New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Posts

(Message Deleted by Poster)

#1

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#2

Re: OT? Sand that grows? Magic steel?

TomD

Mark posted the MM video on tool makers in japan, and I guess there are others out there that show the same thing. So it should be simple enough to tell whether they ever temper. I seem to recall that they do temper saws in sand. Whatever they are doing it allows them to control their production and produce a finely defined product.

I remember when the K car came out hearing someone say that the production of a reliable car by a US company was too little too late. He said that the Japanese had engineers working on minute details of their cars, like tuning the sound of the exhaust. This was at a time when the crappy US car, and the luxury one would have many parts in common like steering column covers, locks, radios.

The Japanese tools are at the level of the experience, not just what the tool does. And this makes sense. I started thinking about this around workplace safety. It started to intrude that amateurs were taking on big enough projects that they could no longer be confident that their exposure levels and risks were less than those of industrial workers. Particularly considering the quality of their workplaces.

On a similar vein once you spend all your free time on a hobby you may want to consider the same distinctions that the better pros consider, not out of a production need, but for the quality of experiences.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#3

Re: OT? Sand that grows? Magic steel?

Schtoo

So maybe, just maybe, there is something special about those vintage chisels, maybe there actually are untempered laminated irons and who knows what else, and maybe there really was or is magic steel. I guess I shouldn't be so skeptical, so damned cynical all the time. I mean, what the heck do I know? Just can't say anymore.

Here's what I do know, only from the folks over here still making laminated tools. No magic involved.

Modern steels are tempered. They stick them in a deep fryer and fry them for a bit and that's that.

Tamahagane, AKA sword steel (the real stuff, not some marketing gimmick BS) is, as far as I am aware, not tempered at all. The reasoning is that the steel has been refined to such a high level that anything brittle causing is burned out. The grain of the steel is very fine and it's been mashed together so many times that it has a toughness that normal steels cannot attain 'as is' but can be made to have if they are hot worked like this stuff is. It is also relatively low in carbon (about 0.7%) so tempering it will make it softer than it might ideally be, so it's fortunate that it does not need tempering.

It is made from iron bearing sands that are stuck in a big clay pot with lots of charcoal and air is blown into the mess for 3 days. The pot is watched the entire time and continuously adjusted to make sure it's going along like it should. The guys who were making the stuff regularly are usually blind before they hit retirement age, simply because of looking at the stuff without eye protection.

I don't know how much of this sand is needed to make how much steel, but I do know that the end product is about 50% 'junk steel', 30% 'garden tool steel', 15% 'cutlery and tool steel' and 5% 'sword steel' as the sword guys take the best bits. Well, they used to at least anyway.

Tamahagane is labour intensive stuff to make, it's been well documented how it's made and there's no mystery to it that a 1st or 2nd year metallurgical student wouldn't be able to understand. It's completely impractical material, unless it's all you have available and many years ago, having anything made of iron that was superfluous was akin to how gold was considered everywhere else in the world. So it's a case of 'make do steel', refined to a ridiculous degree.

(I'd bet you could get a chunk of Chevy axle and make it into something amazing steel wise with enough time, effort and no choice but to make it into something good for lack of alternative options.)

So there you go. Some steel is not tempered after it's been hardened, but chances are you'll never see or use it so it doesn't matter.

And it's still just iron with some carbon mixed through it. Special perhaps, but not magical.

(From the blacksmith's point of view, tamahagane is also a right PITA to work with as well. I don't know why, but they all cringe a little when you mention it.)

I hope that helps clear some things up, although there will always be folks who'll latch onto some little nugget of BS, and drag it out every time someone tries to undo said BS. It's the nature of the internet and the anonymity of it. You can be as idiotic as you want, because nobody is going to reach through the screen and punch you in the nose, no matter how much you might deserve it for being an obnoxious 'rhymes with banker'.

Stu.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#4

Re: OT? Sand that grows? Magic steel?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

"So there you go. Some steel is not tempered after it's been hardened, but chances are you'll never see or use it so it doesn't matter."

Is the steel's not being tempered partly due to differential hardening of the tamahagane?

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#5

Re: OT? Sand that grows? Magic steel?

