Great ideas! Thank you!
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Thanks to all who commented--a wealth of useful ideas!! Will respond individually below.
What I'm trying to do. I'm seeking a system for ordinary straight outcannel gouges. I get them sharp, but it takes too long because every one I do, I feel like it's a project and I'm doing every one different, rather than using a simple straightforward procedure with a beginning, middle and end.
What I do now. I like long bevels too, though I don't have the skill to get them down as low as Paul, and still keep the edge and shoulders square. But I grind them down into the low 20s or so. If need be, grind the edge and shoulders square. Then continue grinding down into sharpening range, still at low angle. Using a coarse diamond stone, fixed diamonds, I then do sideways rotation to get close to an edge; then abrasive paper like 600g SiC around a dowel to clear the burr off the concave side; then start honing on water stones and diamond paste--it's here that I go gonzo--just no system for finishing up--I stay at it til it's sharp, but always a risk of rounding the shoulders or not quite getting the whole edge onto the stones.
Response to Comments. David W., I hadn't thought about that diagonal movement you mentioned, but yeah, that's how it usually goes! David B., your approach of having correctly sized stropping substrates for each sweep (the concave face) is a must. I'm curious why you never do the sideways rotation thing--is it about the shoulders or you just don't want scoring parallel to the edge, or what? Holy Cow, where do you get those synthetic ruby/sapphire rods/boules??!!
Robin, I think those concave/convex slips are going to be the answer to getting into a system that is predictable. Am going shopping this morning. Going back to the diamond stone with sideways rotation for 'unrounding' an overstropped bevel is a good tip too--what I do now, but am glad to get some confirmation from someone who knows what they're doing!
Paul, that's amazing you can get such a low bevel on those gouges and still maintain the edge and shoulders square! That's real skill, I know I can't get them under the low 20s without ending up with uneven edge or rounded shoulders. Sideways rotation for honing--check. Interesting comment on the different treatment of the concave face of the shallow gouges--great idea. It would never occur to me to get the tool fixtured and move the strop!!--another great idea, gotta do that.
Bob, that's interesting about using the score lines to keep track of progress toward the final edge, and to keep the entire edge at the same stage of sharpening. Ingenious. Regarding the vintage gouges that you and Paul spoke of, I'm getting to be a believer. I found a couple of narrow and shallow Addis (forget which one) gouges on ebay for a good price, and they're my favorite ones now--because they're so slim. You can get them into places where the heavier bladed gouges won't fit, and that happens a lot in practice I find.
Charles thank you for the guidance on sideways with rotation.
Again, thank you all for a wealth of specific and useful approaches!
Wiley