New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

On the merits of the divider

Posts

On the merits of the divider

#1

On the merits of the divider

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


"Line and Berry" is a decoration found on Chester County furniture. It can be scratched in or routed with a Dremel. But I have never seen a description for laying these patterns out on a set of drawers of ascending size. I figured it had to be straightforward and indeed once I found the secret "decoder key" it was.


One simply establishes the center line for the drawer and sets one divider to radius R and the second to 2R. The diamond that surrounds the pull is established first at radius 2R. The "tulip" is then drawn from the location of where the diamond intersects the center line using divider set at radius R. Piece of cake.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#2

Fascinating, and nifty!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That's a post worth printing out.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#3

Re: On the merits of the divider

Scott in Douglassville

Really cool, and must be satisfying to have figured that out! Gives me even more appreciation for the level of craftsmanship that went into the design.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#4

Re: On the merits of the divider

Martin from Texas

Ellis, can we make this a "shop shot"?

Or should it be an "article"?

Either way, I think it merits saving.

Thanks Bill!

Re: On the merits of the divider

#5

Re: On the merits of the divider

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If someone what sit as a shop shot let me know and I will add one additional bit of annotation.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#6

Re: On the merits of the divider

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I had the same feeling Newton had when the apple fell on his head- satisfied and relieved that laying these patterns out would be easy. Not ready to state that scratching them will be easy.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#8

Excellent post

Ron Harper

I am spectacularly ignorant on the use of these things. I need an hour lesson to get "yellow sheeted" on their use.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#9

Ellis Walentine

An article in the works

Ellis Walentine

I will put an article together as soon as Bill adds whatever he wanted to add.

In the early days here, we often had "articles" that were not much more than quick tips, particularly Sam Simpson's finishing tips. It is a fine and valid way to preserve useful posts. Shop Shots originally was intended as a place for people to show their shops or anything related to their shops, including tools, fixtures, even methods of work. Shop Shots has also become a gallery of sorts, where people send us photos and descriptions of their finished projects. All are welcome.

Ellis

PS Since Dan Donaldson passed away, I've been too shorthanded here to produce articles as frequently as I'd like. It's not exactly a trivial task; in fact it is really a custom application. If any of you has experience with coding (HTML, CSS) and/or editing, and would like to help give our articles department a new life, drop me a line. My humblest gratitude goes out to Garrett Lambert and Rod Peterson, who sustained our article editing and production so faithfully for many years, and of course, Dan, who was the organizing and driving force as Articles Coordinator. It is great to have this legacy of archived wisdom and experience residing here on WoodCentral.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#10

Divider publication in the works

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been corresponding with Steve Latta on this line and berry thing. When I sent him the "decoder ring" for laying these things out he said that he was preparing an article for some magazine (FW, PW??) on the use of dividers. Watch for it.

I suspect that dividers were commonly used to lay out furniture elements in times past. Their employment vastly reduces chance for errors. Over time I have used a ruler less in making stuff. I use a divider for layout (for example drawer spacing) and take measurements off the piece.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#11

Re: On the merits of the divider

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

Wonderful post, which indeed wants to be an Article!

Also a spectacular project! Two questions come to mind:

1. It looks like the divider 'punctures' will be re-used to anchor the scratch tool you use to swing the arcs--is that right? And have you decided which tool to buy (or make)?

2. Do the divider/scratch 'punctures' eventually end up getting covered over by the inlay pattern?

Or perhaps I have the wrong picture in mind.....?

Wiley

Re: On the merits of the divider

#12

Great

Ron Harper

I will eagerly look for the article.

I am trying to get away from ruler and tape as much as I can.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#13

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. It looks like the divider 'punctures' will be re-used to anchor the scratch tool you use to swing the arcs--is that right?

In fact the "compass" device that can be used to scratch the troughs for the inlay can be used as a divider and the divider step can be left out....if one has confidence. Otherwise the answer to your question is yes.

And have you decided which tool to buy (or make)? Lie Nielsen. Though now that I own it if I needed another I would make it from a marking gauge.

2. Do the divider/scratch 'punctures' eventually end up getting covered over by the inlay pattern?..... some will. The punctures are controversial. I am told the punctures can be seen in the Period pieces. Hence, to be "Period Correct", something I have no inclination to be, they should be left to show. That said, I feel about them like I do about nail holes in molding and scribe lines on drawers. They are an authentic part of the construction and if they don't detract from the appeal of the piece as normally viewed from normal distance, I don't fret about hiding these things. Others go to great lengths to avoid or hide the punctures. Some use a router and template to avoid them altogether, an approach I find inconvenient, if not distasteful.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#14

Ellis Walentine

The article is right here

Ellis Walentine

All I will do is create a permanent version of it for our Articles section. I have also invited an old pal to join the conversation. If he brings additional insights to the topic, we can append them to Bill's article.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: On the merits of the divider

#15

Re: On the merits of the divider *LINK*

William Duffield

I also have the Lie-Nielsen inlay radius cutter. It is very well made, but there are alternatives, that work as well. For example, here is the shop-made cutter that Chuck Bender uses. It is obviously made from a modified pair of Starrett dividers, which can be found second-hand at old tool shows. An appropriate venue for finding these things is being held this weekend in Richmond, VA (on the way to the Woodworking in the 18th Century conference in Williamsburg). See the link below.

Front View. Note that Chuck also uses the L-N radiusing tool, lying in the background, but he has a tendency to roll it over on its side, losing the pivot point's registration.


Back View:


Close-up of the cutter, front and back views.


Chuck's tool doesn't come with interchangeable knives for different width stringing.


Richmond Antique Tool Society show

Re: On the merits of the divider

#16

Ellis Walentine

Funny thing

Ellis Walentine

Chuck is the guy I invited to join the conversation. I know he's on the road in North Carolina at the L-N event this weekend, so I don't know if he'll jump in here or not.

Thanks for the great close-ups of his tools.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: On the merits of the divider

#17

craigd

Re: Divider publication in the works  *LINK*

craigd

I suspect that dividers were commonly used to lay out furniture elements in times past.

In the US, at least since the 17th century. Peter Follansbee has write quite a bit about using dividers (and has a video or two on the subject).




PB carved chest using dividers for layout

Re: On the merits of the divider

#18

Ellis Walentine

Okay, the article is now in our Articles dept.


Re: On the merits of the divider

#19

Re: Funny thing

William Duffield

As I was processing the photos and writing my explanation, it began to dawn on me that there was a good chance it was Chuck that you had invited into the discussion. Who better to ask for help?

If you study the layout of the Line and Berry patterns, you will notice that most of them hide the center point of the arcs under other elements of the design. However, this is not always the case. Some designs leave the center point of some of the arcs out in the middle of the field. I asked Chuck about leaving prick marks in the wood from the dividers. Chuck confirmed Bill's observation. He noted that usually he does it the same way because the marks were usually left on the old ones. They didn't bother to hide them, for example by temporarily attaching a scrap of wood to center the compass on. The finish does hide most of mark.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#21

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: On the merits of the divider

#22

Lots here.  Lots.

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Clearly, I need to update my reading list.

Re: On the merits of the divider

#23

Another article perhaps.


Re: On the merits of the divider

#24

Agree!!  It's one of a kind!  Exceptional!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

How is it we come to expect the exceptional from David?

Wiley

Re: On the merits of the divider

#25

Hugely useful post Thanks