New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Posts

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#26

Oops... Correction.

Schtoo

Hi folks,

I've made a grave error...

The YXR7 steel in the Iyoroi and the chisels at TFWW are indeed YXR7 steel, which is NOT powder metal, but a forge toughened steel similar to HSS. It would be somewhere in between normal HSS and PM-HSS, however as it's a patent Hitachi steel, we don't know it's actual composition and from what I've been told by Fujikawa, the steel does have the same characteristics as HSS.

I have a couple of the Fujikawa PM-HSS chisels, and this is one that Derek has.

The difference?

I mistakenly have been calling the Fujikawa YXR7 Matrix High Speed Steel, however the original designation of PM-HSS is correct, it's a HAP type steel.

Completely different animal.

These YXR7 chisels are intended for hacking through all manner of stuff like nails and whatever and are made cheaply to accomplish that task without costing too much money.

The Fujikawa are PM-HSS, which, in their words;

"Our Nezumi hss chisels are made of HAP材 which contains the original properties of HSS steel also forged and tempered with Traditional Japanese procedures which as we believe creates a long lasting cutting edges.

In other words the HAP材 chisel maintain a longer time very sharp edges in addition those are really suitable for wood working for a long time."

So that's the difference. And based on this 'from the horse's mouth' explanation, I cannot tell you what the Iyoroi and TFWW chisels are actually like. I don't know.

So, sorry Dave. I know how much you push for 'cheap', but these things are not that.

Stu.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#27

Re: Thin for paring, ...

jack curtis

I agree, should have mentioned it in the previous message, the rings just don't bother me, whether as shipped or seated. I use paring chisels for their blade shape and thinness, they kind of slither through the wood.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#28

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

david weaver

You mean you have one of the iyorois?

I've been tempted to order a couple, but I've never gotten past tempted.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#29

Re: Oops... Correction.

david weaver

Actually, I was pushing for you to carry the iyorois so I could cherry pick that and some nicer things that iyoroi makes from your store, but if the fujikawa chises are instead HAP, that makes perfect sense why they're that price.

I know (or guess that) the gods of wholesaling are against you in picking up iyoroi stuff, it must come over here through harima or something as many different places as there are that have the blocky basic chisels made by iyoroi. However it has turned out that fujibato gets it, you should go to iyoroi (take my post) and tell them that if your store had it instead of fujibato, their sales of their special stuff would be much higher. Ouchi and koyamaichi might not like it, but they're really a different kind of brand. Even if you were able to get it but not allowed to list it.

The only place I can think of that carries more than a very basic selection of iyoroi stuff is JWW, and their prices have never made sense to me. I got a catalog the other day and the kitayama stone was $104. That's just one example, there are TONS of things like that in it.

Anyway, HAP explains the comment above where derek called the fujikawa the mother of all chisels to sharpen and howard said that the iyoroi chisels are "a little difficult" to sharpen but not too bad.

You're right, I do like cheap, but I'd prefer it as you get something really really cheap, and are able to sell it to us cheap.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#30

HSS "high speed steel"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This is a largely irrelevant property for a chisel for it predicts neither toughness, hardness, or abrasion resistance relative to a steel that is not tempered at high temperatures (900 F or thereabouts) The only value in knowing that some chisel is made from HSS is that if it is it can be power ground with no fear of altering its hardness for it is designed to cut metal red hot. Many high speed steels, a term that simply means they can be run in metal fabrication applications very hot, are in fact too brittle to be useful for a chisel, or if they contain high tungsten, be nearly impossible to sharpen. In general the die steels generically have better properties for a chisel.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#31

Re: HSS "high speed steel"

david weaver

I gather stu's clarification of what was PM HSS and what was something else was mostly for my edification because I've asked him about the fujikawa chisels several times thinking that they were yxr-7 and hoping he could press the maker to get them in line with the other yxr-7 price-wise.

I don't think he was necessarily implying anything other than that they're HAP (which as of right not equates to expensive) and that's the reason for the price difference vs. the yxr-7 chisels that are out there, which are an entry-level price compared to most decent japanese chisels.

(I harrass stu with a lot of things off the forums).

