New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Posts

pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#1

pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Lars Parrington

where the application is bench chisels used mostly for chopping.

my impression is that a pmv-11 chisel would hold an edge considerably longer than a comparatively priced japanese chisel. i'm not too concerned about the ergonomic differences.

i'd appreciate all of you thoughts on the subject, mostly as a double-check before i go spending all my lunch money.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#2

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

david weaver

It might hold an edge longer, depending on what you're doing. The edge life between it and a good white steel bench chisel shouldn't be enough to favor one over the other solely on edge life.

I seriously doubt it would hold an edge longer than these:

http://www.330mate.com/product/193

If you could manage to navigate through the system and get yourself registered there (i managed it last year) - once you're registered, as long as you pay with paypal, the owner of the site (a notoriously cranky guy) has your address and can get them to you.

And they are about half the price of the LV chisels, but likely a little more difficult on the stones, just based on hardness alone.

Stu has another brand of them for english speakers.

At any rate, I think the LV steel is what they say it is, based on the iron that I got. I would venture to guess that they could turn the hardness up if they wanted to, but it would be at the expense of sharpenability if they did - don't know what the materiality of the effect on toughness would be.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#3

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

wilbur

This is the only direct comparison of PM-V11 to Japanese chisels that I know of. From Chris Gochnour's Fine Woodworking review (http://www.finewoodworking.com/tool-guide/product-finder/veritas-pm-v11-tool-steel.aspx):

"In the end, in terms of edge retention and performance, the PM-V11 chisel ranked second only to the high-end Japanese chisel, which is comparably priced."

Sounds like the two are comparable.

It should be noted that the Japanese chisel wasn't named, and that among Japanese chisels, some are better and some are worse.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#4

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

TomD

Well it said ranked second to high end chisels of comparable price. That does not sound like comparable on performance, only price. And comparably priced Japanese chisels are not all that far up the pole. Though most comparable Japanese chisels might not be comparable since the outfitting is generally better. One would need to rate blade prices one against the other.

It is sorta an unfair comparison since there are a lot of different Japanese chisels, there ought to be one that is better on most points than the LV, simply because whatever one is after there are enough option to cherry pick a match. While LV is trying to make one option that will seduce the average user shopping in that price range. A harder task.

Do we know what steel pmv-11 is yet? Is it Japanese steel given how much of the better cutlery steel is.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#5

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Rob Lee

Tom...

Please..... PM-V11 is an American made steel!!

Part of our selection criteria was a domestic product....

Cheers,

Rob

(Getting tired of the sound of the snow grooming machine outside.....)

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#6

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

my impression is that a pmv-11 chisel would hold an edge considerably longer than a comparatively priced japanese chisel. i'm not too concerned about the ergonomic differences.


Hi Lars

You cannot ignore the issue of ergonomics. The problem with your request is that you are comparing apples with oranges. Not only are you asking about steel, with this comparison you are forced to do so in the context of the design for which the steel was chosen.

Consider that a Japanese bench chisel, per se, is optimised for chopping. It has a short blade and a handle that is hooped to withstand repeated blows from a steel hammer (gennou). The blade will be bevelled at 30-35 degrees. The Japanese bench chisel is designed to be struck. Conversely, it is a pig to push. It is not designed to pare. Slicks are designed for paring. They have longer, uncapped handles and longer blades. They have blades with bevels at approx 25 degrees, which enter the wood more easily at this angle.

Japanese bench chisels are struck because this is how they optimise control. I have a very nice set of Koyamaichi dovetail chisels. Note that Japanese dovetail chisels are NOT the same as Western dovetail chisels. Mr Koyama made mine for me specially with minimal lands for chopping out dovetail waste. Japanese dovetail chisels are simply bench chisels with triangular sections. Most have sidewalls.

The Veritas bench chisel is pretty good at chopping, and has minimal lands and so excels in clearing out the waste of dovetails . It is equally pretty good at paring. It has a longer blade than a Japanese bench chisel, and a longer handle than many Western bench chisels. The PM-V11 steel will handle any bevel angle you add to it from 20 degrees upward, which is the stuff of vintage paring chisels. Essentially, however, it is not a specialist chisel - it is instead a very good all rounder.

