New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Planing across the grain?

Posts

Planing across the grain?

#1

Planing across the grain?

Clementine

Is it OK to hand plane a table top cross grain to flatten it? It seems that doing this would violate all the rules about planing in the direction of the grain. I just completed the glue up on a Stickley top 3’ x 6’, and it looks pretty good (for me), but it could use some flattening. Which plane would I need and is there anything special I need to be aware of?

This link is where I saw it done:

Hand-planing a table top with Timothy Clark Cabinetmaker / Chairwright

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Xae7ZSupWo

Re: Planing across the grain?

#2

I do it all the time...

John in NM

When rough flattening a surface, I often plane diagonally or sometimes directly across the grain, depending on where the high/lows are. I typically use a scrub plane if there's lots of hogging, or a jack with a radiused blade for intermediate flattening. The only thing to worry about is that you don't plane in a direction that induces nasty tear outs, any normal roughness from cross planing will come out when you smooth anyway.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#3

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Planing across the grain?

#4

Re: Planing across the grain?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

What the others said--it's standard procedure.

Only thing you have to watch is how close you are to final width of the top. Depending on a few things--how deep a plane cut you're taking, the exact lay and runout of the grain, for example--it's possible to tear good-sized splinters off the far edge as the plane exits the cut. If you've got a 1/4" to spare on the sides, this is not a big issue, and as a matter of technique just keep downward pressure on the heel of the plane as it exits the cut. This keeps you from taking a heavier shaving from the edge than from the interior.

If you're close to final dimension, the safe thing to do to protect the edge is to not allow the plane to exit the cut at the far side at depth, but rather make all edge cuts from the outside-in, and bring the plane out of the cut before it exits the far side.

Wiley.....a little more wordy than intended

Re: Planing across the grain?

#5

Re: Planing across the grain?

jack curtis

This is a great technique, especially if you're getting a lot of tearout when planing with the grain. As Wiley said, try to avoid spelching, but that's pretty easy to do. Also, be sure and sharpen your plane blade(s).

I typically use a LN LA jack and/or C&W jack for basic leveling, a H&T and/or Mosaku try plane, then a C&W 30" jointer for the finishing touches. This set would be for a very large surface, smaller ones seem to need many fewer planes to address properly.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#6

Re: Planing across the grain?

Sgian Dubh

As others have said, it's a common technique, especially when flatteing large panels such as table tops. But there are other times when planing across the grain is often the best approach. For instance, fiddleback figure as exemplified in ripple ash and, of course, fiddleback sycamore, are just two examples where cross-grain planing is appropriate. In this case, the main reason it works well is that planing with the grain means you are regularly planing into short grain which lifts out leaving divots. Planing across the grain, with a sharp plane it has to be said, frequently reduces the creation of the divots. Slainte.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#7

Ellis Walentine

What they said, and... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

...here's an article I wrote 20 years ago on the subject, when I was 20 lbs lighter and had black hair. Tempus fugit, but time-honored techniques don't.

Ellis


Flattening a Bench Top

Re: Planing across the grain?

#9

Re: Across and diagonally - then with the grain

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This method of planing across over the whole board, then diagonally both ways, then with the grain is really, really inefficient. If there is one low corner to the surface, you could end up planing it when you plane cross grain, again when you plane diagonally, and then a third time, when it fact it needs little material removed.

Instead, do what Nicholson suggested in 1812 and what Ellis suggested in 1993 and use a straight edge and winding sticks to determine the high spots. Then plane only the high spots until the board is close to flat with the jack plane and then clean up with a trying plane. I usually only plane cross grain in places where there is more than 1/16 of material to remove. And I only plane diagonally when I am removing wind, and then only in one diagonal direction, the one that will reduce the wind.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#10

Practical

Ron Harper

It has been said in different way above, but I would assume that when you glued up a top of that dimension, you were very close to your intended thickness, if not at it. Why would you remove more wood than you absolutely had to. Let your straightedge be your guide. I will assume that you are not in wind. Even if you are, my question is valid, and you plane only what you need to to get flat.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#11

Not always appropriate.


Re: Planing across the grain?

#12

Please explain.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My recommendation to chamfer the far edge was in the context of planing across the grain and across the whole board.

There are other methods one can follow to flatten a top, such as removing high spots. Howover, if one is planing across the full width of a board - as was the method to which I responded then, as I understand and how I work, chamfering is needed to avoid spelching.

What did you have in mind?

Regards from Manhattan

Derek

Re: Planing across the grain?

#13

Re: Plane very carefully ...

Bruce McCrory

... Very carefully and sparingly. Most of the remarks so far are directed toward a surface that is probably 2 inches from the bottom, and has been beaten to a pulp; a workbench by another name.

I would follow the basic rules for preparing a board. Give the corners some chamfer consistent with Stickley, to avoid tooth pick spelch. Extremely sharp irons, minimal arc on the edge; and really choke up on the back-iron. Catch only harsh flaws--with a completed piece you can't go very far, pretty much cosmetic at this point. Joint and burnish the scrapers. I would play with scrapers more than a plane. Unless you have 50 to 60-degree bevels to prevent tear out in planes.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#14

Re: Please explain.

jack curtis

Sometimes a chamfered edge wrecks the appearance/style of the piece. I don't disagree on the effect for planing, which is good; but often it makes more sense to plane in from the edges rather than chamfer, particularly at that stage of construction.

