New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Planing across the grain?

Posts

Re: Planing across the grain?

#26

Re: Plano Rack?

William Duffield

Of course it will handle a few wide boards. I was commenting on Plano's ad copy, wherein the accurately point out that it is particularly advantageous for gluing up lots of narrow boards. Getting a couple of boards aligned into a panel manually is a whole lot less of a challenge than a complicated glue up of several boards.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#27

Re: Plano Rack?

William Duffield

It depends on the piece. But who said anything about figured? If the piece allows it, I might even use plywood, especially if it won't be seen. But I have a small shop, and don't build large case pieces any more.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#28

Re: They work well with wide boards too...

William Duffield

If I were building large pieces, I would look into them, but I can't afford the permanent vertical real estate in my shop right now. I can certainly appreciate the disadvantages of handling my bar clamps, which currently hang from the loft railings and floor joists, instead of racks on the walls where they would be easier to access and safer. I spent five hours Christmas evening in the ER, getting staples in my scalp, where I managed to drop two K-bodies I dislodged from their perch while reaching for two more next to them. Something else is going to have to move to a less efficient location to make room for the clamp racks.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#29

Re: They work well with wide boards too...

CStanford

It's usually the horizontal real estate at a premium in most shops. Unless one can figure out a way to make something permanently levitate, horizontal space implies contact with the floor hence the reasoning behind a wall-mounted clamping system (woodworkers rarely walk on the walls, mount tablesaws, bandsaws, workbenches, etc. on walls).

I knew a guy who did kitchen cabs and other built-ins out of a two car garage. He had Plano racks on three walls (one wall was obviously all garage door). He said he could glue up every panel he'd need for four kitchen jobs at a time and still have room for whatever he was doing for his furniture 'hobby.'

Everything else in the shop was on wheels except for his workbench.

He sat down and figure out the panel glueups were killing him on time and organization as well as storage until he was ready for them. He killed a bunch of birds with one stone.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#30

Ouch!

John in NM

Not a great way to spend any evening, let alone Christmas!

Reminds me a little of lifting a ladder off a wall rack, and somehow never noticing the 4x4 my dad had put in front of the ladder. Darn thing rolled right down my arms and whacked me in the nose :D

Re: Planing across the grain?

#31

Re: Plano Rack?

CStanford

You asked what Plano racks were. Now you know. Let's leave it at that.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#32

Good grief!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

That description is sufficient to discourage most from woodworking, and that is my motivation to challenge this standard to making a top.

If your top is set on a surface that is not flat it may distort to the surface somewhat, so planing it flat wont do any good because as soon as you move it, it will move."

Tops are going to "distort" to the frame or cabinet they are fastened to, perhaps enhanced by the floor that is underneath. If the top can be pulled to its frame or cabinet and it is the same thickness around the edges, judged by eye, that's good enough.

All this flatness fretting is seldom justified except as an exercise in personal satisfaction in what can be accomplished by someone sufficiently motivated and skilled. On lookers should not be confused by this fact. If you can do it I am impressed but I wouldn't suggest it as a standard to strive to for most.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#33

Re: Good grief!

hennebury

Hi Bill,

I am big on the fundamentals; Flat, straight, square, parallel.. "Flat" being one of my favorites.

If i were still teaching, flat would be one of the first concepts you would thoroughly learn.

No better way than to plane a large table top.

I am just saying if you want a "flat" surface you need understand what you are looking for, and what affects you reaching your goal. Flat is a concept that you will need and use constantly throughout your woodworking life, from plane soles to jointer tables to dining table tops, frames and bases.

I am not suggesting anybody do this all the time, but it is certainly worth going through the process to understand and appreciate "flat"

"Do the tough stuff first"

Once you have pushed yourself to some limit once or twice, "just because" doing a little less is quite easy going, but you then have the knowledge and experience and can choose to what level you need to do each job.

How flat does a table top need to be? as long as your food doesn't slide off, i guess that's good enough.

If you don't understand the basics from the get-go, you will always struggle and not know why you are having problems and get more frustrated, and are more likely to give up, in my opinion.

Personally i upgraded very quickly from my 6" delta jointer to a 24" jointer and a 24" thicknesser and did glue-ups in sections, therefore minimizing the amount of hand-planing required.

it is quite a pleasant (albeit hard) exercise to handplane a tabletop flat, and a very important one.

I am just offering my point of view to the collective.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#34

thanks for the clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We approach teaching differently, in fact polar opposites. I would become frustrated in your class and likely quit. But I do not deny your approach has merit and might be "good for me". Our differences are fine with me so long as the "students" know where we are coming from.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#35

Re: thanks for the clarification

hennebury

Yes, we seem to be at opposite ends on the teaching/learning process, but that's good, it gives us all something to think about which is the most important part.

