Re: pmv-11 vs. japanese steel *LINK*
Lars Parrington
lots of interesting responses here!! i must say though, that i had quite happily made up my mind before posting here. and now you scoundrels have shattered that ignorant bliss and and thrown me back into dire decision-making confusion. you should really be ashamed of yourselves ;-)
i suppose i had underestimated the power of japanese blacksmithing. i was assuming that while all of that hammering had made their white/blue steels better than our O1/A2 steels, it was still not stronger than our high speed and powdered metal steels. but now, what i'm hearing is that their white/blue steels of moderate quality will hold an edge better than any of our western steels.
i've also read elsewhere (and david has alluded to here) that the new japanese hss chisels will significantly outperform their white & blue steels, particularly if hitachi YXR7 is the hss used. of course, these hss chisels will be more difficult to sharpen, but i have been messing around with diamond paste and machined steel honing plates lately.
thus, i am finding the hss iroyoi's that david linked particularly tempting. i was aware of the hss chisels that stu carries, but not of these, which are ~1/3 of the cost. david, do you have personal experience with either of those chisels? there is also a set of hss japanese chisels available from tools for working wood, and i wonder if they are similar in quality (link below).
i was unaware of the fww review. thanks for posting that wilbur. i sent chris a quick email to see if he could provide any more info about that japanese chisel. he responded: "Unfortunately, I don't know the chisel brand. I acquire them 15 years ago second hand. I know they are not high speed steel but don't know if they are white or blue steel."
concerning ergonomics, it is, of course, an important consideration. however it is also a topic that has been beaten to death in other postings here as well as on other forums. it is also a thing i can get some sense of by just by looking at pictures. i don't know which ergonomic system i prefer yet, so i'm willing to try either at this point. especially since i expect my main use for these chisels will be chopping, mostly while making dovetails.
http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/dept/TBJ/item/MS-JACHYXR7.XX/Special_Alloyed_Laminated_Steel_Carpenters%27_Chisels