New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Long and likely controversial query

Posts

Long and likely controversial query

#1

Long and likely controversial query

Ron Harper

I am very much aware that this wonderful site is regularly used by a very broad spectrum of interests. They go from the folks who think hand tools are very cool and want more of same and on occasion will use one for its intended purpose to the folks who want to build and possibly design beautiful pieces of furniture or other useful wooden objects and very strongly prefer to use hand tools to do that. There are several gradations between these positions. Let me affirm right now that they are all valid, wholesome, etc.

I like to make things and strongly prefer to use hand tools, for my own reasons which may make no sense at all to some of you. I understand that very well. But for those of you who veer toward my spot on the continuum, I would like a little discussion. I know full well that i have all the tools that I every could say that I need to build anything that I am likely to ever be able to build. I actually have too many. I know to some that is an heretical confession. It is true. I have owned some planes for 15 years or more that I have never used. Same with chisels etc.

I have been watching Paul Sellers make some very nice stuff with very few tools. Any of the rest of you wrestling with this. Should I continue to build tool storage for tools that I don't use? I believe I could work out of a chest with the possible exception of saws.

Schwarz is by no means the first to decide that you should be able to put all you need in a tool chest. Tony Konovaloff has been doing it for more than 15 years. I suspect that there are some folks on this site that had ATCs before it was cool.

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#2

Re: Long and likely controversial query

Curt Putnam

At this stage of my development (or lack thereof) I like tools for their own sake sufficiently that I do not want to work out of a chest. That said, I don't go wild buying tools either. Chisels are a possible exception.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#3

Re: Long and likely controversial query

TomD

So Ron Harper = Ron at Kokamo?

Well I am not sure what the lead in was for, but I have a lot of tools I bought for some dumb reasons; or bought and did not return when I found out I did not like them; Or I started with Japanese tools, and then thought I would like to be equally familiar with German, Chinese, or English tools.

My basic approach other than the fact I am not an orderly person, is to display all my chisels in fitted, or open racks. I am not much of a saw collector, so I have a pretty sensible collection and rackage there. My planes are out of this world, but I just built minimal working storage and rotate whatever users I have from storage to the racks. I need better racks at the moment, I have three types. Dowels, japanese, where the planes are vertical, and under the bench.

So overall, the fact I have too many tools does not really affect the me that works. My near the bench storage is pretty much the same as if I did not have excess tools.

I can see your question, it is a good one. It stems in my mind from non-reality. I enjoy reading the stuff from people recreating the old patterns, we have a lot to learn. One of my favourite books is The Village Carpenter by Walter Rose, since unlike Roubo, or Schwatz he was actually in that life.

In that life people had a minimal selection of tools, and they were displayed in tightly fitted cases, like the famous poster, or other minimal systems like the locker. This worked for them because in a range from consummate pros, to people who cared the minimum about their tools, there was little reason to have anything other than the essential tool kit. Molding planes were probably more open ended in some shops. But a worker at that time was A) not a hobbyist, though there were those also; B) he did limited tasks, or he was a generalist with a limited kit; C) the tools of the day were "for real", compared to my career where no pro grade tools were available for the first 15 or so years. I wrote a letter to Leonard Lee at one point and thanked him for the catalog, but said from the three main groups of tools they did not sell a single pro grade offering. A problem we no longer have. Even though we have good tools, we now have an excess, and few guys who hang around, let alone to the extent of a few thousand posts here, are never going to pick up something different, or better. Never buy another thing off ebay, or the latest tool from LN, or LV. The single most popular posts here are the tool reviews, in porn form often, with great pics etc... So how does one stuff that into fixed storage?

So my sumary comment is, these problems arise from trying to stuff the modern world into the old world. It doesn't work. There will be a few who will replicate the old world, but even then I want to search the recesses of their shops... While I don't have a fake façade of organized tools, it amounts to the same for different reasons. I could be that guy with the great pictures, but I would still have 70 more planes somewhere else.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#4