Schtoo

Is the steel's not being tempered partly due to differential hardening of the tamahagane?

I don't think so, and I don't think I wrote anything like that...

When tamahagane is in a chisel or plane blade, as far as I am aware it's not tempered at all and as far as I am aware there is no differential hardening going on. That would require applying 'mud' to the blade before it's heat treated, and while they do apply a kind of 'mud' to the blades when they're heat treated, it's a dip in liquid 'mud' then into the forge to be heated up, then dunked in a trough of water. No special technique required.

(The 'mud' is to help combat decarburization. Looks like thin gravy. The sword makers use a different kind of mud, I think. I don't know. Might be the same kind of stuff.)

When it comes to a sword, I don't know for sure but I believe it's not tempered there either, likely because of that differential hardening thing that likely hardens and tempers the steel in one shot, but I don't know. I also don't know any sword makers nor know anyone who was a sword maker in a previous life.

It could well be something I'm not aware of, but I've been told that anything made with tamahagane doesn't get tempered, at least not in the deep fryer. Might well be an 'all in one' process too. I don't know, I haven't been told every detail.

But I can find out...

Suppose I better find out, just to make sure what they really meant when they said 'not tempered'...

Stu.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#6

Just to clarify

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I didn't get the notion of differential hardening from you, but rather from a couple knife making forums I read. If I'm not mistaken (which is frequently the case) the differential hardening comes from covering the spine of the sword, or whatever, with a coating of clay such that the temperature of the steel in the spine doesn't get as high as the important edge. The hamon represents the border of the clay covering.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#7

Re: OT? Sand that grows? Magic steel?

CStanford

You're not suggesting that people are still going blind making these steels I hope.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#8

Or would that just be a "nugget of BS?"


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#9

there is a chemical basis for this observation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


White Sands "sand" is not the sand one finds on the beach in FL. It is in fact calcium sulfate hydrate, AKA gypsum. When it traveled from the desert of NM to the soggy climate of FL it may indeed have absorbed water and swelled.

If one is ever near there it is worth some inconvenience just to experience the radically different texture of the sand. It is soft.

So the moral of the story, it is best not to dismiss some observation as baloney because it runs contrary to limited experience at least until the science is thoroughly understood.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#10

David's original post mentioned gypsum


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#11

Re: Just to clarify

Schtoo

Apparently yes, the clay slows down the quench, so those areas don't get hardened. Or is it the other way around?

I don't know for certain, never seen it done in person and no-one to ask directly so I won't speculate on how it's actually done but you're correct that the hamon is created where the clay is put and how it's put there.

The only tamahagane blades I've seen, nothing like that going on. They look the same as usual blades.

I've also found a small reference from Tasai on their site that the tempering of tamahagane is different to usual steels because of the low carbon content and that it doesn't get as hard as the usual white or blue steels.

But I've not asked Tasai directly what they learned from experimenting with the stuff, and they're not the only folks making blades from it either.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#12

My first thought too...

John in NM

CaSO4-OH

That OH is the important part, its what makes gypsum a fire retardant, energy from the fire goes into converting gypsum to anhydrite (CaSO4) before it can start heating up the lumber that makes up your house. This is where drywall fire ratings come from.

I have two theories, one is that the gypsum picked up a lot of water from its new atmosphere, as Bill suggested. Second is that the process is cyclical. Sand swells, then dries out some in the winter, but forms a crust leaving air space below (gypsum is fantastically sticky for "sand"). Process repeats, making the jar look much more full than it had been over the course of these people's lives.

Could also be that they've noted the phenomenon and that their memory is playing a little trick on them as to how much was actually there to begin with. I would be pretty surprised if gypsum swelled more than 25% or so by volume, if even that much.

I drive by White Sands every week, I can send David a jar of sand if he wants to experience it himself :D

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#13

The trouble is this...

John in NM

The sand only appears magical to those who take it at face value and assume it is beach sand (in spite of tactile evidence to the contrary). As you have demonstrated, if you relate the story to just a few people of diverse experience and you will quickly find someone who knows why the phenomenon is science rather than magic. I've yet to see the same with old, magical steel, and it has been discussed ad naseum on every woodworking forum out there.

