New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

Posts

Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#1

Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

Phil

In our last episode, we discussed (among other things) how thick a slice is usually taken when shooting cabinet sized component parts. I generally have the hang of it now, using a makeshift shooting board, and a LN LA Jack, with a A2 blade honed at around 32 degrees (which key is it that give you the degree sign?). I'm finding that around .002 in. slice seems to work, although considerable force has to be applied (hard to quantify that of course). I am now wondering if going to an O1 blade and honing around 22 degrees (primary bevel at 20 degrees) would make a significant/noticeable difference in the force required to get the same .002 cut? Also, knowing that I won't get as much mileage from the O1 vs. the A2, will there be any difference in cut quality? I know the theory, I'm interested in seeing if anyone has been down this road, and recommends going to the O1 blade?

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#2

Alt+248  = °

Tony-Memphis

What i do is hold Alt and type 248 for °.

Tony

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#3

Re: Alt+248  = °

roger lance

On a Mac....hold shift & alt and type 8 = °.....just learned that playing around with your suggestion....tx.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#4

O1 vs A2 For End Grain Shooting: No Opinions?

Phil

OK, great, thanks. Now if I can only get someone to weigh in on the O1 vs A2 question.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#5

an answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You seem to be somewhat new here and may not appreciate the fatigue that has set in on this metal stuff. I have been at it for about 12 years now. I'm tired . It is amazing how little the "needle has moved" in this time, though Lee Valley has likely shoved it a lot with the successful introduction of PMV alloy.

If you have the energy, pursue the work. Maybe you can "move the needle" a bit with your discoveries. It will take a lot of energy and be prepared for a chorus of skeptics stuck in traditional ways, or even their own way.

In the beginning I was told that specialty steels like M2 could not be sharpened and a multitude of bogus reasons professed. They had not discovered diamonds. So we have made some progress.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#6

a 2nd answer......

roger lance

If no one responds to your O1 questions, why not get an O1 blade and prepare it as you propose....test it out and let us know what you learned ?

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#7

A2/O1 for paring

Phil

New: I remember Badger Pond (how many folks know what that is?) :)

Yes, there has been no shortage on the various WW sites of postings and dissertations on the merits/deficiencies of this/that/the other steel. I was hoping (obviously naive on my part) that for this specific question, someone would have already been down this path and could give me some insight.

Based on at least one blog article, Chris Schwartz seems to prefer the O1 for this specific task of low angle paring. Ask anyone at LN, and they generally recommend the A2 irons. I guess I'll just have to obtain an O1 iron and see how it compares. I tried a W1 iron from an older LN block plane, and it did not seem to perform as well as the A2 in my LA Jack. I am using diamond lapping film for honing (15, 3, .5, .1 micron (so how do you get the micron symbol?) and all irons are "shave the hair off your arm"/slice a piece of paper sharp. The results with the W1 iron surprised me: I've seen some postings touting how one of the benefits of W1 was how sharp an edge it will take, but it did not perform as well as the A2 when shooting cherry end grain. Of course, you have to factor in operator error in all of this, which is why I was hoping an expert would chime in and share his knowledge. My investigation continues.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#8

Re: A2/O1 for paring

david weaver

The A2 performed better in cherry end grain because it's a lot more durable unless it's used at a really shallow angle. W1 might be something nice to have in chisels, but we'll probably not see much like it on new chisels. Japanese White #2 is like W1 on steroids, that's as close as you'll get.

I'd suspect LN probably went from W1 to A2 at least partially because of how much better behaved A2 is when heat treating.

I'd have some indifference about A2 or O1 in a plane iron for shooting, it's hard on plane irons either way. If you absolutely had to have a 25 degree final angle, then O1. Low angle planes are so easy to take apart and sharpen that it doesn't really make much difference if you sharpen every 20 things you shoot or every 30.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#9

Maybe its in the framing of the question...

