitches'.

Some responses:

1. Oak or maple. Charles and TomD make the 'best practices' point, which is a strong argument. Sgian sorta does too, but cautions about mixing quartered and plain sawn with widely different shrinkage ratios (more or on this below). Bill, Steve, Bruce note that on the 3-1/2" drawers, movement will not be critical, and therefore whatever looks best can prevail. Patrick has noted big movement with plain sawn maple; Roger has used it without issue.

For me, Steve verbalized something that was bothering me, and in fact led to my original post. Which is that oak and satinwood don't look good together, and tended not to be used together historically. Bruce makes the same point. So I need an option to the oak, which will wait for another day.

2. Maple + satinwood. This is a light clear maple, which would look good. No cathedrals, so I don't think it'll cup outright, and it hasn't moved yet in varying weather. The rings are lying in a steep rift. The satinwood drawer fronts are rift verging on quartered. On Sgian's point, Ceylon satinwood has radial shrinkage of 5-6% and tangential of 7-8%, depending on who you consult.

3. Satinwood + satinwood? This morning I ordered from Gilmer's a big rift sawn turning block of satinwood that will provide another option, which is to make the front and sides of the same material.

4. Conclusion: Will choose between the maple and satinwood for the sides. Thank you all very much--every comment really does help.

Wiley

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#17

unnecessary fretting about technical details

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I, and many others, have built many drawers 6" and greater in height from randomly oriented poplar and never had a sticking, cupping or splitting issue. If the joint is securely made the side can't cup. Personally I have never seen a split drawer side, but I can see that it could happen, but not with furniture in a modern home. One fits a drawer to the season, but it is hardly an issue if a furniture maker is going to own the furniture. If it sticks next year, plane some off.

We interpret these shrinkage tables like they are worth something for predicting something. There are many reasons why they are not. In my experience, and for some valid reasons, they over predict wood movement. The standard deviation on the publish values are substantial. The values are rough guides at best for "average" lumber.

Looks and wear are the only things worth considering. Wear in a small drawer is likely not relevant unless you keep your coin collection in it.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#18

I've noticed that about shrinkage tables...

John in NM

When I lived in Tucson we still used evaporative coolers - I've seen the house so hot and humid that boots left in a quiet corner for a couple weeks would mold.

Then other seasons it gets hot and dry, or cold and dry, or cold and wet, and the house follows suit (I never lived in a new house until I built one).

Never seen shrinking or swelling up to even half what is predicted by the tables. In the truly humid southern states, I would expect to see more, but still nothing much like the maximum values on the tables.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#19

Re: I've noticed that about shrinkage tables...

TomD

That is probably true, but stuck drawers are a classic problem, and it has nothing to do with the size of the drawer. It is a mater of tolerances, design and wood. Believe me if you wanted to build a drawer that stuck it would not be an insurmountable technical problem. Saying one's drawers don't stick means nothing without a sense of the tolerances. I have pulled out drawers on nice old furniture that swam in the opening, you know the kind they jam because they get so skewed. Then there are the folks whose drawers suck back in when pulled out...

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#20

Shrinkage tables and the hysteresis effect

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks to all contributing! This is just a note to pick up on Bill's observation,

" In my experience, and for some valid reasons, they [shrinkage tables] over predict wood movement."

and John in NM who noted the same thing.

Back in 2007 on this forum, we had a discussion of this very subject, and Larry Williams said there was a phenomenon called 'hysteresis' which partly explained why wood, once dried, tended not to pick up the amount of moisture expected during seasonal humidity increases.

Sorption hysteresis. Doing some googling, I found a bunch of papers on 'sorption hysteresis'. It's a well-known phenomenon, though the theory and mechanism of how it happens is still being argued. Most of the papers on the subject become quickly impenetrable without a lot of background or further study. But here is a study from 1957 which is clearly written, whose terms are defined, and whose summary results comport well with other experimental results:

http://ir.library.oregonstate.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/1957/6022/Some_Aspects_ocr.pdf?sequence=1

The nut of the matter is that the amount of water a piece of wood will hold at a given temperature and relative humidity (it's equilibrium moisture content, or EMC) depends on that wood's history. Suppose we're talking about the EMC of a piece of wood being held at 60% humidity and 75 degrees: The eventual moisture content of the wood--it's EM--will depend upon whether the wood is coming from a wetter condition (i.e., it's desorbing), or whether it's coming from a drier condition (i.e., it's adsorbing). Desorbing wood will reach steady state at a higher moisture content than adsorbing wood.

This study's experiment with aspen indicated that the desorbing or drying wood would arrive at an EMC~ 12%, whereas a similar block of wood which had been drier, would arrive at EMC ~ 8.5 to 9%. Both blocks being held at 60% humidity and 75 degrees, come to significantly different EMC's. The previously dry piece stayed drier. In the study, see Figure 1 towards the bottom of the article for summary results.

This hysteresis effect, together with the moisture-retarding effect of film finishes, begins to explain why actual furniture shrinks or expands less than the quoted shrinkage figures, which I believe are based on the initial drying from wet wood.

Again, thanks to all!

Wiley

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#21

Which is why......

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

KD wood is more stable than air dried wood, but you started this not I....(ducking). I was not aiming to bring it up....again.

There are some other factors. The data assume a linear shrinkage from 30% to zero and essentially the slope of this theoretical line is reported.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#22

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides--followup

CStanford

If you read some of the replies in too granular a fashion you could come to the ridiculous conclusion that drawers never stick with changes in humidity, etc. and that nothing matters and practically anything goes. This is clearly silly on its face and undoes centuries of standard trade practice in fine cabinetmaking.

Unless your goal is to make drawers that swim in their openings to accommodate potential movement, I'd use quartersawn material around 3/8" to 1/2" thick maximum for sides and backs. And especially so if you already have the material on hand and available for your use.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#23

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides--followup

Patrick Gibbons

I agree. It's always best to be safe than sorry. As the bard said, "The evil that men do lives after them. The good is oft interred with their bones." My woodworking mistakes will show up probably after I'm gone.

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides

#24

Re: Quartersawn drawer sides--followup

CStanford

I'm not a good enough woodworker to get a really crisp dovetail joint using half inch and thicker white pine. It's so soft. But then a lot of people aren't - the telltale sign being wavy arrises giving away the fact the joint was cut rich for a crush fit. The lines always give it away. The first part of the joint (pins or tails) have to be cut absolutely flawlessly straight to make the second part crush fit not give the strategy away.