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#32

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Howard Pollack

Yes, I have one that is about an inch wide. Tough as nails and gets surprisingly sharp. I've been tempted to buy more, but I'm trying to buy tools I need rather than just collect more- focus on building things instead of buying cool tools.... Howard

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#33

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

CStanford

Based on Warren's post right above maybe the real test is PM-VII vs. vintage Buck and chisels of that ilk.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#34

the Relevant test

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We have observed that Lee Valley sold out of their initial production of chisels. I wonder how many chisels this was compared to the number of "old" ( or what ever word one wants to use here) chisels available for sale in this time period.

The point is that it is immaterial how good old chisels are, they are not reliably and readily available. If one needs to make something now, or give a gift now, new chisels are the only practical game in town. Hence, except for historical purposes it mattes not how this or that new chisel compares to some old used chisel. The person with the need will only be interested in whether this available new chisel is better than that, or at least good enough for the need in hand.

It is now over ten years ago that we made chisels because we needed some. Tod Hughes was critical of the effort and advocated buying quality vintage chisels instead. I posted a list of sizes I needed and asked for a quote. Didn't have any available. Nobody else stepped up to offer any either. The situation has only gotten worse as more old tools vanish into hoards and collections. Maybe Warren's post will spark demand and when someone is willing to pay him $200 (your price proposal for a quality Japanese chisel) a piece for them he will sell them to someone in need.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#35

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Lars Parrington

howard,

can you give us an idea of some of your other commonly used chisels, so we know what you're comparing the iyoroi hss to? also, what sharpening media do you use?

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#36

Re: Oops... Correction.

Lars Parrington

stu,

thanks for going through the trouble to dig up this extra info on the funmatsu-nezumi chisels. it's good to know that the cost difference is justified in that there is actually a significant physical difference between them and the other japanese hss chisels available.

well, good on the one hand anyway. on the other hand, the extra info just makes my decision-making that much more difficult ;-)

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#37

Re: the Relevant test

david weaver

Ebay has just about killed the ability to get good vintage cabinetmaker chisels in the wild anywhere.

I see stuff from time to time in shops, but if it is close to ready chisels, I can't find much that doesn't cost more than a new tool.

In four years, I've managed to find in person and in the wild - four decent cabinetmaker's tanged chisels and a couple of parers to go with them.

My experience says so far that the display of longevity is more about warren's skill and care in use than it is about the chisels. The LV chisels have better edge retention if they are longer lasting than a good set of O1 new chisels ( i haven't used them, just guessing ).

The vintage forged chisels do not match good japanese chisels, but they probably could if they'd have been hardened to the same level. The virtue of the vintage chisels is that they sharpen easier and aren't picky about stones.

Todd would sometimes forget that the rest of us aren't necessarily walking around for hours at several flea markets and auctions per week during what would otherwise be working hours for most people.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#38

Maybe Warren could add a few words...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

David said, among other things...."My experience says so far that the display of longevity is more about warren's skill and care in use than it is about the chisels."

That is my thinking as well, if we can add in sharpening details. I wonder if Warren could add a few words about techniques and approaches to chisel use and sharpening that he uses, which may differ from other methods that he sees or hears discussed.

Wiley

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#39

Re: Maybe Warren could add a few words...

TomD

Well two key factors are no pryie, and work efficiently. Often if one rattles on about some better way of doing things one gets serious push back about how something is too difficult or someone prefers to use a jig, and how the writer is just an amateur and doesn't need to take it that far. There is a virtuous cycle; do everything right, and stuff goes fast and the worker gets better over time; or keep screwing oneself into the ground.

So in this case it pays to work out what is the absolute minimum of cuts that are necessary to separate the waste. If one takes the famous Franz Klaus tape, he works the top and bottom differently; uses endgrain, undercuts, and power cuts at different stages; leaves some waste removes other. Don't just look at some guy do something, if you like his results, replicate them in detail. The minimum of cuts and preferably no prying, and the edge will last a lot longer. The correct bevel for your chisel and your work so you get maximum penetration. Use enough force, hit it like you mean it. Chisels that hum less in the cut. And so forth.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#40

Re: Maybe Warren could add a few words...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In May 2011, Bill Tindal asked what chisel I would recommend. Derek Cohen then criticized my choice of 19th century English tools as not appropriate and unavailable. The next morning I went out and bought the present chisel for $15, having not bought a chisel for more than a decade. These chisels when new probably cost less than two hours wages for a journeyman. If such a chisel today would cost $200 or even $60, it is a real indictment for our present manufacturers.

