Re: Sword steel, interested in hearing more.
Sammi Takeuchi
I don't doubt that many of reputable blacksmiths are in possession of good quality (tamahagane, Togo steel etc) through old stock, given, willed or discovery. And probably mid grade tamahagane is probably still very good steel in the end. I think it pays to be aware that the term "tamahagane" is not a designation for a set of specification like O1, A2. M2 and so on. It can be very good, but it can be bad, and everything in between. Like you say, there is no magic. I guess when a blacksmith can produce something consistent out of inconsistent quality tamahagane and be able to produce something outstanding, that's amazing.