Recently- made Craftsman chissels
eliot feldman
I read somewhere that these are not good chisels.What's wrong with them?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Recently- made Craftsman chissels
eliot feldman
I read somewhere that these are not good chisels.What's wrong with them?
Re: Recently- made Craftsman chissels
david weaver
Supposing recent is a relative term, they are soft and the metal seems to have extreme amounts of chromium in it.
I have one, and fortunately only one. I ground it to make a skew. The first time I used it (ground at a 30 degree bevel since there's not as much support around the point based on the geometry), it literally bent so far that I could not hone out the bent part without refreshing the hollow several times.
If I wasn't so cheap, I'd send it to charles, because he made a comment long ago that he'd take any chisels I thought were too crappy to use.
All of that said, I don't know what would happen to one if you tried to heat and quench it in oil or even air. They are worthless otherwise, unless you need to take the handle off of one and use it as a bolt to hold two door shut.
(I'm sure whatever the recent iteration of chinese made cabinetmaker's chisels sears might carry, they are much better than their mid century experiments into highy alloyed steels. It is really incredible how bad mine is. I had tested a shiny witherby parer that seemed soft at one point in the past and it was 52 or 53 hardness, real junk, but this chisel is much softer than that one was. I gave that one away, too.)
Re: chisel review from "bench tools"
Lars Parrington
i don't know about recent ones, but back in 1985 they were made of 1050 steel. 1050 = 0.50% carbon content, which is quite low for a tool steel. as a result, the chisels were not hard enough to hold an edge.
btw, this data is from the chisel review in "bench tools", a collection of fww articles published by taunton press back in 1990. was it wiley who recommended this to me recently? i must say this book has turned out to be superb! a surpising wealth of great articles. they are all ~30 years old, but the information is all still currently relevant.
Re: chisel review from "bench tools"
eliot feldman
Thanks to both replies. I, too, find that they don't hold an edge well. I bought a bunch of them dirt cheap at some kind of garage, antique place in CT last year. They're nice and shiny , though!
Re: chisel review from "bench tools"
david weaver
500 years from now, someone is going to open up a landfill and say "look how shiny those are!!".
Beware the chisels that do not rust 
I have a couple...
John in NM
Bought them in the 1990's before I knew any better. Soft and buttery, but good for what I use them for now - sacrificial chopping, ie trimming the cow's hooves, rough hacking on framing where I might hit a nail, opening paint cans -- hey, it keeps my wife from using one of my good screwdrivers 
Re: Recently- made Craftsman chissels
Clementine
Thanks for supplying documentary support for my shoddy chisel work. Got any numbers for planes that I can add to my poor work/poor tools excuse list?
Not saying they are good but...
Michael Donaldson
They are not made in China. They are actually made in Colorado Springs by a company called Western Forge. They make all of the Craftsman screwdrivers, some of the pliers, and all of the chisels. I interviewed for a job there a few months back, and got to tour the facility. I asked a lot of questions about the chisels, what type of steel they used, what angle they were ground to, etc. The person giving the tour didn't know the answers. I didn't get the job, maybe because I mentioned that I really like my Lie-Nielsen chisels.
Probably just as well...
John in NM
As a dedicated "good" hand tool user, could you really have faced the prospect of helping put crappy chisels into the world? I know I couldn't 