Sometimes Occam's razor cuts in a direction with which one is less than pleased.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#14

Re: The trouble is this...

CStanford

Nothing mythical or magical about having one's eyesight sacrificed to the cause, as it were.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#15

Re: OT? Sand that grows? Magic steel?

Sammi Takeuchi

I have no relevant post to add to this thread, but here is further information on tamahagane.

Like Schtoo says, tamahagane is the most sought after gem of steel after enormous amount of work and materials are spent. For example, 1 hyou (unit of production, 1 hyou = 1 tatara = 1 fiery tub of furnace = 1 batch) requires 13 tons of iron sand, 13 tons of charcoal, which produced 2.8 tons of kera (chunk of steel and iron) and 0.8 tons of zuku (steel with high carbon content). Out of this kera, less than 1 ton of tamahagane was produced, and fraction of that is the highest grade, I would say less 3% of it would be sword grade. Even within tamahagane, there are different grades applied to distinguish different qualities. The Society of Preservation of Japanese Art Swords defines as such:

Tamahagane special grade: C 1.0 – 1.5%, especially fine grained

Tamahagane 1st grade: C 1.0 – 1.5%, fine grained

Tamahagane 2nd grade: C 0.5 – 1.2%, fine grained

Tamahagane 3rd grade OR otherwise known as ‘oowarishita’: C 0.2 – 1.0%, rough grained

Mejiro: same quality as Tamahagane 1st grade, but small, less than 2cm chunk

Do-shita: same quality as Tamahagane 2nd grade, but small, less than 2cm

Zuku: C 1.7% and above, used for oroshigane (to increase carbon) or sagegane, processed steel with about C 0.7%, or further completely decarbonized into iron.

Ookajiyou OR bugera: mixture of iron, steel, incompletely smelted steel/iron, charcoal ash. Recycled steel, carbonized/decarbonized to achieve preferred quality for further use.

As an example, Yasukuni tatara in 1935 produced (wt %):

Tamahagane special grade: C 1.42%, Si (tr)unicated, Mn tr, P 0.013, S 0.007, Ni nil, Cr tr, V 0.02, Cu tr, Ti 0.004, Al 0.006, Sn 0.004

Tamahagane 1st grade: C 1.17, Si 0.02, Mn 0.02, P 0.032, S 0.008, Ni nil, Cr tr, V 0.02, Cu 0.01, Ti 0.004, Al 0.006, Sn 0.003

As a side note, there was another method of steel making and is of older method, but the process is extinct now. It was called Zuku-oshi process. While Kera-oshi process aimed to produce high quality steel (such as Tamahagane), Zuku-oshi process aimed to produce high carbon zuku (as explained above) in order to refine to usable and desired carbon content. Process itself is not much different from kera-oshi process, but tatara design was slightly different in order to achieve higher temperature to produce high carbon zuku.

All in all, I would be hard pressed to say tamahagane is such and such, as there are broad range of grades and pretty much highest grades are off limit to tool makers, as even sword makers are struggling to get their hands on them (due to reduced production and limit on purchase of tamahagane on top of being barely produced). There is overstock of lower grade Tamahagane as well as other parts of kere (chunk) produced through this process. Literally tons of stock going nowhere.

I don't know why blacksmiths think tamahagane is pain in the ass. I have a feeling it has due to large variation in quality and characteristics, though. Obviously it doesn't come with specification and broad range of quality they come come from, perhaps they have to work it until they find the ideal characteristic for that particular piece. I'm no blacksmith, but I would think it's a pain in the ass if so-called tamahagane happens to be of not so wonderful quality, somehow you have to make it worth the reputation and premium.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#16

Well...

John in NM

If one can sacrifice their eyesight to the scientific method rather than romantic desires, I suppose I have done so :D

I can tell you, it never helped in the dating department either :D

Of course I may be misconstruing your post, that happens often enough :D

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#17

Re: Sword steel, interested in hearing more.

James Watriss

I have some sword steel chisels from Imai. They're astounding. But I know very little besides that... Where did you find the information?

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#18

More on sword steel?

James Watriss

I have a few sword steel chisels from Imai, bought on someone else's recommendation. They're astounding, but I don't know much more about them than that, and I'd like to.