John in NM

Seems like what you want to know is whether the lower blade angle would require a bit less force when shooting. As I understand it, the answer to that question will make the steel question moot, as using a low angle for A2 won't work very well.

Bear in mind though, I don't even pretend to know the answer to either of those questions, or even what angle my own tools are sharpened at. I simply haven't found that it improves my life to sweat the details. I grind and then hone, usually grinding at whatever angle the blade was ground at last time. Fortunately I rarely have to change the toolrest angle anyhow so it ends up being the same angle as last time I ground a tool.

I hope such honesty doesn't horrify some of the guys here too much :D

I hone A2 on reguluar old oilstones too, I seem to remember reading about what an inconvenience it is to do so... but it works just fine. Hardly any difference than O1 blades and various Cr-Mn mystery steels.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#10

Re: an answer

TomD

A would say you made progress mostly through repetition, which is something. I had HSS Japanese chisels in 1980, and my TR12 router came with a razor sarp carbide router bit, and as you say people said it was all impossible back then also. Sharpening has probably gotten harder, ever since it because unstylish to grind and polish, LV green may have been the high point. Diamonds in the loose are great, in particular I find them excellent with my head knife.

I'm with you on the main point. People should have to read their way through the first million pages before they post. :)

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#11

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

TomD

"I am now wondering if going to an O1 blade and honing around 22 degrees (primary bevel at 20 degrees) would make a significant/noticeable difference in the force required to get the same .002 cut? Also, knowing that I won't get as much mileage from the O1 vs. the A2, will there be any difference in cut quality? I know the theory, I'm interested in seeing if anyone has been down this road, and recommends going to the O1 blade?"

I am a big O1 proponent, but I don't see a lot of evidence it sharpens up better than other steels. I think it has appealing sharpening properties, but "gets sharper" is a tougher sell. Normally stuff gets sharper from more sharpening, and that is often time better spent with steels that hold an edge well. O1 one is easy to sharpen to a reasonable level, and has good edge retention, in reasonable woods.

Therefore throughout your questions I would say the O1 vs A2 is not really relevant to the question. There are lots of A2 blades sold at 25 degrees, a few degrees lower is not going to disqualify the A2 for the scenario in question.

Will a lower overall cutting angle affect surface quality, and ease of cutting. Yes, can be quite noticeable. Surface quality is dependant on many variables.

I don't normally shoot for endgrain surface quality. I use a finishing plane, and lower angle is good. You can get good results at higher angles also, but one does not get the gloss on some woods, and it is harder to push. There is no reason to go for 2 thou in this operation, and once you drop to say a reasonable level like 4 tens, ease of cut is not longer an issue. More skew is also good.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#12

Re: an answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My first post on this topic of metal was on Badger Pond where I asked the experts why durable steels like M2 weren't used for hand tools. The confident answer was that these steels would not take a fine edge. I have been in (and seemingly on the wrong side of) this metal discussion ever since. I don't recall your contributions back then to metal research but I have a failing memory so maybe I just forgot. Whatever, glad to see someone else willing to carry the torch. With Lee Valley having validated the employment of modern steel in woodworking tools I can retire from the topic and go make stuff .

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#13

Re: O1 vs A2 For End Grain Shooting: No Opinions?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Phil,

At this point, you've got the prototype setup working. Which is great!

I think it would help you right now to test the boundaries and capabilities of your setup and tools. As I recall, you are shooting 4/4 cherry with an LN62--is that still correct?

Here are a couple of tests that might help you answer your own question--maybe you've already done these and are way ahead of me.

Question: With the LN 62, what happens when you shave 1/4" stock? Or 1/2"? Doesn't need to be those exact thicknesses, or any particular type of wood--just use whatever old drawer side or drawer bottom stock you find laying around the work area. What happens to the applied force as you increase/decrease thickness?

