New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Sharpening technique for carving gouges

Posts

Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#1

Sharpening technique for carving gouges

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Curious how you all sharpen gouges:

1. Push the gouge down the stone, rotating it in flight.

2. Sideways, with rotation.

3. Motorized stropping?

4. Combinations?

Much thanks,

Wiley

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#2

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

david weaver

4

1 or 2, depending on the chisel, and sometimes powered stropping and sometimes manual stropping. It makes no difference for the stropping part. I suppose 1 or 2 depends on how steep the sweep is on the gouge.

Maybe with "in the direction of the length of the chisel" method is more on the diagonal than straight up the stones.

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#3

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

Paul Dzioba

Hi Wiley,

Most of my gouges came from the used market and it is rare they are sharpened or shaped to my liking. I shape the bevels on a soft friable white grinding wheel (the Lee Valley wheel has worked well for me). I hold the tool parallel to the floor and roll the bevel against the wheel freehand. I try for the steepest bevel I dare, probably about 15-20 degrees. Careful not to burn.

I hone on oil stones, Washita and hard Arkansas. They work and feel nice on vintage tools. I lift the tool slightly to put on a secondary bevel and roll the tool sideways (your option 2). The trick of course is where you stop and start the rotation so you don’t dub the corners unintentionally. I hone the in-cannel bevel with slips and strop with dowels or a piece of folded leather. The shallow gouges have the most in-cannel so I can turn them over and use them for convex surfaces, my 8 and 9 and cranked gouges don’t get an in-cannel. I like to strop the out cannel bevel with a paddle like strop, holding the tool stationary and moving the paddle over the tool. I have tried a lot of different techniques and this is what works best for me. Your mileage may vary.

Paul Dzioba

P.S. I sharpen my joiner as opposed to carving gouges much the same except mostly they are strictly in-cannel or out-cannel. Also, I like a convex bevel on the out cannel, helps me steer in and out.

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#4

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

CStanford

Sideways with rotation.

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#5

thank you

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I just got a #3 today for a task and have never sharpened one.

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#6

how about option #5

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I have a pair of cone shaped water stones and each has a concave and convex side. I locate the appropriate section and use a side to side motion with roatation but nearly the entire edge is in contact with the stone so it goes really quickly. I then strop on a flat strop by hand. If I have a a nick or if the edge gets severely rounded from too much stroping I flatten the bevel on my outcannel gouges on a flat diamond stone using a sideways motion with rotation. For some reason I don't round the bevel when stropping my incannel couges.

Robin

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#7

Polishing tricks put to use

Bob Hackett

One of the most useful tricks I was handed when learning how to polish metal also works very well for me in sharpening. That trick is to vary the direction of the scratch pattern as it makes it far easier to see when you have all the previous scratches removed and the edge refined. Orientation of tool to abrasive is secondary to the visible scratch pattern when I`m sharpening.

That being said IME the only scratch pattern/direction of abrasion that really counts is the final one so I plan on that final honing and scratch pattern to be in the same direction the tool is going to be used. All previous abrasion takes place in a direction that will allow me to best see when the previous scratches have been removed. That means the angle changes as I move from one stone to the next.

The initial power grinding of gouges usually takes place with the chisel being held parallel to the floor and the scratch pattern perpendicular to the shank of the tool.

I also get my chisels from the used tool market. Picked up two vintage Addis carving gouges this weekend ( a shallow gouge and a bent gouge) for $7.50 each. Beep-beep. :)

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#8

Re: thank you

CStanford

Rick Butz wrote a small, sane, and sensible guide to sharpening carving tools that cannot be beaten IMO:

http://www.amazon.com/Woodcarving-Rick-Butz-Sharpen-Tools/dp/0811729966/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1359654892&sr=1-2&keywords=rick+butz

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#9

This has the advantage

Chuck Nickerson

that if one is new to sharpening gouges (Me!), it helps maintain a regular shape for the gouge's cutting edge.

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#10

Great ideas!  Thank you!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks to all who commented--a wealth of useful ideas!! Will respond individually below.

What I'm trying to do. I'm seeking a system for ordinary straight outcannel gouges. I get them sharp, but it takes too long because every one I do, I feel like it's a project and I'm doing every one different, rather than using a simple straightforward procedure with a beginning, middle and end.

What I do now. I like long bevels too, though I don't have the skill to get them down as low as Paul, and still keep the edge and shoulders square. But I grind them down into the low 20s or so. If need be, grind the edge and shoulders square. Then continue grinding down into sharpening range, still at low angle. Using a coarse diamond stone, fixed diamonds, I then do sideways rotation to get close to an edge; then abrasive paper like 600g SiC around a dowel to clear the burr off the concave side; then start honing on water stones and diamond paste--it's here that I go gonzo--just no system for finishing up--I stay at it til it's sharp, but always a risk of rounding the shoulders or not quite getting the whole edge onto the stones.

Response to Comments. David W., I hadn't thought about that diagonal movement you mentioned, but yeah, that's how it usually goes! David B., your approach of having correctly sized stropping substrates for each sweep (the concave face) is a must. I'm curious why you never do the sideways rotation thing--is it about the shoulders or you just don't want scoring parallel to the edge, or what? Holy Cow, where do you get those synthetic ruby/sapphire rods/boules??!!