The question you must answer is what you want to do with your chisel?

Regards from Mont Tremblant

Derek

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#7

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

TomD

Cool.

Sounds like a rich person's problem. The sound of snow grooming machines around here is normally some teenager.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#8

amen to those insights

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In my opinion, as much as I have been an advocate for modern steel, when it comes to a chisel for me ergonomics trumps the steel.

Personally I am unwilling to suffer the expense and maintenance of owning a different chisel for every application. The two Japanese chisels I have tried, both from Japan Woodworking and the cheapest of those offered, suffered two disadvantages for my style of work. While they are a delight to use in a striking position, being short and balanced to the bevel end, they are not comfy for paring. My needs for a chisel require both operations while preparing a drawer or case side.

Furthermore, I was having second thoughts as to whether I had missed something in my initial decision to eschew Japanese chisels and retried one for dovetailing a drawer. It was substantially thicker than the chisels I have been using and I found this thickness got in the way of the habits I had acquired with the thinner chisel. Nobody else seems to mind their thickness so this factor could be a unique concern only to thin chisel owners.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#9

Thin for paring, ...

jack curtis

I buy ultra thin Tasai's for paring, there is nothing to match them. I buy ultra thick tataki Tasai's for bashing timbers, mortise Tasai's for mortising, and a few Koyomaichi's for the same functions plus lots of vintage Japanese chisels just to try them out for carving and special joinery (most work amazingly well); and have no need for generalized bench chisels.

I don't dispute that you like it a different way, but I do dispute that everyone does.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#10

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Rob Lee

Hey...even tool magnates need a day off.... :D

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#11

Re: Thin for paring, ...

wilbur

On the flip side, I use my Japanese bench chisels for most tasks, except for mortising. I do have some Japanese paring chisels, but I find myself reaching for them for the lower bevel angle that I have them at, not so much for the ergonomics.

I find that if I have mushroomed the end of the chisel handle over so that the wood fibers cover the metal ring, there is not much discomfort in using a Japanese bench chisel for paring. The ring as it comes with the chisel does seem to have a big potential for not being friendly to the hand:


But after mushrooming the end, it's a lot nicer to use, and I find this to be pretty comfortable.


I'm not sure if Derek or Bill did that with their chisels or not. Still, chisel ergonomics is a very personal thing.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#12

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel *LINK*

Lars Parrington

lots of interesting responses here!! i must say though, that i had quite happily made up my mind before posting here. and now you scoundrels have shattered that ignorant bliss and and thrown me back into dire decision-making confusion. you should really be ashamed of yourselves ;-)

i suppose i had underestimated the power of japanese blacksmithing. i was assuming that while all of that hammering had made their white/blue steels better than our O1/A2 steels, it was still not stronger than our high speed and powdered metal steels. but now, what i'm hearing is that their white/blue steels of moderate quality will hold an edge better than any of our western steels.

i've also read elsewhere (and david has alluded to here) that the new japanese hss chisels will significantly outperform their white & blue steels, particularly if hitachi YXR7 is the hss used. of course, these hss chisels will be more difficult to sharpen, but i have been messing around with diamond paste and machined steel honing plates lately.

thus, i am finding the hss iroyoi's that david linked particularly tempting. i was aware of the hss chisels that stu carries, but not of these, which are ~1/3 of the cost. david, do you have personal experience with either of those chisels? there is also a set of hss japanese chisels available from tools for working wood, and i wonder if they are similar in quality (link below).

i was unaware of the fww review. thanks for posting that wilbur. i sent chris a quick email to see if he could provide any more info about that japanese chisel. he responded: "Unfortunately, I don't know the chisel brand. I acquire them 15 years ago second hand. I know they are not high speed steel but don't know if they are white or blue steel."

concerning ergonomics, it is, of course, an important consideration. however it is also a topic that has been beaten to death in other postings here as well as on other forums. it is also a thing i can get some sense of by just by looking at pictures. i don't know which ergonomic system i prefer yet, so i'm willing to try either at this point. especially since i expect my main use for these chisels will be chopping, mostly while making dovetails.


http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/dept/TBJ/item/MS-JACHYXR7.XX/Special_Alloyed_Laminated_Steel_Carpenters%27_Chisels

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#13

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As received from Japan Woodworker my Japanese bench chisel was not ideal for dovetail use. It is too fat and/or the sides not beveled right to get into the corners of the dovetail. Again, I am not into specialized chisels, especially when one will do what I need to do. No doubt there are Japanese chisels ideal for dovetailing. See my two reviews of the Lee Valley chisel posted sometime last fall. I found it ideal for my style of drawer making, equivalent or better than the chisels I custom made for the task.