Question: Do you have a heavier plane? Like a No. 6 or No. 7? Doesn't have to be dead square on the side, like the LN, because this is just a diagnostic test. If you have one, sharpen it up, and try it, same as you did the LN62, on the same thinner and thicker stock. What happens? Your attack angle is about the same, as between the LN62 (32+12 = 44 degrees), compared with 45 degrees for the No. 6 or 7 or 8. If you get about the same feel in action from the different weight planes, then that would suggest a lower angle is probably the way to go. But if the heavier plane ploughs through the heavier shaving more readily, that would indicate that mass is more the issue, though still there could be a usable tradeoff against lower angle.

Whatever the results, I think these tests would give you a lot of insight into the nature of the problem.

Just a hunch: lower attack angle will prove useful, but not decisive. 44 degrees is just fine.

Wiley

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#14

A Giant Leap Forward

Phil

OK, when in doubt, read the directions. Referred to Charlesworth Furniture Making Techniques Volume Two (side note: in my opinion, he has the best writing style, and the photographs are better than any other WW book I can think of). Sanity check no. 1: my previous post focused on thickness of slice. I had no idea where this should be, but after some trial and error and much input from WC folks, came to the conclusion the .002 was not too far off from ideal. Charlesworth, page 18:"I would suggest that a shaving of about 0.05mm thick is about right." So far so good. I had arbitrarily chosen 3/4" thick stock to fool around with, thinking this was likely the thickest stock I was likely to need to shoot. Charlesworth, page 16:"Shooting becomes valuable when the thickness of the timber being prepared is below about 1/2." OK, maybe the resistance I am dealing with is more a function of component thickness than sharpness of blade or blade angle. Lets try thinner piece: lots easier (but we knew that already didn't we?). But the mission was to get full width shavings of the arbitrarily chosen test piece which is 50% thicker: what to do. Who is that guy I ran into at the LN show, Tico something? He had a very slick (figuratively and literally) ramped shooting board. Time for a design change to the experimental set up. Lets see what raising the back of the shooting board up by about 1 inch will do. See below. I still wonder if approaching at a 22° with O1 would be sig. different than A2 at 32°? I may have to break down a buy another blade. Watch for future installments of this mind-numbing saga.


img

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#15

Re: A Giant Leap Forward

TomD

Seems like you are switching horses between finish quality and the best set-up with a shooting board, which is understandable since they are both interesting questions. But it is hard to follow.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#16

Re: A Giant Leap Forward

roger lance

Tico Vogt...Super Chute 2.0 shooting boards. Also see Derek Cohen's site InTheWoodshop for shooting boards.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#17

A2 and O1 and ... (I really shouldn't but ...)

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Phil

I have been using A2 with a 25 degree bevel on a LV LA Jack (same set up as yours) successfully for several years. Although the common intelligence says that this is an inferior set up, since A2 is not at its best under 30 degrees, I have very rarely seen a chipped blade.

The reason for choosing A2 over O1 has been its greater durability, and since the hardwoods I work are indeed very hard, this was a no-brainer. A2 gets as sharp as O1 - it just needs a little more attention when sharpening.

It is possible to use just about any cutting angle. Many here do not have a low angle plane and get by happily with a common angle (45 degrees). Before I began using the LA Jack I used a half pitch (60 degrees) HNT Gordon Trying Plane. There is no doubt, however, that a lower cutting angle can produce a smoother surface. The alternative to a low cutting angle is a skewed, slicing cut, such as from a Stanley/LN #51.

The introduction of the PM steel by LV is going to benefit those with the LV LA Jack as PM-V11 steel can be ground at 20 degrees. It is not going to help you. My choice for you would be A2 and grind/hone it at 25 degrees.

How you hold and use your plane is also of significance. This, and a few other points, is described in this article on my website:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/ShootingPlanesCompared.html

Add this feature to your shooting board for significant improvement in results:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/RunningFencefortheShootingBoard.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#18

Re: A2 and O1 and ... (I really shouldn't but ...)