PS If you're still in NY and missing home, Hulu is showing the first two seasons of the Australian version of Wilfred. What a difference between it and the comparatively wimpy US version. Aussie Wilfred is downright threatening, same actor though.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#15

Re: Please explain.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)



Sometimes a chamfered edge wrecks the appearance/style of the piece. I don't disagree on the effect for planing, which is good; but often it makes more sense to plane in from the edges rather than chamfer, particularly at that stage of construction.

Hi Jack

I can see what you mean. However, the amount one chamfers is so slight that it is planed away. It is not always convenient to rotate a board/panel in order to plane in from opposing edges.

Regards from Perth .... Manhattan

Derek

Re: Planing across the grain?

#16

Re: Please explain.

jack curtis

Yeah, well sometimes the chamfer can be that small, sometimes it has to be much larger to have the effect you're after, depends on the wood, plane, and planer.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#17

Re: Please explain.

CStanford

Absolutely true. All it takes is a little grain runout at the edge to render a shallow chamfer useless for preventing spelching. It's better than nothing though.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#18

Re: Practical

CStanford

Wow, I'd be scared to death to glue up a top that size that was at or even very close to finished thickness. And I'd be using Plano racks too.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#19

Re: Plano Rack?

William Duffield

Again, Google doesn't help me with this one. It is suggesting a storage system for fishing tackle.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#21

Re: Plano Rack?

William Duffield

Thanks, Richard, for the explanation. Somehow, I was thinking about the planing operation, not the gluing up operation. I never worked in the type of shop environment where something like that would have made sense. Where I worked, and for what I build now, aesthetics always required the fewest, widest boards possible, and the closest possible matching of figure across glue lines. Time and material costs saved by using lots of narrow boards just isn't really important to me.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#22

Re: Plano Rack?

CStanford

Why on Earth would you assume the system won't handle a few, wide boards?

Re: Planing across the grain?

#23

Re: Plano Rack?

CStanford

What about solid wood dividers in case pieces? You using wide, figured stuff there too?

Re: Planing across the grain?

#24

They work well with wide boards too...

John in NM

The big advantage of Plano's is saving time handling lots of bar clamps, it really is a great system, they really are quick and easy. Since they require installation along a wall or similar, they have their own dedicated space and gluing up a couple big tops doesn't use up all your usual bench space.

Re: Planing across the grain?

#25

Re: Planing across the grain?

hennebury

Before planing, you need to have a good understanding of the concept of flat and the importance a good reference surface for setting your top on. Plus the flexibility and stresses on the wood when gluing large tops.

To check for flat you need a reference straight edge long enough to reach diagonally across your table top.

To check a surface for flat i use 5 points and 6 lines and the straight edge.

The five points are the four corners of you table top and the middle.

The six lines are the four lines that make the perimeter of the table and the two across the diagonals.

To check for wind, warp, or twist, place the straight edge across the diagonals one way then the other, this will tell you how the corners sit in relation to the center, from this you can determine what has to be planed and what does not.

When the straight edge touches the corners and the center point in both diagonals your table is not warped or twisted and you have a flat reference. you can then use the straightedge to check as you plane, length-wise, and diagonally to bring everything into a flat plane.

Consider the thickness and flexibility of your top; Large tops out of thin lumber can flex a lot.

A freshly glued up surface can shrink around the glue joints as a water based glue slowly dries and the moisture equalizes. So pressure from clamping and moisture can distort your top gradually, So wait to finish planing at least a few days or more if you can, the longer the better.

If your top is set on a surface that is not flat it may distort to the surface somewhat, so planing it flat wont do any good because as soon as you move it, it will move.

So lets say that you have a large perfectly flat workbench, as large as your table top.

You put your newly glued up top on the bench and notice the it wobbles, its warped cupped twisted etc.

So the first thing is to support your table top. place a few wedges between the top and the bench to support and stabilize the top.

From this point you can now proceed to flatten the top of your table.

Chamfer the edges, then with the largest plane that you have plane across, then diagonal one way then diagonal the other the finish up with the grain. then switch to a smoothing plane long grain to finish.

Now that you have one surface flat you can, with a marking gauge referenced on the now flat surface, scribe the thickness (say 1-3/4" or whatever) all around the edge. Flip the table over and resting the now flat surface on your flat workbench, plane down to the scribe line. You now have a top that has flat and parallel surfaces.

First of all when doing up large tops try to get them as accurate as possible from the start;

Joint and thickness plane oversize.

Edge joint and handplane the edges to an accurate fit. This will reduce the amount of clamping pressure required to hold the boards together while gluing.

Glue large multi-piece tops up in sections.

Get properly prepared for glue up, so that there is no panic and struggling.

If you have a large jointer and thicknesser:

Glue up in sections; a four-board table top of say four 10" boards would be glued up "two and two" then re-jointed and re-thicknessed.

Mark