New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Lumber dimensional defect definitions

Posts

Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#1

Lumber dimensional defect definitions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I find that "crook" is not commonly known and used to describe distorted boards. It is often incorrectly called bow. There definitions will help us communicate better, for example in the discussion earlier on straightening lumber.

Bow- a deviation in a direction perpendicular to the flat face, from a straight line from end to end of the piece.

Crook- a deviation in a direction perpendicular to the edge, from a straight line from end to end of the piece.

Cup- a distortion of a board in which there is a deviation flatwise from a straight line across the width of the board.

Twist- a distortion resulting from turning or winding of the edges of a board so that the four corners of any face are no longer in the same plane..

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#2

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

Sgian Dubh

*Crook is also known as "Edge Bend".

*Twist is aka as "In winding".

*And one you missed- "kink", a sharp deviation in the length along an edge, often caused by a large knot that intersects the edge leading to severe grain disruption and the stress that is a result of the stress causes the kink.

I suppose it should be mentioned that saying a board or plank is warped is a non-specific term that merely denotes the fact that the wood is distorted in some way, and it needs the definitions we've just provided to clearly identify in what form the warp has shown itself. Slainte.

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#3

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

Steve Elliott

A way to remember what "bow" describes is to think of an archery bow. When strung it has a curve like a bowed board.

I think I have an illustration that shows these conditions and will post it if I can find it.

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#4

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

Lars Parrington

if we're going to be comprehensive, we should mention that a cupped board might also be called crowned. on such a board, the crowned side is the convex side, and the cupped side is the concave side.

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#5

PS, blessed by NHLA

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the terms listed in the original post are the terms blessed by the National Hardwood Lumber Association (a US organization) to be used in the manufacture, grading and marketing of hardwood lumber.

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#6

so does crook bow like a bow

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The benefit of employing these terms is to avoid confusion. In you lumber straightening post I thought at first you were straightening cup, and then bow, only to eventually find out you were straightening crook.

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#7

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

As an apprentice patternmaker I learned the same terms that Bill posted for describing defects in a board. I think "crown" is a term used more by carpenters in how they utilize boards i.e. orienting the crown side of the cup up for deck boards or orienting the crown side of a bow up when setting rafters.

Robin

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#8

Re: so does crook bow like a bow

Steve Elliott

In my lumber straightening post I was describing a technique to use for removing either crook or bow. Usually I use it for both.

I confused the issue a little by referring to your post, Bill, which described removing cup but showed an image in which both cup and bow were being removed.

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#9

Bows and crooks for an arch

Bruce McCrory

I went to Hoadley, because, like spelling "tomorrow" (sp?) I never remember tangential vs flat-sawn (correct?). I was thinking I could build a cheat sheet, because Tindall's (NHA) crook and bow definitions still had me scratching my head. In an earlier discussion, I think Elliott posted two different straightening methods, for each condition, of bow and crook. I think?

Here's what I determined after a few minutes perusing Hoadley: Wood Definitions--

Wood is the basic resource for construction, craft and art globally. It therefore has almost an unlimited dictionary of names, duplication of names for different conditions, multiplicity of descriptive names for one condition; and terms for species, mechanical properties, figure, cut surfaces, color, defects of tree, defects of processing, moisture and drying reaction, and—to reduce this list, … (breathe) …—grain reaction, and milling conditions. Something critical has not been listed. Oh, terms vary between wood use specialties, industries, nationalities, and through the grind of historical evolution.

A list of definitions can usually be found in a technical book’s Glossary, or Appendices, or Index; and, usually in simplified graphic figures and photographs. So I cancelled my cheat sheet. Thankfully.

As some have noted, particular associations, and councils for hardwood and softwood industries define their own terms. There are numerous associations. Think of how many ways a tree can be processed, from lumber to veneer to sawdust to chemical byproducts, and you have a short list of “definers” and specifiers. But not all. Yada, yada, ya...

Finally, to clarify in my mind, from Hoadley--

"Bow- A form of warp; deviation from lengthwise flatness in a board.

"Crook- A form of warp; a deviation from end-to-end straightness along the edge of a board."

So, my take on this is that for an arched wall opening, a bow is best for the head trim, and a crook best for surrounding trim. Right? Or, is a crook in a beam better for the header? Anyone for futtocks?

Unfortunately, the only example I found in "Understanding Wood" called the warp both crook and bow. I [wood] think based on a similar curve in a road, that the specific definition was crook. Carrying the road analogy further, a dip, or hill, [wood] equate to bow.

This is so much fun....

Right?

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#10

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

Mark Hennebury

I agree with Bills, except when applied to crooks, I see crooks everywhere, most show up in my inbox offering to share millions of dollars with me each week. :D

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#11

And cups ...

Bruce McCrory

... will work great for cylinders; or water pipe, only in opposition to natural curvature, you know ... to seal the seam tighter. I think?

"Water" reminds me .... I am only here to avoid thinking about the flood we had in the house yesterday. My first insurance claim in about 30 years; the only claim. Is that moisture reaction?

Ciao,

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#12

You`re lucky

Bob Hackett

Around here they walk right up to your house, knock on the door, offer to shake your hand and then ask you to vote for them. :D

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#13

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

TomD

Maybe crown is the beneficial instance of a longi arch, one that one can take advantage of, and crook the the samish thing, but describing geometry that needs to be removed.

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#14

Crook was Something nixon claimed he wasn't


Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

#15

Re: Lumber dimensional defect definitions

Larry Barrett

Bruce Hoadley, in Understanding Wood, uses the same definitions (see page 80) and has drawings and pictures to illustrate.