New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

colorists here?

Posts

colorists here?

#1

colorists here?

Bruce Mack

Hello. I just finished a white oak accent lamp which I wanted to stain a slightly reddish brown. I have an assortment of Moser and Trans Fast water soluble dyes, mostly those purporting to simulate cherry. They were too red, so I drove to my store and bought Trans Fast green, thinking green + red makes brown. Mixed well, it looked good on my sample, but on the workpiece I see some migration of the green, creating a disturbing variegation. It's like differential creep on filter paper. This happened with quick paper towel blotting of the applied stain, so wasn't evidently a problem with leaching of the color on wet wood. Kiwi paste shoe polish used as a glaze mitigated a disaster. I'll not use green in the future, but is there an explanation or another suggestion to brown a too-red tint? Thanks.

Re: colorists here?

#2

No, but...

Schtoo

I've kind of forgotten about this stuff, since I refuse to stain anything anymore, other than a generic brown and only under extreme duress.

I seemed to recall having more luck (and control) using blue and yellow to take out red. Yes, the 2 colours make green, but I felt like I had that little bit of tweaking available to me when the colour would tend to go one way or another. It means more tinting colours of course, but I dunno.

I asked the guy at the paint shop, and he suggested (I think, this was years ago and my Japanese was mediocre at best!) going along the 'try both sides' idea because I didn't have any experience at it, it would let me creep up on the colour I needed.

He asked said to tell the person it was for to be happy with whatever came out of the can...

(Interestingly, I gave the same advice to someone 20 years ago when I was working in a hardware shop. At that time, I had to ask the paint guru so the information was second hand from me.)

I'd think that colour seeming to come out of suspension might be something other than the tinting medium's colour though. Possibly a tint incompatibility rather than the actual colour it is.

I remember that some colours we had to make up at the hardware shop, you'd have to get some in a very roundabout way because the direct route would have two tinting mediums that didn't work well together and you'd get some strange things happening. By going in a roundabout way, you avoided the weirdness.

My memory could be fuzzy though. I can tell you that we had a dozen bases and a couple dozen tinters to go with them, plus a few phone books to make it all work. And that was just one paint brand...

Good luck, I hope it works out.

Stu.

Re: colorists here?

#3

migration?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't understand the migration part. Indeed if one puts a dye mix on something like filter paper the dyes can migrate at different rates from dyed to undyed paper and separate according to their affinity with the paper. But if the paper is uniformly coated with the dye mixture there can be no differential migration and hence no color difference developed. Ditto for the wood. I am further puzzled by the observation that the test piece was acceptable.

Did the color variation correlate with early wood/ late wood or pores?

I stain oak with pigment stain so I have no advice on dye staining this wood.

Re: colorists here?

#4

Re: No, but...

Bruce Mack

Schtoo-I like the suggestion of alchemy. I was dabbling in an art where I have essentially no experience. There may well have been an incompatibility or incomplete dissolving. The paper towel used to wipe off the excess acquired a pea soup green color. I was lucky this did not happen to the wood.

Bill-the scraps I used for testing were the bevel cutoffs from the lamp stiles (legs). I dipped them into the dye and then wiped them and let them dry. While I had a couple of pieces in the wood lattice that did not get dark enough from this brew, they did not seem to have more or less green.

"be happy with whatever came out of the can" is funny as well as a life lesson---thanks both!

Re: colorists here?

#5

Just watched this process

CJ

This is alchemy in my opinion, which is why I paid a ridiculous amount to have a refinisher come to the house to stain new red oak trim to match the 1924 original stuff. The original stuff is a very nice brown, but you can actually see the green through the finish if you look close. It is NOT at all obvious at first.