Re: Long and likely controversial query

roger lance

Ron....I'm probably on the wrong side of the continuum for your question but I continue to buy hand tools and take advantage of LV's free shipping which I've done again this time. I'm now replacing some older hand tools which were purchased years ago with better quality tools....so I'm now, for the first time, faced with the prospect of selling tools that I'm replacing as I want to have tools I use as opposed to tools I've collected. My shop is limited in size and I'm an everything has a place type so in addition to asking the question about a potential purchase....will I use it ?? (which is akin to do I need it or do I just want it ??).....I also have to ask....do I have a proper place to store it ?? This even includes jigs which I have a propensity to make.....there must be a proper storage spot or its a no go. Also, with jigs and other equipment, if I'm not using it....maybe its time to lose it. I've given away old jigs to younger guys who might get some use from them. In short, there is a limitation on the herd....it must be in use.....and I don't need multiple ways of doing something.....pick a way of working and the tools that are required to do that job and stick with that approach until absolutely certain that another way is better.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#5

Re: Long and likely controversial query

TomD

I wish I thought that way properly managed space and organization are the things I am in need of most. I have enough room in the usual sense. I have about 80 x14, not the best shape, and a storage shed, and a basement.

I don't mind selling stuff. I don't mind taking a bath on it. Let's say I spent 100, and I get 20, if i wasn't using it, and it was adding to the general disorder, then It isn't a loss to me. What worries me is that if I sell my mint LN plane, next week I will read an article by X and find it is just the thing I need. That happens over an over. I am putting it in it's worst light, I might actually need the thing gotten rid of. But if I keep it, it is killing me also. I am not willing to drop capabilities, and I tell myself that is where I get caught. I could reduce, but only at the cost, at some point, of loosing capabilities.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#6

What is the controversy?

Bruce McCrory

You have no controversy, according to Rob and Tom... [Free Shipping!]

What drives me nuts is that I need to replace my power equipment, and I can't afford to buy any of the replacements. Actually, the problem is: It breaks so easily, now. Maybe, it's because of junky, cheap imported electricity ....

I, of course, have my own opinions about tool storage. The idea of a "chest" is about as appealing as its much handier cousin ... Cardboard Box. Having used cardboard and other things so long, a machinist's tool box (read, pull out drawers, not tills) is the only way I will go. You can always calculate volumes to match scale for your limit of tools.

Besides, horizontal surfaces are always covered, like any shelf, or warehouse.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#7

James Pickering

Re: Long and likely controversial query

James Pickering

I have maintained, and used, the same basic tool kit make-up from my time as a truck cab and body building apprentice in the immediate post WWII years up until now (semi-retired wood worker). Please go Here for pics. Of course, I find some vintage tools irresistible - North Bros. 2100 bit braces & 1530 hand drills, Millers Falls No 2 hand drills for instance - and I keep a few of those around to fondle.

James

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#8

Thanks

Ron Harper

Some helpful responses. Tom. I am not talking about capability. I guess in theory maybe I am, but, if I have not used it in 25 years, it can't be much of an issue.

As I have posted before, I do not relish the thought of working from a chest. I think the answer may be to design racks for what a chest would hold ( except for saws of course) and use Roger's mantra "will I use this?" Before I bring anything else home.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#9

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Long and likely controversial query

#10

Re: Why I don't want a toolchest at this stage of

Bob Hackett

Why I do believe I just herd a bit of Jethro Tull in the background there for a moment.

"Life`s a long song,

But the tune ends too soon for us all".

Well said David.

"If I dasn`t haz ta locks `em then I dasn`t has ta box `em", is my motto.

I don`t believe I`ll ever need a bigger box than my shop and the door locks real well on that come the end of the day if I ever feel the need to do it.

One of the joys of living in Maine is that for the 15 years we`ve lived in this house we have never had to lock any of our doors when we go out. We leave the keys in the ignition of all our cars while they`re in the driveway too.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#11

Re: Thanks

TomD

My comment about capability was an OT comment. What I was alluding to was that part of my disorder in innate, and the other part is that I can make everything from a saddle to a milling machine in my shop. You try to jam that much capability into a shop, and orderliness is not going to help with freeing up space. If I was orderly I would just add anodizing, or something.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#12

What did you say was the address?


Re: Long and likely controversial query

#13

Re: What did you say was the address?

Bob Hackett

I`ll gladly give you the address. Good luck finding the house without calling us to come get you.

If you do by some chance find the house on your own good luck getting past both our two wolf hybrid companions as well as all the neighbor dogs above that they are good friends with. It`s a long dead end right of way we live on that borders a river and we live on the very end of it.

