New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Seeking opinion on table dimension....

Posts

Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#1

Seeking opinion on table dimension....

roger lance

I'm building a simple dining table with four tapered legs and an apron connecting both the legs and top.....the style of table is frequently called "country".....my concern is with the distance between the bottom of the apron and floor.....the top of the table is 30" high.....the top is 1" thick....and the apron is 4" wide....this leaves 25" between the bottom of the apron and floor....is that enough room for people to sit at the table comfortably and have room for their legs under the apron ??.....I realize the other piece to this is the chair which is yet to be determined but some chairs I've got are about 17 1/2" tall at the seat and have additional upholstery of 2 1/2" thickness which seems to tight under the proposed apron....so in your experience is 25" ok or not ??

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#2

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have an antique dining table with an exceptionally wide apron and only 23" clearance. It is inconvenient. 24" would be fine.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#3

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

Perhaps this may help. This table is getting on for 200 years of age. French-Huguenot kitchen table in Yellow- and Stink wood.


(apologies for the quality - taken on the computer).

It is 30" high, and there is 24" under the skirt.

Regards from Perth (yes, finally home)

Derek

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#4

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

From the bottom of the apron on our dining room table to the floor is 23-1/4". Apron and top together are 3-1/2" (apron about 2-1/2" of that). Works fine. I would think your 25" clearance would feel luxurious.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#5

Perhaps the issue is the chair.....

roger lance

These chairs have 8" between the top of the upholstery and the bottom of this apron (which is decorative and has no function as the aprons will have for the rectangular dining table).....this distance works well, all have been comfortable.....but the round apron is 27" from the floor, so such chairs would only have a 6" space under the new table which will be tight for some (me for sure).....so I may have to turn to shorter seated chairs as I'd like to keep the connection of apron and leg as generous as possible to maintain strength....I had planed to cut a bead on the bottom of the apron to give it some detail and a curved relieved edge but these chairs also suggest another possible solution which is to curve the aprons which would still allow the original m/t joint at the leg and some added space below the apron....could lay in a curve of 1" - 1 1/2" depth which would make the apron 3" - 2 1/2" wide at apex of curve....thoughts ??


Thanks to both Bills and Derek for your help. I am encouraged by your comments. Its good that you are home safe and sound Derek.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#6

Re: Perhaps the issue is the chair.....

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Curving the apron sounds like a possibility - and it could become a nice design feature.

Another possibility, depending on your design interests, would be cloud lifts (think Greene and Greene). These get overdone at times, and are often badly done; but can be quite graceful.

Yet another would be a detail a little in from each corner that looks like the sectional profile of a crown molding and then a straight line across the remaining apron, although this could look awfully fussy on a country table; and, functionally, you would want a detail that wasn't a thigh-jabber for anyone close to the corner. So maybe not as sensible as your curve or a cloud lift or two.

Or you could just require that all guests have a Body Mass Index of 20 or below, thus ensuring skinny thighs...

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#7

Re: Perhaps the issue is the chair.....

Larry Barrett

Roger, in your first note, regarding the chairs, you said that they were 17 1/2 + 2 1/2 for upholstery, which adds up to 20" total. In this second post you seem to be assuming 19", but maybe I am reading this incorrectly.

In any event, presumably when one sits on one of these chairs the upholstery squishes down some, or even alot, so that the actual seating height will be less than 20 or 19". Try sitting on one of these chairs and measure your clearance, then sit on an un-upholstered chair and see if much difference. Your table height, with apron, seems reasonable.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#8

Better measurements......

roger lance

Larry.....I've made some better measurements by placing a chair on a bench as opposed to trying to get readings in place.....to the top of the front chair stretcher is 17 1/4".....to the top of the upholstery is 19 1/4".....to the bottom of the round apron is 27".....

