New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Pfeil bench chisels

Posts

Pfeil bench chisels

#1

Pfeil bench chisels

Ron Harper

Anybody used these? Opinion?

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#2

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

roger lance

Ron.....I've got some.....but my opinion here is as limited as my inexperience with chisels as these are my first set after using Stanley plastic handle chisels in construction work.....they take an edge and seem to keep it....used them to dovetail drawers where QSWO was the fronts and hard maple was the side stock....found them to be durable.....I expect that the ergonomics might not be the best....but when you are limited like me, you get use to the feel and get on with the work.....those handles won't win a beauty contest....but they seem to be all around users (paring, dovetailing, etc).....I plan to keep on with them as I have no pressing reason or experienced shortcoming to replace them....


Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#3

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

david weaver

They are chisels with steel similar to pfeils carving gouges, it feels like fine steel, who knows what it is (it doesn't matter).

AS roger said, the euro style handles are a little different, but they're reasonably light chisels and they get sharp easily and hold their edges well.

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#4

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

CStanford

Very nicely done drawer.

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#5

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

jack curtis

I have 6 or 8 Pfeill's, some are for carving, which I like fine, can get them very sharp and they hold that edge nicely.

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#6

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

Edward in Vancouver

I'm a bit confused about Pfeil. LV won't carry them, and Mr. R. Lee gives a very "diplomatic" "we don't stock 'em" response whenever the subject comes up. Many books and magazines give them the thumbs down, but don't really elaborate as to why.

But I must confess I am prejudiced, as both my parents are Swiss.........

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#7

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

david weaver

I don't know what LV's reasons are, but I would bet it has something to do with woodcraft being the sole supplier of Pfeil tools in the US.

The funny thing about magazine reviews (and the only reason I've used these chisels) is that long ago, FWW said these were good chisels. Friend of mine (who has them- loyal FWW subscriber) read the review and went to parkersburg to get them. He's pleased. He's a power tool user, they hardly get used.

IIRC, the next review they said they weren't as good. He was pissed.

They still hardly get used.

Still, even if LV wanted to pick up Pfeil they could probably only sell them outside the US - that wouldn't be a very good thing to have in a catalog.

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#8

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have one Pfeil carving chisel (well, a bunch of palm chisels, too, but only one big one), and I've been very impressed at its edge holding ability. I've even abused the dickens out of it and it keeps on ticking. But I have no experience with their bench chisels. I can't imagine they'd have one kind of steel for the gouges and another for the chisels.

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#9

FWW chisel review of Oct. 2008.....

roger lance

David.....I also read this review and it was a factor in my purchase of Pfeil (Swiss Made) bench chisels.....they said:

"Because of its shape, the hornbeam handle is particularly easy to grasp from the end. The blade was perfectly flat with nicely softened edges, making it easy on the hands. The cutting edge held up better than average. The fine craftsmanship and high performance make this a very close runner-up for best overall among the Western chisels."

Best overall for Western chisels was Lie-Nielsen. I suppose that tool reviews and these discussions here on chisels and steels etc etc have some value. But at some point, you simply have to make as informed a decision as you can and buy a tool and then use it knowing that there will be a "better" tool that will come along. Literally, every major woodworking power tool in my shop has been improved, surpassed, eclipsed, or no longer produced....I expect the same will be true of hand tools.

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#10

Re: FWW chisel review of Oct. 2008.....

david weaver

Always, that will be the case. It's funny that the LN chisels won considering they had just come out and had to be used at 30 degrees to get good edge retention.

(I did have some LN mortise chisels, where a final bevel of 30 degrees is no big deal, and to their credit, they were very tough at that..very tough).

There must've been a review before that where the pfeils came out on top, though my buddy might not have a great memory about the details. He's happy with the pfeils, they are good regardless of the review material that comes out of the magazines. AT one point, that must've been the way to sell tools - get a favorable comment in FWW and then the vendor is listed at the end of the article or after the reference. That was how he had made his tool purchases, and probably a lot of readers did (and still do).

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#11

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

jack curtis

I considered buy a set of bench Pfeill's, but decided to go Japanese instead, not because the Pfeill's were inferior exactly, but more because of the system and how that would play out with a bunch of other tools. Similar, but not identical, to the Pfeill's are the Dastra, which I use a lot for carving, too.

Re: Pfeil bench chisels

#12

I like them...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I have a set of these and their nice chisels. They take a edge well and they stand up to the hardwoods I work with. I don't use them much anymore because I made the jump to Japanese ones.

If you're thinking about buying these let me know I could sell you my set for a reasonable amount.