Where'd you find the information?

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#19

Re: Just to clarify

jack curtis

The only tamahagane blades I've seen, nothing like that going on. They look the same as usual blades.

I've got at least one tamahagane tool, a vintage hatchet once used by a wooden sandal maker; and I've seen a palm-of-the-hand sized blob of it. It does look different to me. It has a very deep, shiny, silver glow look vs the gray sheen of "regular" steel. The glob was really a bunch of steel globs kind of stuck together. These are probably inept descriptions, but no tool user/maker/artist would mistake the two when seen side by side. S/he'd be able to easily pick the tamahagane as being special.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#20

Watched the Nova show?


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#21

Re: OT? Sand that grows? Magic steel?

CStanford

"I'm no blacksmith, but I would think it's a pain in the ass if so-called tamahagane happens to be of not so wonderful quality, somehow you have to make it worth the reputation and premium."

A really unfortunate and persistent theme across the entire genre I believe. A dizzying array of details is provided, not unlike the ones in your post, accompanied by the curriculum vitae of the "the master" and one feels a pressing need for a pair of hip boots.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#22

Re: Sword steel, interested in hearing more.

Schtoo

James,

They're not actually 'sword steel', sorry.

How do I know that?

After putting Mr. Tsunesaburo through the wringer, asking about those exact same chisels, and he putting the question to his contact for Imai, and then finally to the fellow who made the chisels.

They're not tamahagane, and never were.

What they are, from a loose translation, is white steel that's been 'refined' like sword steel, so the steel ends up being 'different' than white steel usually is, a little more effort to sharpen but it holds up better and stays sharper for longer.

I don't know how exactly it's been done though. The message that came back to me didn't include that information.

This 'sword steel' is a lot cheaper than the real stuff. Mr. Imai does not refer to them as 'sword steel', that's something that was stuck on them by who made them available to you.

(You might not like my taking a swing at them in this manner, but it's this kind of stuff that several of the makers here have specifically asked me to 'correct' whenever I encounter it.)

Also, Sam's information is a lot more accurate than mine, but I can tell you that some tool makers do have a very limited amount of 'real' sword steel, Tsunesaburo being one and they got it 'willed' to them from the estate of a now passed sword maker.

I don't know why they cringe, but they do. Maybe it is indeed because it's not a quality controlled modern product, maybe because it's a bit of a handful to work with, maybe because one slip and you have a piece of scrap that's worth it's weight in gold. I don't know for certain, but you sure do pay for the stuff.

Stu.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#23

Re: Just to clarify

Schtoo

As a finished product, perhaps a different colour and overall appearance, but Bruce asked about differential hardening and on the plane I has pass through here, nothing like that at all. It looked the same as a normal blade. I've never seen it used on a tool in any manner other than 'normal' steel is used.

There was certainly nothing out of the ordinary that stood out that would identify it as tamahagane.

(Only if you ignored the hand engraved name on it of course.)

I did take some pictures of that plane, I think. It was only here for about a day before it went overseas. If I find them, I'll make them available somewhere.

Stu.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#24

Re: Sword steel, interested in hearing more.

david weaver

Figure that the 0.7% carbon content tested in a sword, which is a figure that gets thrown around a lot for tamahagane, has a lot to do with the sword makers *knowing* that the steel they were using after forging had to be in that range to be tough enough to handle sword duties. Otherwise, it might be like swording things with a razor, which results in the bits at the very edge pinging off.

I heard the same thing about the imai chisels, same steel, more forge work. I've only had one of the white #1 chisels, a timber framer, but it didn't excite me to use it chopping out plane bodies because it *was* definitely hard, but it was also definitely not very tough. I have another vintage laminated PS&W chisel that is already hard and not very tough - but two orders less hard and I could grind the trouble it out of. when the daiya in the MM video goes through the macassar ebony blanks with his chisel, I can say for sure I don't have a chisel that would tolerate that (maybe the KIs would if they were bench chisels).

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#25

Re: Just to clarify

david weaver

IT looks the same as any other steel in the older iwasaki tamahagane razors, too. You'd never spot which of their razors are tamahagane, and which are his brew of altered swedish steel without looking at the price tag, especially if you can't read kanji.