I think that if i took one of your classes, you would probably boot me out; I would drive you insane asking you questions about why and how for everything that you said to do.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#36

Re: thanks for the clarification

hennebury

I should mention that in my old shop i had a 48" x 72" cast iron Surface plate with 8" thick web skirt. mounted on a cast iron base. A hand scraped lab standard reference surface that i purchased from the Canadian Nation Research Center. weighing in at about 2500Lbs.

I called the lab to confirm my assumption that accurate tension-free set-up should be by applying equal torque to the leveling screws on each of the four corners, and was told by the technician that he "didn't know and had never really thought about it"

Re: Planing across the grain?

#37

Nope!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....you would drive the classmates that lacked curiosity insane. I do teach and lecture, and I am so smitten by those that want to know the why and how that I get distracted immersed in the answers. Classes invariably last twice as long or I never finish if the class has set time. But that is when I am in teaching mode. When I am in get the product out the door mode, its achieving "good enough" and be done with it. "All's well that ends".

Re: Planing across the grain?

#38

I am with Bill on this one

Ron Harper

I have admiration for those who can get a 4 ft by 6 ft table flat to within a thousandth, though I do not understand the compulsion to do so. It will certainly not remain that way.

I am a guy who will put raised panels on the back of his cabinets because someone may turn them around, so I am certainly not an advocate of sloppy work. I just feel that we have gone overboard in pursuing accuracy to tolerances that make little sense in a medium that moves in an uncertain manner after we are done with it.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#39

Re: Nope!

hennebury

The curious make it fun, and i always looked forward to teaching.

You seem to have found a good balance; I never really managed the "good enough" part, had i done so I would have been far better off in many ways. That may sound arrogant, but really it had more to do with insecurity than arrogance. Always trying to do more or better than needed is more a vice than a virtue.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#40

Re: I am with Bill on this one

cstanford

There are a couple good arguments for not processing lumber to machine shop tolerances. The fact that the wood will move after the project is assembled is not one of them. I'm not sure who is responsible for giving this canard credence but they should be strung up by their thumbs.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#41

Do you mean to say...

Bob Hackett

That the wood stops moving once the project is assembled?

I think we all know better than that.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#42

Joking right?

Ron Harper

You surely are not telling us that you don't believe that wood moves in furniture.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#43

What he is saying...

John in NM

Is that wood does move in use after assembly, but that alone is not a sufficient reason to aim for less than machine shop tolerances. The rationale behind this and the real reasons to work to less than machine shop tolerances are left to our speculation, and aren't really of much interest in any case :D

Re: Planing across the grain?

#44

Re: Do you mean to say...

cstanford

Nope. Not saying that at all. I'm just saying how much it moves after assembly has nothing to do (or should do) with the craftsman's decision on tolerances during the build. And I'm not talking about allowing for wood movement by certain construction strategies (floating panels, etc.) either.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#45

Re: Do you mean to say...

cstanford

You're in control of the overall level of crispness and fit of your own build, writing off sloppy fit and ill-proportioned work under the theory that the wood will move within a level of tolerance is what I'm talking about.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#46

Want to work to machine shop tolerances?

Bob Hackett

Then start working metal instead of wood. Two different animals with different characteristics and tolerances. One will swell and move in reaction to moisture and the other will corrode.

BTW- there are appropriate and inappropriate tolerances for just about every machine shop job and they are spelled out on the blueprints/drawings. Deviate from those tolerance and the part will be rejected. Try fitting a forged aluminum piston into a cylinder with the same clearance as a cast piston and see what happens. Same alloy material worked in different ways and pressed to work in different environments many times require completely different tolerances.

There is no single sweeping standard for "machine shop tolerances". Someone who refers to "machine shop tolerances" without quoting those tolerances from a blueprint that applies to a specific job is talking thru their hat and assumes that their audience is as in the dark about such matters as they apparently are.

Stepping down from the soap box now. :)

Re: Planing across the grain?

#47

What I did

Clementine

Rather than work the entire table top across the grain I was selective in planing a few places, a couple fairly large and some smaller. I used a 5 and 6 across the grain, went diagonal with a 7, and finished with a 4. I tried to get the plane irons as sharp as I could, but there were a few issues with tear out, so I sanded the entire top with 80 and 120 grits with a 3"x21" belt sander. I worked a few spots by hand with sandpaper and then went over the whole thing with a quarter sheet 220 sander.

The wood is used pine 2x12s from a water bed frame and a wheelchair ramp (neither needed any longer!), so I will never get it to machine quality. It is smooth, and I think flat enough to keep a book or a bowl of chili from sliding off onto my lap. It's for the wife, and she will keep it in the back of the house. Since we don't get much company way out here, that will cut down on personal embarassment.

Pretty thorough discussion and lots of solid advice for future efforts. Like Socrates once said, I am grateful to everyone I learn from.

Cheers

Re: Planing across the grain?

#48

Oh, I agree...

John in NM

I was simply parsing syntax as a community service :D