New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

The ultimate sharpening device

Posts

The ultimate sharpening device

#1

Clint Searl

The ultimate sharpening device

Clint Searl

The many threads on sharpening, burrs, wire edges, stones, etc. suggest that some real help is needed in that endeavor. To that end, I submit the following aid.

http://www.m-powertools.com/products/pss1/pss1.htm


Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#2

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm tempted to offer to pop some popcorn for the ensuing discussion, but it's so hard to fit popcorn into our DSL connections.

For straight ahead plane irons and chisels, and for those comfortable with side-to-side scratches on the sharpened edge*, this might have its virtues for those who have hard time hand sharpening. But it would be a leetle hard sharpening a gouge on this, or many skew blades (Stanley 289, any of the Lee Valley skews, skew chisels of any significant width).

Now, I use a sharpening jig (LV Mk. II**), but I like to think the action of using it is training my hands to hold the angle when I sharpen odd-ball shapes. This would not do that.

Still, an interesting design.

--------

*Seems to me there was some discussion of this issue in the last couple of years, but I can't recall if there was any data-based conclusion as to whether sideways scratches weakened the edge or not.

**Cheaper than this tool, although you do have to provide your own abrasives - stones, diamond plates, etc.

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#3

Interesting design....they will sell a bunch....

roger lance

but limited....still have to flatten the backs somehow.....and BU smoothing planes use higher bevels on their irons than this jig provides for.....other issues will come to other minds.....but they deserve credit and will make sales with this.

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#5

Re: Oooh! Shiny!

William Duffield

But, it's useless for a jack or scrub plane, which don't work very well at all without a camber. And my 3" slick wouldn't fit, even if I didn't prefer it with a camber.

And then there's those two pieces of aluminum, sliding against each other, which won't last long once the grit removed from the steel, and little bits of diamond, get between them.

Pass the popcorn, Bill.

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#6

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

William Duffield

Those don't look like the hands of a furniture maker of 40 years or so.

Otherwise, point well made!

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#7

There was a recent thread on some forum....

roger lance

where a young shop teacher was looking for a way to teach sharpening skills on chisels and plane irons to novice 15-16 year olds....something fool proof and low cost and safe....this might work for him.

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#8

Re: There was a recent thread on some forum....

john sayles

cool device and had one to use for a while (back in prototype days), but (1) you're stuck with their replacement diamond stone pads, and (2) the pads wear in the same place every time.

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#9

Re: It's a shooting board in disguise!

Edward in Vancouver

It is a neat idea, might only work well for block plane irons and chisels.

Now how do I mickey-mouse a similiar set-up with wood blocks, a base, and stick-on sandpaper?..............

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#10

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#11

Re: There was a recent thread on some forum....

TomD

"where a young shop teacher was looking for a way to teach sharpening skills on chisels and plane irons to novice 15-16 year olds....something fool proof and low cost and safe....this might work for him. "

I get what you are saying, no problem. But that kid is being robbed. It is like teaching a kid to drive the golf ball by getting him one of those drivers that uses a 22 blank to project the ball. Every hour spent doing stuff that isn't real, is a wasted hour towards the goal. Just jump in and get to it. At 16 kids play complicated video games, learn to drive, and excel at sports. In a few more years they will be fighting our wars, and trading our bonds... Okay same thing...

They rise to a challenge and know lame at a glance. DMT is one of those brands that has never failed to disappoint me, also.

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#12

Wow 2009....not brand new then.


Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#13

Re: The kind of thing...

david weaver

.. that sells well in an infomercial setting, but in reality isn't what you want. And I don't recall it being cheap.

I saw one at rockler a couple of years ago, I don't remember what the brand was, but I think it was blue like that. It was small enough that you'd think twice if you had to remove any metal with it.

For the life of me, I can't figure out why someone would want deep diamond scratches going parallel to the end of a chisel.

Warren's tool picture looks more pragmatic.

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#14

bridger

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

Bridger

looks like a handyman/homeowner level device. could work out for someone who doesn't. really need a high degree of sharpness nor use much variety of edge geometry, and maybe can't justify spending the time to develop sharpeningskills. it'll be a crutch for anyone wanting to get past that point for sure....

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#15

Re: I hope..

david weaver

.. it's not still 75-$85. I couldn't imagine giving $50 for it, which would buy a carborundum stone, a medium india and a fine india.

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#16

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#17

Or, to rephrase,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"This unique system causes experienced sharpeners to turn their heads in pain."

Re: The ultimate sharpening device

#18

Re: Or, to rephrase,

david weaver

I was just thinking. Did sharpening get turned on its head, or did the sharpeners just feel like they were turned upside down and dumped on their heads?