What the fellow did was to put down the blue dye stain, followed by lacquer. He then stained the trim using a dark brown pigment stain. The trick he used was to put on a coat with a wet brush and then come back with a dry brush to move the stain around until he hit the right density. It was like watching magic. While a part of me took mental notes and thought, "I can do that", so long as the patent attorney gig is paying well, I'll keep having him back to avoid the inevitable evidence of me practicing on the damned woodwork. ;)

Cheers,

Chris

Re: colorists here?

#6

Stephen Shepherd

Re: colorists here?

Stephen Shepherd

I would suggest you try a dry powdered pigment burnt umber, available at pottery supply houses or art supply stores. You can mix it with spirit base, water base or in thinned linseed oil.

Has a reddish background and is a very stable color.

Stephen

Re: colorists here?

#7

Re: colorists here?

Bruce Mack

Stephen-Thanks. I'll buy some.

CJ- The result of my mistakes and attempted remedy with shoe polish actually looks ok. This may of course be a self-serving observation. If my friend asks about finish maintenance I'll direct her to Florsheim :)

Re: colorists here?

#8

a little color theory for you

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

first of all red and green do not mix together to make brown they miix to make grey. if one of the colors is more intense then the other the result will be a greyish green or greyish red.

yellow and black make brown and a redish yellow will get you a better brown

Robin

Re: colorists here?

#9

Ellis Walentine

Two step staining

Ellis Walentine

I have had much luck with using a dye stain followed by a pirment stain, especially on close-grained woods, but also on oak. You have to be more careful with oak and open-pored woods because the dark pigment particles get into the pores and can create a pretty garish appearance. Sometimes a thin coat of shellac, sanded back, will prevent this pigment build-up.

You will want to experiment with different stain colors to get a combination that is just right. I generally try to choose a dye stain that has the background hues I want, such as golden or reddish-brown. Then I follow up with a pigment color that deepens and saturates the look to the desired end result. In your specific example, I'd try a brown-brown pigment or gel stain over the reddish dye color. VanDyke brown is a very neutral brown. Most walnut and mahogany stains have too much red in them for my taste.

So, here's another vote for alchemy.

Ellis

Re: colorists here?

#10

a more convenient approach

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I love burnt umber. Use it for oak and walnut. Indeed the dry pigment can be milled into a solvent based system but the pigment must be worked into the system, usually by mortar and pestle or equivalent. A quicker and more reliable way to get there is to mix burnt umber Japan Color into General Finishes "clear oil based sealer" which I am told by their chemist is the same base for their oil stains. Instant home made oil stain.

Re: colorists here?

#11

Re: Two step staining

Bruce Mack

Thanks Ellis. The shellac as a pore filler sounds good. In my hands a pigment stain on oak evokes a soot-stained Tudor banquet hall.

Re: colorists here?

#12

doesn't need to be

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Minwax....probably "golden oak". The secret to good pigment staining is perfect sanding.

Re: colorists here?

#13

Re: doesn't need to be

Bruce Mack

Wow. Point made.

Re: colorists here?

#14

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: colorists here?

#15

Re: colorists here?

Patrick Gibbons

Bruce, I have always disliked using stain because of the underwhelming results I've experienced. I have found using a buildup of garnet shellac gives a wonderful reddish dark color. Before Christmas I reported my success with fuming white oak with ammonia. While I did not finish with shellac, I can easily imagine the end product being a very dark, warm color with red tones. The picture below is a fumed cherry and white oak with tung oil. The hinges and hasp are white oak.


img

Re: colorists here?

#16

Its the milling

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It happens that I know a finish formulator. I am told that these pigments must be milled into the oil. Traditionally a mortal and pestle device was used, I'm told. This person's lab has some mechanical monster that does this step. The finer the pigment is ground the better it works, I'm told.

Seeing his mechanical monster and comparing it to my measly mortal and pestle, and making the assumption that Mr. Japan of Japan Colors has a similar mechanical monster, I have abandoned mixing my own.

But it is nice to know that only 100 miles to the west I can get some colors at Maryville, pronounced "Murville" in these parts.