Another thing I love about Maine is neighbors still look out for each other up here. You won`t make it thru the first winter unless you do just that. :)

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#14

Re: Thanks

Ron Harper

I am guessing that I am older than you. I probably will die before I get to be as good at making furniture as I would like to be. I would like a small forge, but I decided no. I would like to do some stained glass particularly since Kokomo Opalescent glass is here. I decided no. I will support and admire the work of those who do those things. I will focus on furniture and gardening.. With some cookin thrown in.

Ron

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#15

Re: Long and likely controversial query

CStanford

I can say without any reservations whatsoever that you should get rid of anything that hasn't been used in your 15 years of ownership.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#16

Agree

Ron Harper

Gonna do it

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#17

Re: Yeah well... "rationality, priceless"   


Re: Long and likely controversial query

#18

Re: Long and likely controversial query

TomD

I have a daughter like that, thanks for the tip!

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#19

Jack Guzman from Maine

same here


Re: Long and likely controversial query

#20

Re: Long and likely controversial query

Patrick Gibbons

I started selling off tools that are redundant last summer. I had a Record fillester plane I sold because I had purchased a Veritas left-handed model. Of course I could have used the right-handed Record just two weeks ago, but still I think it was a good decision to sell it. Just last night I ran into some stuff in the shop that was not in optimal condition due to lack of use. It needs to go away to someone who will utilize it.

On the subject of tool chests; I started making one about three years ago out of 1" yellow pine. Somehow I transferred the pins from the wrong side of the board thus ruining the whole side. I then decided the yellow pine was too heavy and cutting dovetails in yellow pine is tough because of the stringyness of the wood. I'm still going to make one. This year I hope. I would tell you to build it. If it doesn't work for you, then bring it into the house for furniture or sell it or give it to someone else. Just like the unnecessary tools, what came into the shop can leave the shop.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#21

Oh I intend to build at least one

Ron Harper

Probably not for tools though. I have two grown step- daughters.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#22

Re: Long and likely controversial query

Hank Knight

Ron,

Why are you asking this question? What is it about your current circumstances that is troubling you? Is it that you think you should be achieving some standard or ideal articulated by others (Schwartz, et al.)? Or do you really think you would be happier if you trimmed your tool kit to fit in a box? If the latter, then go for it. If the former, then my advice is to take a deep breath, figure out what makes you happy, stick with that and relax.

I have tools I don't use or haven't used in years. From time to time I think about getting rid of them. They take up space I could probably use, but I've managed without a lot of inconvenience. I could probably sell some of them. The money would be nice to have, but I don't really need it. The fact is that I like having them, and I don't feel any moral imperative to get rid of them. My lust for tools has calmed down over the years, but I still buy an occasional tool because either I need it or I just want it. I have absolutely no feelings of guilt about buying a tool because I want it.

Woodworkng is my hobby. I do it because it makes me happy. Perhaps it's selfish, but I organize and run my shop in the way(s) that make me happy. I admire Chris Schwartz and James Krenov and Roy Underhill and Adam Cherubini and all the others. I strive to improve my skills so I can build excellent pieces as they do, and I've learned a lot from them. If their methods suit me I try to emulate them, but I don't see their personal style of work as some kind of objective standard I should seek to achieve. If it suits Chris Schwartz to work out of a tool chest, that's fine. It doesn't suit me. I prefer to have my tools on shelves, in drawers and hanging on the wall. I don't feel any need to pare down my tool collection to fit in a box. If I did, I would do it, but I don't. I'm happy with the tools I have and the way I've organized my shop.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#23

Re: Long and likely controversial query

Ron Harper

Hank,

I am in the midst of a shop relocation, as well as a change to working primarily with hand tools. Thus prompting some re examination.

Ron

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#24

One more thing

Ron Harper

I am not much of a conformist. As my wife :).

If i am going to have to build a new storage system to hold my tools, it makes sense to ask some questions. For example, 15 years ago I bought a 55. I have only looked at it twice since then. I listed in on the bay yesterday. I will soon sell some chisels and will probably give away a bunch of block planes.

Re: Long and likely controversial query

#25

Re: One more thing

Hank Knight

Building a new shop would be fun and it would probably cause me to do some soul searching too. I've been in the same place for many years and I've gotten comfortable here. That probably prompted my reply more than anything else. I didn't mean to imply that you were a conformist. I've just seen too many posts from people who appear to be following the crowd rather than their own muse.

BTW, I have a 45 I've had for 15 years and never used. One of thse days I'm going to pull it out and see what it will do. ;)