Robin, I think those concave/convex slips are going to be the answer to getting into a system that is predictable. Am going shopping this morning. Going back to the diamond stone with sideways rotation for 'unrounding' an overstropped bevel is a good tip too--what I do now, but am glad to get some confirmation from someone who knows what they're doing!

Paul, that's amazing you can get such a low bevel on those gouges and still maintain the edge and shoulders square! That's real skill, I know I can't get them under the low 20s without ending up with uneven edge or rounded shoulders. Sideways rotation for honing--check. Interesting comment on the different treatment of the concave face of the shallow gouges--great idea. It would never occur to me to get the tool fixtured and move the strop!!--another great idea, gotta do that.

Bob, that's interesting about using the score lines to keep track of progress toward the final edge, and to keep the entire edge at the same stage of sharpening. Ingenious. Regarding the vintage gouges that you and Paul spoke of, I'm getting to be a believer. I found a couple of narrow and shallow Addis (forget which one) gouges on ebay for a good price, and they're my favorite ones now--because they're so slim. You can get them into places where the heavier bladed gouges won't fit, and that happens a lot in practice I find.

Charles thank you for the guidance on sideways with rotation.

Again, thank you all for a wealth of specific and useful approaches!

Wiley

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#11

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#12

If lacking equipment this works

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I wrapped a section of sticky paper on a bottle of approximate diameter and rotated the tool diagonally over the bottle. Tool axis parallel to long axis of bottle and direction of travel was about 20 degrees off the long axis of the bottle, northeast to southwest. The motion was mostly rotational with some travel down the bottle. As usual the factory had dubbed a corner which took a fair amount of grinding to remove. But it all went well otherwise with good control.

These carbon steels do grind easy!

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#13

Brilliant!


Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#14

Forgot to mention....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For the bevel I will do it like I do lathe tools. I will stick a piece of the sticky paper on a thin strip of wood so as to make a "file", fix the tool in the vise with sharp end sticking up and "file" on it till sharp. I don't have any small stones for this task and it is too hard to control big stones to keep then flat on the bevel.

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#15

O.T. Corundum question

Patrick Gibbons

David, man-made sapphire and ruby are beautiful stones, albeit lower-priced, compared to many naturals, heat treating aside. Why do you say they're worthless as gems?

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#16

2nd on the brilliant


Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#17

The Alexander Weygers Method

Patrick Gibbons

Weygers was an artist, blacksmith, engineer, guy-with-a-whole-lotta-talent. He advocated gouges having the upper portion of the cutting edge forward of the bottom to counter wedging that occurs when the bottom of the curve cuts first. I haven't tried it yet though it makes sense to me. Would like to hear from others who have.

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#18

not brilliant..... desperate for a solution

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think desperation is the "mother of invention". It works even better than "necessity".

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#19

Great minds thinking alike....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

This suggestion about fixing the tool and 'filing' with a paddle + abrasive was also suggested above by Paul Dzioba, and I'm gonna do it that way. It seems like a no-brainer now, but I never thought of it.

I can see now that you can get great control over the angle created at the edge by the stropping motion, thereby avoiding or minimizing roundover.

Thanks!

Wiley

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#20

Re: The Alexander Weygers Method

TomD

I read his books on Blacksmithing, and was interested in that design. The nearest I ever came to getting there was when Country Workshops had some guttering adzes made up to his design, for chair work. By the time I liberated the money from my pants pockets, they had sold them out, and they did not return. While the design makes sense, the one thing that worried me about it is that gouges are used in different ways. So imagine that you want to cut a bead using the shape of the gouge to both describe the circumference, and skim over the surface to round the bead. I think having the wings of the gouge out front might interfere with both those functions.

I haven't made any weygers gouges, but I have done enough blacksmithing (which is to say not much) to know that the process would be quick and easy, with the most time consuming part being fitting the handles ( and I say that as a woodworker who has five lathes and buys epoxy by the drum). My point being that if one was making these gouges, one could toss them out and have regular gouges as well. So no downside.

The idea of elevated wings is found on some conventional gouges sorta, some parting and some turning gouge grinds come to mind. He took it further by giving the gouges a conical section that also allowed them to be turned without dragging, but that is another feature that might strike the non-maker as being expensive to buy since one does not get 6 inches of reserve channel to grind through, even though few users ever get past the first 1/4 inch.

Re: Sharpening technique for carving gouges

#21

Easy answer...

John in NM

The gem market is not and never has been about beauty, it is all about rarity. Man made gems are simply not rare, they can be made in vast quantity and very cheaply.

A lot of amatuer facetors cut nothing but man-made rough, because it makes an amazing stone. Personally I prefer the synthetic corundum and beryl to cubic zirconia - CZ strikes me as a bit over the top, optically speaking. But it is without a doubt one of the most popular synthetics.

Somewhere I still have a huge piece of pink sapphire that was made by the Czochralski method and some hydrothermal emerald from Russia. Fifteen years ago, these are what passed for "rare" in synthetic gems. I have no idea if they are still, technology tends to advance quickly if there is a profit in it, changing stuff like this from rare to common in only a few years.

As an aside, for a little while aluminum was worth more than gold. Before large scale electrolytic refining was developed it was extremel expensive to produce just a small amount of metal from what is the most common metal atom in the world. Now it is only slightly more expensive than iron, and while the prices of other metal commodities have soared recently, aluminum has stayed relatively flat.