I agree with David that care and experience are big factors. We often see people suggest that Japanese tools need special care and English tools do not; I don't see any evidence to support this notion. You want to baby your chisels no matter who made them.

I don't recommend electric grinders, hollow grinding, diamonds and or buffing wheels. I am not a fan of microbevels. A chisel in use is a wedge; deviations from a flat bevel disrupt the action. I finish my chisels on Arkansas stones and strop on clean leather. About 70 seconds altogether for sharpening.

I also hold the chisel by the handle when striking. If you hold the chisel by blade, or even if you have a short chisel, you have very little control of the angle of the chisel and it flops around. When the edge is buried in the cut, it is vulnerable when struck as if you were prying. It is worse if the chisel is hollow ground because the edge is more buried in the cut and it is more vulnerable because there is greater leverage.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#41

Re: the Relevant test

CStanford

Here you go:

http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_trksid=p5197.m570.l1313&_nkw=vintage+buck+brothers+chisels&_sacat=0&_from=R40

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#42

Actually ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

In May 2011, Bill Tindal asked what chisel I would recommend. Derek Cohen then criticized my choice of 19th century English tools as not appropriate and unavailable. The next morning I went out and bought the present chisel for $15, having not bought a chisel for more than a decade.

Warren, the context of this discussion was a series of chisel steel tests I was completing. You raised the need to include a vintage chisel in this modern gathering. My comment was that unless the steel was commonly available it was not helpful to forum members seeking to purchase a new chisel. You went out and purchased a chisel at a market to prove it was available. I responded by saying I (and others) could not necessarily do the same, and that this, therefore, did not prove anything.

That is by-the-by. There is an interesting - perhaps more than merely interesting - issue here ...

This other level is that we may wish to determine whether we are going forward or backward with toolmaking. The trouble is, if we decide that the steel in our new chisels is not as good as the steel in your old chisels, how are we going to convince toolmakers to mend their ways?

Regards from Mont Tremblant

Derek

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#43

Lots of 'em available... Look:

CStanford

http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_trksid=p5197.m570.l1313&_nkw=vintage+buck+brothers+chisels&_sacat=0&_from=R40

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#44

Re: Actually ... *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is Bill's question that I was responding to.

I think you are too focused on steel composition when there are many other factors like heat treating, forging, sharpening media, skill, technique, etc. I think the 18th century and early 19th century is important for chisels because of the great number of highly skilled artisans interacting with toolmakers.

The number of skilled artisans is much greater now than when I was starting out. We had the feeling 40 years ago that that if guys in 1770 could do it, we could too. That includes toolmaking. I think there is a demand for the tools that will allow us to work at high levels.


Traditional chisels

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#45

Re: Actually ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I think you are too focused on steel composition when there are many other factors like heat treating, forging, sharpening media, skill, technique, etc. I think the 18th century and early 19th century is important for chisels because of the great number of highly skilled artisans interacting with toolmakers.


Warren can you suggest how we go about assessing heat treating methods? We struggle to know what the steel is that we are discussing, never mind the complexities of achieving the ideal level of hardness for each, or how his is achieved. Forging? In the 21st century? Sharpening .... well I think that there are enough posts and methods already to fill a book. Each has a different rationale, and we can debate the appropriateness of these for years and years. I understand what you prefer here - no argument from me - but it is not ideal for all types of blades ... which is the issue, that is, that there are many types of steel being used these days, and how to understand each in the most relevant manner. Technique ... I assume that you refer to their use in woodworking. That is woodworking.

Regards from Mont Tremblant

Derek

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#46

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Howard Pollack

Sure. I mainly use a variety of Japanese chisels. The very best are those made by Kuneiki and one ebay mystery chisel. I've been fooling around trying to find a sharpening media that I really like (cuts fast and isn't messy) but haven't yet succeeded with that. But typically I sharpen on man made courser Japanese water-stones and a natural Japanese finish stone. -Howard