From what I have observed one is either a Japanese tool enthusiast or not. Once that decision is made your choice will be easy, you will be passionately satisfied with it and you can get on with making stuff

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#14

PS.... LV chisel back order issue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A friend has spent months fretting over chisels- what to buy or make. I loaned him my LV PM chisel over Christmas holidays. He was smitten and promptly placed an order for a set. He was informed they would be delivered in March. He was crushed. Which reminds me he has not returned it!

Congratulations Lee Valley on a successful product launch. But if you need a chisel tomorrow the PM steel is not an option.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#15

Bottom line

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the amount of time you will spend sharpening what ever chisel you buy, even the "Blue Handles", will be trivial compared to the time to make and fit a drawer. Which, is why ergonomics is such an important factor in my mind.

Buy one of each and see what you subconsciousness reach for. This way of making a decision has left a good many tool on my shelf in preference for an alternative. I thought I preferred the weight of a 4 1/2 plane until I realized I was always grabbing the 5 when I wasn't thinking about it.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#16

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Schtoo

Lars,

The price of the ones Dave linked to and the ones at TFWW are priced cheaper than I can buy the Fujikawa ones.

I will find out exactly why tomorrow. I've told Dave before that something funny must be going on somewhere, and it's time I found out what it is.

Stu.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#17

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

TomD

Deserve a day off! If that is what it takes to keep the gold flowing!

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#18

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

david weaver

Drop the hammer!! You know where we'd like to buy them from, even if the best they can do is just to get closer.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#19

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

TomD

I bought some HSS Japanese chisels around 1980. They are great, and they work better than any western chisel I have ever tried. At the time they were something like 25 bucks for 3. At that time the LV chisels were 125 for 10, and about 25 bucks each for the set of longer LVs I bought, just to put the price in context. Nothing new, nothing much better.

Over time. I have tended to gravitate towards the Japanese chisels that were easier to sharpen, as they all hold an edge well, but that might just be me. My biggest set is god level blue steel, and they get less use due to being harder to sharpen. It isn't that they are too difficult, it is more like the experience just isn't there. But I hear you on the diamond.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#20

Re: PS.... LV chisel back order issue

Rob Lee

Hi,

Yes, the first lot sold out quickly, second is in house though...didn't realize we are quoting out to March though...will check that when I'm back in the office next week.

Good news is that Bailey repl plane blades are in process too, as well as additional plane blade styles.

Cheers,

Rob

( just back from dogsledding with DC.....)

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#21

Re: PS.... LV chisel back order issue

Phil Smith

Glad to hear you have the second batch of chisels in house, and that the chisels sold well. It was a little disappointing to place order and then learn they would not ship till March. I'll just use my home made 3V's until the new chisels arrive.

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#22

Re: PS.... LV chisel back order issue

Jerry Nicholson

I tried to order some Monday and got the "back ordered until March" message.

Jerry

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#23

Re: Thin for paring, ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wilbur

The hoops of my Japanese chisels are set the same way as yours. While they can be pushed, compared with a Western chisel such as a Stanley #750 or a Veritas, they are uncomfortable to push. They are designed to be struck, and it is that mode in which they become precision instruments.

Regards from Mont Tremblant

Derek

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#24

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

Howard Pollack

I have one of these chisels, it is a little (really just a little) tough to sharpen, but it almost never needs resharpening. It is a really fine chisel. -Howard

Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel

#25

Iyoroi HSS chisel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Lars, I have a HSS Japanese chisel that was sent to me by Stu. I do not know the maker.

Let me just say that this is the Mother of all chisels to sharpen. They are not designed for use in a shop, but on a work site being slammed through nails. I have to hollow grind them to stand a chance if getting a sharp edge (and even then they are tough stuff). That is some steel!

Regards from Mont Tremblant

Derek