Phil

Derek (and everyone else who replied to this inquiry) Thanks for all the great guidance. There are a no. of variables at play here, and I was trying to optimize all of them at once. The most vexing part of this has been force required to make the cut. Since this is hard to quantify, I can only use my experience to judge what is reasonable relative to the force required to move the plane through the cut. I was stubbornly stuck with the 3/4" stock that I chose to use as a test piece. I tried a no. 7 bench plane and a block plane, but found the best performance with the LN LA Jack. But it still took some degree of force to push the plane through the cut and end up with a controlled cut that yielded a full width regulation shaving (not sawdust). The Eureka moment occurred when I went to the sloped/ramped board. The force required was greatly reduced: by how much I can't quantify (I'll work on getting a force transducer hooked up for my next experiment :) ). I do have to wonder if the reduction in force could be doubled again by going from the 32° I am at now to the 22° that I would hone at should I give the O1 iron a try. It seemed to me that a 10° change in iron angle could make a significant difference, but I am only guessing here. You state that you have had success with the A2 at 25° (OK that's 70% of the reduction in angle I was after) I will try that to see how much this reduces the required force.

Thanks again (all) for the shared wisdom.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#19

quick test with M2?

Lars Parrington

i wonder if M2 would be a good steel for this task. it might well be better than O1 or A2.

if you happen to have any worn out planer or jointer knives hanging around (easy source of M2), i can envision a quick and easy test. use 2 strips of that material in place of the iron on your low angle jack. one would do the cutting, the other goes on the opposite side of the cap iron's screw, just to balance out the load. they wouldn't engage the depth adjustment mechanism, but for this test you could adjust depth by tapping with a hammer. since you already use diamond film for sharpening, you should have no trouble putting a nice edge on the M2.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#20

Re: For the sake of practicality

david weaver

.. I wouldn't chase super low angles when the object of the game isn't to remove tons of material, anyway.

You're not gaining a lot by doing it, but you could find yourself with beat up edges.

At one point, I had LN's best offering for shooting (the #9) and LV's best offering (the LA jack). I still have the latter. The former works on a 20 degree bed, but I never noticed it to be lacking in any way when doing shooting work, despite the higher angle.

At 30 degrees, you have a plane less than common pitch and no problems. It's nice to be able to work with no problems.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#21

Re: For the sake of practicality

Phil

Interesting: I have been laboring under the apparently mistaken impression that for paring operations, the lower the angle the better (better meaning less force required). Your point regarding the LN no. 9 is bolstered by the fact that the angle on the newer dedicated shooting plane, the LN51 is also at an angle that is higher than the angles I am already at with the LA Jack with a 30° or so bevel. It would appear that I'm already at a reasonable angle concerning the bevel. I think I'll concentrate on technique at this point. Thanks for the input.

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#22

Re: Paring vs. shooting

david weaver

When you're paring, it's you and the chisel. No momentum or anything like that, and you're dead on a line more than creeping up to it.

Things you enjoy on paring chisel don't necessarily have as much utility translated directly to a plane. AT some point in the not very distant future, your sawing is going to be good enough that you're sawing so close to the line that shooting effectively involves removing the saw marks.

(and you'll probably end up shooting less unless you're shooting miters or cabinet or door frame parts).

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#23

Re: A Giant Leap Forward

David Charlesworth

Phil,

I am delighted you find my books useful.

My 1/2" recommendation was made before the advent of the L-N 51, which will comfortably shoot thicker stuff. I do however wonder what the point is when thick stuff is so easy to plane freehand in the vice.

I know there have been some supply issues on some of the books but these will be resolved. I also have stock, and L-N continue to sell the DVDs.

best wishes,

David

Re: Shooting End Grain: Follow-up

#24

Re: A Giant Leap Forward

Phil

David: And I am delighted that you decided to post in my humble thread. I have referred to your texts often, and suggest everyone serious about hand tools should do themselves a favor and acquaint themselves with your work. Thanks for weighing in, and stay healthy. Regards, Phil