so the distance from top of upholstery to bottom of round apron is 7 3/4".....when I sat at this round table (compressing the upholstery), I had about 1 1/2" space between the top of my thigh and bottom of round apron.....so theoretically, if I were to sit at the new rectangular table with an apron 2" lower than the round apron, I'd have my thigh compressed by 1/2".....therefore if I were to curve the bottom of the new apron by an 1" - 1 1/4", I'd have 1/2" - 3/4" of space which is plenty adequate.....this looks like a good solution at this point as I'd retain a strong m/t joint at the leg, I'd have a design feature of interest in the curved aprons, I'd get some adequate space under the apron for human legs, and I could continue with chairs similar to those at the round table.....this is designing as we go.....find a solution that works and claim you were going to do it this way all along.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#9

Ellis Walentine

Options

Ellis Walentine

When we have design problems, we need design solutions. And there's another aspect to this and that is: for whom are you designing this piece. That could enter into your decisions depending on whether the client was of average build vs oversize build. Or, if you want to make it more generic than that, consider 7.5" as the minimum space between the seat and the apron, IMO, based on my experience.

What I would caution or question you about, though, is the net height of the seat, which is what's important here. Your cushioning probably has some durometer of compressibility to it, so the net height is probably lower than the uncompressed height. If that makes the difference, I'd say skip the apron revisions.

Ellis

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#10

Re: Options

roger lance

Ellis....the table is for me....it will seat six with a top of 42"x72".....and be used in a dining room that is 12'x12'.....I went to the simple "country" table design of four legs attached to the table by aprons to eliminate a more complicated base design that could possible be obstructive to feet and foot placement.....I wanted it to be comfortable.....I wanted people to sit at the table, enjoy their meal, and want to linger at table with wine/conversation after eating without ever having the table be on their mind which it would be if it were uncomfortable for them by having insufficient space under the apron or their feet/legs hitting the base structure.....I used some dimensions which various literature recommended like 30" table height and 25" space under the apron.....but I wanted to be sure.....I think your 7 1/2" minimum distance below the apron to the seat (compressed upholstery or solid seat) is a fairly reliable standard that I will incorporate here.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#11

Re: Options

Bruce McCrory

I don't think you want to skinny up an apron that much. Especially with a rectilinear table. Look at the arch detail closely. Compare it with physical examples you can touch and feel. An arched apron will also define your style, so other compensations will likely be needed.

Just my 20 bucks worth. ... [2-cents, inflated.]

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#12

Re: Perhaps the issue is the chair.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Roger,

You've likely already thought of this, but it seems like you could take direct action by clamping sticks to the bottom of the curved apron--straight sticks, they wouldn't have to follow the curve--to test the precise clearance you would have while sliding into place, sitting there, and then getting up. All while using the chairs in question.

The direct simulation might be more convincing, and provide more specific accuracy, than numerical solutions, however sensible they are. Undertaking to cut into those aprons is a big, big step, and you want to know to the quarter inch if you need to or not, and by how much.

Wiley

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#13

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

CStanford

A valuable resource:

http://www.cawspi.org/Furniture%20Design.pdf

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

Where was that hiding?

Jack Guzman from Maine

I went through many woodworking books both old and new looking for something like that for years. Always got vague guidelines. That is a good resource indeed. thanks---Jack

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#15

Re: Where was that hiding?

CStanford

It's a keeper for sure.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#16

Re: Where was that hiding?

CStanford

You need this too if you ever do commercial work:

http://www.amazon.com/Interior-Graphic-Design-Standards-Reznikoff/dp/0823072983

This one will cost you a few bob.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#17

Re: Where was that hiding?

CStanford

It's amazing the answers and resources one can find when the mortgage payment is due in fourteen days and there ain't no time for scratching one's posterior, reinventing the wheel, and such.

Good luck with your woodworking.

If I'd built my house like you did I wouldn't have to worry about crap like this now would I?

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#18

Depends..... 


img

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#19

You're absolutely right !!


Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#20

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

CStanford

See page 3 of the link I provided earlier today for your answer.

The link does not take into account seating NBA basketball players and midgets at the same dinner party.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#21

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

roger lance

page 5 under typical dimensions lists the general guideline I was using....ie 30" for table top height and 25" under the apron to the floor....one never knows who might show for dinner....having both extremes at the same time might be fun.

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

#22

Re: Seeking opinion on table dimension....

CStanford

My recommendation in that case would be for something buffet style - the dinner party at least.